Helmet cams- GoPro or Contour GPS?
-
I am considering getting one of those indestructible sport cams and I thought I'd see if anyone here has any opinions or experience with them first. I am leaning towards the Contour GPS because of the bluetooth capabilities (I like the idea of being able to control it with my phone, adjust settings and preview the video so I know it's pointed where I want it) and because I like the lower profile of it from the front. I also like that the unit itself is water resistant without the case, meaning it can record sound.
I like the GoPro, but it seems if you want to do much beyond the basic functionality you need to buy more bits and bobs for it. I have friends with GoPro2's and they love them, and I've seen comparison videos and the GoPro2 does seem to produce slightly better video- the contrast and color rendering seems better.
The GoPro2 really bothers me in that you have to make a choice between waterproof and sound, and that you really don't buy a camera, you buy a camera kit so if you want wifi you need to buy another piece (which means another case) and if you want an LCD you have to buy another bit (which means another case) and so on.
The Contour GPS suffers a bit in video quality (from what I've seen) but not enough in my mind to give up things like phone control, sound and GPS tracking, all right out of the box.
I've been reading reviews until my eyes bled and I think I have a handle on it- I'm likely going to go for the Contour partly because of the added options and partly because I already have access to two GoPros, and it might be nice to have some variety.
Anyone got any other thoughts to throw into the mix before I take the plunge?
Def
-
While the Contour is no doubt a fine piece of gear, apparently just owning a GoPro allows one to get breathtaking action shots like these: :)
-
Seems like a good argument to me...
Def
-
And I notice they didn't have any problems making the "waterproof or sound" decision.

-
Go pro seems to be cat's meow in ski community, no experience with either personally.
-
@J-sews said:
And I notice they didn't have any problems making the "waterproof or sound" decision.
With the GoPro, the unit itself isn't water proof at all. It has to be in the waterproof case if it's to be used around water, which means the microphone on the unit is covered. The Contour has a waterproof box too, but that's for diving more than 1m underwater. The unit itself is water resistant so the microphone isn't blocked.
Of course if you are using it more than 1m underwater you probably aren't missing any witty banter.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
Judging by the overwhelming response to this thread I can tell you are all on the edge of your seats as to which one I ended up buying, so here goes....
Yesterday I went out and bought a Contour GPS camera. The price was right, the feature set is amazing and while the video quality isn't quite as good as the GoPro, it's really only the kind of thing you'd notice when you put them side by side. One of the big selling features for me was this:
http://contour.com/camera/media
Watch the video and you'll see the GPS location on the right auto update as the guy on the bike goes down the mountain. I have been using My Tracks on my Android to trace our exact track when kayaking and this is nice because it actually connects it directly to the video, so I no longer have to point to a map while watching the video and saying "this is about where I was when that happened."
I also like the fact that I can use my phone as a viewfinder and to adjust settings and modes as I go. I haven't shot any video yet as I've been charging batteries (I got two extra batteries with it assuming the Bluetooth and GPS are going to kill them PDQ) and installing/updating software.
Def
-
Sweet purchase boss! My buddy took a goPro snowboarding which wasn't bad but he kept turning it off instead of on so it was a whole video of us sitting and BSing on the side of the mountain.

Stay multi my friends
-
I updated the firmware on mine this morning and it bricked. If I have a chance this afternoon I'll take it back to the store to have it replaced.
:(
Def
-
I have the Contour GPS, and I have had it a few days now. Initially I was not amused with it as the first one I had bricked when I updated the firmware. The second one I had also bricked. The third one I got very explicit instructions from a customer service rep and it didn't brick. I can't help but think that the instructions the rep gave me (which differed greatly from the instructions in the software and on the website) should have probably been published somewhere. However, as I quickly learned, instructions are not Contour's strong suit. There are no comprehensive instructions on their site, camera or software. There is a quick start guide, but that really doesn't offer much info, and the info it does offer is not really accurate. For example, part of the update process says to hit the Bluetooth button. Sounds simple, right? Wrong. There is no Bluetooth button. I checked the Quickstart guide where they have the breakdown of what parts are where and no where was there anything marked Bluetooth Button. While looking at the site there was something marked "Hidden Button" but you still have to do a fair bit of research to find out that the Hidden Button and Bluetooth Button are the same button.
I could go on at length about the lack of clear instructions, especially since the software is the same way. They say that the Storyteller software is great for editing the videos, but it only has one button (the AWESOME button, which apparently makes that segment of video more AWESOME) and I can't find any features on how to crop videos or edit them together, speed them up, slow them down.... yadda yadda yadda. Anyways, I can go on about the lack of any instructions, but you get the idea.
The camera itself, once you have the damned thing working, is actually pretty sweet. Unlike Frank's GoPro (which is also an awesome camera) this one doesn't need to be in the housing to use it. The GoPro camera itself doesn't have any mounts unless it's in the housing, and isn't water resistant at all by itself, so you always need a housing when using it. The Contour GPS is water resistant to (I believe) ten feet (3m) so I can mount it on my kayak and not worry about the occasional splash. Even so, I did get a dive housing for it for when I go snorkeling, even though I rarely go terribly deep, and rarely for any significant length of time. Really, what am I going to miss out by not having sound under water? :P
The dive housing is nice, even if it's somewhat bulky. The GoPro dive housing is less cumbersome but it doesn't float, so Frank has a float attachment for it. The Contour dive housing floats with the lens pointing straight up, and since it's a bright yellow/green color, it should be relatively easy to find. This would make a neat premise for Blair Witch III- The Sea Hag since it's possible this camera could wash up on shore somewhere, intact and ready to be played.
While the accessories for the Contour may not be as prevalent as the GoPro accessories, there does seem to be just as many out there. I bought the tripod mount and a USB battery charger a few days ago at Best Buy and they were apparently on Two for One since I only paid half as much as I should have- something I wasn't arguing about! The tripod mount is just a clip that has a standard camera screw mount in the bottom- the camera itself doesn't have one, so I figured this was a mount I needed.
The Contour itself came with a goggle strap and two rotating mounts, but with the Bluetooth and GPS functions I figured I'd better get a couple of extra batteries as well, and since much of my activity includes water (kayaking, snorkeling, wakeboarding, driving my Jeep through mud, working in the rain etc) I figured the dive housing was a safe bet too. Oh, and I also got a car mount, and I have to say, it is the best, most solid automotive mount I have ever encountered, which I suppose is important since the Contour is actually quite hefty compared to the GoPro- although that's largely because of the difference in body. The GoPro is plastic while the Contour is aluminum, which is lighter than steel but nowhere near as light as plastic.
The video coming out of the camera is beautiful, and I like that it has sound- again, unlike the GoPro. I also like that it's very simple to operate. Many of Frank's videos start with a closeup of him as he checks for the little red LED and looks at the tiny LCD screen to see if it's in the right mode and on. The Contour has a few LED's and if any of them are on then the camera is ready to go. There's a HUGE switch on the top- slide it forward and it's recording, slide it back and it's off. Brilliant.
The camera has a small switch in the back that allows you to go from one mode or the other, and you have to set up these modes in advance, so it can be a bit limiting, while on the GoPro you can select whatever modes you like any time you like, if you are willing to enter a complex formula of button presses since it only has one button (actually it has two, but they both do the same thing). Luckily the Contour GPS and Contour + models both allow you to use your smartphone (extra piece required if you use iOS, but built in support for Android) to change the settings and use the screen of your phone as a viewfinder- this is important with cameras that you have to point vaguely in the direction of what you want to film and hope you are getting it. If you don't have a smartphone handy, the Contour also has a couple of lasers that fire out of the front- anything between the red dots is getting filmed.
Frank and I will probably do a comparison video soon, but so far I think the Contour is a slightly better camera despite the major fault of the instructions. It's a nice, solid camera with some heft to it so you know it's there. I'm glad I got it instead of the GoPro, although they do both have major benefits over the other. The more standard camera shape of the GoPro lends itself better to things like chest harnesses while the bullet shape of the Contour is better for goggle or helmet mounting. The Contour provides sound while the GoPro is lighter. The Contour is limited to two modes (unless you have a phone handy) and to change between one mode to the other you need to open the water proof back, while the GoPro can be changed to any mode while still safely packed in it's housing.
All in all you really can't go wrong with either camera (unless you try to update the Contour software without involving customer support! :P) but I am glad that I got the Contour as it's more suitable to me, and it gives Frank and I the opportunity to compare them on a regular basis- that conflict has worked well for years with Ford and Chevy, Pepsi and Coke, Mac and PC, dog and cat etc.
I'll post some video as soon as I figure out how.... :P
Def
-
I want to see some Jeepin' footage!
Stay multi my friends
-
Sorry to hear about the trouble you've been having with the firmware upgrades. A friend of mine has a GoPro and loves it, but he mostly uses it for diving so the no sound issue isn't really an issue for him. But I agree, I hate buying that requires me to go buy extra stuff for it to work properly. :ahhh I think you made a good choice with the Contour GPS and hope you have long years of fun with it once you two get to know each other better :D
-
Being a TV guy tested both, GoPro and Contour. The video quality is no doubt on GoPro. But personally for my needs I took Contour Plus. Its good enough in daylight conditions. Its lens can be turned when camera is placesd with any angle and I like its possibility to connect with my phone as monitor. The same phone software also allows to change presets with white balance, quality etc. I don't like how it records sound. Can't understand how the microphone is set up - some sounds are ok, others, including speech - is hardly heard even with maximum mic gain. Possibly its problem with my camera, but, well, I don't need sound anyway.
If you look for more "plug and play" with better quality and use it only on your helm or in places where it is set horizontally - its GoPro. If you understand what advantages you get from Contour - its a good choice as well.
-
I've not spent a lot of time testing it but so far I'm quite happy with it. As for it not picking up voice properly, well I don't have much intelligent to say anyway....
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
I found out another interesting thing about my Contour GPS yesterday. It is water resistant against splashes and amazingly ineffective against even minor submersion without the dive housing. This was news to me as I thought it was supposed to be rated to ten feet. Turns out the cheaper model is, but this model isn't. Score another one for ineffective instruction/spec sheets.
Fortunately it doesn't appear that any of permanent damage was done, and after a night spent in a bag of rice it's good to go again.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
Well it's not good after all. Contour explains that the camera is only water resistant from the front, not from the back, which strikes me as pretty freaking stupid. They are going to replace it under warranty though, so now I have to send it in to them.
On the one hand it's good that they are willing to replace it, on the other this is just another one of the things that really lets this company down. The camera is good but the software sucks, the instructions suck and the marketing sucks. I like the camera and I like the features- the ones that exist that is. The non-water resistant water resistance seems odd.
Def
-
That is weird, like a watch that is waterproof on crystal but not case back.
-
Yeah, it's a little weird. Still, they are looking after it and that's good.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
That and the cheaper model is submersible but not the more expensive one...
I guess you have to look for a waterproof case now?
-
I actually do have a dive housing for it but I didn't bring it along since it was supposed to be water resistant. After all, I got this one specifically because it allowed you to get sound without worrying about it getting wet.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login