I had been waiting until I could do this thread justice, and I should have responded before now. Walter Koenig deserved it, but he also deserved to have it done right.
Pavel Chekov was never meant to be in Star Trek. The character was a concession to studio executives that had no faith in the Wagon Train To The Stars show, and so they insisted on adding a character that looked like he stepped in from an episode of the extremely popular Monkees show, which explains the mod haircut in the 2200's.
But, had that never happened, we may never have met the second youngest member of the original Enterprise crew, and that would have been a shame.
He was absolutely a great, and there was always a little bit of smurf disturber in him, which made him the perfect upstart character rather than just be someone who was little more than set dressing. That was obvious when filming Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, where the crew goes back in time to 1980's Los Angeles. The scenes where he and Nichelle Nichols (Uhura) are walking around and asking where they keep the "Nuclear wessels" in his thickest Russian accent were not scripted- he literally went out on the street and started asking random people while hidden cameras captured people's actual responses... while we were still in the Cold War.!
But, he was always an ancillary character- the original Star Trek was very much about Bones, Spock and Kirk, and while the others had the odd opportunity to shine, they never really got the spotlight.
When Babylon 5 came along and they introduced the character Al Bester, the manipulative Psy Cop who was always one step ahead of everyone else and who turned cruelty into an art form, well, I love Babylon Five and I will say the Bester episodes were far and away the absolute best of the series, showing us what a brilliant actor he truly was.
As much as we loved the boy genius Pavel Chekov, we absolutely loathed Al Bester- and I have always said that the best actors are the ones that play the best bad guys. I don't know of too many better bad guys in any series that were better than Al Bester.
My absolute favorite appearance of his was on Futurama, where the surviving members of the original crew (short only DeForest Kelly and James Doohan) played stylized versions of themselves, and he had exceptional lines like "I don't have any experience fighting people. Well, except you guys."
That wasn't the best part of it though.
At one point Fry says "And look at Walter, after Star Trek he became an actor!"
And Walter follows up with "Not just an actor, but a well rounded person, with my own keys and everything!"
That kind of self deprecating humor always appeals to me, and he carried it off so brilliantly I have to wonder if it was an improv that got left in because it was so perfect.
But, despite doing other things (like having keys) he was always there for the fans, including doing a fan sponsored Star Trek series on YouTube called Renegades, that also starred the late, great Grant Imahara from the Mythbusters. He appeared in it as Admiral Chekov, rounding out the story of of a classic character beautifully.
As much as I love Chekov though, I am always going to be a bigger fan of Bester.
"You're an optimist. Thank you! I'd almost forgotten what one of your kind looked like."
"Not everything is about Babylon 5" (Bold words to utter on a station called Babylon 5, in a show called Babylon 5....)
And, as great as he was, he also let others get the better of him (he was the bad guy after all), as in the scene with rogue telepath Lyta Alexander:
Bester: "The Corps is Mother, the Corps is Father."
Lyta: "In that case Mr. Bester, I'm an orphan."
RIP Walter- you will be missed and your memory will live on.
Def