I myself was not a Union Guy (I was almost anti-union really) until I got my present job. During hiring I haggled over salary and HR said, sorry, no can do. Union position which means a defined grade and step.
I said, well then I don't want to be in the Union
They said, due to the Janus decision, you can opt out, but your position will remain a Union position
I said, what in Smurfette does THAT mean?!
In the end, I just signed on
We also had a terrible Union. Didnt meet the rep for 18 months. Absentee. And I could not believe the violations of the contract I was witnessing and that nothing was being done about it.
Eventually we applied to the labor board to quit that old Union so we could shop around.
We chose en masse to go with Teamsters (personally I voted to stay completely out of any Union but was out voted)...They also adopted the previous Union contract - I think they have to until the next round of negotiations.
Through a series of misadventures, (think Gilligan's Island when they wanted to dress him up like the deity they found on the totem pole, and send him to talk with the native chief. Gilligan says "No. You cant make me you cant make me you cant make me" cut to next scene of Gilligan dressed up like the totem pole.), I was nominated and voted Steward. We then hit the negotiations table and between a new, strong Union and a new group in city management, we came up with a much better contract. It still gets violated now and then but things get put in check through grievances, labor board arbitration, and actually, most often just through mutual cooperation.
We dont let much slide by. The picture has to fit the frame. Meaning the money has to fit the job and the job has to fit the money. And we try to make sure everyone is getting their gear, clothing, training and certifications. The city does genuinely work at keeping things right.
What really opened my eyes was that last United Auto strike against all Big 3 American companies once...well, Toyota, Honda, etc didnt step up to the plate first to set the bar. They just reacted to what United Auto Workers did to GM, Ford, and "Dodge of Europe", and after the fact at that.