Self defense Folder, deployment method.
-
I could equally ask why you're equating combat with self defense. They're not remotely the same thing.
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
-
To each their own, but to me combat and self defense are the opposite sides of the same coin.
Physical self-defense is the use of physical force to counter an immediate threat of violence.
Combat or fighting is a purposeful violent conflict meant to weaken, establish dominance over, or kill the opposition, or to drive the opposition away from a location where it is not wanted or needed.
When I defend myself it is combat. Any physical alteration can quickly, even though unwittingly, become a life or death situation and to treat it any different is setting yourself up for a failure that no one can afford. When I defend myself I take purposeful and violent actions that are meant to establish my physical dominance over my attacker and drive him from the location. Sounds a lot like Wikipedia's description of self defense.
Luckily I have never used a blade or firearm in my civilian life for self defense. In the military our standard ROE is not to shoot until we are being shot at which, in my book anyway, is self defense. I don't believe that a uniform or patch on my shoulder changes that. Someone attacked me and now I am returning the favor.
Anyway, sorry to derail the thread so much but I find the topic intriguing and thought provoking. I sincerely hope I didn't ruffle your feathers I simply like to here justification for beliefs so that I can also read, learn, or watch the story behind it and develop my own opinions better. At the end of the day it doesn't matter though and we agree on two very specific, and important things. The first is that you will be screwed in a knife fight and the second is that the best engagement is the one that you are never in. Unfortunately though leaving the situation is not always an option and for that reason I try to always have a plan of attack.
-
a lightsaber deploys the fastest
....in the olden days we used bottles, baseball bats and beer glasses as they were fast enough. :D I am surprised to be around..
Thumbstud or auto seem reliable and fast to me now
-
@dmanuel said:
To each their own, but to me combat and self defense are the opposite sides of the same coin.Physical self-defense is the use of physical force to counter an immediate threat of violence.
Combat or fighting is a purposeful violent conflict meant to weaken, establish dominance over, or kill the opposition, or to drive the opposition away from a location where it is not wanted or needed.
When I defend myself it is combat. Any physical alteration can quickly, even though unwittingly, become a life or death situation and to treat it any different is setting yourself up for a failure that no one can afford. When I defend myself I take purposeful and violent actions that are meant to establish my physical dominance over my attacker and drive him from the location. Sounds a lot like Wikipedia's description of self defense.
Luckily I have never used a blade or firearm in my civilian life for self defense. In the military our standard ROE is not to shoot until we are being shot at which, in my book anyway, is self defense. I don't believe that a uniform or patch on my shoulder changes that. Someone attacked me and now I am returning the favor.
Anyway, sorry to derail the thread so much but I find the topic intriguing and thought provoking. I sincerely hope I didn't ruffle your feathers I simply like to here justification for beliefs so that I can also read, learn, or watch the story behind it and develop my own opinions better. At the end of the day it doesn't matter though and we agree on two very specific, and important things. The first is that you will be screwed in a knife fight and the second is that the best engagement is the one that you are never in. Unfortunately though leaving the situation is not always an option and for that reason I try to always have a plan of attack.
In combat, you're equipped, trained and expecting to engage with a hostile opponent. You're also generally with a group of people in a similar situation.
In a situation of self-defense you're generally alone, wearing street clothes and not expecting to be attacked.
You cannot equate the two because the circumstances are completely different.
-
@dmanuel said:
The first is that you will be screwed in a knife fight and the second is that the best engagement is the one that you are never in. Unfortunately though leaving the situation is not always an option and for that reason I try to always have a plan of attack.To me, this line is golden.

@jekostas said:
In combat, you're equipped, trained and expecting to engage with a hostile opponent. You're also generally with a group of people in a similar situation.In a situation of self-defense you're generally alone, wearing street clothes and not expecting to be attacked.
You cannot equate the two because the circumstances are completely different.
I think it is hard to say what people will do in one situation where they won't in another, conflict is conflict, be it in war zone of on the street. If a bullet is coming my way, whether the shooter is wearing an uniform or street clothes, or I am alone or in a group, I just don't want to be there to receive it. :D
No! Go to 0:27 and 0:30, and check out how slow Obie and Vadie brought out their sabres!
Every Lightsaber Ignition & Retraction
I am faithful your beer bottle will hit him silly, before he could unleash his sabre. :D
-
I used to feel having an ASP would be a good defense against a knife but not so much.
-
I prefer thumbstuds for the more positive tactile feedback, but personally I would prefer a fixed blade for defensive work; much less to go wrong.
-

- Without Pics
-
You don't need a knife for self defense. You just need a good teacher and some training.
Jim Carey Self Defense - Not a Dekiti Tirsia Siradas video
:D :D :D :D
-
I believe that the folding knives are considered as the best self defence weapons. I consider folders as best because they can be placed in your pocket for everyday carry.
-
Best in term of it is legal to carry in most states and most places, no permit required.
Best in term of it is easy to carry and has other functions other than self defense.BUT.
**Not the best defense tools in all situation. ** Often when it comes to that, using nearby objects (picking up a chair, flipping a table, throwing a bike , etc.) is just as effective if not more.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I believe that the folding knives are considered as the best self defence weapons. I consider folders as best because they can be placed in your pocket for everyday carry.
Best compared to what? They certainly are not better than carry a firearm.
Wow, necro thread rises from the dead! :o
How is some folding knife the best defense weapon?
As far as the United States goes, it has to be one of the worst. With 40 of the 50 states now permitting the concealed carry of a gun, the knife becomes as relevant as any other medieval archaic weapon. Poor. And since most hard core criminals will have a gun, again, the question is how is some silly folding knife going to be of any help. Aside from getting you killed, that is.
I see these threads so often on knife forums, and I can't help but shake my head in wonder. To be a little blunt, how many keyboard comando's have ever seen a real knife fight, or the immediate aftermath of one??? If you ever do, you will never carry a knife for a weapon again. It ain't a Hollyweird fantasy where the good guy goes home unscathed. It's a messy ,bloody affair, where both parties get sliced and diced. A knife does NOT have the stopping power of a firearm or blunt object like a club. You stab an attacker and it has little or no effect. With the adrenaline flowing, he's going to keep on fighting and attacking you until he bleeds out, and that can take a while. Meanwhile he's got a knife too, and he's still trying to kill you. If he has a gun, he can still have enough left in him until he drops, to empty half a magazine into you. If his buddy (and they always work in at least 2's) who's keeping watch for the cops see's you pull a knife, it's very possible he's gonna jump in and then you're fighting two of them at once. Still a lose-lose situation.
Let me be a little more direct here and tell you what will happen in a real knife fight. And when you pull a knife on some mugger/attacker, you will be in a knife fight. When I was in the army, my engineer training was at Ft. Leonard Wood Missouri. This was the 1960's, and the Buck knife was the fashion. They sold them at the base PX for almost half the cost of the civilian stores, so every swinging Richard in the army had the black pouch on the belt.
Well one day just outside the mess hall, two your GI's get into it over the sale of a lid of pot that one claimed was "light". Yes it was-no it wasn't kind kind of thing. It escalated into a fight, and after some punches, they both pulled their Buck knives. By the time they were done, one was dead, the other in critical condition. Both looked like horror film victims. When the ambulances carried off the dead and injured, they brought in a water truck from the motor pool to hose off the pavement. Yes, there was that much blood on the cement. It looked like they had slaughtered a cow or three there. I was one of the witnesses, and I had to give my testimony to the MP's.
That fight forever changed my mind about the carry of a knife for defense. No way, no how, am I going for a knife if I'm attacked. If the other guy has a knife, I'm running like h--l, and if he has a gun, I'm handing him my wallet. Nothing in there worth dying for. If he's unarmed, I'm not going to prison for using a knife on an unarmed person. And that brings up an other whole issue. Are you going to get in some fight, and pull a knife and stab someone? You're going to have to stab them repeatedly to get an effect, and if you thought that guy in Florida was racked over the coals for shooting Travon Martin just once, what do you think they will do to you for stabbing some punk a dozen times or more. Or are you under some delusion that you will stick him once and he's gonna just fall over? And when it comes up in court, YOU are going to look like the aggressor.
There is no situation that pulling a knife is going to help. Just the opposite. If someone pulls a knife on you, then a bar stool, chair, fireplace poker, pool stick, fire extinguisher, beer pitcher, trash can lid, mop handle, shovel, walking stick/cane, large wrench, ratchet handle, jack handle, hiking staff, end table, will work to block the knife while you punt his cajones up into his pelvis like you're going for a field goal, then retreat and get the H out of Dodge. Pulling your own knife and engaging him on his own level is plain stupid and insane.
Why do you think that police officers will just shoot soon as knife comes into it? It's just too dangerous to mess with.
It's a semi free country last I heard, so carry what you want. But for defense I use a blunt force trauma tool. I know when I break the guys wrist or hand bones, he's gonna have a hard time using his knife on me. Washington D.C is my hometown, and it has some sketchy characters in it. I carry a stout Irish blackthorn stick, and it beasts a knife any day. When I was a kid, a lot of the men carried a black jack for defense. They were legal then. If anyone asks about my stick, I tell them I have an old injury that bothers me time to time. No laws agains it, and it even goes on board airplanes with me, so when I get off in Key West or where ver I'm gong, I'm decently armed. If I need a knife, I just stop at a box store and buy a SAK recruit that I gift off when I leave.
After witnessing that knife fight at Ft. Leonard Wood, I won't even carry a knife that has a blade lock and may temp me to think of it as a weapon.
I keep my sticks by the door, and just grab one on the way out. They go places a knife can't. The one on the far left and second from the right are my serious situation sticks.

-
I would agree with most of what you said, but disagree with a few things.
Every time anyone mentions defending yourself with a knife its immediately assumed they are talking about going one on one with another person wielding a knife. If I have time to notice another person wielding a knife i'm running every time.
You're going to have to stab them repeatedly to get an effect
There is no situation that pulling a knife is going to help. Just the opposite.
This is not true. Their are many places on the body that will immediately disable a attacker. With little research and no training one could easily achieve these results. For instance a slicing strike just above the knee will disable a attackers ability to walk instantly. Also a slicing attack above and behind the elbow will render that arm useless.
I am in no way condoning carrying a knife purely for self defense or intending to use it in self defense, but if a unarmed attacked pins you up against a wall or a similar situation like that and you cannot fight your way out a knife would be a excellent last ditch weapon to save your life.
-
@Kampfer said:
Let's say you carry a folder for self defense, do you believe one hand open is absolutely necessary?
What is your favorite deployment method? thumb stub, hole, assist, wave?
Do you think such method is totally reliable under pressure in a split of second?
Or old fashion two hand open is more reliable?Will avoid the politics of this, just the facts ma'am.
Fave deployment method goes without saying, even though I will. Spydie hole all day long just because that is what I use all the time. I bet if I tried something else it would end with the knife thrown across the room.
Nothing is totally reliable under pressure. If there is anything that is sure in a fight this is it.
That said two handed is just as reliable as say Spydie hole but no way is it more so. Muscle memory is key.
-
@cbl51 said:
As far as the United States goes, it has to be one of the worst ... the knife becomes as relevant as any other medieval archaic weapon. Poor.@cbl51 said:
Why do you think that police officers will just shoot soon as knife comes into it? It's just too dangerous to mess with.I find these two quotes to be both interesting and contradictory. Last I heard most cops won't shoot you on the spot for having a baton in your hand yet you assert that it is better. However later on you go on to talk about how it is too dangerous to mess with and immediately is perceived as a killing weapon.
-
As far as the United States goes, it has to be one of the worst ... the knife becomes as relevant as any other medieval archaic weapon. Poor.
@cbl51 said:
Why do you think that police officers will just shoot soon as knife comes into it? It's just too dangerous to mess with.I find these two quotes to be both interesting and contradictory. Last I heard most cops won't shoot you on the spot for having a baton in your hand yet you assert that it is better. However later on you go on to talk about how it is too dangerous to mess with and immediately is perceived as a killing weapon.
I noticed the same thing but wanted to stay on topic. Not in the mood to argue.
IMO saying a pistol is more dangerous then a knife up close is a mistake. Why? Try to grab a pistol and a knife someone is trying to use against you and see how each works out.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


