Ambitious long term folder test.
-
Nice pic!
Nate
-
Nice pic!

And you have winter, instead of the autumn weather we 'enjoy' in Germany since November...
-
Thanks.
We havent really had much winter here either. Mostly wet and fairly warmSent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
Day 5:
Not much to report. The Dragonfly has been used for the usual opening of packages and featering of firewood. Its still scary sharp.
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
So I have been thinking a bit about the next phase of the tests.
Wich knife should I test when Im done with the dragonfly?
Maybe I should go for a knife that is popular in general?
We here are obsessed with steel quality and materials, always looking for a flaw. But we are hardly representative for the average consumer.
I bet that over 90% of them have no Idea what a Spyderco or a Boker is. But a lot of them still buy and use folding knives. Some buy typical traditional folders, some buy chineese offbrand junk, and a lot buy knives with a familiar face on the package. Knives that you find in almost every sporting goods store in America and Europe.
So I got this one for the next phase:

The new Gerber Bear Grylls Compact II. Made from 420C steel and apparently made in America.
I wont open the package until Im done with the Dragonfly. Then a 120 days of testing will follow.For the final phase, I plan to get a cheap SRM knife and see how that compares over time to the others.
Looks like I have a plan for wich folding knives I will be carrying for the next year or so. [emoji2]
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
Would have messed with my brain if you had started a thread talking about a Compact II review.
Love my SAK Compact.
-
What SRM are you thinking about using?
Nate
-
@Grathr said:
So I have been thinking a bit about the next phase of the tests.
Wich knife should I test when Im done with the dragonfly?
Maybe I should go for a knife that is popular in general?
We here are obsessed with steel quality and materials, always looking for a flaw. But we are hardly representative for the average consumer.
I bet that over 90% of them have no Idea what a Spyderco or a Boker is. But a lot of them still buy and use folding knives. Some buy typical traditional folders, some buy chineese offbrand junk, and a lot buy knives with a familiar face on the package. Knives that you find in almost every sporting goods store in America and Europe.
So I got this one for the next phase:

The new Gerber Bear Grylls Compact II. Made from 420C steel and apparently made in America.
I wont open the package until Im done with the Dragonfly. Then a 120 days of testing will follow.For the final phase, I plan to get a cheap SRM knife and see how that compares over time to the others.
Looks like I have a plan for wich folding knives I will be carrying for the next year or so. [emoji2]
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
I'm interested in seeing how this goes, a ton of people use Gerbers low end offerings and never really complain. I've been carrying one a few times lately just for the heck of it and honestly it's not as useless as you may be lead to believe.
-
So I have been thinking a bit about the next phase of the tests.
Wich knife should I test when Im done with the dragonfly?
Maybe I should go for a knife that is popular in general?
We here are obsessed with steel quality and materials, always looking for a flaw. But we are hardly representative for the average consumer.
I bet that over 90% of them have no Idea what a Spyderco or a Boker is. But a lot of them still buy and use folding knives. Some buy typical traditional folders, some buy chineese offbrand junk, and a lot buy knives with a familiar face on the package. Knives that you find in almost every sporting goods store in America and Europe.
So I got this one for the next phase:

The new Gerber Bear Grylls Compact II. Made from 420C steel and apparently made in America.
I wont open the package until Im done with the Dragonfly. Then a 120 days of testing will follow.For the final phase, I plan to get a cheap SRM knife and see how that compares over time to the others.
Looks like I have a plan for wich folding knives I will be carrying for the next year or so. [emoji2]
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
I'm interested in seeing how this goes, a ton of people use Gerbers low end offerings and never really complain. I've been carrying one a few times lately just for the heck of it and honestly it's not as useless as you may be lead to believe.
Lies!
No really not complete junk. One of my Soldiers has one and since I am the camp sharpening ho I sharpened it.
Not the worst knife/MT I have ever seen, I mean it is not a Buck X-Tract for example.
-
So I have been thinking a bit about the next phase of the tests.
Wich knife should I test when Im done with the dragonfly?
Maybe I should go for a knife that is popular in general?
We here are obsessed with steel quality and materials, always looking for a flaw. But we are hardly representative for the average consumer.
I bet that over 90% of them have no Idea what a Spyderco or a Boker is. But a lot of them still buy and use folding knives. Some buy typical traditional folders, some buy chineese offbrand junk, and a lot buy knives with a familiar face on the package. Knives that you find in almost every sporting goods store in America and Europe.
So I got this one for the next phase:

The new Gerber Bear Grylls Compact II. Made from 420C steel and apparently made in America.
I wont open the package until Im done with the Dragonfly. Then a 120 days of testing will follow.For the final phase, I plan to get a cheap SRM knife and see how that compares over time to the others.
Looks like I have a plan for wich folding knives I will be carrying for the next year or so. [emoji2]
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
I'm interested in seeing how this goes, a ton of people use Gerbers low end offerings and never really complain. I've been carrying one a few times lately just for the heck of it and honestly it's not as useless as you may be lead to believe.
Lies!
No really not complete junk. One of my Soldiers has one and since I am the camp sharpening ho I sharpened it.
Not the worst knife/MT I have ever seen, I mean it is not a Buck X-Tract for example.
Hey, buck's steel is no joke. I really like using it, sharpens easily and keeps a working edge for quite some time. Not like the special steels out there but it also costs much less. But yeah, the ten buck Gerber knife I've used hasn't really dulled much at all yet.
-
Of course the steel on your X-Tract knife is going to stay sharp for a long time. Hard to make it dull when you are afraid to take it out of your pocket because everyone laughs at you when you do.

-
Just to be clear, I like Gerber tools and knives, wich is why I chose the compact II.
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
@ducttapetech said:
What SRM are you thinking about using?Nate
A SRM 710.
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
What SRM are you thinking about using?
Nate
A SRM 710.
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
Good choice! That's a lot of knife for very little money!
-
-
Day 14:
I just got Zoidbergs G10 version in the mail, so its time to reset the daycounter and put the FRN on the shelf.
Thanks again Zoidberg!
Day 1:
First impression: the G10 version feel much more solid than the FRN. As you can see from the pics, the G10 version has steel liners, wile the FRN have none. The G10 version is as a result of this, also heavier than the FRN. Its also got a tighter pocketclip than the FRN.My impression of the FRN Dragonfly after 14 days, is that it is a very capapble knife for lighter tasks, but when I use a lot of force on it on hardwood or cutting branches, It does not feel as solid as Id like. I can feel a little movement in the plastic and the mechanism when I do it. It probably wont fail or break, but it does not feel right either.
I tried the G10 on some hardwood today, and it feels a lot more solid when putting some force behind it.

Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
I am surprised by how different these two knives are for something that nominally is just something with different scales.
-
Never got around to sending you a PM so I'll just say it here. Use it like it's yours. Sharpen it, thrash on it, let it rust etc etc, whatever happens is all good. Have fun mate.

Sent from the land of the long white cloud.
-
Also looks like I forgot to move the clip to the other side.
Sent from the land of the long white cloud.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login