New SOG multis?
-
@genevabuck said:
Guys, maybe not multi tool related, but can anyone identify the orange knife that SOG is displaying on the wall of that video? I want.Looks like it might be this one: http://www.sogknives.com/outdoor/knives/huntspoint-boning-s30v.html :)
-
@50ft-trad said:
Something else I noticed on there website, they have the paratools and PPPs back up.
Nate
Have they put gear covers on the PPP yet? The PT-510 was far superior to the PPP IMHO
I will have to look again Al. They quit making them for a while.
Nate
Gears of madness are still exposed I'm afraid ... or at least they are on the sales pics
-
Little write up about the SP2.0 and it gives some dimensions at the end of the article:
"Total Components: 12; open: 6.1-inches; closed: 4.3-inches; weight: 6.3-ounces; comes with a pocket clip."
Heavier than I was expecting it to be. I figured it would weigh the same as a PPP. Doesn't bother me any, it's still pretty light - I was just expecting it to be lighter.
-
I'm almost 100% convinced now, that this tool is every bit as weak and delicate as the original version. I'm sure this runs on the same crappy little cast peg that kept breaking on the original, which means this is going to break just as easily, and therefore be unusable for a lot of jobs that you would expect from pliers of this size.
Here's why ...
Firstly, lets look back to Bob's pic of the weak peg and how it is engaged with the handles


Now look at where the peg is on the second picture, with the pliers in the deployed position. The peg is at about the 4 O'Clock position on the handle pivot. Now if you imagine closing thos pliers up into the tool, they will run round to the left to about the 9 O'Clock position once the pliers are closed. Look also at the distance that peg is away from the plier pivot .....
.... The distance and extent of travel is suspiciously similar to the part circle that you can see stamped into the body of the tool, almost as if the inside of that stamping is internal clearance for that peg to run ...
Can you see I mean?
If this is the case, the 2.0 version is at least as useless as the original version (considering also their recent trend for shipping production out for low cost manufacturing, and the drop in quality that followed). This tool would therefore be unfit for anything most of us would consider to be normal pliers use. Try using them on even a moderately heavy task that you would expect to do comfortably with pliers of this size, and that tiny little peg is going to shear right off.
Why have they re-released a cosmetically different version of a tool they discontinued because of the amount of warranty returns?
It doesn't make sense! :ahhh :ahhhUnless they have made some very significant design changes (which it doesn't look like they have), the company is once again going to be overrun with people returning faulty products .... pretty much every single one that gets used as a pair of pliers as it happens

Oh .... and to add to that .... the "gearing" on the end doesn't actually run on anything ... it just makes the tool significantly less comfortable in screwdriver mode. So .... they have taken a tool which was singularly the most ergonomic multitool in screwdriver mode, the most redeeming feature on an extremely limited pliers tool, and made it very uncomfortable. How did the meeting go when the proposal to bring this tool back happened?
"Hey guys, remember the Switchplier? Hows about we bring it back, keeping all the inherrent flaws that made us disco it last time, but this time lets make everything that was good on the tool, just as bad as well"

-
Hahaha, trad, you crack me up! I do see what you are getting at, though. Preferably, they fix the flaws of the previous edition before releasing something as "2.0". In this case refining the mechanism so that it is stronger.
However, I still want one.

-
@rdub934 said:
Hahaha, trad, you crack me up! I do see what you are getting at, though. Preferably, they fix the flaws of the previous edition before releasing something as "2.0". In this case refining the mechanism so that it is stronger.However, I still want one.

Me too, badly...
Since I'm a light-user, its probably all good

-
@rdub934 said:
Hahaha, trad, you crack me up! I do see what you are getting at, though. Preferably, they fix the flaws of the previous edition before releasing something as "2.0". In this case refining the mechanism so that it is stronger.However, I still want one.

Hey, if you want to get one for the purposes of looking pretty in a collection somewhere ... go for it. If not, I'd hang on to see what the truth is in the mechanism.
I got one of the original Switchpliers not long back, and I really like the idea of it, but haven't had the courage to carry it for fear of snapping off the feeble peg inside. I suppose that at least now, they have another pathetically weak set of pliers to replace it with if it does break, whereas before there was nothing available to replace my broken tool with.
-
Just checked the Patents for the Switchplier:
Hand tool with retractable jaws US 5829329
Hand tool with retractable jaw assembly US 5957013
And is not being referenced recently by SOG :P
So you must be right Trad ! They didn't do anything to improve the mechanism.

-
@Ombudsman said:
So you must be right Trad ! They didn't do anything to improve the mechanism.
So, basically ....
DO <u>NOT </u>BUY THE NEW SWITCHPLIER!
.... unless you just want it to sit in a drawer looking pretty ::)
Such a shame! For a while there I thought they had actually started trying to do something about their recent decline, and start making some proper tools again. So why have they rereleased it again when they already know it's not up to the job? Add this to the disfunctional donkey turd that is the Powerduo, which they've still not done anything about, and it's like they are actually trying to fail.
I'm ... completely bewildered ........... it makes no sense whatsoever

-
Still, though, this probably matches up comparably to other light duty, pocket-carry tools such as the Gerber Balance or Octane, or the Leatherman Skeletool (which is known to fail if used for heavy tasks).
-
That is exactly my question. How bad is it? I mean the last task my pliers had to fulfill was shortening wooden skewers to the shashlik would fit into my frying pan :D
-
@rdub934 said:
Still, though, this probably matches up comparably to other light duty, pocket-carry tools such as the Gerber Balance or Octane, or the Leatherman Skeletool (which is known to fail if used for heavy tasks).Not even close!
Look at the Skele, Balance and Octane, and how these forces are transmitted to the head. The go back to the pic above. Remember that pathetic little pin is only on one side of the head. Think how wire cutters are sited very close to the pivot to be most effective, well that pin is even nearer and so subjected to more force, is only in a cast material (not usually good with tensile or shear forces), and will gradually weaken with every use. Having never broken my original Switchplier (because I don't use it), I can't be more definitive in what the breaking point is ...
At a guess, I'd say Dime would be a nearer comparison, because if you overload those the backspring buckles - but remember you are trying to stay at that level of duty on a fuller sized tool where it's very easy to apply that little bit too much force
-
I love the looks of the new switch pliers.
It's to bad it won't be a quality tool.
-
If its the same cast pin design and it breaks, I'll drill it out and replace it with a hardened steel dowel pin. :D
-
@Ombudsman said:
Just checked the Patents for the Switchplier:Hand tool with retractable jaws US 5829329
Hand tool with retractable jaw assembly US 5957013
And is not being referenced recently by SOG [emoji14]
So you must be right Trad ! They didn't do anything to improve the mechanism.

That says 1998. I wonder if there the same now?
Nate
-
Just checked the Patents for the Switchplier:
Hand tool with retractable jaws US 5829329
Hand tool with retractable jaw assembly US 5957013
And is not being referenced recently by SOG [emoji14]
So you must be right Trad ! They didn't do anything to improve the mechanism.

That says 1998. I wonder if there the same now?
Nate
http://www.trademarkia.com/switchplier-75714205.html
I bet it is the same. Tradmarkia page for SwitchPlier - filed in 1999, but check this out, "REGISTERED AND RENEWED
3/16/2011". Have they been sitting on a re-release for 4 years? Lol -
@Syph007 said:
If its the same cast pin design and it breaks, I'll drill it out and replace it with a hardened steel dowel pin. :DOk I'm totally ignorant when it comes to steel and such. But I conclude from the above, that the pin would hold if done from hardened steel, right? Now check the design again. Unlike the images of the Switchplier the pin is not part of the plier-head. So, maybe the original design was good, but they changed it when it came into production to save money. So, if I understand this correct, all we have to hope for is that they don't jump hoops and make it correct this time.
-
If its the same cast pin design and it breaks, I'll drill it out and replace it with a hardened steel dowel pin. :D
Ok I'm totally ignorant when it comes to steel and such. But I conclude from the above, that the pin would hold if done from hardened steel, right? Now check the design again. Unlike the images of the Switchplier the pin is not part of the plier-head. So, maybe the original design was good, but they changed it when it came into production to save money. So, if I understand this correct, all we have to hope for is that they don't jump hoops and make it correct this time.
Yep most folders used hardened steel stop pins in construction and those take alot of shear force, so its totally doable. I understand the convenience of having them cast as part of the plier head but that is a very weak design and Id be shocked if they repeated it blindly to have the same failure rate. That would just be absurd.
Im excited to get one and take it apart though! :D
-
I want one.
-
@ducttapetech said:
Hand tool with retractable jaw assembly US 5957013
That says 1998
Nate
Yet for some reason it reminds me of 1898

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login