Bike Lights
-
Gee Dave,
Interesting how you know me and feel qualified to pass judgment on what kind of cyclist I am, despite having never met me or seen me ride in traffic. You should go into business as a professional psychic. That said, I'm not going to bother to address anything else in your post as I'm not going to buy into your judgment of me.
The only thing I will say, and this goes hand in hand with you seeming to think you know who I am as a cyclist, you're completely, 100% wrong about the "road tax". I suggest you educate yourself.
Since no one is actually reading what I've written here, or bothered to consider the merits of what I have clearly and specifically posted about how I ride, and instead are simply parroting their own opinions rather than actually considering the factual evidence I have presented, I see no reason to continue participating in this thread.
@16VGTIDave said:
Bicycles are vehicles, and have similar rights, yet few of the responsibilities as any other motorists/vehicles on the road. Despite not directly paying road or fuel taxes (completely true), not having any training or licenses, or paying for insurance - my mandatory vehicle insurance has mandatory fees to cover cyclists (aka uninsured motorists). But, bicycles are still considered vehicles. No argument from me about that point.What most cyclists seem to disregard is that the laws of physics trump legal laws. Every time. My point? A 175lb spandex clad cyclist on a 15lb road bike traveling at 30kph is no match for a 2800lb car traveling at 80kph. And when the driver of said car has to suddenly decide between oncoming traffic (almost certain death) and a "legally lane sharing" bicycle, they will choose the bicycle (the much lesser threat to their life). And there is nothing that well shaped spandex clad cyclist's ass can do about it because the only warning they will have is the squealing of tires and maybe a honking horn.
You might be wondering "Where did a guy who has ridden a bicycle for over 4 decades get such an attitude?". Well, let me tell you, and I see this all the time during the summer:
Citiot (city idiot) cyclists drive out to the country to ride the scenic roads. These roads (some are classed as highways which prohibits pedestrians and bicycles by definition) have narrow lanes, gravel shoulders and a posted speed limit of 80 or 90 kph. There is often farm equipment and heavy trucks on the roads (highways), and sometimes horse drawn wagons on the shoulders. Yet for some reason, these citiots think it is okay to ride these roads, often 2 or 3 abreast down the road (highway) so they can converse. Now, imagine the reaction from a local motorist heading into town to go shopping, when they round a corner or crest a hill at speed, only to find the road blocked by slow moving traffic (cyclists). At this point, the laws of the road are irrelevant. Physics is all that really matters. It is the cyclist(s) who put themselves in harms way, and the motorist who will likely be legally punished if an accident results. If the cyclist survives such an accident, they may even sue for injuries, damages, etc, and will probably win. Thereby driving up all MOTORISTS insurance costs.Now, I'm not trying to discriminate against cyclists. I think they should be treated fairly and with respect, just like every other vehicle on the road. So as soon as cyclists on the roads have to take training, get a licence, pay to register their bike, have their bike safety inspected, and have valid insurance, they will have the right to claim their fair share of the road. Or bicycles could simply be banned from all roads with speed limits above 50kph (30mph) unless they have met all the previously mentioned vehicular requirements. Keeping to the right shoulder while displaying a slow moving vehicle sign (the large reflective orange triangle) would make cycling MUCH safer for motorists.
Dave
-
Let's all remember to play nicely. Honestly I don't see anything offensive in that post at all Paul. If you'd like to send me a PM and let me know what specifically you found offensive I'd be happy to help settle this.
Def
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
Whilst I've no intention of getting involved in this heated debate.I must confess cyclists who insist on riding 2 and 3 a breast are a complete pain in the neck. I commute to work each day on my bike and take great measures to ensure I'm not an obstruction to traffic. I see no reason why cyclists think they have the God given right to obstruct traffic, jump red lights etc etc.
-
Keep it up chaps, we're on our way to getting the full set.
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/hmYWmj" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm3.staticflickr.com/2848/10739147314_e92a1bee82_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
This isn't an either/or discussion. BOTH sides have valid points, however BOTH sides share blame on the confrontations.
I see both sides of this since I bicycle commute to work from late spring to early autumn (41 miles round trip) AND I live out in the premier cycling country of Baltimore county. On the weekends, hoards of cyclists clog the roads, sometimes making for traffic nightmares as they ride 2, 3 or even 4 abreast on 2 lane roads posted for 50 mph. For those of us who live here, it is extremely rude and disrespectful. I've had people tell me to shut off the tractor because it was making too much noise at their "Rest break". Seriously?
This sort of behavior is elitist and leads to resentment from non-cyclists who are trying to use the roads, at or near the speeds at which the roads are posted.
On the flipside, aggressive drivers and inattentive drivers are a huge danger to cyclists. Even riding the line (at the edge of the road) is extremely dangerous when motorists are unaware of where their vehicle is in the lane. It is for this reason that many advocate for cyclists to ride in the middle of the lane--essentially forcing the motorist to pay attention to BOTH sides of their car. Being clipped by a car door or window is a trip to the hospital. Motorists have no "skin" in the game for these "minor" impacts, and hence many minimize the risk.
There is no clear cut answer to this. Cyclists have to be conscious that they are impediments to traffic and should make road choices, time choices and riding position based on the balance of personal safety and traffic nuisance. Motorists have to recognize cyclists have rights on the road and are extremely vulnerable. Although it's not currently the law, someday, hitting a cyclist could be considered assault with a deadly weapon.
As for road tax: Get real. In the US, it's the top 40% of earners pay 106% of the taxes and the bottom 40% pay -9% of all taxes (that's negative 9 percent). This nugget comes from the Congressional Budget Office (circa Dec 2013) based on IRS data from 2010 and includes tax credits as well. Who pays road tax? The top 40% of US earners pay road tax. Who doesn't pay road tax? The bottom 40% of earners. Place the bicycles where you may.
Now get out there and play nice. :)
-
STUPID Drivers SUCK no matter what there driving.
-
Def, if my posts are a problem, please feel free to nuke them as you see fit.
Heinz D, I wasn't judging you. As you so correctly point out, I don't know you. If you ever find yourself in the Toronto Ontario area, PM me. I'd be happy to have you out for a beer or coffee, and we can discuss this in person. I was, however, relating the issues I've seen and had with cyclists, and what I believe may be a solution to this issue. I apologize if I offended you, that wasn't my intent. Though, if my description fits your cycling style, I have nothing to apologize for. Either way, dismissing the points I made, because you chose to take insult, does not make them any less valid.
With respect to paying for use of roads, all taxpayers contribute and all reap the benefits, even if they don't ever use a road in any fashion. That said, it is quite clear that motorists (car, trucks, busses, motorcycles, mopeds, etc) pay additional fees directly (vehicle licensing, driver licensing, safety inspections, emissions inspections, fuel taxes, tire taxes, tolls, parking fees, insurance, etc) for the use of the roads. Commercial motorists pay significantly more. Cyclists don't pay ANY of these additional fees. If cyclists don't want to be discriminated against, they should end the discrimination. The argument of having a car and a bicycle "so I've paid" is not a valid argument. I have 2 cars (each with the required licensing and insurance), a motorcycle (with the required licensing and insurance), and a bicycle (with no licensing or insurance). I can only operate one vehicle at a time. I still don't believe that I have a right to ride where ever or however I want to - as compared to many (but not all) cyclists I have been witness to over the years. Again, since I've never met you, this is NOT a personal attack. Unless, by your admission, you match my previous description.
Now, since I believe that one should not be allowed to impose restrictions without offering valid solutions, I offer the following:
-Some areas used to license bicycles for use on roads, and I believe that this practice should be reinstated.
-Cyclists should have to have training, testing, and licensing, like all other road users.
-Cyclists should have to pay for their own insurance.
-Cyclists should have the required safety equipment on their bicycle at all times, like all other road going vehicles.
-Cyclists should obey all of the applicable road laws, not just a few of them (e.g. lane splitting or filtering is illegal in most areas, and while I disagree with this law, I still obey it on my motorcycle and bicycle).And just to get somewhat back on topic, based on some of the suggestions, I plan on adding a flashing white led light to the front of my bike. This is in addition to the lights, reflectors, and headlamp (off road only) I currently have.
Dave
-
Unless I have had many spicy burritos, I do not have to worry too much about bicycle emissions.
-
This is why **everyone **needs to pay attention and be safe.
-
@16VGTIDave said:
Now, since I believe that one should not be allowed to impose restrictions without offering valid solutions, I offer the following:
-Some areas used to license bicycles for use on roads, and I believe that this practice should be reinstated.
-Cyclists should have to have training, testing, and licensing, like all other road users.
-Cyclists should have to pay for their own insurance.
-Cyclists should have the required safety equipment on their bicycle at all times, like all other road going vehicles.
-Cyclists should obey all of the applicable road laws, not just a few of them (e.g. lane splitting or filtering is illegal in most areas, and while I disagree with this law, I still obey it on my motorcycle and bicycle).And just to get somewhat back on topic, based on some of the suggestions, I plan on adding a flashing white led light to the front of my bike. This is in addition to the lights, reflectors, and headlamp (off road only) I currently have.
Dave
I don't think you've thought this through, no offence

When one considers that the average child has his\her first bike from the ages of 4 and then the subsequent years bring the arrival of bigger bikes as the child grows up.
To then say that training, testing, licensing, insurance etc etc should be required by law is frankly a non starter.
What age are you planning on enforcing your "laws"Most of the idiots on the road (not counting the Sunday riders who churn out in droves!!) are not old enough to drive, drink alcohol, vote etc etc.
I agree that a certain cycling proficiency should be required, but that did use to be the case here in the UK. I remember at primary school during the last year we all had to bring our bikes one evening per week for several weeks. The playgrounds had mock zebra crossings, road markings, traffic lights etc etc.it was all serious stuff, we also had to study the highway code. At the end of the course you had to pass a test to be classed as a proficient cyclist.
Unfortunately it was scrapped years ago.
-
Now, since I believe that one should not be allowed to impose restrictions without offering valid solutions, I offer the following:
-Some areas used to license bicycles for use on roads, and I believe that this practice should be reinstated.
-Cyclists should have to have training, testing, and licensing, like all other road users.
-Cyclists should have to pay for their own insurance.
-Cyclists should have the required safety equipment on their bicycle at all times, like all other road going vehicles.
-Cyclists should obey all of the applicable road laws, not just a few of them (e.g. lane splitting or filtering is illegal in most areas, and while I disagree with this law, I still obey it on my motorcycle and bicycle).And just to get somewhat back on topic, based on some of the suggestions, I plan on adding a flashing white led light to the front of my bike. This is in addition to the lights, reflectors, and headlamp (off road only) I currently have.
Dave
I don't think you've thought this through, no offence

When one considers that the average child has his\her first bike from the ages of 4 and then the subsequent years bring the arrival of bigger bikes as the child grows up.
To then say that training, testing, licensing, insurance etc etc should be required by law is frankly a non starter.
What age are you planning on enforcing your "laws"Most of the idiots on the road (not counting the Sunday riders who churn out in droves!!) are not old enough to drive, drink alcohol, vote etc etc.
I agree that a certain cycling proficiency should be required, but that did use to be the case here in the UK. I remember at primary school during the last year we all had to bring our bikes one evening per week for several weeks. The playgrounds had mock zebra crossings, road markings, traffic lights etc etc.it was all serious stuff, we also had to study the highway code. At the end of the course you had to pass a test to be classed as a proficient cyclist.
Unfortunately it was scrapped years ago.
Sort of in support of Dave's contention, it would be very easy to make the requirement that to ride a bike on a road with a posted speed over 30 mph (ie 30 and below are exempt), one would have to have proof of training and insurance is certainly doable.
-
Interesting that most of these bicycle safety measures involve making it more difficult to be a cyclist, while absolutely not affecting drivers in any way.
-
Now, since I believe that one should not be allowed to impose restrictions without offering valid solutions, I offer the following:
-Some areas used to license bicycles for use on roads, and I believe that this practice should be reinstated.
-Cyclists should have to have training, testing, and licensing, like all other road users.
-Cyclists should have to pay for their own insurance.
-Cyclists should have the required safety equipment on their bicycle at all times, like all other road going vehicles.
-Cyclists should obey all of the applicable road laws, not just a few of them (e.g. lane splitting or filtering is illegal in most areas, and while I disagree with this law, I still obey it on my motorcycle and bicycle).And just to get somewhat back on topic, based on some of the suggestions, I plan on adding a flashing white led light to the front of my bike. This is in addition to the lights, reflectors, and headlamp (off road only) I currently have.
Dave
I don't think you've thought this through, no offence

When one considers that the average child has his\her first bike from the ages of 4 and then the subsequent years bring the arrival of bigger bikes as the child grows up.
To then say that training, testing, licensing, insurance etc etc should be required by law is frankly a non starter.
What age are you planning on enforcing your "laws"Most of the idiots on the road (not counting the Sunday riders who churn out in droves!!) are not old enough to drive, drink alcohol, vote etc etc.
I agree that a certain cycling proficiency should be required, but that did use to be the case here in the UK. I remember at primary school during the last year we all had to bring our bikes one evening per week for several weeks. The playgrounds had mock zebra crossings, road markings, traffic lights etc etc.it was all serious stuff, we also had to study the highway code. At the end of the course you had to pass a test to be classed as a proficient cyclist.
Unfortunately it was scrapped years ago.
In Croatia all kids have to pass a course to be allowed to drive a bike without adult supervision. They get a certificat and all. They also have to wear helmets.
And if your bike doesn't have front and rear lights, or you drive at night without a reflective vest, you can expect a pretty steep fine.
-
@Jothra said:
Interesting that most of these bicycle safety measures involve making it more difficult to be a cyclist, while absolutely not affecting drivers in any way.When one looks at traffic infractions, things like running lights, lane splitting in locales where it isn't allowed, obstructing traffic, illegal turns, riding under the influence, etc, there are NUMEROUS laws directed at drivers that have little to no real world application to cyclists.
For example: Do you wear a orange triangle of a slow moving vehicle? By law, I have to mount one on my tractor when it's on road, why not cyclists?
I'm just pointing out that cyclists, at least in the US, have been able to skirt laws of the road, claiming to be "pedestrians". Perhaps that needs to be re-addressed.
-
I had a big thing written, but realized it's mostly moot: unless you live somewhere very exceptionally strange, you live in a place that defines bicycles as vehicles (as opposed to motor vehicles), and treats them accordingly.
Familiarizing yourself with your local bicycle laws is basically only a Google search away.
Edit: I have read my province's entire Traffic Safety Act from beginning to end. Most drivers can't say the same.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Interesting that most of these bicycle safety measures involve making it more difficult to be a cyclist, while absolutely not affecting drivers in any way.
When one looks at traffic infractions, things like running lights, lane splitting in locales where it isn't allowed, obstructing traffic, illegal turns, riding under the influence, etc, there are NUMEROUS laws directed at drivers that have little to no real world application to cyclists.
For example: Do you wear a orange triangle of a slow moving vehicle? By law, I have to mount one on my tractor when it's on road, why not cyclists?
I'm just pointing out that cyclists, at least in the US, have been able to skirt laws of the road, claiming to be "pedestrians". Perhaps that needs to be re-addressed.
I feel sure that if the police in the UK witnessed such traffic violations the cyclist would be pulled over and dealt with. I do have a friend who had a close call with riding under the influence several years ago, and another for speed. As to obstructing traffic, that would apply if the cyclist was hogging the lane when unnecessary to do so. Where I live there are several roads where the condition of the road surface in towards the kerb is in a lesser condition than at the centre of the lane, and I ride close to the kerb when it is safe to do so, and take the lane when it is not. As to illegal turns, there is a road I use on the bike where to go into town I have to turn left, but the junction is ahead only. I cycle to the junction, dismount, push the bike round the corner and get back on :D
I am a driver first and foremost, but recently getting a bike has opened my eyes to the cyclists perspective. As mentioned earlier in the thread, idiots transport themselves on two wheels and four, and I am now relearning roadcraft based on the inherrent handicaps of cycling. I find most cyclists here to be "inconvenient" to the motor vehicle driver, but most I come across here (as a driver) have got enough sense to not make a hazard or obstacle of themselves without due cause. The only exception to this would be youths riding around estates/neighbourhoods, but even they are no more arrogant and disrespective on two wheels than they are on foot.
Where cyclists probably have the biggest unfair advantage for getting away with offences, is the growing trend towards policing the roads with traffic cameras. Not having license plates means that a cyclist exceeding speed limits or running red lights would not be identified. I pay road tax for my car, but not for my bike. Again, this would not be enforcable as the police in-car cameras and recognition software has no database of people's arse cracks to identify them by. For all those who wish to see new laws introduced, or old laws amended to cover pie and chocolate fuelled vehicles, give thought to how those laws can be enforced without doubling the amount of road patrols.
I do however have insurance. If I am in an accident and it is my fault, I have third party liability cover, and if it is not my fault I have legal assistance for me to claim. Have I had my proficiency assessed? No - and if there was a test I would probably fail. I cycle accordingly until my proficiency, experience, and confidence is such that I can exercise more of my legal rights to on-road cycling.
Changing topic lanes quickly though ... :P ... here at MTO we are normally very accepting of other people's stances on various topics, but on this one there is a lot of posturing and quite frankly unthinking drivel been spoken. I actually find it rather amusing :D Both forms of transport are quite valid, regional laws have been set as to how the relevant authorities think the situation should be managed. Everyone just needs to chill out. There are more perspectives than just yours, and they are not necessarily wrong

You sound like a bunch of bickering old grannies :D :D
-
I try to drive my truck safely, and I try to drive my bicycle safely. It's not as difficult as we're all making it sound.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login