Merit Badges
-
I've been thinking of a way to rally the community in a fun way that makes them come back and get involved again.
I'd also been thinking seriously about revisiting the "ten things every member should be able to do thread" but I kind of wanted a bit more longevity.
Then MadPlumbarian and Aloha007 hit the nail on the head.
Merit badges.
We come up with a number of tasks, challenges or accomplishments, create a merit badge type graphic for it and members can post them in their signature line.
I'm thinking that we can have easy challenges like a Forum Supporter badge where all they have to do is donate, medium challenges like the Japanese PST Badge which people get when they have a Japanese PST (example) or a more challenging thing like so many posts in a certain time for a Spammer badge. We can take it a bit further and have several levels of something like the Spammer badge- say a green spammer badge for ten posts in an hour, a yellow spammer badge for twenty five posts in an hour and a red one for 50 posts in an hour.
My thought is this- we come up with 25-30 badges and add to them as they go. Some can be limited time things (mark them with a date and year maybe?) while some can be permanent. And, it will be largely self (or community) policing- if guys think they have earned a badge they can take it, but they have to prove to everyone around them that they did it.
All in all I think this could be very interesting. We can add badges as we like, guys can suggest and design badges to add to the list.... there are quite a few possibilities.
So, any thoughts? We will need to come up with a number of them to start and give people something to sink their teeth into.
Def
-
self regulating could be a mite problematic.
I think they should be able to request with proof and then have it assigned by a mod.
-
I think the community is tight enough that it can self regulate. I really don't want something that adds to the moderator workload.
Def
-

I'm with Micah on the self regulating thing. We had problems enough while mods adding badges (ColoSwiss getting blocked out due to wrong badge for some weird reason for example ), letting anyone do it is a recipe for disaster.
Not sure about the spammer badges, maybe SOTY and SOTM only. (Year/Month)
I'd add an official OCD Squad for the guys taking care of the list in giveaways and keeping them in order. I already gave Beat a custom title like it some time back when I realized I couldn't make a badge, and Zoid got a SOTY for his efforts on the Million Post Spamathon.
Also if we're adding badges maybe it's time to revisit the In Memoriam badge I suggested for members no longer with us.
</topic/54626
-
Merit badges would be different from the membership banners. People would just put them in their signature lines.
It wouldn't be any effort on our behalf to add them, it would be up to the members to add their own. And so what if someone takes one they didn't "earn" properly? The idea is to get people involved without going to toour much effort. Besides I think people will have more fun earning them than stealing them.
Def
-
@enki_ck said:

I'm with Micah on the self regulating thing. We had problems enough while mods adding badges (ColoSwiss getting blocked out due to wrong badge for some weird reason for example ), letting anyone do it is a recipe for disaster.
Not sure about the spammer badges, maybe SOTY and SOTM only. (Year/Month)
I'd add an official OCD Squad for the guys taking care of the list in giveaways and keeping them in order. I already gave Beat a custom title like it some time back when I realized I couldn't make a badge, and Zoid got a SOTY for his efforts on the Million Post Spamathon.
Also if we're adding badges maybe it's time to revisit the In Memoriam badge I suggested for members no longer with us.
</topic/54626
indeed we already seem to have profile overload with titles, banners, etc. I tried to keep those as reduced as possible, but opening the door for people to have a heap of them just seems excessive. Unless we find a different format to display them.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
We come up with a number of tasks, challenges or accomplishments, create a merit badge type graphic for it and members can post them in their signature line.@Grant Lamontagne said:
Merit badges would be different from the membership banners. People would just put them in their signature lines.
Def
-
ok so you're just saying some images for their signature lines, that will be easier in the self regulation.
Sorry I seemed to gloss over the signature line thing. A close friend of ours here lost his mom Sunday and going to the funeral home yesterday has brought back a whole backwash of emotions. As always I need to read the entire message.
We will of course have an issue where people hit a maximum character limit in their signatures by including such banners. we have the option of extending maximum characters or figuring out the shortest possible filenames. Perhaps a word replacement could work in this situation. We should do some testing.
-
As far as regulation goes, maybe a Merit Badge Thread (or even a sub forum) where members will need to either earn, prove or declare each merit badge?
And yes, the file names will have to be short, I was thinking of hosting them in the Gallery, and that's part of my suggestion about the time limit on some, so when folks reach the character limit they can remove older, timed out ones. Not a perfect solution, but good enough for a start.
Additionally the badges themselves will have to be small, as guys might rack up a pile of them and we don't want them getting in the way of the flow of traffic. I'm thinking maybe something like military medals- once you get past a certain point they are bars because you can't put that many medals on your chest. I'm thinking something along the size of this guy:

That way the signature line will look like this:

Rather than this:



You get the idea.
Sorry to hear about your friend by the way. And sorry for what it brought back.
Def
-
-
no worries, yeah I can understand how we wouldn't want them to be huge.
I don't see how we can have them as self regulated and expiring. My guess is that once someone has added to their signature they won't bother removing.
The more I think about it, the word replacement feature might be the best option, for example you would put "SPAMOFMONTH" in your signature which could be replaced with the BBC code for an image
As for the crap here, it sucks but that's life. She went into hospital a week ago and it wasn't looking great... also she turned 89 Saturday. Funeral/burial later today. It's Maria's Best friend's mom, so we'll go. It's nowhere near the intensity of my mom for me, but I can definitely relate to his loss. There's still a big difference between 56 and 89.
-
here's something that looks somewhat promising:
https://github.com/Spuds/SMF-Member-Awards
Introduction
A system where members can be given awards to display in their profile and posts.
Features
This mod allows users with the permission to upload images that will serve as rewards.
Award images can be assigned a name as well as how they are to be earned (e.g. Contest, Posts, or the name of a game)
Awards can be placed in categories for display grouping and easy maintenance
Awards can be defined as assignable so members with assign awards permission can give an award (not define a new award though)
Awards can be defined as requestable so members can request an award for the moderation team to approve / deny
Awards can be assigned by member, by group or by mass selection
Automatic award assignment can be set for various milestones such as post count, topic count, join date, time on line, etc
Award post placement can be defined on a per award basis, above avatar, below avatar or with signature. Allows you to define badges as well as awards
The award image and the details assigned with the image are stored and can then be assigned to members.
Once assigned, the member can view his/her award album, as well as others awards.
They will be able to select their favorite image, as well as see who else has earned that award.
Those with correct permissions can edit the image and information assigned to that image, as well as completely delete it.
And more!might do the trick... not sure how self regulation friendly it would be...
-
-
-
If I'm reading the features correctly, that mod has the capabilities to do group nominations.
-
@zoidberg said:
What if others have to nominate you for you to get the badge?Few ideas for the MBs. Fishing, fire making, hook or scaler usage, hosting giveaways, hacks, nice pics, greeting newbies.
Mr. Pinchy love bites....

I like the idea overall, I'll do a bit of
and see if I come up with anything. As long as my head doesn't explode, that is...... -
Installed the "member awards" mod.
Required some minor tweaks to install (minor update to the install for compatibility with another mod already in place, and remove all the russian language files since we don't need them) but we should be able to test it out now.
suggestions for test awards/badges?
-
"Most Fred Badge"
Award it to Fred and see what happens.
Def
-
sorry I did some basic manufacturer badges using the same format as the title badges
Seems to work...
-
Ok. I'm not seeing anything.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login