127 Hours Blade.
-
@English333 said:
If you were caught in a similar predicament what blade would you want to...well you know. No limits - fixed, multi, folder, hatchet. What would you choose and why?Lol, reading your question actually sent shivers down my spine! I guess it's because not only is it a true story but a similar situation could happen to anyone of us be it today, tomorrow, next year or even in the next hour.
To be caught in a situation where your only chance of staying alive is by having to amputate one of your own limbs is just horrific. But I guess we'd all do it or die trying.
What would I pick to get the bloody job done and over with??
.....of the top of my head I'm thinking along the lines of LM's serrated blades, probably the wave. All major blades OHO, first serrated then bonewood saw :ahhhWait... How about the Vic XXLT...you could then cauterise the blood flow!

-
I would think there are few people who could actually 'do' the deed ?
most people in that situation would keep putting off the 'job', hoping for a miracle, until they were to weak to amputate anything.
it's purely hypothetical (hopefully
) but I think if you could do it you could do it with any blade ? something that struck me when I read Mr Ralstons book was that the tool he described was ~
A) a cheep multitool from a "gas station" (given to him by his mother I believe?)
&
B) he had been digging at a large rock with the blade !!!
so it wasn't 'shaving sharp' ::) -
@English333 said:
If you were caught in a similar predicament what blade would you want to...well you know. No limits - fixed, multi, folder, hatchet. What would you choose and why?Gurkha Kukri and a shield.
-
I honestly think I'd rather have a machete. I could probably resign myself to amputation a limb if I could lop it off quickly rather than carve away at it.
But then that situation is much more unlikely for me as someone always knows where I'm going and it shouldn't be too hard to find me. If I was in a situation like that I'm sure for me it would more likely be a matter of surviving until someone finds me.
Def
-
Satellite phone with batteries and gps.
-
Good question , I'm just reading the book at the moment.
I've usually got a a 108mm sak a craftsman or a swisschamp and if Id got my backpack in that situation id have a silkie pocket boy so I think I'd have a good selection of amputation tools on me. -
A meat cleaver ,quick and clean,

-
From Wikipedia, he used a cheap MT.
Ralston prepared to amputate his trapped right arm at a point on the mid-forearm, in order to escape. He experimented with tourniquets and made some exploratory superficial cuts to his forearm in the first few days. On the fourth day he realized that in order to free his arm he would have to cut through the bones in it, but the tools he had available were insufficient to do so.
When he ran out of food and water on the fifth day, he was forced to drink his own urine. He carved his name, date of birth and presumed date of death into the sandstone canyon wall, and videotaped his last goodbyes to his family. He did not expect to survive the night. After waking at dawn the following day (Thursday, May 1) he had an epiphany that he could break his radius and ulna bones using torque against his trapped arm. He did so, then performed the amputation, which took about one hour with his multi-tool, which included a dull two-inch knife. He never named the manufacturer of the tool he used, other than to say it was not a Leatherman but "what you'd get if you bought a $15 flashlight and got a free multi use tool".[7]
-
Yikes :o
I cannot even imagine the scenario. I believe I could amputate someones arm or leg in this type situation by my own :ahhh. I cannot even begin to imagine.
-
Hmm lets see.. machete with hollow handle containing morphine. :D And Im going to assume I have a belt to use for a tourniquet.
-
Flight school has beat it into my brain: file a flight plan. Let someone know that you are going somewhere, roughly where, and how long you anticipate being out. Going with someone adds a layer of safety.
Carrying a PLB or some form of communications equipment isn't unwise; I don't stray too far from cell coverage without my dual band portable.
I saw the movie a couple years ago, and IIRC they depicted him using a standard red-handled SAK which he dulled or damaged by trying to chip away at the rock.
If I absolutely had to amputate a human arm with one of my tools, I think I would choose my Wave. No doubt though, I would probably have died in that canyon.
-
A meat cleaver ,quick and clean,


:D
in all seriously if it was in a bushcraft situation i would have my kukri,plus a folding saw,if while mtb'ing it would be a mt,probably my spirit,could i do it,i guess i could,i snapped my ankle while mtb'ing 14 years ago,i had no phone so had to hobble using my bike as a crutch for 3miles untill i found someone too help,ok not like hacking a arm off but it was a bad break,after watching 127 hours my wife makes me leave a note as too where ive gone :D
-

::)
:D

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
