Interesting Old SAK
-
-
Yah - I guess it's a Vic (Armee Suisse) - I assume there were't really fakes in those days
Terrible condition - But looks like it would clean up well.
However for $350 - I don't think so!!
-
hmmm, proto-Alox
-
Any thought on if the scales are factory ?
... I see quite a few 1908 army issues in aluminium ... ok 5 or 6 :) it would make sense if they were to be used any where where they would get wet.
I think the condition is fair .... as for the price pretty much depends if it is factory or a mod .... also any one see one cheaper anywhere :)
-
A very cool knife.
But there is something odd about the overly-rounded shape of the leather punch; I thought the SAK wood saws had slanted and not vertical teeth until the 1950s or so; and I have never seen an Armee Suisse tang stamp earlier than about 1930. The Gesetzlich Geshutst screwdriver (without caplifter of the early soldier) on this knife looks longer than the Elseners (maybe it's the perspective of the photo angle) and was phased out like in the 19-teens.
So is it possible that this knife was made by a factory other than Victorinox? The figured bail is like theirs... Maybe somebody made it from assembled parts and custom aluminum scales.
Have never seen one like this and you will not see one again. $350... -
Have an old Wenger with aluminum scales, so a similar Vic is not out of the question.
Didn't JazzBass come up with an old alox-handles Vic a while back?
-
@J Mackrel Jones said:
Maybe somebody made it from assembled parts and custom aluminum scales.
Have never seen one like this and you will not see one again. $350...That was my guess. Biggest issue I had was the 4 turn corkscrew. I've seen Victorinox knives from 1897 on and never seen one before 1973 that has a 4 turn corkscrew. Wengers, on the other hand, did have them.
When it comes to older knives, without seeing the knife in person, it's very hard to say what it really is. Knives before 1940 are largely hand made so there are a lot of variations even between two factory made knives. I've seen knives that were <u>clearly</u> not Victorinox knives with Elsener blades in them, indicating that someone in the last 100 years took a blade from a Victorinox knife and put it in their own.
Modding knives is pretty easy if you have basic mechanical skills. It's not that unlikely that people have been doing it for many years.
-
Thanks as always for the info.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login