ST300 & SwissTool
-
I sold my Swisstool because it was hard to open the tools.
-
@SteveC said:
I sold my Swisstool because it was hard to open the tools.I have 2 that have the same issues. I wont send them to Vic because unlike LM they take their sweet time.
I like my Swisstool way more than the Spirit and as much as I like my ST300. If you don't need or cannot have OHO tools then both hit the mark hard.
Having longer flanges on the philips the ST300 gets the nod from me.
Main blade on ST300 has a bit more utility being pointier bit more cutting edge. I dont like the way its oriented on the tool however. Vic did a better job with the cutting edge positioned along the frame.
ST300 awl better IMO
154CM cutters no contest.
I prefer the locks on the Swisstool. They are more natural to release I can close each tool one handed.
Swisstool has a flipping chisel. I love this tool so much. Come on LM do a chisel
I dare ya.Swisstool has an amazing crate opener thing. This tool is a beast and is so handy to have.
I have zero issues with beating the Swisstool within inches of its life. I have hammered with it, pryed things that would have busted most other tools, and over all used it like I stole it.
I like them both and for different reasons.
-
Well said Aloha. I enjoy my Swisstool, but unfortunately, I've found it to be too heavy for carry in most outfits I wear. Same with my ST200 as well.
Sent from my XT901 using Tapatalk
-
Update: two weeks into testing, my brother keep asking when he can switch back to ST300.
-
This is outcome I expected .
-
Both are very good tools for those folks that have the hand span to get full benefit from them. The Swisstool CS Plus wins for me on chisel/scrapers, scissors, awl, and the bit wrench. Putting aside the CS+ or X model, the choice is a more even one, though the Swisstool still benefits from the external blades and saw, which would likely swing it for me. My modest hand size means that neither would make regular daily carry though
-
I like the Swisstool very much for the reasons I mentioned earlier in this thread. I have always liked the bluntish plier head as well. The ST300 was a nice surprise to me when I first got it. I agree with 50ft tho on the handle splay, if you have small to med sized hands then these very well may not be the tools for you.
I think sometimes we all get a bit "familiar" and "settled" with our tools. In order to be swayed requires a clearly "superior" tool. Small advantages don't outweigh the familiar nor do "special" implements one tool might have ( chisel for example ).
These are my thoughts YMMV.
-
@Aloha007 said:
I like the Swisstool very much for the reasons I mentioned earlier in this thread. I have always liked the bluntish plier head as well. The ST300 was a nice surprise to me when I first got it. I agree with 50ft tho on the handle splay, if you have small to med sized hands then these very well may not be the tools for you.I think sometimes we all get a bit "familiar" and "settled" with our tools. In order to be swayed requires a clearly "superior" tool. Small advantages don't outweigh the familiar nor do "special" implements one tool might have ( chisel for example ).
These are my thoughts YMMV.
I'm terrible with this kind of thinking. Even if it is a lesser MT, use it enough and I'll bond with it. Time can do funny things.
-
I've noticed just thru videos, here, and other sources that while folks have several options of ( fill in the blank ) those same folks tend to keep with a "known" item. Switching from my SS Wave to a Polished Wave then to my BO Wave was a "process"
. -
@Aloha007 said:
I think sometimes we all get a bit "familiar" and "settled" with our tools. In order to be swayed requires a clearly "superior" tool. Small advantages don't outweigh the familiar nor do "special" implements one tool might have ( chisel for example ).Agree, sometime those are important factors.
But men often jump on new and pretty, exciting young things and ditch the old ones..(ask their ex-wives)
-
Mother's Day get together, I caught my brother carry his ST300! Busted.

He has some explaining to do. -
I think sometimes we all get a bit "familiar" and "settled" with our tools. In order to be swayed requires a clearly "superior" tool. Small advantages don't outweigh the familiar nor do "special" implements one tool might have ( chisel for example ).
Agree, sometime those are important factors.
But men often jump on new and pretty, exciting young things and ditch the old ones..(ask their ex-wives)
Even if they remind you of grandma in some sort of way as pointed out earlier?
Edit, sorry thread dyslexics I'm guessing, was in another thread.That hit the nail on the head for me.
Still haven't shook that thought. -
Sorry I didn't understand what you mean.
-
@Aloha007 said:
I think sometimes we all get a bit "familiar" and "settled" with our tools. In order to be swayed requires a clearly "superior" tool.I went from a Supertool to Wave for my work EDC and that spanned about 18 years. Then I got a SwissTool as a gift. Was immediately sold on the spring loaded external tools. I wasn't going to go back to a heavy tool again so I ordered a Spirit. The spring loaded external tools were that game changer for me. Can't fathom giving them up. Why in the world Leatherman hasn't jumped on that band wagon is one of life's great mysteries....
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
My apologies, I was thinking of a post a member made about swisstools in another thread where they had said,...
"The appearance reminded them of grandma's cutlery."
Not quoting anyone, just that idea resonated with me, and it might with your brother subconsciously as well if given one tool before the other and swayed him. -
I also like my Swisstool for the quality.
If the Supertool had better quality i would like it a bit better but on mine the quality was too low for in comparison with my Swisstool.
Handles didn't close flat so the tool rattled when i walked.
The friction that keeps the handles open and closed was worn within two months and so it became a balisong multitool.
The file was machined very bad and only half way.I sold it for those reasons.
I have the feeling that Victorinox wants to sell excellent tools that last a life time.
And leatherman is more after my money than my satisfaction with their products.My opinion.
-
I agree that the Swisstool is very high quality but for me it was to way too hard to open the tools on compared to my Rebar and other LM's which are super easy. So for me a very high quality tool is no use to me if it's a pain to use.
Function over fashion every time for me.
-
@SteveC said:
I agree that the Swisstool is very high quality but for me it was to way too hard to open the tools on compared to my Rebar and other LM's which are super easy. So for me a very high quality tool is no use to me if it's a pain to use.Function over fashion every time for me.
I don't have any problems with my Swisstool and i don't think or heard that there are a couple of bad examples from the factory that slipped qc.
Do you cut your nails very short.
Because if you own a Victorinox there is one thing you shouldn't do: cut your thumb nails extremely short. Couldn't open the tool for a week :D.A friend of mine has very strange nails. They lay almost flat on his fingers,i don't know if he is able to open a Victorinox.
See the picture.
-
I worked roadside emergency service for last two years, my nails get soft when wet and can't open nadda on side of road in that case. Being it's white out here for six months a year that is an issue for me, jmtc.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
