Danish Knife Law
-
First off, I'm sorry if a similar topic has already been started, but I wasn't able to find one. Secondly, if the mods think this belongs in the knife-section of the forum, please move it. :)
Basically, I just need to vent my frustations a bit. As some of the danish member problably have noticed, there's a big debate going on, with the danish knife law.
Recently, a group called Denmarks Hunters Association (Danmarks Jægerforbund) posted a video on Facebook, with 6 different knives, all of which were bought in Denmark; some in sporting stores, others in normal supermarkets. They displayed how all 6 of them could be open one-handed, and therefore are illegal, according to danish law. They even showed a corkscrew, with a foil-cutter, which could be opened one-handed.For quite some years, the general view has been that if a knife was designed to be used one-handed, it was illegal. But recently a court ruled that any knife, that could be opened one-handed, falls under that category and is therefore illegal to own, sell and use. And yes, that includes our beloved SAKs and several other multitools. I had to take a look at my collection of pocket knives and multis, to see which ones could be opened with one hand - only 1 out of 12 tools, passed that test. And that is all knives and multis that I've either bought in Denmark or that has been for sale in Denmark within the last 4 years.
Even something as my girlfriends Signature might be illegal - it doesn't matter if she or any of her co-workers can open it with one hand; it just takes one person (most likely the police officer checking the knife), to be able to open it with one hand. We've reached a point, where you potentially could be labeled as a criminal, because you bring a corkscrew to a picnic. If I use a utility knife at work and forget to take it out of my pockets before I leave, I would effectively be breaking the law.
I'm sure the danish politicians are stumped, as to why the United States doesn't have any more problems with knives, with the current law as it is. This is outrageous!
The worst part, is almost the fact that if you desire to be a law-abiding citizen and want to turn your "illegal" knives in, you can't do it, without facing the penalty, even if the knife were bought when it was legal.
We are reaching a point, where any version of one of mans oldest tools, is illegal...
</rant>

-
That really sux!!!!! Wow!!!! Texas recently ok'd switchblades so it's the opposite here.
-
I almost forgot... Yesterday, the owner of a hunting-shop about 20 miles from here, got a fine for 100.000 DKK, just under 15.000 USD, for selling 44 illegal knives - knives that he thought was legal. I've seen several interviews with owners of hunting stores, who aren't able to tell if a knife is legal or not anymore; it seems that alot of them might stop selling knives all together, due to the hassle.
-
How do you cut meat?
Are allowed fixed blades???

Crazy!

Original SAKs are OHO??? It is very difficult for me!!! ??? ??? ???
-
@alexTOOL said:
How do you cut meat?Are allowed fixed blades???

Crazy!

Original SAKs are OHO??? It is very difficult for me!!! ??? ??? ???
So far, kitchen knives are still legal - as long as they're in your home. Fixed blades out in public isn't legal, unless you have a specific purporse, like you're using it for work, you're hunting, being a scout and so on. However, if you have a fixed blade with you (as far as I remember), you are not allowed to, by example, go shopping between your home and your destination. You have to go straight from your home to your destination and back, without any stops.
I've checked with a modded Explorer (added alox scales from a fake SAK, but the insides are still original), a Spartan and a 1-layer Wenger, with a blade and can opener and I can fairly easy open all 3 with one hand. I wouldn't do it, unless I had a specific reason, as I don't really like the idea of cutting myself, but it is possible.
I think it was a guy from a hunting store in Odense that said in a interview, that whether or not your knife can be opened one-handed, depends on the patience and willingness to get cut, of the officer who is testing it. If you don't mind getting cut, you can open almost all knives one-handed. -
That is just insane and honestly cannot comment without going political and losing my cool so I will not say much besides it is completely ridiculous.
-
This sounds more like a ridiculous drinking game than sane law making.

Do you gave any interest groups, like the aforementioned hunter's association working for a saner situation, or do the usual nanny state interests have the debate, if any, to themselves?
-
@Steinar said:
This sounds more like a ridiculous drinking game than sane law making.
Do you gave any interest groups, like the aforementioned hunter's association working for a saner situation, or do the usual nanny state interests have the debate, if any, to themselves?
The hunters association is doing alot of work, to pressure the government into changing the law and a few politicians have already made statements that they will look into it. We're coming up on an election in a few months and this seems like a cause that most people can get behind, so we problably won't see any change until after the election, but one can only hope that the knife law will undergo serious scrutiny.
The idea with banning OHO blades and locking blades, was mainly to avoid stabbings in the nightlife, but if you're setting out to stab someone, you problably won't care about the law anyway. -
Firstly thank you for bringing this to our attention

It must be immensely frustrating for anyone in retail, or anyone who uses a bladed item outside the realms of home cooking. We as enthusiasts are a little biased on the whole as to what we think people should be able to own, use and carry. Without getting into sociopolitical rhetoric, this is an appauling situation primarily due to the lack of clarity. You cannot abide by, appeal against, or draw concessions against a law when nobody knows what that law does and doesn't cover.
I hope for the nation's sake the whole affair is reviewed and resolved soon for the retailers (and other related employment), and the general public as a whole.
-
And how about a SAK like this:

No locking + rounded blade tip.
Impossible to stab anybody!!!


-
If you are going to stab someone there are plenty of items capable of doing the job. Are screwdrivers illegal to carry as well

-
@alexTOOL said:
And how about a SAK like this:

No locking + rounded blade tip.
Impossible to stab anybody!!!


Trust me, if you can open it with one hand, it wouldn't be a good idea to use it in front of a police officer in Denmark these days...

@50ft-trad said:
Firstly thank you for bringing this to our attention
It must be immensely frustrating for anyone in retail, or anyone who uses a bladed item outside the realms of home cooking. We as enthusiasts are a little biased on the whole as to what we think people should be able to own, use and carry. Without getting into sociopolitical rhetoric, this is an appauling situation primarily due to the lack of clarity. You cannot abide by, appeal against, or draw concessions against a law when nobody knows what that law does and doesn't cover.
I hope for the nation's sake the whole affair is reviewed and resolved soon for the retailers (and other related employment), and the general public as a whole.
To be honest, I'm even concerned about using a utility knife at work these days. I still carry my Explorer and Gerber Suspension with me, when I'm at work, but I do my best to keep them away from where the customers can see them. My girlfriend even told me about a customer where she works, who saw her using her Signature and claimed that it was illegal. You can do more damage with a damn car key!
I just checked the hunters associations webpage and I can see that at least 9 media outlets have reported on this in one way or another, so it's definitely something that's got the peoples attention by now.
@SteveC said:
If you are going to stab someone there are plenty of items capable of doing the job. Are screwdrivers illegal to carry as well
Well, if you're going out drinking, I wouldn't recommend having a screwdriver in your pocket, but I honestly don't know if it would be illegal to carry one with you in the daytime. If you look the part, a carpenter or similar, most people wouldn't think twice about it, but from a legal standpoint, I have no idea. Wouldn't be surprised if it were illegal though.
-
I can see that all the attention from the media isn't necessarily a good thing. A danish storechain, called Dansk Supermarked, has in some of the stores sold different multis, from Bahco, Black & Decker and Hi-Tec. Apparently, it said on their website that the tools could be used with one hand - they've been removed from their sites and I don't have the specific model-names, so I can't check.
It even got to the point where someone actually reported one of the stores to the police, for violating the weapons law, by selling illegal knives.
One of the multis in question, is the one in the picture below. The article mentioned three different tools, but this is the only one with a picture. -
Freaver, isn't the Suspension actually designed to be OHO?
-
@50ft-trad said:
Freaver, isn't the Suspension actually designed to be OHO?Yes it is. Nonetheless, the shop right across from where I work, sold them about a year ago. I know that it's illegal and I wouldn't make a thing of it, if it gets confiscated and I get a fine. For that same reason, I only carry it, when I'm at work. I'd never dream of using it in public.
My problem is with the knives that only "speSmurfpillsts" would call one-handed, such as the SAKs. I like to think that I know a fair deal about the danish knife law, but when we get to a point where even hunters and owner of hunting stores doesn't know what's right and what's wrong, then we've got a bad situation.Just to use the Suspension as an example: I'm well aware that I'm carrying a multitool with a knifeblade that makes it illegal, according to danish law - I've made an intentional choice, to carry that multitool, knowing that.
The kid that gets an old Böker from his dad or the scout buying his first SAK, might unwillingly be breaking the law. -
I fully appreciate what you are saying there, and I hope you all get a speedy and balanced resolution to the matter

-
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
I fully appreciate what you are saying there, and I hope you all get a speedy and balanced resolution to the matter

When the government is handling things this is never the case. In the USA at least.
I'd imagine many members here feel the same about their own countries. I can still hope though :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
I fully appreciate what you are saying there, and I hope you all get a speedy and balanced resolution to the matter

When the government is handling things this is never the case. In the USA at least.
I'd imagine many members here feel the same about their own countries. I can still hope though :D
Most definitely.

-
The Captain beat me to it - when making restrictions, it takes no time; when losing restrictions, it takes ages. I just hope we'll know more by the end of the month.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


