Danish Knife Law
-
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
I fully appreciate what you are saying there, and I hope you all get a speedy and balanced resolution to the matter

When the government is handling things this is never the case. In the USA at least.
I'd imagine many members here feel the same about their own countries. I can still hope though :D
Most definitely.

-
The Captain beat me to it - when making restrictions, it takes no time; when losing restrictions, it takes ages. I just hope we'll know more by the end of the month.
-
I kind of have to wonder... is there any REASON for this restriction? Like, did some nutjob go on a rampage and kill a busload of orphans or something? Or is there a 'Mothers against anything with an edge' coalition group whipping up hysteria?
I'm not trying to be too glib here, but jeez...
The fact that some cop has practiced and practiced to be able to OHO a 91mm SAK should NOT make someone consider a knife OHO. There's a woman who shoots archery with her feet. That doesn't make bows a weapon that any sane person would consider foot operated.
As for the 58mm line being outlawed... As others have pointed out, screwdrivers are a vastly better weapon. I actually knew a guy who went to prison for robbing a gas station with a screwdriver, one of the big foot-long ones. That'd be a foot-long screwdriver, not a footlong gas station. :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I kind of have to wonder... is there any REASON for this restriction?YES!
As Capt already indicated:
@captain spaulding said:
That is just insane and honestly cannot comment without going political and losing my cool so I will not say much besides it is completely ridiculous.Communism spreads through variety of methods/movements throughout Europe.
-
Sounds exactly like what is happening in USA to restrict fire arms ownership.
My suggestion is like what NRA calls gun owners to do: STAND AND FIGHT!
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I kind of have to wonder... is there any REASON for this restriction?
YES!
As Capt already indicated:
@captain spaulding said:
That is just insane and honestly cannot comment without going political and losing my cool so I will not say much besides it is completely ridiculous.Communism spreads through variety of methods/movements throughout Europe.
Communism.. Really? We are so close getting all political here... let's keep the gargamel out of here ok?
-
GARGAMEL! RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!

Oh, wait; What the smurf is that smurf doing with the toothpick?
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I kind of have to wonder... is there any REASON for this restriction? Like, did some nutjob go on a rampage and kill a busload of orphans or something? Or is there a 'Mothers against anything with an edge' coalition group whipping up hysteria?As far as I know, no. Admittedly, when they "tightened the noose" the first time, there was alot of problems with stabbings, between mostly immigrant gangs, but as already pointed out, they don't care if they're carrying an illegal knife. At this point, the law is just incriminating just about everyone.
@Lynn LeFey said:
The fact that some cop has practiced and practiced to be able to OHO a 91mm SAK should NOT make someone consider a knife OHO. There's a woman who shoots archery with her feet. That doesn't make bows a weapon that any sane person would consider foot operated.Like I mentioned in my first post, I've tried and succeded at opening - with one hand - the 12 knives and multitools showed in the first post. That includes a modded Explorer, with "fake" Alox scales; it didn't take me that long to open it either. Most of them, I could open pretty easily on my first try. It's not a way I would prefer to do it, as it's uncomfortable and dangerous, but it is possible. Even the orange one, which I thought wouldn't be included in this, is actually OHO, if you have the finger strength for it. I actually thought that would be near impossible, since it's so relatively close in design, to the Lansky World Legal.
If it was something like a Swisschamp, it would problably be alot more difficult, but I still think it would be possible, with very little training.
BTW, the Lansky World Legal is a knife I would <u>love</u> to try opening one-handed. If anyone got one, can you please confirm whether or not it would be possible?@Kampfer said:
Sounds exactly like what is happening in USA to restrict fire arms ownership.My suggestion is like what NRA calls gun owners to do: STAND AND FIGHT!
That is already happening - not on as big a scale as could be wanted, but it is happening. Right now, I think people are waiting for an official statement from the politicians and the courts, both to clarify exactly what the definition of an illegal knife is, and to hear if they are going to review the law and hopefully loosen it up a bit.
The big problem is, that the original definition, was that any knife <u>designed</u> to be OHO, was illegal. Last year, there was a case that made it to High Court, where the ruling ended up being that any knife that a person could open with one hand - even if it took several tries - were to be considered OHO and therefore illegal. Already at that point, the downward spiral began.
I still only see two politicians going into this matter and so far, it'll take at least a few months before they decide whether to change the law or not.
-
Over here in Ireland, knives and pointy objects of any description are illegal in a public area, according to the law.
This includes toothpicks.
It does have a stipulation that if you have a valid reasonable
excusereason to carry, you can do so.
The reason needs to be better as the knife/spear/toothpick gets bigger.
I am certain that the Guard will let you off the hook for carrying a toothpick as long as you are not acting in an offensive manner.
Its different with a OHT, and fixed blades. -
What happens if you only have one working hand? For example someone with a deformity or amputation? So then because of your disability you become even more limited by not being able to carry a tool as it is illegal....stupid laws stupid lawmakers.
-
Or a buddy!
I think that the swiss have got their knife laws right on the nail.
You wont get a second glance from the police or the public for carrying a SAK/Multitool with no locking blades, and you need a reasonable reason to carry anything like a fixed blade over a certain size, or assisted opening knifes(switchblades, balisongs, etc), or one handed opening knives.The best part is that people that are missing a limb or have a medical condition preventing them from using a normal SAK are legally allowed to carry such knives. :D
Notice: I only read this on the net and have not been to Switzerland. I cannot guarantee this info in any shape as being correct from a legal standpoint!
-
@Freaver said:
BTW, the Lansky World Legal is a knife I would <u>love</u> to try opening one-handed. If anyone got one, can you please confirm whether or not it would be possible?From the Lansky World Legal Knife thread.
@Etherealicer said:
I also can open it one handed... -
I'm a little disappointed about the Danish high court ruling, since it sounds like it ignored the premises of the law. I'm accustomed to the lower levels being "pragmatic", while high court rulings focusing on general principles and take the premises and papers that went into making a law more into account. (Reasonably enough when looking at the respective roles for the different levels.)
(And Pablo O'Brien, don't be ashamed about the Irish law... Much of Europe, Norway very much included, have knife laws which seem focused more on giving the police arbitrary powers than making life better and making it easy to be a law-abiding citizen...)
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Or a buddy!I think that the swiss have got their knife laws right on the nail.
You wont get a second glance from the police or the public for carrying a SAK/Multitool with no locking blades, and you need a reasonable reason to carry anything like a fixed blade over a certain size, or assisted opening knifes(switchblades, balisongs, etc), or one handed opening knives.The best part is that people that are missing a limb or have a medical condition preventing them from using a normal SAK are legally allowed to carry such knives. :D
Notice: I only read this on the net and have not been to Switzerland. I cannot guarantee this info in any shape as being correct from a legal standpoint!
I would have to respectfully disagree. People should be able to carry any knife they please without restriction. Why should I not be able to carry a locking folding knife? What is considered a reasonable reason? A reasonable reason in my opinion is because I wan't to and some high paid government official should not be able to decide if that is acceptable to him/her.
-
That would be nice capt, except that it is unlikely that it wouls happen, thanks to the public, goverenment, media, etc.
The most I think we can hope for is unrestricted SAK carry, and maybe some of the smaller folders and fixed blades.
Everything else would need a "reasonable reason" to carry.As long as knife stabbings and suchlike bad publicity, the public will not allow free carry, even if most of this bad press comes from people wielding kitchen knives.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
That would be nice capt, except that it is unlikely that it wouls happen, thanks to the public, goverenment, media, etc.The most I think we can hope for is unrestricted SAK carry, and maybe some of the smaller folders and fixed blades.
Everything else would need a "reasonable reason" to carry.As long as knife stabbings and suchlike bad publicity, the public will not allow free carry, even if most of this bad press comes from people wielding kitchen knives.

Yea, it really is a shame. I feel bad for you guys, but hope for the best.

-
This thread reminds me of George Orwell's 1984, where you can't have a razor blade.
-
@firiki said:
This thread reminds me of George Orwell's 1984, where you can't have a razor blade.The important observation of 1984 is by making vague laws, the regime made people self-police themselves to a very strict standard, since it was hard to know whether your broke the law. Sounds familiar?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


