Danish Knife Law
-
That would be nice capt, except that it is unlikely that it wouls happen, thanks to the public, goverenment, media, etc.
The most I think we can hope for is unrestricted SAK carry, and maybe some of the smaller folders and fixed blades.
Everything else would need a "reasonable reason" to carry.As long as knife stabbings and suchlike bad publicity, the public will not allow free carry, even if most of this bad press comes from people wielding kitchen knives.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
That would be nice capt, except that it is unlikely that it wouls happen, thanks to the public, goverenment, media, etc.The most I think we can hope for is unrestricted SAK carry, and maybe some of the smaller folders and fixed blades.
Everything else would need a "reasonable reason" to carry.As long as knife stabbings and suchlike bad publicity, the public will not allow free carry, even if most of this bad press comes from people wielding kitchen knives.

Yea, it really is a shame. I feel bad for you guys, but hope for the best.

-
This thread reminds me of George Orwell's 1984, where you can't have a razor blade.
-
@firiki said:
This thread reminds me of George Orwell's 1984, where you can't have a razor blade.The important observation of 1984 is by making vague laws, the regime made people self-police themselves to a very strict standard, since it was hard to know whether your broke the law. Sounds familiar?
-
Modern legislation tend to be more vague, allowing flexibility. (compare some laws from 50, 60 years ago to some modern Laws). The old laws were a lot more descriptive and offered very little flexibility.
There is, however, a general legal principle that since the government comes from a position of authority when enforcing the Laws in case of vagueness, the discretion allowed should be in the interest of the person "ruled" meaning that the whole government should be "nice" and understanding. So if you are not endangering other people the government should not try to make a safe tool appear dangerous, just so that you get punished. The grey zone should be used in the interest of the person, not so as to punish the person. Ofcourse, not all nations have the same legal beginnings or principles. for example US legal system is different to the mainland European legal system, which is different to the UK system, because of differing beginnings, ideas, scope etc.
Anyway, I will stop boring people with legal matters now.
-
This thread reminds me of George Orwell's 1984, where you can't have a razor blade.
The important observation of 1984 is by making vague laws, the regime made people self-police themselves to a very strict standard, since it was hard to know whether your broke the law. Sounds familiar?
It's been almost 20 years since I read that book but it does ring a bell, yes.
:ahhh
-
@dks said:
Ofcourse, not all nations have the same legal beginnings or principles. for example US legal system is different to the mainland European legal system, which is different to the UK system, because of differing beginnings, ideas, scope etc.It's true. Here, I'd like to quote Odysseas Elytis' verse "where you hear order, there's the smell of human flesh".
-
@dks said:
Modern legislation tend to be more vague, allowing flexibility. (compare some laws from 50, 60 years ago to some modern Laws). The old laws were a lot more descriptive and offered very little flexibility.There is, however, a general legal principle that since the government comes from a position of authority when enforcing the Laws in case of vagueness, the discretion allowed should be in the interest of the person "ruled" meaning that the whole government should be "nice" and understanding. So if you are not endangering other people the government should not try to make a safe tool appear dangerous, just so that you get punished. The grey zone should be used in the interest of the person, not so as to punish the person. Ofcourse, not all nations have the same legal beginnings or principles. for example US legal system is different to the mainland European legal system, which is different to the UK system, because of differing beginnings, ideas, scope etc.
Yes, it is a very good and reasonable principle, which the Danish high court obviously has found rather irrelevant.
-
In theory a legal challenge could be pursued on that principle, or an EU court ruling could be sought, which ofcourse, if it agrees with the Danish court may screw things up for all of us in Europe
...It all depends on the legal system of Denmark, of which I know very little about..
-
@captain spaulding said:
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Or a buddy!
I think that the swiss have got their knife laws right on the nail.
You wont get a second glance from the police or the public for carrying a SAK/Multitool with no locking blades, and you need a reasonable reason to carry anything like a fixed blade over a certain size, or assisted opening knifes(switchblades, balisongs, etc), or one handed opening knives.The best part is that people that are missing a limb or have a medical condition preventing them from using a normal SAK are legally allowed to carry such knives. :D
Notice: I only read this on the net and have not been to Switzerland. I cannot guarantee this info in any shape as being correct from a legal standpoint!
I would have to respectfully disagree. People should be able to carry any knife they please without restriction. Why should I not be able to carry a locking folding knife? What is considered a reasonable reason? A reasonable reason in my opinion is because I wan't to and some high paid government official should not be able to decide if that is acceptable to him/her.
I mostly agree with you, on that one. Unless you need it for work, hunt or similar, I don't see any reason to carry a fixed blade or a folder with a blade that's over 5 inches long. All this time I've been EDC'ing knives, the Danish maximum of 2.75" has been more than enough for my needs, both at home and at work.
If it were up to me, I'd say that OHO locking blades, with a maximum length of 3" should be legal - and then of course increase the efforts on making sure that people don't bring knives with them, when they're going drinking/partying.
Either that, or something along the lines of what they have in the UK - if I remember correctly, a folder in the UK can be either OHO or locking, but not both. Don't know about the length of the blade though, but I think it's just about the 2.75-3" mark?@dks said:
In theory a legal challenge could be pursued on that principle, or an EU court ruling could be sought, which ofcourse, if it agrees with the Danish court may screw things up for all of us in Europe
...It all depends on the legal system of Denmark, of which I know very little about..
I'm not too strong in legal matters, but I'd think this case would be "too small" for an EU court?
-
@Freaver said:
I mostly agree with you, on that one. Unless you need it for work, hunt or similar, I don't see any reason to carry a fixed blade or a folder with a blade that's over 5 inches long. All this time I've been EDC'ing knives, the Danish maximum of 2.75" has been more than enough for my needs, both at home and at work.If it were up to me, I'd say that OHO locking blades, with a maximum length of 3" should be legal - and then of course increase the efforts on making sure that people don't bring knives with them, when they're going drinking/partying.
Either that, or something along the lines of what they have in the UK - if I remember correctly, a folder in the UK can be either OHO or locking, but not both. Don't know about the length of the blade though, but I think it's just about the 2.75-3" mark?Just because a 2.75" blade has been more than enough for YOU why does that mean everyone else should be limited to that as well? Just because you do not see any reason to have a larger blade does not mean someone else has a legitimate reason or simply a desire to carry a larger knife. The real problem I have with it is why should anyone be able to tell you what you can and cannot carry?
"Oh it's for the safety of the people", blah, blah, blah. The criminals are going to get/have whatever blades they wan't and it was mentioned that the criminals are not using pocket knives in their crimes anyways. Its kitchen knives that are the main blade of choice.
I know my opinions on these things might not be the most popular, but these laws are only hurting law abiding citizens and further enforcing the governments power to control the law abiding citizens while doing nothing to stop the criminals. Same story different country. It happens all over the world.
I am sure our different views have to do with many things including personal opinions as well as being raised in two very different countries. I am in no way saying I am right and you are wrong. These are just my opinions and what I think on the matter.
Please do not think I am directing this towards you personally because I am definitely not. I know its hard to determine this over the internet and when reading we always put our own impression on the writing and i'm sure it sounds like I am directing this at you.On the lighter side of things are you still not smoking? I quit 12 days ago and am not looking back.

-
@captain spaulding said:
I mostly agree with you, on that one. Unless you need it for work, hunt or similar, I don't see any reason to carry a fixed blade or a folder with a blade that's over 5 inches long. All this time I've been EDC'ing knives, the Danish maximum of 2.75" has been more than enough for my needs, both at home and at work.
If it were up to me, I'd say that OHO locking blades, with a maximum length of 3" should be legal - and then of course increase the efforts on making sure that people don't bring knives with them, when they're going drinking/partying.
Either that, or something along the lines of what they have in the UK - if I remember correctly, a folder in the UK can be either OHO or locking, but not both. Don't know about the length of the blade though, but I think it's just about the 2.75-3" mark?Just because a 2.75" blade has been more than enough for YOU why does that mean everyone else should be limited to that as well? Just because you do not see any reason to have a larger blade does not mean someone else has a legitimate reason or simply a desire to carry a larger knife. The real problem I have with it is why should anyone be able to tell you what you can and cannot carry?
"Oh it's for the safety of the people", blah, blah, blah. The criminals are going to get/have whatever blades they wan't and it was mentioned that the criminals are not using pocket knives in their crimes anyways. Its kitchen knives that are the main blade of choice.
I know my opinions on these things might not be the most popular, but these laws are only hurting law abiding citizens and further enforcing the governments power to control the law abiding citizens while doing nothing to stop the criminals. Same story different country. It happens all over the world.
I am sure our different views have to do with many things including personal opinions as well as being raised in two very different countries. I am in no way saying I am right and you are wrong. These are just my opinions and what I think on the matter.
Please do not think I am directing this towards you personally because I am definitely not. I know its hard to determine this over the internet and when reading we always put our own impression on the writing and i'm sure it sounds like I am directing this at you.On the lighter side of things are you still not smoking? I quit 12 days ago and am not looking back.

You do have a valid point about blade length, but for a long time, 2.75" have been the maximum allowed length in Denmark, so I think most Danes have been accustomed to "small" knives and can overcome most tasks with them. Of course, as a hunter, scout or other outdoors person, you're most likely going to need something bigger, but at that point, other rules comes in to play.
I feel you, with the fact that other people are trying to tell you what kind of knife/tool/sword you can or can not carry, but I fear that if switchblades, automatic knives and/or OTF-knives became normal and legal in Denmark, we would possibly see a rise in stabbings, because it gets easier to get a hold of these knives.
On many points, we agree 100% and on some others, we disagree a bit - as you mentioned yourself, this is most likely due to our own personal opinions and upbringings. :)
Regarding the smoking, I've just recently passed 12 months without a cigarette. I do admit, however, I been very happy with my electronic cigarette in that time, but hopefully I'm done with that as well, within the next 12 months.
If you don't have any helping tools, you are in for a tough ride. Even though I had my e-cigarette, I've still been battling the urge for a cigarette from time to time... -
Some interesting thoughts here, but I gotta say Capt has it nailed. Why can't anyone carry whatever they want, wherever they want, however they want? If someone is going to commit a crime, they are not going to care what the law says....they are criminals intent on committing a crime....duh. Here in Arizona you can carry guns concealed or open, knives can be whatever you choose. At least to this point the state legislature has had enough common sense to realize that restricting the freedoms of law abiding citizens has pretty much zero impact on crime.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
How about making fewer humans? If we were not so numerous there would be less crime? :D
-
I think we all should note we are getting very close to getting into a political discussion here. This is something all of us probably have strong opinions about, so I think we should tread carefully... I feel the urge to get in on a discussion (which would end up as pure politics) here myself, so I assume I'm not the only one.
-
Point of information regarding UK knife law.
If it's with a justifiable reason, such as using it for work, you can carry anything. You'd struggle to justify a 5" fixed blade for box cutting, but within reason there's no need to worry about lockers and OHO knives.
You're not allowed to carry a weapon of any sort, some things are obviously only useful as weapons (a cricket bat with nails sticking out) and some things it's a bit more grey. If you're holding up a Post Office with a carrot, that's a weapon and is illegal. If you're a load of druggies in a car with cricket bats under the seats, that's illegal. If you're a cricket enthusiast who keeps his kit in the car, that's OK.
Unless it isn't for some reason (like it's being used as a weapon), a folding knife with a blade of <3" such as a SAK is fine. There is no mention anywhere of OHO and there is a bit of case law that has defined a locking knife as not a folding knife.
-
My opinion: Danish law could do with a bit of clearing up. I think you'd struggle to have a knife that it was impossible to open with only one hand somehow, whilst still being able to open it with two.
Hopefully they'll clear it up in the direction of allowing SAKs rather than banning everything.
Where do you stand with buying knives for work?
captain spaulding:
I don't want your laws over here or anything resembling them. In my opinions the amount of gun crime you have is ridiculous and a terrible waste. You have 5 times our population and have so far this year had ten times the number of fatal police shootings than we've had over the last ten years. OK so far more people get run over and everyone's got to die eventually but I personally don't see that statistic (or any similar ones) as being something to be proud of or aim at.I respect your right to decide that that's how you want to run your country, but that's not a country I'd want to be a part of.
-
This is going no where fast as usual and will just end up being a back and forth of personal opinions that will go no where. I respect everyone's views and opinions equally and will leave it at that.

-
Any other country have written knife laws like Ireland? :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login