UK Legal Carry Thread!
-
-
not saying i'm right - i done a comparison between the juice S2 and SX, and it came up there - i've attached a screenshot. I've never played with a juice before, so i honestly have no idea.

-
@eamo said:
not saying i'm right - i done a comparison between the juice S2 and SX, and it came up there - i've attached a screenshot. I've never played with a juice before, so i honestly have no idea.Yeah...also just checked Leatherman.co.uk,they make no mention of it

-
@eamo said:
Pablo, going off topic (as usual) what are the laws here ?ok, i wouldn't bring my wave into any of the towns near me, but where i live, well you rarely see a garda, even if you're looking for one :) so it's never bothered me - then again, i live in the arse end of sam maguire country :D :D :D
and, my lads are forbidden from taking their hikers/leap outside the house without express permission from me.
Unfortunatly, knives and pointy objects of any description are ILLIEGAL to carry in public spaces in Ireland, period.
You need a good reason to carry them, like you need them for work, hunting, fishing, camping etc. Thats the kind of excuses you need to have them in a public space, and its not allowed, for example, to carry the knife into a shop on the way to camp. Or carry it at 2am.
It all depends on the guard. If he/she decides to let you off the hook after catching you with a knife, he/she can. Equally, he/she can arrest you. Its up to them.
A fuller explaination is below, with the law written out too:
http://www.bushcraft.ie/index.php/articles/58-knives-and-the-lawAs you see, its much worse than even the UK.

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Pablo, going off topic (as usual) what are the laws here ?
ok, i wouldn't bring my wave into any of the towns near me, but where i live, well you rarely see a garda, even if you're looking for one :) so it's never bothered me - then again, i live in the arse end of sam maguire country :D :D :D
and, my lads are forbidden from taking their hikers/leap outside the house without express permission from me.
Unfortunatly, knives and pointy objects of any description are ILLIEGAL to carry in public spaces in Ireland, period.
You need a good reason to carry them, like you need them for work, hunting, fishing, camping etc. Thats the kind of excuses you need to have them in a public space, and its not allowed, for example, to carry the knife into a shop on the way to camp. Or carry it at 2am.
It all depends on the guard. If he/she decides to let you off the hook after catching you with a knife, he/she can. Equally, he/she can arrest you. Its up to them.
A fuller explaination is below, with the law written out too:
http://www.bushcraft.ie/index.php/articles/58-knives-and-the-lawAs you see, its much worse than even the UK.

(Remember I'm from Norn Irn ;))
Now,that's the first time I've heard a reason from the Republic to keep the boarder!
-
Indeed! Stay away! >:D >:D
Hell down here for multi and SAK carriers.
-
wow. so my precious wave is illegal here too. that sucks.
-
In the end, it's all down to Reason.
If you look and act like an upstanding citizen, and the knife in question is a Midnite Minichamp*, it is probably safe, within Reason.
Its a case of low risk-very bad consequences.
Unlikely that you get caught-possibly a fine (or jail AND a fine) if you be caught/seen by a guard. :(I would not be worried personally about carrying a Hiker/etc in the countryside. Not many people, let alone guards.

Its up to you though.*Picked for this example because a Midnite Minichamp is possibly the least threating SAK in existence. Only 58mm long, but a ridiculous amount of layers and tools for its size(In a good way).
Thedeadly stabbyblades are far far from prominent on it.
Bonus points if the scales are pink. -
yeah, i think the gardaí seem to still have a fair amount of discretion, something which seems to have been taken from police elsewhere from my reading of things. I'm not worried about getting into hassle because of my squirt or wave, as you say, reason/intent plays a large part here.
But I have very little experience of dealing with police anywhere i've lived, other then getting the odd form signed so what do i know ??? -
Yea. I don't have any experience with the Gardaí also, but there are stories of guards seeing SAK's in cars, etc and passing on with little comment.
A small few bad stories though, but thats to be expected.
"Just Be Reasonable", maybe that will be my motto.
-
Damon,getting back to the SX,that's the surf specific Juice. That picture/site you found is the only reference to a locking Juice I've found. As a heads up,Amazon.co.uk have old S2 for about £45 at the moment.
Have a look in the Mod Squad...Gareth,50ft-trad and myself,amongst others have modded a variety of tools to a Bladeless spec for full UK legality
-
@kirk13 said:
Damon,getting back to the SX,that's the surf specific Juice. That picture/site you found is the only reference to a locking Juice I've found. As a heads up,Amazon.co.uk have old S2 for about £45 at the moment.Have a look in the Mod Squad...Gareth,50ft-trad and myself,amongst others have modded a variety of tools to a Bladeless spec for full UK legality
thanks John for that, i guess i can proceed on the basis that the juices are non locking. i have a couple months before i have to buy anything, be the end of the summer before our travels. I find MT's are like a belt - i don't feel dressed without my belt, and at the very least my squirt P4 as well.
The thing regards modding is that i also want a blade, though it's not as used as the pliers or screwdrivers, but even so, having a knife is "normal" for me - i know society seems to differ.
I would like to go with Mikes suggestion and get a farmer (or any SAK) but funds are needed elsewhere, and I prefer just one tool.
Thank you, Mike and Pablo for all the advice :)
Be interesting to see how this thread plays out over the next few years. -
I hear you Eamo,I feel naked without a knife of some sort. I would never disagree with Mike LOS about getting a Farmer,but Spartans and Tinkers can be had for under £15 delivered.
Other option...what about a Delux Tinker?
-
see the pliers on the vics are lightweight, same as my squirt. nothing wrong with them, my squirt gets a lot of use (not meaning to cause offence to anyone, i mean compared to my wave).
i have an old battered swisschamp thats been on a lot of trips with me, got a lot of use over the years, i've just gotten used to something beefier (i guess) like the wave. So, the vic and small leathermans are ruled out. My squirt covers that base.
I have time to play with my dilemma :)
Getting a seperate blade like the spartan does have an appeal though. I do like the hikers my lads have, very nice knife and covers everything needed except for the pliers.I think at this stage i might be overthinking this ??? :-[
-
@eamo said:
see the pliers on the vics are lightweight, same as my squirt. nothing wrong with them, my squirt gets a lot of use (not meaning to cause offence to anyone, i mean compared to my wave).
i have an old battered swisschamp thats been on a lot of trips with me, got a lot of use over the years, i've just gotten used to something beefier (i guess) like the wave. So, the vic and small leathermans are ruled out. My squirt covers that base.
I have time to play with my dilemma :)
Getting a seperate blade like the spartan does have an appeal though. I do like the hikers my lads have, very nice knife and covers everything needed except for the pliers.I think at this stage i might be overthinking this ??? :-[
People on MTo overthinking mo or issues like what tool? Never!

Seriously,you need a PST or PST2. Juices are ok,but they're a bit fiddly. PST chassis slips easily into the pocket,good tool load out,proper size pliers.
You know you want to

-
yes, i know i want to, but must resist, have to resist . . . . . for a couple months anyway . . . .
-
so finally, as i have a UK trip coming up, i ordered a Juice C2 - i think it's the original pre 2014 version judging from the pics which i'd prefer but don't really care either way. happy days :)
-
Hope you like the Juice. Definitely one of the more 'interesting' MTs out there IMO.
-
Gareth, would that be interesting as in "may you live in interesting times" or interesting as in "hey, thats a really cool interesting tool" ??? :D
it's not going to be my main MT, i just want to have something a bit bigger (and legal) then my squirt with me, in fact i'll leave it in the UK when i leave, for use when i'm over again during the summer (and as a tool for my host, who isn't into MT's despite my trying) - it should be with me today, hopefully.
I have a wave which i love, and a Squirt P4 which goes everywhere, for it's small size i think is a really really good little tool, bigtime. Probably my most used.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login