School Carry
-
The kid should not of even been in the office in the first place as it was mistaken identity, which if I remembering correctly would (if a adult in the court system) get your case dismissed as evidence pertaining to your case would not be admissible and your case would be dropped.
I'm not sure how correct the guy making the video is on the actual law's in bringing a knife to that particular school and the seemingly non existent guideline to determining if the knife is actually a weapon or not. The knife in question would appear to not fall into the "weapon" category, but when things like this are left up to interpretation then any case can be made to make someone a criminal and it really only goes in one direction to hurt the person being accused. The vast interpretation would rarely if ever help this particular situation.
I definitely DO NOT agree with the opinion that since he was a good kid he should be given a pass and if he was a problem child they should make a example and throw the book at him. While he might be right everyone should be punished equally no matter your moral character.
I do agree that people are in this state of worry and fear about things (in my opinion the news) portrays as weapons such as knives, but scissors which are just as dangerous if not more dangerous are completely fine and no one even thinks of them as a weapon. It just shows how easy it is to brainwash people into fear and get them to think/conform to whatever you please.
With all that said if there is a rule that says no knives at school AT ALL then this kid should of know better and deserves what he gets. If the facts about the rules are correct and there is a ban on knives that are only considered weapons then I think the kid should of not been suspended and even more so since he was wrongfully identified in the first place. If it is the second case I would press for legal action against the school.
-
I actually agree that there should be limitations when one is around kids. Not all of them are responsible and some aren't all too bright. Case and point the kid that almost broke his neck yesterday during a visit to the ZOO with the group I volunteer with.
The hard line in my opinion should be the "tool of the trade". While it might sound silly, I for one would be very disappointed if I walked into a room full of aspiring IT techs and found no tool on any one of them (or in their bags, jackets, etc.).
Being honest, I think some kind of restriction (Of course staff is exempt from this) in book is good to prevent or limit students bringing knives to schools with ill intent. Knives restriction in school is different from firearm restriction, as firearms are already much harder to obtain by a minor.
This is exactly what I meant. I remember one of my high school colleges bringing a butterfly knife to our school just to be the cool guy. Equating that with a fairly common SAK or LM knock off was complete and utter bs in my opinion as it was a technical school and on an average day we'd spend at least 2 periods in labs where equipment might fail but the tools to fix it simply weren't there (there were only some labs that had tools, however those were geared towards making things so no wonder).
In the end the guy got a pass because his father was a cop -
@captain spaulding said:
I do agree that people are in this state of worry and fear about things (in my opinion the news) portrays as weapons such as knives, but scissors which are just as dangerous if not more dangerous are completely fine and no one even thinks of them as a weapon.Many schools have policies against bringing scissors to school, and schools tend to use the blunted type. So there is awareness.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I do agree that people are in this state of worry and fear about things (in my opinion the news) portrays as weapons such as knives, but scissors which are just as dangerous if not more dangerous are completely fine and no one even thinks of them as a weapon.Many schools have policies against bringing scissors to school, and schools tend to use the blunted type. So there is awareness.
Shows how long it's been since I have been in a school. I used to carry a folder clipped onto my pocket every day at school.
-
I EDC'd a SAK from grade 6 onwards. It was a common occurrence for a teacher to ask me to cut, tighten, poke a hole, etc for them when they couldn't find scissors or what ever. When the TV show MacGyver aired, everyone laughed at how he was copying me, and wondered why he didn't have a larger, more useful SAK like my Climber. That was "the good old days" when a tool was a tool until it was used as a weapon.
A few years ago (a couple or 3 decades later), my wife and I were volunteering at my son's school and I needed to cut something. The principal was about to run off to the office to get scissors when I said "I've got it", pulled out my Champ without a though and used the scissors. The principal turned pale and looked like he was going to faint! He then whispered that he wouldn't say anything if I kept my Champ hidden for the rest of the day, but that I couldn't bring it onto the school property again. I apologized and excused myself, as I had to be going. He asked what was wrong and I told him that "I'd rather be a man than go naked" or something to that effect. Apparently the rules are flexible when volunteers are concerned, as my Champ and I were quietly encouraged to stay and help. It is good he didn't find out what was in my wife's purse (Kershaw Shallot and a Leatherman Squirt, both pink!), he might have had a heart attack! This shows how ridiculous things are these days, when everything is considered a weapon regardless of how it is used.
-
I used to carry my Skulletool to my son's school, used openly in classroom in front of his teachers, and also spotted few others dad's had Leatherman on their belts. The school my son attends is a private Christian school, so I guess the staff and parents are some what conservative in nature, less alarming see such things.
But that soon to be change as we will be sending him to public school after this summer, that was the reason I looked the laws on knife carry.
-
I have experience with the whole principal-thing, I am a freshman at a high school in the area, and I play in the orchestra, we were setting up risers for a vocal performance when a screw sheared in a hole, and we couldn't get it out. I pulled out my S54 tool chest plus, and I gave it to him. He gave it back to me, and pulled out a champ, school colors, with our logo on it! He told me that every teacher had one, and I looked in to it. Sure enough, they all do. There are no weapon rules in my school, but there just as much a suggestion as driving laws in China, so I carry a classic SD and that only.
Sent from my iPhone using A box of monkeys on a treadmill and a quantum leap
-
When I was in college I used to carry my leatherman wave/charge clipped to my pocket. They don't really care here.
-
"Weapons" and school -- it makes me shudder. What exactly is a weapon? Define that please! A folder is the worst type of knife to use in any situation. The blades can break easily if forced off side and they can be folded back on the user. As one post said, some goof used a #2 pencil for a "weapon" -- you could also use a BIC pen for that matter. Most of this is to cover, legally, the school district from being sued by the parents for harm to their children.
As far as carrying - we work in several school districts, and I have a SAK SOS kit on the right belt section followed by a Swiss Tool right behind that - nobody has ever said thing one about it. Perhaps because I am a contractor?
If they are getting "edgy" about you having a weapon on school property, perhaps it should be treated like CCW - none on school property. Not on you, not in the truck, not in any way near the school property if you are going in or working at the location. I try to group my school jobs in order, and leave my .380 home when I do those jobs. Period. Problem solved.
Perhaps you could do that too when going over to the school. It only takes one goofy principal to make an example of you, and your life miserable for a long time. Just take some advice from on old timer -- JUST do it, and make the goofy system happy and get on with life. Don't debate the subject, don't argue, just don't carry things with you if there is going to be a problem and everyone will be happy. You, your family, your lawyer, your insurance company, and whatever you maybe offending.
My 2 cents worth - your mileage may vary
-
@aerojet said:
"Weapons" and school -- it makes me shudder. What exactly is a weapon? Define that please! A folder is the worst type of knife to use in any situation. The blades can break easily if forced off side and they can be folded back on the user. As one post said, some goof used a #2 pencil for a "weapon" -- you could also use a BIC pen for that matter. Most of this is to cover, legally, the school district from being sued by the parents for harm to their children.Sure. Kids can use other items as weapons. But the difference is that kids have no need for a knife at school. Whereas a pencil or pen is a necessary tool for school. So I wouldn't say the rules are all about preventing the school from being sued. It's about the fact that some kids would, definitely, bring a knife to school specifically to be used as a weapon. Might as well make them leave it at home.
-
@hiraethus said:
84mm SAK should be OK according to the rules. Good excuse to get a small Tinker or alox Cadet.
A 91mm SAK main blade clocks in right at 2.5 inches, so it should be fine by those rules too.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I definitely DO NOT agree with the opinion that since he was a good kid he should be given a pass and if he was a problem child they should make a example and throw the book at him. While he might be right everyone should be punished equally no matter your moral character.Just for discussion purposes. Let's assume Little Joe is caught with a knife at school. He is packing a 4 inch fixed blade in his pocket in a sheath. Little Joe has been in trouble on a number of occasions, in particular using knives or other similar devices to threaten harm to his classmates and in one particular incident managed to cut a fellow student. Not seriously, but it drew blood. In addition, Little Joe has previously given illegal drugs to his classmates and was caught drinking intoxicants at school. Needless to say Little Joe because of his past problems is currently under the supervision of the juvenile division of the court. Little Joe pulled his knife from his pocket, removed it from the sheath and threatened Sally in the classroom.
Now for another example. Little Johnny has never been in trouble and has never been reprimanded or otherwise had a problem in school, with the law or otherwise. Little Johnny spent the weekend with his granddad on a camping trip. On the way home from the camping trip grandpa gave Little Johnny his Case peanut knife and told him he had owned it for 40 years but wanted to pass it along in the family. Little Johnny was very excited over receiving his first knife from his grandpa. On the way home from school Johnny removed the peanut from his jacket pocket to show it to his best friend on the bus without removing the blade from the knife.
Should the punishment for each "offense" be equal?
-
@captain spaulding said:
I definitely DO NOT agree with the opinion that since he was a good kid he should be given a pass and if he was a problem child they should make a example and throw the book at him. While he might be right everyone should be punished equally no matter your moral character.
Just for discussion purposes. Let's assume Little Joe is caught with a knife at school. He is packing a 4 inch fixed blade in his pocket in a sheath. Little Joe has been in trouble on a number of occasions, in particular using knives or other similar devices to threaten harm to his classmates and in one particular incident managed to cut a fellow student. Not seriously, but it drew blood. In addition, Little Joe has previously given illegal drugs to his classmates and was caught drinking intoxicants at school. Needless to say Little Joe because of his past problems is currently under the supervision of the juvenile division of the court. Little Joe pulled his knife from his pocket, removed it from the sheath and threatened Sally in the classroom.
Now for another example. Little Johnny has never been in trouble and has never been reprimanded or otherwise had a problem in school, with the law or otherwise. Little Johnny spent the weekend with his granddad on a camping trip. On the way home from the camping trip grandpa gave Little Johnny his Case peanut knife and told him he had owned it for 40 years but wanted to pass it along in the family. Little Johnny was very excited over receiving his first knife from his grandpa. On the way home from school Johnny removed the peanut from his jacket pocket to show it to his best friend on the bus without removing the blade from the knife.
Should the punishment for each "offense" be equal?
In short yes both should be punished the same.
You can make up all sorts of scenarios to try and make one sound better than the other, but at the end of the day both would have brought a prohibited item to school. Simple as that. Your first scenario with "little Joe" is quite ridiculous anyways. If a child brought a knife to school and threatened another child and even used a knife to cut them (doesn't matter how bad) he would likely be in jail and expelled immediately.
-
Fortunately (in my humble opinion) judicial and most other systems do not operate in this fashion, however I understand your position. Thanks for your response.
-
@kilowatt said:
Fortunately (in my humble opinion) judicial and most other systems do not operate in this fashion, however I understand your position. Thanks for your response.Don't get me wrong I am not saying the troubled child does not "deserve" more punishment, but I do believe everyone should be reprimanded equally in this particular situation. If we are talking a court of law things are a bit different.
Just my opinion though. No right or wrong here.

-
@captain spaulding said:
I definitely DO NOT agree with the opinion that since he was a good kid he should be given a pass and if he was a problem child they should make a example and throw the book at him. While he might be right everyone should be punished equally no matter your moral character.
Just for discussion purposes. Let's assume Little Joe is caught with a knife at school. He is packing a 4 inch fixed blade in his pocket in a sheath. Little Joe has been in trouble on a number of occasions, in particular using knives or other similar devices to threaten harm to his classmates and in one particular incident managed to cut a fellow student. Not seriously, but it drew blood. In addition, Little Joe has previously given illegal drugs to his classmates and was caught drinking intoxicants at school. Needless to say Little Joe because of his past problems is currently under the supervision of the juvenile division of the court. Little Joe pulled his knife from his pocket, removed it from the sheath and threatened Sally in the classroom.
Now for another example. Little Johnny has never been in trouble and has never been reprimanded or otherwise had a problem in school, with the law or otherwise. Little Johnny spent the weekend with his granddad on a camping trip. On the way home from the camping trip grandpa gave Little Johnny his Case peanut knife and told him he had owned it for 40 years but wanted to pass it along in the family. Little Johnny was very excited over receiving his first knife from his grandpa. On the way home from school Johnny removed the peanut from his jacket pocket to show it to his best friend on the bus without removing the blade from the knife.
**
Should the punishment for each "offense" be equal?**What are the laws of the land? You have to take into account what the "local" law says. Can't let your own personal experience/ideas give the answer here. Read the law, apply it to the situation, you have your answer. Period.
Remember: law and justice are not synonims.

-
Just measured the blade length of Kick's blade, from tip to handle is exactly at 2.5"
I think it is legal to carry in school.
-
Kick-A.S.S. version 2 to meet Restrictions on knives in California schools
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login