Neck knives.
-
Thanks for the comments gents :)
-
I just remember that I also have one of these:

It doesn't fit any of your requirements though Mike (other than being usable as a neck knife)
-
The TOPS Tibo was one I remember looking at when I was buying a neck knife. Didn't actually suit what I was looking for, but I think it rather fits the bill here.
-
Those two are nice Gareth.
Nate
That's us mobile -
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I'd say Ghost Banshee and BK11. Again we gotta think what really counts in this category of knives
Well my criteria would probably differ from most in that I'd be using it as a small survival type knife. If you watch Gideon Tactical on YouTube he puts these little knives through the mill and shows what can be achieved with even small blades :)
Sad to say but over here in the UK any sort of knife garners the wrong sort of attention so anything that can be carried discreetly in the woods is a big bonus. And having something capable of heavy tasks in a compact package is excellent life insurance imo :)
Oh I love Gideon's channel. Someone who doesn't rant on and on but tests his stuff.
I agree with what you said. My criteria would be the following:
Blade shape - this is somewhat straight forward but I want a drop point, clip point or spear point without any recurves, serrations or anything else that makes it funky. To me this is the last resort in a way and I don't want my last resort to push me into being overly creative with it. For those that know me this might be somewhat surprising, but after trying to process a hog with a sheep's foot/wharnecliff blade, I can say it can be done but it simply wastes time. And don't get me started on the delicate carving experiment.Blade steel - I really dislike some steels, some I think aren't the best for every possible application and in this case it is a big factor. This is something that would be close to my body and I sweat. The other side of it would be the brittle factor of the steel. True it has a lot to do with tampering and a small knife wouldn't be used to some crazy amount for prying or impacts, but the small amount it can be used for does make a less brittle steel preferable.
Ergonomics - there are some small knives that feel really big in hand and some that do just the opposite. If you're cutting anything for a while, holding a piece of steel in hand isn't the most comfortable thing to do, but if the ergos are good it simply gets easier.
Sheath - Simplicity rules here. And attachment options, because I might not want to have the neck knife around my neck.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I'd say Ghost Banshee and BK11. Again we gotta think what really counts in this category of knives
Well my criteria would probably differ from most in that I'd be using it as a small survival type knife. If you watch Gideon Tactical on YouTube he puts these little knives through the mill and shows what can be achieved with even small blades :)
Sad to say but over here in the UK any sort of knife garners the wrong sort of attention so anything that can be carried discreetly in the woods is a big bonus. And having something capable of heavy tasks in a compact package is excellent life insurance imo :)
Oh I love Gideon's channel. Someone who doesn't rant on and on but tests his stuff.
Another vote for Gideon Tatical. I always look for his reviews on a knife, and I just ordered a Seal Pup Elite (Amazon is having a 15% off sale here) knife based partially on his recommendation of the regular Seal Pup.
-
@Gareth said:
I just remember that I also have one of these:
It doesn't fit any of your requirements though Mike (other than being usable as a neck knife)
I don't remember seeing that one mate, recent addition? I was considering trying out the cheaper Secret Edge from them before I got my Boker TUF. The TUF is a bit heavy as a neck knife, but could be carried that way I suppose. I settled on that one as it's quite a good food prep knife, but could be used for harder tasks if needed
-
@Gareth said:
I just remember that I also have one of these:
It doesn't fit any of your requirements though Mike (other than being usable as a neck knife)
Well there mandatory your side of the border aren't they? :D
The Tibo is on the fantasy wishlist as it does look near spot on :) And I can vouch for TOPS quality :)
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I'd say Ghost Banshee and BK11. Again we gotta think what really counts in this category of knives
Well my criteria would probably differ from most in that I'd be using it as a small survival type knife. If you watch Gideon Tactical on YouTube he puts these little knives through the mill and shows what can be achieved with even small blades :)
Sad to say but over here in the UK any sort of knife garners the wrong sort of attention so anything that can be carried discreetly in the woods is a big bonus. And having something capable of heavy tasks in a compact package is excellent life insurance imo :)
Oh I love Gideon's channel. Someone who doesn't rant on and on but tests his stuff.
I agree with what you said. My criteria would be the following:
Blade shape - this is somewhat straight forward but I want a drop point, clip point or spear point without any recurves, serrations or anything else that makes it funky. To me this is the last resort in a way and I don't want my last resort to push me into being overly creative with it. For those that know me this might be somewhat surprising, but after trying to process a hog with a sheep's foot/wharnecliff blade, I can say it can be done but it simply wastes time. And don't get me started on the delicate carving experiment.Blade steel - I really dislike some steels, some I think aren't the best for every possible application and in this case it is a big factor. This is something that would be close to my body and I sweat. The other side of it would be the brittle factor of the steel. True it has a lot to do with tampering and a small knife wouldn't be used to some crazy amount for prying or impacts, but the small amount it can be used for does make a less brittle steel preferable.
Ergonomics - there are some small knives that feel really big in hand and some that do just the opposite. If you're cutting anything for a while, holding a piece of steel in hand isn't the most comfortable thing to do, but if the ergos are good it simply gets easier.
Sheath - Simplicity rules here. And attachment options, because I might not want to have the neck knife around my neck.
Thanks for your thoughts mate and I'd agree with most of your assessments :)
Yeah the blade shape is a key factor too as a tanto would hardly be helpful :D
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Yeah the blade shape is a key factor too as a tanto would hardly be helpful :DNot quite as practical, but I've always liked the look of the clip point blade geometry on the Blackjack Model 155:

Overall Length:6.375"
Blade Length:3.00"
Cutting Edge:2.75"
Blade Thickness:0.17"
Blade Material:154CM -
Now that does look good mate :)
-
Hanging round here certainly won't make it any smaller :D
-
I more often than not carry a neck knife. The three I have and currently use are a Nemesis Hellion (VG-10), my custom designed piece (CPM-154CM) or my custom Hartsook Talon Lite (440c)
-
That Hellion looks the part

-
@jekostas said:
I more often than not carry a neck knife. The three I have and currently use are a Nemesis Hellion (VG-10), my custom designed piece (CPM-154CM) or my custom Hartsook Talon Lite (440c)Nemesis has a few nice models.

@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Hanging round here certainly won't make it any smaller :DYes. I see how that works now (lol)
-
@50ft-trad said:
I just remember that I also have one of these:

It doesn't fit any of your requirements though Mike (other than being usable as a neck knife)
I don't remember seeing that one mate, recent addition? I was considering trying out the cheaper Secret Edge from them before I got my Boker TUF. The TUF is a bit heavy as a neck knife, but could be carried that way I suppose. I settled on that one as it's quite a good food prep knife, but could be used for harder tasks if needed
Actually, no. Add it to the meet-up wish list and I'll remember to make sure and bring it down. :)
-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
This is a neck knife I like. The Buck KAALA S30V steel. 6 3/4" over all 3" blade. The picture is when it was new it looks more used now. It is my camp knife. Maybe not as thick as some but it works for me.Here is a custom,by a maker with the moniker of Mal Dion,that could be the fraternal twin to your Buck.



-
That does look pretty slick mate :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


