Smaller knife = less scary???
-
@50ft-trad said:
@captain spaulding said:
@50ft-trad said:
To coin a phrase, size is not everything.
I have some good friends who are not knife carrying individuals, but are very used to me carrying knives. One day I went hiking with them, and got a very strong "oh, that looks naughty" reaction to my Buck Hartsook.
Depending on your location, and prevailing cultural trends in that location, depends on what knives would be considered socially acceptable. I know my stag handled Muela folder would raise more eyebrows than my similarly sized Nieto Manolina, which I would consider to be one of the more universally acceptable knives.
If I am using a knife where it may be viewed by others who do not know me, and may be concerned as to my intentions with a knife, I am very careful as to which knife I choose based on the likely perception as to whether it is a utility pocket tool or a weapon. I have a perfectly UK legal Boker Plus XS, and wouldn't consider that knife to be public friendly, whereas the locking blade on a MP700 looks more socially acceptable.
I have openly sheath carried a fixed blade knife on my hip, and walked past a court house with it, and nobody batted an eyelid. I was also carrying a lock windlass and was penning boats through at the time.
Awareness of what message you might be giving to other members of the public is not just wise to avoid unnecessary confrontation and questioning, in my opinion it is also common courtesy to your fellow man. In a society where knife carry and usage is neither common nor overt, I feel no need to flaunt my legal right and cause potential discomfort for others who don't know if I'm a potential hazard or not
These two sentences are conflicting for me then.

I am not understanding how carrying a larger folder which will only be seen briefly when in use is considered openly flaunting my legal right?
When I say large folder I am generalizing it to be roughly Spyderco Endura size.
I think we've confused each other here

I carried a fixed blade sheath knife in a marine setting. Despite the location being in a town centre, the activity justified it. Someone walking through a shopping centre with a chainsaw might get sphincters twitching, but outside the shopping centre removing branches overhanging the car park, no questions asked.
As to when there is no obvious need for anything more "scary" to the uninitiated than a 91mm SAK, stay with that or something similarly "urban" (according to local variations). A Boker Plus XS is a sub 3" slippy (UK Legal) but is likely to appear more "aggressive" than some other less legal knives.
Those who are likely to take exception to your carry, are likely not going to know what is legal and what is not. In a public setting a traditional slippy or mid sized SAK in the hands of a 40 year old isn't going to start a stampede. Neither is a larger bladed item in the appropriate setting. Eating an apple with a Spydie Paramilitary whilst sat on a park bench is gonna make many folks over here think you're a nutter that's about to go pop
This just reinforces the conclusion that the country and general location you are in seems to be a very determining factor in this. I guess it is opinion about what is really overkill as well. If I saw a guy eating a apple with a PM2 I would not think it was overkill at all. To be honest depending on the size of the apple the PM2's cutting edge is pretty ideal for such a task. If I saw a guy eating a apple with a machete I would think something is wrong. :ahhh :D
-
@captain spaulding said:
...If I saw a guy eating a apple with a machete I would think something is wrong. :ahhh :DI've seen that, and didn't think anything of it. But, it was during an off-road trip. :D
I can carry basically anything knife wise, except an auto or balisong. I usually have a folder and SAK on me, and most times, the small blade on the SAK will do the job, so that's what I'll use. I've used big folders in public settings, and no one either noticed, or seemed to care.
Certain places (toy shops, daycare, ect) I'd use a SAK, and preferably the scissors if possible.
I live in a more rural area, and it's pretty common to see guys with knives on their belts. Out here, no one really cares. During hunting season, you'll see guys in full camo, with machetes, fixed blades, ect walking around the stores, and no one bats an eye. I've seen them in town as well, but it's only the very odd time.
I think we should be able to use what we want, and when we want to. BUT, I also think we should be respectful of situations where it might cause others worry. No need to scare/freak people out just because legally we can.
-
@derekmac said:
I think we should be able to use what we want, and when we want to. BUT, I also think we should be respectful of situations where it might cause others worry. No need to scare/freak people out just because legally we can.That's something to seriously consider. If too many people get scared too often then they might start agitating to change the existing laws so you can no longer legally carry certain classes of "scary" knives in public. Look at what happened to what is allowed or banned on commercial flights as an (extreme) example. If politicians see votes in something they are likely to react. It doesn't matter if it is logical or sensible or even practical, they might do it.
-
With me, it's really just to keep from being bothered by other people. And I don't really downsize, just go for a bit more subdued. I don't like bringing unneeded attention to myself, especially from the types of people who will complain and say things about someone for having a blade on them. It's not that I care what people think, it's that I don't want to have to deal with them telling me what they think.
-
YES!
I saw some people freak out at my Classic, calling it a "white weapon".
People usually twitch at the Tinker and shake their heads...
For a Tenacious almost everybody just steps back and I got two threats on calling the cops to take it away (and I'm not waving it around)Might have to get a smaller knife, friendlier knife for edc... Kershaw Rainbow or Dragonfly or something :-\
Luckily I'm a 30-ish, suit-wearing white male with no police record so I doubt I'll have any problems, but still "meh".
PS: I was watching this this morning
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eC0vUULOLq0 -
Apart from the knife (blade) size and the environment and people, depends on the blade shape (agressive or serrations), mechanism (one hand opening or automatic) and color! (bright colors are seen like toys or friendly) and it has to be proportional to the task (the machete and the apple).
SAKs knives are looked more indulgently (swiss cross effect :D) and integrated knives like the one on multitools even more, but if when are deployed are not too agressive (better a Vic Spirit than a Skeletool) -
Yep, ,somenoe waving a scalpel in front of your face is far less scary..
-
@Corwyn said:
YES!
I saw some people freak out at my Classic, calling it a "white weapon".
People usually twitch at the Tinker and shake their heads...
For a Tenacious almost everybody just steps back and I got two threats on calling the cops to take it away (and I'm not waving it around)Might have to get a smaller knife, friendlier knife for edc... Kershaw Rainbow or Dragonfly or something :-\
Luckily I'm a 30-ish, suit-wearing white male with no police record so I doubt I'll have any problems, but still "meh".
This just really goes to show its about your location.
To be completely honest if I was in your situation and your knife is completely legit and you are using it for a legitimate purpose and people threaten to call the cops I would probably just tell them to go smurf themselves and go about my business. If they call the cops who cares. You are not doing anything wrong and I would push for them to be charged with filing a false police report. Easy peasy. That's just me though. :D
-
@captain spaulding said:
YES!
I saw some people freak out at my Classic, calling it a "white weapon".
People usually twitch at the Tinker and shake their heads...
For a Tenacious almost everybody just steps back and I got two threats on calling the cops to take it away (and I'm not waving it around)Might have to get a smaller knife, friendlier knife for edc... Kershaw Rainbow or Dragonfly or something :-\
Luckily I'm a 30-ish, suit-wearing white male with no police record so I doubt I'll have any problems, but still "meh".
This just really goes to show its about your location.
To be completely honest if I was in your situation and your knife is completely legit and you are using it for a legitimate purpose and people threaten to call the cops I would probably just tell them to go smurf themselves and go about my business. If they call the cops who cares. You are not doing anything wrong and I would push for them to be charged with filing a false police report. Easy peasy. That's just me though. :D
Cap,again,with respect,have you been in this situation? ie,needing to defend your legal position?
Although the circumstance are different,a few years ago a friend of mine went to her Union regarding a serious issue at work. As a result of her employer,she was forced out of her job. She,with her unions help,fought her termination. She won,but it took 3 years to do so. In the interim,she couldn't take a new job without nullifying her claim. The payout from her former employer failed to compensate her for three years lost income.
One thing I've noticed over the years,with respect to LEOs,they don't like Joe public quoting law at them!
As I say,I respect your stance,but I wonder how it stands up when put to the test?
-
"You're not in Guatemala now Dr Ropata."
-
@captain spaulding said:
YES!
I saw some people freak out at my Classic, calling it a "white weapon".
People usually twitch at the Tinker and shake their heads...
For a Tenacious almost everybody just steps back and I got two threats on calling the cops to take it away (and I'm not waving it around)Might have to get a smaller knife, friendlier knife for edc... Kershaw Rainbow or Dragonfly or something :-\
Luckily I'm a 30-ish, suit-wearing white male with no police record so I doubt I'll have any problems, but still "meh".
This just really goes to show its about your location.
To be completely honest if I was in your situation and your knife is completely legit and you are using it for a legitimate purpose and people threaten to call the cops I would probably just tell them to go smurf themselves and go about my business. If they call the cops who cares. You are not doing anything wrong and I would push for them to be charged with filing a false police report. Easy peasy. That's just me though. :D
I did, but I'm still at work and the guy is like 2 meters from me every day. If my boss wasn't a knife nut as well, I wouldn't even be bringing it with me.
Regarding legitimate purpose, meh... I mostly open boxes, envelopes or occasionally food prep with it but I guess a Vic Classic or a work-supplied box-cutter could do the same.
Regarding police, I'm not really concerned, as if you don't slit someone's neck they are aren't likely to care either, but if they get a complaint they must start an investigation and it can get annoying. Also if on that perticular day I'm with a Vic Trekker or showing off my sexy new stiletto to a friend I could get in a lot of trouble... best case scenario everything confiscated in a knee-jerk reaction (including my home collection)... worst case scenario wrapsheet, fine and maybe even some suspended jail time ...
Seeing as I'm working as Marketing Manager in a Multinational company (Romanian paycheck though, that's why I can't afford a Para 2 :P ) I really couldn't afford this kind of trouble as it might screw up my career on long term... -
Its so sad when tools get given personalities of their own.
People projecting fear onto items rather than onto criminals and criminal acts. -
@captain spaulding said:
YES!
I saw some people freak out at my Classic, calling it a "white weapon".
People usually twitch at the Tinker and shake their heads...
For a Tenacious almost everybody just steps back and I got two threats on calling the cops to take it away (and I'm not waving it around)Might have to get a smaller knife, friendlier knife for edc... Kershaw Rainbow or Dragonfly or something :-\
Luckily I'm a 30-ish, suit-wearing white male with no police record so I doubt I'll have any problems, but still "meh".
This just really goes to show its about your location.
To be completely honest if I was in your situation and your knife is completely legit and you are using it for a legitimate purpose and people threaten to call the cops I would probably just tell them to go smurf themselves and go about my business. If they call the cops who cares. You are not doing anything wrong and I would push for them to be charged with filing a false police report. Easy peasy. That's just me though. :D
Cap,again,with respect,have you been in this situation? ie,needing to defend your legal position?
As I say,I respect your stance,but I wonder how it stands up when put to the test?
Don't know about Spaulding, I have. Went rather well. Took about 30minutes of my time. I didn't mind, I was at work getting paid anyways and got to watch the smurfer (out of state college student) squirm a little.
For the most part, I don't care what people think if i pull out my SOG Vulcan and use it. Now how you use it, I kind do. If you a folder out like that and start waving it around like a ninja, yeah, not good and it make knife users look bad. Use it to cut an apple or open a package, around here, no problem.
Nate
That's us mobile -
Coming from the UK I have to say I don't feel at all comfortable opening a knife in public, and if I do so its very discretely. Its just not worth the inevitable grief it will cause sadly ::)
Having said that I still edc a Farmer everyday and that's almost as big a knife as its legal to carry over here :)
Sent from my K013 using Tapatalk
-
One time I bought glasses, the lady helping me asked what I was looking for. My answer went something like "When I talk to a group of engineers, I want them to ignore my glasses." We dress partly for ourselves, partly for society around us.
The subject has been touched before, but anything atypical, be it a knife or yellow top hat, attracts attention, and in an urban setting, attention is in my experience usually unwanted. It's not only about legality, it's also about social cost vs practical utility. If I try to explain how something works to a co-worker, and he just ends up staring at a knife in my belt, then it's just as much my problem as his. Oh, I carry a knife at work (of course! :D ), but I'm discreet about it, and I often simply take one of the Stanley or Mora knives around the place if I need something done instead of using my own. (Hey, saves the blade too. :) )
I work in an office, and people react less if they see me do something with one of the Mora knives from a toolbox than pulling forth a folder. That said, only one co-worker has ever shown a slightly negative reaction when he saw one of my knives; that was a gentleman's knife with about 10 cm handle length. (While quickly deploying a Spyderco to do something small resulted in "Hey, that's a cool knife! What kind is that?" from someone else.)
Disclaimer: I live a place where knives are strictly regulated on paper, but most people are pretty reasonable about it, LEOs included. If it has a Swiss cross or a Leatherman logo, very few will bat an eye. I usually EDC a SAK because they're practical and I like them.
-
I am the resident warden at a retirement complex and carry out day to day repairs for my residents, usually with my Spirit or Woodsman. It helps that I have a really good relationship with my residents/Neighbours and also that the SAK is seen as 'nerdy' rather than dangerous in the UK. If I walked around the estate or the village with a tactical knife, I don't think I'd get the same latitude, and with good reason. I simply don't need it - it's an inappropriate tool for me to be carrying around.
Yes, we should all be able to carry around what we like, but if we choose to carry something we must also accept that others may have a completely different view from us about what we're carrying and why.
Whilst you know you're not carrying a weapon, someone else who doesn't know you well, will not. That's not anyone's fault - it's the way we're wired. I would object to attending a meeting with somone who insisted on bringing a baseball bat with them. They might have very good reasons for it, but I don't know those reasons.
There's a great article by Jon Ronson (English Journalist) about getting a SAK for his son - He, his wife and his son all have differing views on what carrying a SAK means - it's very funny;
-
That was an entertaining read. :)
Oh, and I would love a world where I could carry a fixed blade without anyone caring. Back in my childhood (in this case the 80s), one of my teachers always carried a small fixed blade in his belt. He used it for the small stuff all of us are used to having a knife for, from doing quick adjustments in a woodwork class to removing a splinter from the finger of a pupil. I think that world is forever gone. Perhaps it would not have disappeared if more people thought like the cap and fewer did like I have done. That would be somewhat self-fulfilling, though.
-
@Steinar said:
That was an entertaining read. :)Oh, and I would love a world where I could carry a fixed blade without anyone caring. Back in my childhood (in this case the 80s), one of my teachers always carried a small fixed blade in his belt. He used it for the small stuff all of us are used to having a knife for, from doing quick adjustments in a woodwork class to removing a splinter from the finger of a pupil. I think that world is forever gone. Perhaps it would not have disappeared if more people thought like the cap and fewer did like I have done. That would be somewhat self-fulfilling, though.
I literally see someone with a fixed blade on their belt almost every single day here and no one freaks out or even says a thing. No one is whispering to there friends or threatening to call the cops and it's not like its in a situation like out on a farm. I'm talking at the grocery store shopping for food.
I will respond to the other post, but I just woke up so give me a bit.

-
I so want to say something but it would almost surely get this thread locked and probably get me banned.
You opened a can of worms cap'n ... ::)
-
There are always two sides no matter how thinly sliced. On one hand, those legally carrying knives and on the other, those who object regardless of legalities.
I'm a pretty easy going guy who loves the idea of people getting along and going about their business without getting into others.
Cursing isn't illegal, Spitting tobacco onto the ground isn't either ( not that I'm aware ), Talking loudly in a theater, smelling ( body odor ), wearing patches with obscene sayings aren't outlawed as far as I know but the bottom line is we do live in society. On the so called farm or out in the sticks do what you will, but in the general public, legal or not, there will be someone who objects, right or wrongly. Why put yourself in that situation? What are you trying to say? What's the message?
Kirky is totally right, you are not going to win an argument with LEO on the street EVER!!!!!. At the very least the officer will tell you to put your knife away, then what? What point was made? Now what? You pull it out tomorrow and another complaint, and around you go.
It's not about conformism ( if that's the beef here ), it's not about standing up for rights ( if that's the beef ), what exactly is the stance? What is the point?
Legally I can do many things but why? Why the hassle as others have stated? Why the annoyances of being is a situation where I have to defend myself.
I personally like to be invisible. I like to totally blend into my environment unnoticed. I know some like to make statements, carry "flags" and "banners" for whatever they believe in and that's terrific. I honestly applaud them and am thankful in some cases. In my little world I like to remain anonymous and like my business to remain the same.
There was a time here in California when you could openly carry a firearm. I remember it well as there were those "flag" waving people that walked around doing so. IMO they effed it up for those that loved the "idea" and possibility of open carrying however didn't do it themselves.
Some one mentioned earlier that it's this type flouting of our legal rights that eventually leads to them ( rights ) being taken away or heavily legislated. We keep pushing ( what ever it may be ) and eventually the masses push back and sadly win.
If a knife is what's needed then use one but if it's more about "I'm gonna use the biggest LEGAL knife I can" then I'm lost.
I guess my position is simple, just because I legally can doesn't mean I will. I rather like my invisibility.
EDIT
As mentioned by the Capt. this is not aimed at anyone just my opinion. Also as mentioned I'm a laid back guy so hang onto the rocks fellas.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
