Something to help you date your Vic SAKs based on tool evolution
-
-
Good idea PFR
Two new versions w minor other changes
If anyone wants the xcel source for this just let me know via a PM

-
-
-
-
-
-
It is a really very cool piece of work. Any chance that you can add the locking notch on the caplifter 91mm (I believe this to be 1999 - 2000). Half stop on caplifter 84mm (2012?). Pin hole in scales (date unknown). Change from nickel to stainless inlay (1978?).
All my dates are very theoretical

-
Thanks for all your comments team - Glad to be of assistance

VS - Great feedback - ^^^ - I already have a Version 5 with minor updates so I will add your suggestions and republish here shortly.
-
Well here it is .... tadah .... The latest and greatest Version 5.
Quite a few significant changes from V4 - Can't remember them all but here are some I can

-
Voetsaks suggestions incorporated - (see above) - Thanks mate
-
File changes described more clearly
-
Magnifying Glass changes described more clearly
-
Saw changes described in more detail (eg tooth count!)
-
Later dates corrected/added
-
Some formatting & cosmetic changes - Hope the thicker lines are OK for you - They look much better in the xcel!
As always chaps - All suggestions/corrections gratefully received.
There are still quite a few '?' left on the sheet.Hope this is useful and thanks for all the comments and feedback so far

-
-
-
Well folks - This seems to me a constantly evolving tool - As I learn more information (.... mainly from MTo!)
So here is version VI
And thank you to all from who I have learned information - I hope you know who you are !!
SAK dating is always as much an art as a science - However I think we are 'getting close' with this version!!
Quite a few changes this time:
-
We have new columns for: The main blade - showing thickness and some tang stamps; The Technicians screwdriver
-
New rows for 1909, 1923 and 1974 !!
-
Various corrections and updates eg scales column
-
Various formatting changes - Eg introduced the vertical lines, got rid of the nasty thick black lines - I hope this helps
As always - Any feedback on technical content or formatting, usability etc etc - gratefully received

Piccie via photbucket above - PDF attached - Let me know if you want the source xls or a jpeg etc
The pdf image is a lot clearer for some reason - Strange as the jpeg was snipped from the pdf!!And don't forget Detron's spreadsheet - Which approaches this same information a different way!
-
-
@Huntsman said:
The pdf image is a lot clearer for some reason - Strange as the jpeg was snipped from the pdf!!Jpgs are lossy and use a system giving a sort of gaussian blur to compress photos... that's why you never use it for text and vector graphics. For those, png or gif are better

Jpgs are nice for raster images, where blurring is less visible. -
when you push down on the inline phillips and it moves down a little this is the newer version this is a good way to tell if you have the glass magnifier lens or the plastic one
-
The pdf image is a lot clearer for some reason - Strange as the jpeg was snipped from the pdf!!
Jpgs are lossy and use a system giving a sort of gaussian blur to compress photos... that's why you never use it for text and vector graphics. For those, png or gif are better

Jpgs are nice for raster images, where blurring is less visible.Ah - Thanks Corwyn - Although there are some teccie terms in there which I recognise - But don't totally understand what they mean!! Will look them up or ask a buddy!!
But I guess it means: use jpegs for pictures and png for images from xcel powerpoint etc !!!Also my bad - This image actually is a .png - That is what my snipping tool generated!
But it is still blurry
The pdf really is very clear

-
@Huntsman said:
Also my bad - This image actually is a .png - That is what my snipping tool generated!
But it is still blurry
You really are trying to make me eat my words, right?

Yes you are right, that is what I meant, but your photo is not blurry because it's a png. It must be something Photobucket did to create the resize and create the preview.Look here at the actual file. No blurring.
http://i1027.photobucket.com/albums/y339/SAKHuntsman/SAK Dating/Vic Dating MTo VerVI_zpszktrfkfo.pngAnd here it is reuploaded via Picasaweb:
-
@Huntsman said:
Well here it is .... tadah .... The latest and greatest Version 5.Quite a few significant changes from V4 - Can't remember them all but here are some I can

- Voetsaks suggestions incorporated - (see above) - Thanks mate
- File changes described more clearly
- Magnifying Glass changes described more clearly
- Saw changes described in more detail (eg tooth count!)
- Later dates corrected/added
- Some formatting & cosmetic changes - Hope the thicker lines are OK for you - They look much better in the xcel!
As always chaps - All suggestions/corrections gratefully received.
There are still quite a few '?' left on the sheet.Hope this is useful and thanks for all the comments and feedback so far
great work man! I have been so busy with school, that I have not had any time for my own spreadsheet. thank you for sharing
-
-
Here is something I was messing around with this eveing.
It a little pictorial to help you date your SAKS based on tool evolution.It's a bit rough and ready (actually it's probably not even ready
)
And does assume that you know about the diffrent tool evolution changes (eg I've not explained differences in detail and used abbreviations etc - BBut I can tell you OSS means Old Soldier Style.
But you may find it useful.The dates came from the SAMS website and that sheet from Urwys Wyss of Victorinox
http://victorinox.metodi.me/91mmtools.php#scissors
Probably best if you use my table alongside this website to see the piccies
I like my table as you can see what changes happened at teh same time and it gives one overall picture.I'd like to tidy it up a lot so any suggestions greatfully received
Cheers
Here are the revisions I offer for Vic cellidors:
1968 Last year for Sharpened Bottle opener/scraper
1971 No "PAT" on Can Opener
1973 - 5 to 4 turn corkscrew
Back layer phillips:
1952 - 1968 square, file, no can-key
1968 -1980 square, no file, can-key
1980 - 1992 round, can key
1992 - present round no can key
Divot Repair tool - 1992- 04?
Emblem Inlay on front scales - 80 Stainless Steel, before they were nickel/silver
-
@El Corkscrew said:
Here are the revisions I offer for Vic cellidors:Thanks El C - This is great to get some feedback on the dating table

I have inserted *some comments *after you suggestions - Can anyone else comment, confirm, or dispute - Mainly on the first two items !!
Please let us know ..........1968 Last year for Sharpened Bottle opener/scraper
*Hmm - That is a dramatic change - Current version and SAAMS says 1980 - Although with a ? - So they were not sure - Some evidence please ! *1971 No "PAT" on Can Opener
*Also is a dramatic change - Current version and SAAMS also says 1980? - Ditto ! *1973 - 5 to 4 turn corkscrew
*This is an interesting one and we mentioned it in ano thread - Makes much more sense to me as I have some SAKs which have alu tipped tweezers but four turns CS - Which is not possible according to SAAMS - I am happy to update that one *

Back layer phillips:
*Yes we also discussed this in ano thread - We have never seen a no file/no can key square SD - and SAAMS is a bit devoid of dates for the back SD - and we are all agreed on the 1992 date - So I am happy to update based on your dates *

1952 - 1968 square, file, no can-key
1968 -1980 square, no file, can-key
1980 - 1992 round, can key
1992 - present round no can keyDivot Repair tool - 1992- 04?
*Sure why not? I think I guessed the current end date in my table !
*Emblem Inlay on front scales - 80 Stainless Steel, before they were nickel/silver
Yep this is the date that is in the table
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



