Climber vs. Evo 14?
-
Why pick one SAK's are cheep enough to have both. Then you can give us a good review based on your evaluation.

-
Lots of comments on Vic scissors being better. How so?
My experience is that for everything but cutting paper, the Wenger scissor design is superior:
- No spring breakage, ever,
- No slipping when cutting something a little hard (like small cable ties)
- Aside from the above, they'll cut anything Vic scissors will cut
@50ft-trad said:
The locking screwdriver is nice, though not essential,Am I the only one who has given knuckle blood on account of the large screwdriver tip on a Vic folding on me at the worst possible time? :o
-
Climber all day son! Why do you think the only SAK emoji is this one haha -->

Corkscrew > phillips - The climber has the can opener with 2d phillips tip, so that tilts the scales in favor of the corkscrew + micro flathead driver right off the bat. Corkscrew + tiny flathead driver are more rare than a phillips screwdriver. More likely to "save the day" whereas the phillips is more likely to "save a trip to the nearby toolbox/bag/car/desk/garage." Phillip screwdrivers are way more common than corkscrews and micro flatheads where I'm from, so I'd rather have the uncommon tools that other people don't already have. The corkscrew and micro flathead driver are also more multi-purpose for things they weren't specifically designed for. I always imagine helping a pretty lady or rich ceo with his or her wine/glasses/watches/small electronics.
plain scissors > serrated scissors - and that's just how I feel
small blade > nail file - I love having a secondary small blade on my person. Stealthier around others. More control. Keeps the large blade sharp and clean :D I have a normal nail file by my TV which I use often enough to forgo carrying around one in my pocket.
91mm < 85mm - I honestly can't tell the length difference when they're riding in the pocket, but still, damn you Victorinox and your lack of 84mm scissor models :(
To me, the Climber is the sweet spot. 3 layers is the sweet spot for 91mm IMO. 2 layers is a sacrifice. 4 layers is too wide. Dont need a saw or file in my pocket when im in the city. Don't need the small limited 91mm pliers, and I always have a Swisstool X in my backpack nearby.
Climber vs Compact - Climber is obviously more useful, but with extra usefulness comes extra weight. I like both!
Climber vs Yeoman - Climber wins with better cutting (small blade), prying (true cap lifter), poking (awl). Yeoman has a mag glass that I'd rather have in my wallet, and a Phillips that I've went over.
Climber vs Cadet or Pioneer - The alox brothers are missing scissors so they lose.
-
Too close to call for me which is why I own both of them.
-
@mrog said:
Climber all day son! Why do you think the only SAK emoji is this one haha -->
<snip>Great write-up!
How about Climber vs. Mountaineer?
The Mountaineer adds a 4th layer for the file, but it is a thin layer, not like the Phillips/magnifier of the Explorer. I'm trying to talk myself into one of these next...
I find that I use the file for cleaning up sloppy molding on plastics and sharp edges elsewhere.
-
Climber all day son! Why do you think the only SAK emoji is this one haha -->

<snip>Great write-up!
How about Climber vs. Mountaineer?
The Mountaineer adds a 4th layer for the file, but it is a thin layer, not like the Phillips/magnifier of the Explorer. I'm trying to talk myself into one of these next...
I find that I use the file for cleaning up sloppy molding on plastics and sharp edges elsewhere.
Yep. This. Ok I like the file on the Evo but I just don't love the scales or the scissors. So that's a Mountaineer for me please

-
@mrog said:
91mm < 85mm - I honestly can't tell the length difference when they're riding in the pocket, but still, damn you Victorinox and your lack of 84mm scissor models :(Well... you're definately not going to see those nowadays, now that the Delemont range has launched. Victorinox isn't crazy to make two similarly-sized lines with the same tools to cannibalize each other...
-
Climber all the way. Better scales, I like a secondary small blade and absolutely never use a nail file, better can opener, better flat driver, better awl, has the hook, better scissors. No contest for me.
-
I prefer the Climber, if only because I like the Vic scissors over Wenger's. I also like having a second blade.
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
-
91mm < 85mm - I honestly can't tell the length difference when they're riding in the pocket, but still, damn you Victorinox and your lack of 84mm scissor models :(
Well... you're definately not going to see those nowadays, now that the Delemont range has launched. Victorinox isn't crazy to make two similarly-sized lines with the same tools to cannibalize each other...
Well, you're correct on that! Probably their strategy all along. I just wish there was an option for flat scales and that they'd change to the Vic awl.
-
I think it was a good call. Wenger had obviously put more thought into their 85mm line than they did in their 84mm line. Better to kill the minimal 84mm line that was completely covered by Wenger's offerings.
-
I prefer the EVO14.
- The shorter length means better pocketability which is important to me.
- Prefer nail file over the short blade which is an unnecessary duplication to me.
-
@roamingcat said:
I prefer the EVO14.- The shorter length means better pocketability which is important to me.
- Prefer nail file over the short blade which is an unnecessary duplication to me.
Whoa! It took you 7 years to make up your mind?!
:o :o

-
Well, it's tricky, both knives have their merits. I am also still pondering the question!

-
Not owned a Delamont knife before so might try one of these of the little Executive 81. That Wenger scissor mechanism looks better than victorinox’s spring which has an irritating habit of popping out of its groove on the Victotinox scissors. I hear the Evos have locking knife blades though which make them illegal to carry here in the UK. The Delamont knife is a bit more expensive though. I thought Delamont was a research/design centre now. Interesting they have kept the knife production line open there. I guess they don’t have the Victorinox spring but I guess healthy market from French Swiss. Last time I saw that production line waa in a pre Victorinox video being hosted by their marketing person a Ms Christ who now sells pastry cups. She may be called Christ but couldn’t perform post 9/11 .
-
@mattbod said:
I hear the Evos have locking knife blades though which make them illegal to carry here in the UK.I believe that only applies to the S variants. That is to say, the Evo 17 is fine, while the Evo S17 has a lock.
Also, it's not outright illegal. There are various exemptions, and you are perfectly entitled to carry one **if **you have a <u>legally valid</u> reason. -
@Fast Bill said:
Great write-up!How about Climber vs. Mountaineer?
The Mountaineer adds a 4th layer for the file, but it is a thin layer, not like the Phillips/magnifier of the Explorer. I'm trying to talk myself into one of these next...
I find that I use the file for cleaning up sloppy molding on plastics and sharp edges elsewhere.
Yep. This. Ok I like the file on the Evo but I just don't love the scales or the scissors. So that's a Mountaineer for me please

Mountaineer is the least I would choose if Swisschamps would be forbidden.
-
@Tasky said:
I believe that only applies to the S variants. That is to say, the Evo 17 is fine, while the Evo S17 has a lock.
Also, it's not outright illegal. There are various exemptions, and you are perfectly entitled to carry one **if **you have a <u>legally valid</u> reason.I would really like to carry a rescue tool in the glove box of my car to cut myself out if I rolled it. I don’t trust the Old Bill though. They like to stick a nice easy charge on you and if I ever got pulled over and they found it. This guy tried to argue food reason but failed. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1266170/Disabled-caravanner-prosecuted-keeping-penknife-car-use-picnics.html
-
@mattbod said:
I would really like to carry a rescue tool in the glove box of my car to cut myself out if I rolled it.Probably best to go with the type with a shielded cutter, in that case...
ResQMe Window Punch & Seat Belt Cutter | Road Safety UK
Emergency keychain tool with seatbelt cutter and window breaker. Designed for rapid vehicle escape and compliant with road safety protocols.
(www.spservices.co.uk)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login