School Carry
-
Kick-A.S.S. version 2 to meet Restrictions on knives in California schools
-
At the stories about little Joe and little Johnny:
They both broke the same law, but Johnny probably got off easy with a warning. Will the school call the cops on Joe? You bet! Now he must deal with the judge. -
@Kampfer said:
At the stories about little Joe and little Johnny:
They both broke the same law, but Johnny probably got off easy with a warning. Will the school call the cops on Joe? You bet! Now he must deal with the judge.I read the actions of the two boys very differently - Joe threatened Sally with his knife, Johnny didn't. So I would expect (hope for ?) different outcomes. Context is important ! They may have both broken a "carrying a knife" law (depending on the laws that apply where they are), but Joe threatened to use it to cause bodily harm which is a whole different ball game (to me, at least).
-
At the stories about little Joe and little Johnny:
They both broke the same law, but Johnny probably got off easy with a warning. Will the school call the cops on Joe? You bet! Now he must deal with the judge.I read the actions of the two boys very differently - Joe threatened Sally with his knife, Johnny didn't. So I would expect (hope for ?) different outcomes. Context is important ! They may have both broken a "carrying a knife" law (depending on the laws that apply where they are), but Joe threatened to use it to cause bodily harm which is a whole different ball game (to me, at least).
The act of the threatening bodily harm would of been a past event which is why I said in my post
Your first scenario with "little Joe" is quite ridiculous anyways. If a child brought a knife to school and threatened another child and even used a knife to cut them (doesn't matter how bad) he would likely be in jail and expelled immediately.
He would of never been in school after that to have gotten caught with a knife in the other scenario which we were discussing.
-
The issue is punishment for the same offense. For purposes of punishment most systems, judicial and non-judicial such as in an employment situation, factor in past conduct and the circumstances surrounding the violation itself. Two people may violate the same law or rule, but it is not unusual for one of them to receive more punishment than the other. If you prefer to analyze things with a black and white lens then both should be punished equally. If you believe all factors should be taken into consideration then perhaps each violator may receive different punishment.
There are many reasons for punishment including reformation, retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, etc.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
