Please help ID old SAK
-
So I bought a SAK lot out of eBay (30 knives). Most of them are the usual huntsman, spartan, and the kind. But one of them seems to be an old SAK. Could you please help me to ID it and let me know if it has any collectible value before I try to re-profile the busted main blade? Thanks in advance.
Here are the pictures...



-
Assuming it's 91mm, then it's a Victorinox Model 234U from c. 1949-1951. If it's 84mm then it's a Model 234kU from the same time period. Collectibility? Unfortunately not much. While these knives are over 60 years old, this particular model is not super rare so they are really only collectible in good to excellent condition. Yours is pretty worn so it honestly doesn't have much value to a collector, so I'd fix it up and use as a very cool EDC.
-
I'd call it a Spartan but back in the day it only had a model number. That type of can opener was only produced somewhere in the 1940s I believe.
-
Depending on the length (84 or 91 mm) it is either a vintage Standard of a Tourist made after WW2 1946-1951.
It is reasonably collectible, but it depends a lot on condition. Are the springs all ok, are the scales nice and solid?
I got a similar one for 15 Euros but the condition was quite poor. In mint condition it can go a bit higher.I mean these were made in a short period, and have the cool can opener and are quite old, but they aren't war-stuff and they are the most common, mass-produced model.
I'd restore it partly as a show piece and not make any major reprofiling to it. If it ends up nice and shiny, it may pick up a decent penny on resale if someone really wants it.
-
Wow, that was quick! Thanks guys for helping with that. It's definitively a 91mm, so I assume it's a Model 234U from c. 1949-1951 as JazzBass mentioned. I don't plan on selling it, just wanted to make sure that I wouldn't be destroying the rarest SAK ever while trying to restore it :D
-
@Omar Rapace said:
Wow, that was quick! Thanks guys for helping with that. It's definitively a 91mm, so I assume it's a Model 234U from c. 1949-1951 as JazzBass mentioned. I don't plan on selling it, just wanted to make sure that I wouldn't be destroying the rarest SAK ever while trying to restore it :DThat will be a great user - I love the old bail on those things. Congrats on a lucky find

-
@Omar Rapace said:
Wow, that was quick! Thanks guys for helping with that. It's definitively a 91mm, so I assume it's a Model 234U from c. 1949-1951 as JazzBass mentioned. I don't plan on selling it, just wanted to make sure that I wouldn't be destroying the rarest SAK ever while trying to restore it :D
That will be a great user - I love the old bail on those things. Congrats on a lucky find

Yes, but most importantly, we want so see lots of pictures during the restoration and even more after

-
@Omar Rapace said:
Wow, that was quick! Thanks guys for helping with that. It's definitively a 91mm, so I assume it's a Model 234U from c. 1949-1951 as JazzBass mentioned. I don't plan on selling it, just wanted to make sure that I wouldn't be destroying the rarest SAK ever while trying to restore it :D
That will be a great user - I love the old bail on those things. Congrats on a lucky find

Yes, but most importantly, we want so see lots of pictures during the restoration and even more after

+1 - we lurve pics.
here's a pic - nothing to do with the thread, but it's my latest mod :D;
<a href="http://s923.photobucket.com/user/magentus2112/media/Farmer_zpsjd9y5jpd.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i923.photobucket.com/albums/ad80/magentus2112/Farmer_zpsjd9y5jpd.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
@Omar, you could show pics of the rest of the lot. We all love pics.
I love beat up well worn knives. If you choose to use the knife as a beater post a pic of it here /topic/50642 it's a place for the knives with character and soul. Knives that if they could talk would have tales to tell...and maybe mild cases of PTSD.
-
Alright, I did a quick re-profiling of the blades and some cleaning (this knife was filthy).
Both blades had very rounded tips so I had to spend some time with a file to try to fix that. I also filed the edges since they were all chipped and cracked. Sharpened with edge-pro and Spiderco sharpmaker. Then I polished with 3M Trizact. I am pretty happy with the result :D

-
Nice work - looks great. Some high grit sandpaper (400, 600, and 1000) and those scales should polish up pretty good. Nice bokeh on the pic, btw.
-
Aint she purty. This will make a nice user.
-
Here is another one from the lot I couldn't identify (closest I found on SAKWiki is the 84mm Artisan, but this one has an extra layer for the file). The tweezers are all metal and the scissors have a screw.
Anyhow, pretty good shape once cleaned. It was so dirty that some of the tools were seized. But alter a good bath and some oiling, it is now very smooth :D




-
That is a Model 136kmaU from c. 1972. It's basically an 84mm version of the 91mm Master Craftsman, some some people call it a "Master Craftsman Small".
A lot of these older 84mm models have the problem of "there really isn't an official name for it", as they were discontinued long before Victorinox was regularly naming knives. 84mm versions of the Huntsman, Woodsman, Camper, Climber, Mountaineer, Grand Prix, and Master Craftsman are all officially just the 246k, 236k, 237k, 235k, 235km, 135km, and 136km respectively. When discussing them we tend to give them the equivalent 91mm name with "Small" appended to them. Problem with this particular knife is that I just don't like the way "Master Craftsman Small" sounds, so I started calling it the "Journeyman". This is in no way official and made up 100% by me.
-
Thanks JazzBass! Very kind of you to take the time to explain in such detailed way.
-
@Omar Rapace said:
Thanks. Just FYI, it's from a Nikkor 85mm f/1.8 G lens at f/4 on a Nikon D600.Nice - I have a very, very similar setup: a D610 with a Nikkor 50mm f/1.4 G. How do you like that 85mm? I was thinking of picking one of those up as my next lens purchase.
Your first picture of the 136maU - same aperture setting on that one, too?
-
@Omar Rapace said:
Thanks. Just FYI, it's from a Nikkor 85mm f/1.8 G lens at f/4 on a Nikon D600.
Nice - I have a very, very similar setup: a D610 with a Nikkor 50mm f/1.4 G. How do you like that 85mm? I was thinking of picking one of those up as my next lens purchase.
I like the 85mm very much for portrait. Great optical quality and (almost) affordable.
@jazzbass said:
Your first picture of the 136maU - same aperture setting on that one, too?Yes, same f-stop (f/4). The close-ups were taken with Micro Nikkor 55mm f2.8. The "before" pictures of the 234U were taken with my iPhone.
-
Great pics Omar! Looks like you struck gold with your lot :)
-
@Fattsgalore said:
@Omar, you could show pics of the rest of the lot. We all love pics.
...Here is the rest of the lot (minus a like new black SwissCard Lite). That's 30 SAKs in overall good shape for less than $6 a pop! Having fun cleaning/lubing them :D
I might replace some of the scales and upgrade some with "plus" accessories.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login