Should I carry these?
-
I've recently found a Swiss electrical supply company has several golden yellow Alox versions of retired 93mm models (Woodsman, Pioneer and Farmer Harvesters) plus the still available Electrician with their own branding printed on the engraving panel. All are at reasonable prices in the $20-35 USD mark. Shipping may add a lot, but I think I'll have my grandparents order me at least the Woodsman and Farmer Harvester for birthday or Christmas if the shipping isn't too high (I've contacted the company about shipping to the US). I'll likely order a few of the others with money I receive from other family members and family friends.
Problem is, every one of them are models I wanted for carry, as most had the hawkbill blade, a feature I typically carry my grandfather's battered old 40 year old Klein Sheepfoot Slitting Knife for. I have the rule, just because it's old or supposedly rare doesn't mean I can't carry it. But, I don't want to ruin something that could really appreciate in value over the years. Their high prices were what made me avoid them, but these prices are retail for the non-colored versions. These models have three reasons why I don't want to carry them. One, all of the Aloxes are retired models. Two, they're colored Alox which is usually more expensive than their non-colored cousins and is also apparently valuable on the secondary market. Three, they're promo Alox knives.
Should these be something I should carry, or put in the knife box to only take out to look at occasionally? I realize that this company is selling these as tools for electricians to use in their line of work, not as collector's items.
Could it be these are not at all completely retired, or is Victorinox doing these as a special run for this company?
-
I'm guessing these are the ones from Bugnard? If so,yes,you really should carry them!
-
Hey, just keep them clean and sharp and pocket lint- free, and you should be just fine
Sent from my outdated communication device using an obsolete application
-
I'm not a huge Alox buff so I'm not aware of the value certain models hold but if I can offer my advise / opinion..... Carry them! Use them! They are tools, and tools are meant to be used. I can't fathom having a tool you spent money on to sit in a box. That poor tool! Lol. Anyway, just my 2c :-)
-
Why torture yourself by letting them sit in some drawer.
Carry + Use

-
I think the proper answer is...buy 2 of each, one to carry, one for the investment :)
I went through similar thoughts when I got my first colored alox (orange Farmer). Then I tore it apart for a mod :) Seriously, though, carry it and use it.

-
Use them and enjoy. That's what SAKS are for.

-
I'm in the minority here, but I'd say pick the model you're most likely to use, and use that one. Keep the others for collecting or as investments.
I'd retire your granddad's old Klein; you'd be furious with yourself if you lost it. Especially after he's gone. There are enough user knives in your collection that you don't need to risk the heirloom pieces.
Yeah, they were originally meant to be used, but they have a different meaning for you now, right?
I have no regrets that I retired most of my Wenngers, for example. Some day, when I go to sell them, I'll thank myself for doing it. Meanwhile, I have plenty of users.
-
I'm on the fence myself. On one hand the tools were most certainly meant to be used and enjoyed. On the other hand as we know Aloxoholics will pay a premium for certain models. If you have no inclination to sell then by all means use it and enjoy. If however you even have a slight inclination then you can still use and enjoy and sell but not for the POTENTIAL if it was NIB.
We all see Alox in used and in some cases abused condition still sell for much more than the original cost.
-
Well.. I usually don't carry my coloured Aloxes (including my gold Bugnard Pruner), because I don't like the way the paint wears but also because I like scale tools and my smooth cellidor too much :D
In this case and if you like the config, go ahead and use them... Golden Bugnards are really nice, but not really something you'd call rare... They've been made constantly for around 20 years and are available quite easily on eBay for prices comparable with regular silver...
Don't quote me on this, but I think it might be the most common colour apart from red.
-
I need a set of these.
They are very nice.
-
How do you view them? Do you see them as tools/knives? If so, use them!
If you see them purely as investments, lock them away safe and hope the interest in them doesn't wain over time.
You need to make the decision on what they mean to you. If you made the decision based on what they mean to me, you'd get rid of them and get a proper celidor SAK with scale tools :D
-
Too nice to use all the time; too nice not to use... can only see the option of having two... :/
-
@50ft-trad said:
How do you view them? Do you see them as tools/knives? If so, use them!If you see them purely as investments, lock them away safe and hope the interest in them doesn't wain over time.
You need to make the decision on what they mean to you. If you made the decision based on what they mean to me, you'd get rid of them and get a proper celidor SAK with scale tools :D

You and your Yorkshire pragmatism
-
I have a few I use heavily, especially my Cellidor SAKs and my late '90s Leatherman Super Tool and PST II. I have a few I don't use, due to condition or handle material (I have many I've gotten as gifts that have Mother of Pearl and/or wood handles). All my limited edition knives (like my 2008 Remington Mother of Pearl/ Wood handled) gift set doesn't get used. Also, I have the knives of my father, grandfather, and great grandfathers. Occasionally I use them as backups, but typically they stay in the knife box.
Right now, I'm thinking get the Pioneer or Farmer Harvesters to carry, then one of the cheaper two-blade only models as the investment. I haven't got anything back on shipping yet. I may have to resend the email in German or French.
-
@cody6268 said:
Right now, I'm thinking get the Pioneer or Farmer Harvesters to carry, then one of the cheaper two-blade only models as the investment. I haven't got anything back on shipping yet. I may have to resend the email in German or French.You might find it easier to ask one of our Swiss members to help with the purchase
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



