Gerber Mp600 owners club ;)
-
Lake Ellesmere
-
I have only been to the reserve at the end of Timber Yard Rd on that side of the lake.
Hmm, is that timber I see? :pok: -
Well I have been there, but it was creepy.
-
-
I am in for MP600, kinda like this tool but again, it won't be carry.
-
Rejoining after selling my Pro Scout. (Regret that sale)

-
I used the wire cutters on my MP600 BN the other day. They're not good at all. Not big enough to cut through a power cable in one go. Cutting single stranded wire of 16 gauge half pinches it and half cuts it.
REALLY poor execution on the wire cutters, Gerber. Especially for the MT electricians are likely to choose.
At first, I thought carbide cutters would be brilliant, but reading about the breakages really made me realize that Leatherman's choice of 154CM was better: not brittle enough to shatter, but harder than anything likely to need cutting.
I need to try the standard cutters on an MP400. They should at LEAST be able to cut a coat hanger and 10 gauge wire without any drama. If not, I might be off of Gerber for good.
Their overall quality is just not there.
-
@Smaug said:
I used the wire cutters on my MP600 BN the other day. They're not good at all. Not big enough to cut through a power cable in one go. Cutting single stranded wire of 16 gauge half pinches it and half cuts it.REALLY poor execution on the wire cutters, Gerber. Especially for the MT electricians are likely to choose.
At first, I thought carbide cutters would be brilliant, but reading about the breakages really made me realize that Leatherman's choice of 154CM was better: not brittle enough to shatter, but harder than anything likely to need cutting.
I need to try the standard cutters on an MP400. They should at LEAST be able to cut a coat hanger and 10 gauge wire without any drama. If not, I might be off of Gerber for good.
Their overall quality is just not there.
That sucks. I wasn't impressed with the cutters either. On the upside, I will take the BN600 off your hands when your done with it [emoji6]
-
If you look where the cutters meet, you'll see that there is a tiny gap closest to the pivot. And the gap gets a bit larger further out. I'm pretty happy with the performance, but I don't cut much with them. Mostly cable ties and other simple things. No problems there.
But it's clearly a design issue, they just need to machine the carbide cutter seats a bit deeper and the cutters would meet closer and cut much better. You can cut paper with the 154CM cutters on Leatherman tools, so they clearly got that right. (Used to own a Rebar, gave it to my sister)
-
@mechtec said:
I'm on the fence about getting a carbide cutter version with the stories about shattering inserts. A lot of people complain about the 600 design but I would trust one with my life!Don't do it, unless you absolutely don't need a wire cutter. Because the carbide cutter is garbage. It doesn't cut any wire well. The other stories say if you try to cut thick solid gauge wire or steel coat hanger wire, the carbide shatters.
I traded off my MP600 BN. Just received a bladeless MP600. Both were brand new.
I think what happened is that Gerber designed in a bit more tolerance to the plier head, since if the carbide cutters actually met, they would shatter. But since they don't get close enough, they just kind of bend and half-shear wire. It is an utter design failure.
With that, I'm out of this club. Looking forward to receiving another MP400.
-
BUMP
Who else here loves the handle splay of the MP600? It puts the new LM Signal to shame IMO.
I'll add that I prefer the regular wire cutters as opposed to the replaceable ones because in my experience they cut better.
Anyone share my love for this tool? ???
-
I do buddy, even though I don't carry it much lately. I like the Diesel too.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
I do buddy, even though I don't carry it much lately. I like the Diesel too.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
Would you say the Diesel is better or the same as the pro scout?
That's one I struggle with. I would say overall they are the same to me, but each has pluses and minuses. I like the Pro Scout's pliers and ease of flickiness better as the Diesel's is a little tougher/trickier to flick. Neither has a metal saw, but the PS's remgrit saw could potentially do the job. The Diesel has a wood saw, although the remgrit may handle that too. Diesel is heavier too, but I prefer how it feels in hand. It has the 2D phillips, but also has the largest flathead while the PS doesn't. I think the Diesel slightly edges out the MP600 for my liking, but it's very close.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
I do buddy, even though I don't carry it much lately. I like the Diesel too.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
Would you say the Diesel is better or the same as the pro scout?
That's one I struggle with. I would say overall they are the same to me, but each has pluses and minuses. I like the Pro Scout's pliers and ease of flickiness better as the Diesel's is a little tougher/trickier to flick. Neither has a metal saw, but the PS's remgrit saw could potentially do the job. The Diesel has a wood saw, although the remgrit may handle that too. Diesel is heavier too, but I prefer how it feels in hand. It has the 2D phillips, but also has the largest flathead while the PS doesn't. I think the Diesel slightly edges out the MP600 for my liking, but it's very close.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
Makes sense. I was comparing the two and it seems to come down to very few differences. The pro scout also has the 3d phillips, blade exchanger, and the USA tag. I eventually want to get a pro scout because I had a diesel and it would be nice to compare the two in hand. Thanks for the feedback
-
I do buddy, even though I don't carry it much lately. I like the Diesel too.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
Would you say the Diesel is better or the same as the pro scout?
That's one I struggle with. I would say overall they are the same to me, but each has pluses and minuses. I like the Pro Scout's pliers and ease of flickiness better as the Diesel's is a little tougher/trickier to flick. Neither has a metal saw, but the PS's remgrit saw could potentially do the job. The Diesel has a wood saw, although the remgrit may handle that too. Diesel is heavier too, but I prefer how it feels in hand. It has the 2D phillips, but also has the largest flathead while the PS doesn't. I think the Diesel slightly edges out the MP600 for my liking, but it's very close.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
Makes sense. I was comparing the two and it seems to come down to very few differences. The pro scout also has the 3d phillips, blade exchanger, and the USA tag. I eventually want to get a pro scout because I had a diesel and it would be nice to compare the two in hand. Thanks for the feedback
Yeah the 3D phillips is a plus, but you lose the large flathead, so it's a matter of preference there. The blade exchanger with remgrit saw is a plus too, but I don't know what other blades are available, and don't like having other parts to carry since I don't use a sheath. The Diesel just seems a little more complete to me. It all comes down to personal preferences though, as all these MTs do. The Pro Scout is great though, and I recommend it if you like Gerbers. It's definitely one of the best

The reason it's a tough choice for me also is because I want to sell one or the other once I sort everything I need to sell.
Sent from my SM-G920R4 using Tapatalk
-
Now to further complicate my Gerber situation, I just ordered a bladeless MP600. It has the blade exchanger with remgrit saw, and thanks to the extra space due to no blade, it has both the 3D phillips and large flathead (which the Pro Scout lacks). I really don't necessarily have to have a blade on my MT anyway, although the Gerber blades are good utility type blades. This one will likely edge out the MP600 PS, and will make my choice between it and the Diesel tougher.
I think the remgrit saw would really handle either wood or metal in a pinch, and I honestly rarely have use to saw either one. So that beats the Diesel as it has no metal sawing capability. I'm thinking overall tool loadout goes to the bladeless MP600. The key area the Diesel will still win for me is the feel in hand. To me it just feels a little more solid and smoother. The handles don't splay quite as far either, which is a plus for me. I like the feel of it when squeezing the handles. It may just come down to me keeping both the Diesel and bladeless MP600, and selling my other Gerbers when the time comes.
I'm thinking I must enjoy torturing myself like this ::)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


