HELP TO DECIDE
-
Add victorinox Spirit to the list
For most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
-
..people in the know carry the ST300

-
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
+1
Specifically the Spirit X. (with plain edge blade and scissors)
The Spirit X may be less costly than the Wave in Italy. I've read that Leatherman products are more expensive outside of the US. Here in the US, the Spirit costs about $100 and the Wave costs about $90.
The Wave has one-handed opening blades on the outside of the tool, as well as out-side accessible files and a saw.
The Spirit has EVERYTHING (except the pliers) accessible on the outside of the tool, and has a better fit and finish than the Wave. The scissors are not full-scissors, but more like a smaller snips.
The Surge is a nice tool. I especially like the outside-accessible scissors and exchangeable saw and file blades. But it is sure big and heavy compared to the Spirit. (less so, compared to the Wave) I find it to be just a bit too big. (my hands are medium to small for a man) If you have big hands, maybe that's not the case with you.
The OHT is an interesting idea: all tools available on the outside, and all able to be opened one-handed. But I think by the time you get done flipping the tool around in your one hand to find the implement you want, you will have lost the advantage of one-handed opening. (time and convenience)
I'll be interested to hear what you decide to purchase first.
-
Oh, and by the way, welcome!

-
I recommend the SOG Powerlock for its pliers and its tools are pretty good too

-
Both wave and spirit offer pretty much a "complete package" in MT world, comes down to how you like to carry a MT:
Pocket carry with clip-> wave -> fast blade access
Shealth carry-> spirit -> perfect fit n finish -
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
-
I'd recommend the dog blacktip, as you get a taste of sog for only $30 from west marine. I then suggest deciding what is most important in the tool.
Long blades- surge, wave
Long drivers- OHT, spirit
All have outside opening blades, but oht and spirit are 100% external accessed tools
Scissors- surge are biggest, wave has longer blades than spirit, but lighter duty and shorter lever
Surge has the blade exchanger, which makes it highly versatile
All have excellent warrantys, my recommendation is telling us what your uses will be for the tool, and perhaps check some out in a store nearby if possible?
Welcome to MT.O

Fwiw, I pocket carry. I can carry wave/surge with pocket clip, but not deep pocket. The powerlock (or blacktip ;) ) I can't pocket carry. Vic spirit can be, but still not a fan, very dense little brick in pocket. The OHT is the only one I can comfortably deep pocket carry, as while it's not the lightest, it's the largest, so has my favorite pocket presence. It rides without flipping/bouncing around as much, though leaves little room for much else :D
So I guess this means, I disagree with Grant :o
-
I carry my spirit in a custom made pouch in my back pocket with a mini prybar and torch,dont really notice it there,

-
Pics


-
@Zed said:
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
The only one on your list I'd avoid is the Powerassist,it's the single worst multi I've owned(and I've had two),but,id go with Zed and Kampfer here
-
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
The only one on your list I'd avoid is the Powerassist,it's the single worst multi I've owned(and I've had two),but,id go with Zed and Kampfer here
Curious, do you not like the powerlock, or just that one handle on the PA?
Have you handled a blacktip? (non-assisted, similar style?) -
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
The only one on your list I'd avoid is the Powerassist,it's the single worst multi I've owned(and I've had two),but,id go with Zed and Kampfer here
Curious, do you not like the powerlock, or just that one handle on the PA?
Have you handled a blacktip? (non-assisted, similar style?)TBH,the only SOGs I would carry now are the Paratool and the PPP. I've had the Powerlock,which is ok,but is too big for my hands...which kind further rules out the Blacktip :D
As to the Powerassist,I really don't like the assist mechanism,and find the safety's too flimsy. I just don't trust them at all.
Oh,and SOG needs to make a better Phillips
-
Here's a shortlist to work from, picking what I would recommend from each main manufacturer.
Leatherman: Wave
Victorinox: Spirit X
SOG: Switchplier (Internal tools can be bought separately and are easily fitted if the stock loadout doesn't suit you)
Gerber: MP600 or MP400 or MP450 (Subject to tool preference). The OHT was styled after these tools, but failed to capture the functionality.
The OHT is bulky, limited in function, and has stubby blades. The Surge should only be considered if the Wave feels too small in your hands (it's more likely the Surge will feel too large) - try for size first if possible. The Powerassist is volatile, and can deploy the blades when you don't want them to - avoid!
-
^^^^That is a great list
-
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
The only one on your list I'd avoid is the Powerassist,it's the single worst multi I've owned(and I've had two),but,id go with Zed and Kampfer here
Curious, do you not like the powerlock, or just that one handle on the PA?
Have you handled a blacktip? (non-assisted, similar style?)TBH,the only SOGs I would carry now are the Paratool and the PPP. I've had the Powerlock,which is ok,but is too big for my hands...which kind further rules out the Blacktip :D
As to the Powerassist,I really don't like the assist mechanism,and find the safety's too flimsy. I just don't trust them at all.
Oh,and SOG needs to make a better Phillips
Thanks

Yeah, sometimes I forget not everyone is me, so things work differently for others :)
Phew! Glad the blacktip avoids your specific issues with the PA- I was afraid there was a fatal flaw in one of my favorites!
Agree about that silly #150ft- great analysis!
-
Do yourself a favor and check out the Rebar as well.
-
Pics

Very nice! I love the slip sheath for the knife, I wish I had one of those for every knife and tool I own. I like your spirit setup too! I can see how that could be back-pocket-friendly, for sure. I also like the prybar

Streamlight nano?
Yeah nano ,usually a solitaire,the knife slip came with a rough rider

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login