HELP TO DECIDE
-
Victorinox spirit or leatherman wave
both excellent mt's 
@Kampfer said:
Add victorinox Spirit to the listFor most people, wave of spirit are the clear winners.
Me, like most of us here, have them all. :D
The only one on your list I'd avoid is the Powerassist,it's the single worst multi I've owned(and I've had two),but,id go with Zed and Kampfer here
Curious, do you not like the powerlock, or just that one handle on the PA?
Have you handled a blacktip? (non-assisted, similar style?)TBH,the only SOGs I would carry now are the Paratool and the PPP. I've had the Powerlock,which is ok,but is too big for my hands...which kind further rules out the Blacktip :D
As to the Powerassist,I really don't like the assist mechanism,and find the safety's too flimsy. I just don't trust them at all.
Oh,and SOG needs to make a better Phillips
Thanks

Yeah, sometimes I forget not everyone is me, so things work differently for others :)
Phew! Glad the blacktip avoids your specific issues with the PA- I was afraid there was a fatal flaw in one of my favorites!
Agree about that silly #150ft- great analysis!
-
Do yourself a favor and check out the Rebar as well.
-
Pics

Very nice! I love the slip sheath for the knife, I wish I had one of those for every knife and tool I own. I like your spirit setup too! I can see how that could be back-pocket-friendly, for sure. I also like the prybar

Streamlight nano?
Yeah nano ,usually a solitaire,the knife slip came with a rough rider

-
@50ft-trad said:
SOG: Switchplier (Internal tools can be bought separately and are easily fitted if the stock loadout doesn't suit you)This is actually a great suggestion. It doesn't have room for the sheer number of tools featured on a Wave or Powerlock, but you could pair with a nice folder, then replace the blade on the SP2 with a saw. That load-out would cover almost all the bases that the Wave covers in essence. The common drivers, openers, and an awl to boot. More compact and lighter than all the other options you mentioned.
If you took you Surge budget, that would cover the SP2 and really nice folder!
Or get something budget like a Ka-Bar Dozier for $20 and save some cash for the next tool purchase. 
-
@50ft-trad said:
Gerber: MP600 or MP400 or MP450 (Subject to tool preference). The OHT was styled after these tools, but failed to capture the functionality.The OHT is bulky, limited in function, and has stubby blades.
I have to disagree here. :P
Sure it's not perfect but saying it failed to capture the functionality is really pushing it.
The OHT and MP600 share very similar length blades, the Gerber PE being the shortest.
Rebar and Spirit blades are less than a cm longer.I wish someone would make spring loaded (OHT) blunt nosed pliers (MP600) with capable wire cutters (Surge/ST300).
-
@50ft-trad said:
Gerber: MP600 or MP400 or MP450 (Subject to tool preference). The OHT was styled after these tools, but failed to capture the functionality.
The OHT is bulky, limited in function, and has stubby blades.
I have to disagree here. :P
Sure it's not perfect but saying it failed to capture the functionality is really pushing it.
The OHT and MP600 share very similar length blades, the Gerber PE being the shortest.
Rebar and Spirit blades are less than a cm longer.I wish someone would make spring loaded (OHT) blunt nosed pliers (MP600) with capable wire cutters (Surge/ST300).
-that don't impede gripping area (??)
:D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Gerber: MP600 or MP400 or MP450 (Subject to tool preference). The OHT was styled after these tools, but failed to capture the functionality.
The OHT is bulky, limited in function, and has stubby blades.
I have to disagree here. :P
Sure it's not perfect but saying it failed to capture the functionality is really pushing it.
The OHT and MP600 share very similar length blades, the Gerber PE being the shortest.
Rebar and Spirit blades are less than a cm longer.I wish someone would make spring loaded (OHT) blunt nosed pliers (MP600) with capable wire cutters (Surge/ST300).
Having never owned an OHT, I've never done a side by side comparison, but I have held an OHT and it "gave the impression" of having particularly short blades and someone's comparison or review said it's like having Juice tools in a Surge. If the MP600s are indeed shorter, then fair enough, but they don't feel "undersized" like they seem to on an OHT.
Blade size aside, the MP600 does offer a greater range of functionality than the OHT currently does. Depending on the model you choose you can have scissors, file, diamond file, awl, blade changer, and a wide range of different plier heads, not to mention the other tools on the military versions. They are also compatible with Gerber's bit adapters, whereas I don't believe the OHT has a compatible bit set..... but I could be wrong on that. I think the MP600s have more tools on them too, but I haven't checked so I could be wrong there too.
Like always, the better tool is the one which best suits the users need, so everything is subjective

..... oh, and good point SAKnight
:D -
@50ft-trad said:
Gerber: MP600 or MP400 or MP450 (Subject to tool preference). The OHT was styled after these tools, but failed to capture the functionality.
The OHT is bulky, limited in function, and has stubby blades.
I have to disagree here. :P
Sure it's not perfect but saying it failed to capture the functionality is really pushing it.
The OHT and MP600 share very similar length blades, the Gerber PE being the shortest.
Rebar and Spirit blades are less than a cm longer.I wish someone would make spring loaded (OHT) blunt nosed pliers (MP600) with capable wire cutters (Surge/ST300).
-that don't impede gripping area (??)
:D
In my experience placement of the cutters are not a problem.
One day when I have the time I'll take pics to show why.
Surge/ST300 because the jaws close more and they have the handle side stranded wire cutters. -
@50ft-trad said:
Do yourself a favor and check out the Rebar as well.
..... but if you like the specs try to handle one before you buy, as I think they're really uncomfortable. Tried it twice, and couldn't get along with it.
Really? I actually find the rebar much more comfortable than the wave.
-
The rebar is more comfy than the wave, but the spirit is even more comfortable

-
Judging from the short list of OP, he/she may want an OHO blade on a MT. Among all those listed, I would favor LM Wave.
If we are open to suggest we want, then I too would give my vote to Spirit. For the easy quick access to all tools, excellent fit and finish and consistent great quality.
-
I'm more of the scissors type so outside of the Micra, it's a Surge due to the outside opening scissors- followed by a Wingman then Wave.
But after using a Swisstool, I'm casting my lot with them.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Do yourself a favor and check out the Rebar as well.
..... but if you like the specs try to handle one before you buy, as I think they're really uncomfortable. Tried it twice, and couldn't get along with it.
Really? I actually find the rebar much more comfortable than the wave.
@Zed said:
The rebar is more comfy than the wave, but the spirit is even more comfortable
Wow, I'm really very surprised at that, gents. I find the Wave fine, but the Rebar to be covered in hotspots. I would certainly much rather use the Wave over a prolongued period of time than the rebar. Though of course I agree on the comfort of the Spirit
-
to start thanks to everybody.
well, i need a multitool good for sailing but even good for edc, so an easy accessible blade is a must for me, better if one handed (so i've excluded the powerlock, the reebar and the super tool 300).
For edc i need a good pair of pliers with a good wire cutter (in the oht and the surge i love the replaceable 154cm wire cutter, in the powerassist, but also in the powerlock, i love the replaceable pliers and the compound system) and some screwdrivers, or a bit driver (and in the wave there is one big and one small, but the bit driver of sog is universal so i don't need to buy a kit of drivers). in case of outdoor i like to have also a saw.
i like also the sog life-warranty instead of the 25 of leatherman -
I think mini surge would suit your needs. /topic/51718 also replace the driver with a phillips, and get the bit adapter from leatherman so you can use universal bits.
-
I'm a former boat owner, so despite being a fan of the Spirit, I'm now more inclined to suggest the Wave based on this latest info. The shiny surface of the Spirit helps greatly with corrosion resistance, but hinders the grip with wet or oily hands.
The Wave on the other hand has better lanyard options for tieing your tool off so it doesn't go in the drink, has a more positive grip in the wet, plus the OHO serrated knife for when you need to cut a line QUICK for safety reasons! That said, I always prefered to have a dedicated knife rather than one on a multitool. The Leatherman is more susceptible to rust in a marine environment, but in my opinion it will be a more superior tool for you.
If you are prepared to consider a dedicated knife (either a clipped folder or a fixed sheath knife), I would personally still leave the MP400 /MP600 option open too. Scratch the Spirit for marine, but by all means consider it as an EDC tool. It really is a fantastic tool, but it's not the right tool for out on a boat IMHO.
If you're considering sheath carry, the bit set for the Wave will carry easily, but if you want to use standard bits, the bit extender you can get will sort that problem too. It's not often I will recommend a Leatherman tool over alternatives as I've had a lot of disappointment with them in the past, but on this occasion it's the right thing for me to do
-
Surge and Wave are my favorite in the list. I don't care for the OHT because it's huge and lacks tools.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
surely the other way around ;)