HELP TO DECIDE
-
can a powerlock/powerassist 's owner write pro an cons of those two mts?
I have a PowerLock, a Surge, a Wave, a Charge ALX, a Spirit, a SwissTool, an MP600, an MP400, and a Pocket PowerPlier.
The PowerLock has a one-handed opening pliers, but I don't think I'd risk it on a boat. It opens butterfly-style and has a glossy finish, so if you slip, it's going to fly overboard. Using a lanyard is a good option, but it shouldn't be necessary just to open it without losing it, right? Also, the blade is not as easily accessible, and that is one of your priorities.
I like the MP600, but the blade is also not easily accessible, and the wire cutter is really bad. It doesn't cut ANY wire well. Too bad, because the rest of the tool is great, especially for the money.
"Mini-Surge" is just a smarty-pants way of saying "Wave".
With the latest information, I think I'd go with the Wave, Surge, or Charge. How to decide which? Go by hand size and whether you find yourself needing scissors often.
The Surge is good for those with big hands. It works OK in small hands too, but just requires moving it around in one's grip sometimes. It also has externally accessible scissors, whereas the smaller scissors of the Wave and Charge are inside the tool, and take much longer to get to. It takes long enough that you'll find often yourself settling for the blade, because it's so much faster to get to. The Surge also has an awl, which the Wave/Charge don't. Lastly, it has the longest blade, which in a pinch, might be better for fighting. (maybe not too, because the big mass of the tool in the hand would slow the hands down...)
Personally, I like the Wave/Charge better. My hands are on the smaller side, and it just feels better. I use scissors as much as a knife blade, but the feel when using the pliers is just so much better to me, that I prefer the Wave/Charge better in the end.
Between the Wave and Charge, the Wave is slimmer and less expensive, and just as useful as the Charge. But the Charge (AL, ALX, and TTi) are less slippery when wet, because the handles have some texture, instead of just smooth stainless steel. I think you'd be less likely to drop it on a boat.
Then, it's just down to the specific model of Charge to get:
Wave is the base model.
Charge AL adds hard-anodized aluminum scales and better blade steel for the plain-edged blade
Charge ALX adds the better blade steel, aluminum scales, a cutting hook on the back of the serrated blade, a crimper in the pliers, and replaces the scissors and dedicated large flat head screwdriver with another identical bit driver.
Charge TTi is just like the ALX, except that it has titanium handle scales instead of hard-anodized aluminum.
The dual bit drivers (triple, if you count the micro bit driver) on the TTi and ALX are a polarizing feature. On one hand, they let you carry four bits on board, which is nice. But at the heavy cost of scissors and a large flat head screwdriver, which doubles as a prying tool.
Pick whichever Charge you like, then find it used here or on ebay at a fair price. I got my Charge ALX used on ebay for the price of a new Wave, ($90) and I got a like new Wave for only $50.
Lastly, here's a video that compares many of the multi-tools mentioned above:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
Nice post! Very thorough, I've never really considered the Charge as much more than an overpriced Wave (additional features weren't worth it for me), but the added grip of the handles is a good point to focus on in this case.
Also, I wasn't sure if you knew that the Mini Surge is a modded Wave, but I figure I'll post a link here anyway. It's pretty impressive I think.
/post/1038727
-
I think you made a typo, charge tti is same as charge al but with different blade steel and handle material.
Mini surge, is awesome!
-
Good catches, Fellas. I forgot that the TTi now has S30v blade steel.
Alas, I'm beyond my editing period.
If mod wants to fix the typos, go ahead.
-
It looks a little overbuilt to me but the Surge gets my vote.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login