Sak Help?
-
Thanks huntsman,
The corkscrew is the only thing he doesn't like, idk, he just said he doesn't like it
anyway, since I don't have any larger(111)sak, how is the locking on these? There are the two diff ones, the liner and the slide, I'm guessing the liner is like any other, but I didn't see any with pliers, and with his small fingers I think a slide might be better, but are they good? Like I said I have no experience with these!
JRI have both 111mm with slide lock and liner lock, and personally like the liner lock better for possibly more sturdier construction(but you may need a little finger dexterity and strength to close blade with one hand, probably may not be ideal for a young child, depending on how you look at it).
The 111mm is an interesting idea, but are we sure this will reduce siblings rivalry since it has bigger blade/appearance?

The kids hands are kinda small and weak, that's the one thing that's got me worried, his brother on the other hand I don't think will care, I have yet to see him really use his sak, right now he is so into sports and food, he'd find a fork or football more interesting! Today the little guy starts robotics, so he's more of a gear-head and will probably sleep with his sak, on top of that he's been waiting for his since his brother got his 4yrs ago!
JR -
Ok, here's a thought, if the little guy is so interested on the pliers and not a corkscrew, what if I kinda broke tradition and instead of getting a sak, got a Multitool? Maybe a leatherman? I can't afford a sak Multitool, it's still a tool for 12, that atlas huntsman mentioned is more then the Hercules, and yet that comes with scissors and a extra Philips! Yet if he's going to get into robotics and other stuff, maybe a Multitool is better? Maybe something with the interchangeable bits? I guess later tonight I'll have to let him try out a leatherman and see how it goes?
JR -
I'd have to agree about the corkscrew. My Explorer is the only SAK that has one. I use it for disentangling shoe lace knots, and carrying the eyeglass/jeweler's screwdriver, and that's it. The inline Phillips is nowhere near as good as the backside one, as it won't fit as small a screw as the backside one can. In addition, the can opener's flat head can fit into places to reach Phillips screws the inline Phillips can't.
I've tried at least 10 SAKs over the years. My favorites are still 4-layer models, especially my original SAK--the Fieldmaster which I bought when I was 8. Anymore these days, I'm carrying a pliers based tool along with an SAK, typically my Leatherman PST II or Super Tool. I prefer the PST II, as it's compact enough that I won't need a sheath. That way, I have the extra file and screwdrivers as well as the full-sized pliers and a partially serrated blade. It, combined with my Fieldmaster gives me the tools to complete most tasks.
If he's getting into robotics, then why not try one of the CyberTool variants? I think the CT34 Lite has just about everything he wants--and more! But then again, it has that useless corkscrew. I'd have this one on my list if it had the backside Phillips instead.
-
If you can afford a 111mm SAK with pliers, you can afford a pliers-based multi-tool.
If hand size and strength is an issue, a Wave is probably out of the question.
I'd suggest a Gerber MP400. That's their compact one, but still usable when he's grown. It'll take their own bit driver adapter, which is quite good, and then he can use any 1/4" hex bit. He'd get pliers, scissors, a few good screwdrivers, all for $26.
Some time down the line, get him the bit adapter that uses the square shank of the Phillips, and maybe one of those Ryobi or Milwaukee bit kits at Home Depot.
It is a bit more fun to fiddle with than a SAK.
Lastly, you could do the easy mod to remove or replace the blade, then he could even take it to school with him.
last thought, the big locking blade of a 111mm SAK may not be such a good idea for a little guy.
The Leatherman Juice S2 is a good option, but not nearly as versatile as the Gerber MP400, especially considering it costs twice as much.
So, given this latest information, my vote is for an MP400. (if you think his hands are big enough for a compact full size MT)

-
If you consider a Wave, that has the replaceable bits you mentioned. It's also a good size plier for younger hands.
No corkscrew, and all the accessories you could want (except an Awl).
-
Interesting possible change of direction. I initially thought LM Blast actually or PST 2. The metal file could come in handy for robotics ( ? ). Not sure about handle splay for a 12 year old tho.
Because he likes the mag glass ( and who doesn't? ) MT wise he'll have to compromise on that. If he/you think pliers are high on the list then I say go for a MT as the pliers on the SAK are super tweezers mostly. Funny thing is what he really needs is BOTH a SAK and MT
.BTW do any SAKs with the mag glass come with backside phillips vs corkscrew?
-
If you're moving towards full size pliers multitools, my recommendation would be the Diesel. Smaller gripping circumference than any of the Leatherman tools, all the tools he's looking for, compatible with a bit kit (just make sure you buy the right one), and won't break the bank if he damages it while he's learning about tools.
If you're worried it might be too big a tool for him, check out my thread which compares handle ergonomics, as the Diesel is a better choice than even smaller stuff like a Juice.
File, woodsaw, scissors, drivers, openers, no corkscrew :P, compatible bit set available, and pliers, all in a format that his hands will be able to cope with.
-
Ok, schools out, so he'll be in robotics club now, today is more or less a gathering to exsplain about everything.. So, he should be home soon to rip our ears apart on what he'll be doing
so when he's done maybe I can show him an original wave and a skeletool to see what he thinks, and see what he likes better between them or a sak.. So we'll see..
JR -
LEAP ??? :D :o
-
Well I let him fidget around with the LM wave, and he liked it, but,, he likes the sak better.. I liked how he just said "but I like the carpenter"! Of course one that is no longer manufactured.
JR -
GET BOTH MTo way.
Swisschamp and dedicated pliers.
-
Anyone a Victorinox Hercules owner?
JR -
Yes. Too big for pocket carry; good spot just before the workchamp in the lineup; lacks one handed opening and the stronger bottle opener/prybar of the smaller liner lock models.
-
@Grass said:
Yes. Too big for pocket carry; good spot just before the workchamp in the lineup; lacks one handed opening and the stronger bottle opener/prybar of the smaller liner lock models.Thanks, too big for pocket carry no biggie, same for one handed, at least he should have a easier time opening it with two hands.
JR -
Robotics club? I think either a Craftsman or a Spirit would work for that.

-
Does anyone know what kind of sheath is suitable for a Hercules or Workchamp?
-
@MadPlumbarian said:
So I did a little one on one with the little guy and asked him what he liked and this is what I came up with..These are the tools that he likes
Saw
Pliers
File
Mag glass
And the hook
Of course the blade, can opener/screwdriver, and bottle opener/screwdriver..
The one tool he didn't like was the corkscrew ...

SwissChamp

Mark the question as "Closed"

;)
Brilliant!!
He may not like the corkscrew now but it's only a matter of time before he finds some neat things to use it on. It's also a great place to put the little driver and he may find some good uses for that as well.

:D -
Ok, an update, I still couldn't figure out what to get him, nothing fit his tool combo and he wanted the larger 111, but I don't even have any sak that size. So, this morning for giggles I went on Amazon and my jaw dropped
, the original one that my grandfather gave me, and the one that I gave my older kid when he turned 12 was on sale, and I mean ON SALE! So I showed the wife, and said its not totally what he wants but it's what I gave the other kid, so she's like so, it's on sale, lol. So we fig that we might as well get it and just keep the tradition going, so I got him a champion plus, and cheap too! No it's not the imitation cause when I loaded the page it showed that I had bought the same one 4yrs ago for the other kid, just like it says now that I got it today! Idk how long it's going to stay that price so I highly advise anyone to grab it if your on the lookout for one!
JRNow I just got to get him a sheath, probably a black one so he doesn't get his brothers brown one mixed up..

-
There are Champions available, new from Vic?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login