Mega MT Test - Saw Test - In progress
-
@50ft-trad said:
Is your favourite still the one on the 108mm Vics, Nikola?


:ashley:
:P
Not really. >:D
I got two loose 108mm saws from lowtech some time ago to install them in some holder or into one of my GAKs to try the size/format again at some point and redo all the tests but never got around to do so yet.
-
...
But I think we in this forum know the winner will be the Surge with a big jigsaw blade (if that is allowed)2nd = 130mm Wenger. It has the longest saw blade and the most material behind it for stiffness, as well as the excellent double-cut, neutral pitch teeth (cut on push and pull strokes)
3rd place = 111mm Victorinox
4th place = 91mm Victorinox
5th place = who cares? This is getting into "loser" or "better than nothing" category.
Wouldn't bet on that. Although the 130mm Wenger and the 111mm Vic saws are longer, they are also thicker than the 91mm and 85mm saws, almost twice as thick. That means you'll have to saw away twice as much material to cut the same branch thickness making you slower and using more energy.
Also the Surge blade exchanger saw is shorter to compensate for the space needed for the blade exchanger and also thicker than a standard saw. So I would rank it somewhere in the middle or lower part of the spectrum.
One of the better saws on multies is the one on the Juice models. About the same length as the Wave one and thin.

The surge is capable of holding a far longer, thinner blade as well though. You just can't close it. As for the Vic saws, that's precisely why I don't prefer the spirit saw, and why I love sog's (albeit short) wide tooth narrow spine saw
-
Many short plus a summary.

Hey, Zoidberg.
Sorry for making it confusing, I re-write what I have, so do you still stick to 'many shorts + 1 summary"?
:DSay I was looking for the info:
I would like to see the summary first - what tools worked better.
Then I would look at the tests in order of the sizes that interested me - everything in that size.
Followed by a quick visual comparison of the sizes for reference - gives it some perspective.
Summary plus different sizes plus size comparison, now I'm the one making it confusing. :D
-
@SAKnight said:
This reminds me of a competition my father had back in the day, his huntsman vs his friend's original supertool, through a 2x4. Huntsman took it, but I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.For me, I prefer Leatherman's saw on dry wood, and Vic's on green

Can't wait to see your tests!!
Edit: Short videos with a summary is preferable to me also
After 48+ min of testing and learning, I tend to think there maybe some trick to use MT saw more efficiently. But it may not make much of a difference if you fingers/arms are fatigue. So there is some merits of being athletic and fit, and you may saw longer and faster.
Is there any reason for LM for dry vs Vic for green? Or it's just experience?
-
@50ft-trad said:
If I've understood the question correctly.....I'd do in depth reviews of each tool showing the full range of features it has to offer, and then a "highlights" video which shows the big winners and big losers for a particular function in each of the main tool groups. This way, if a saw is a key item on their multitool, they can review the saw "highlights" video and see which tools work well on that function, then look at the tool specific video for more details on it.
This means you'll also have to do file reviews, screwdriver reviews for common tasks (electrical connections, door hinges, battery changes on small electronics, thumbscrew torture devices, MRI scanner calibration :P), scissor reviews, plus in depth compilation reviews of all the individual tools and the functions they offer ....
.... should keep you occupied for a while >:D
:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D
:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D
I think you speak the truth, but I ain't sure I can handle it...
:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D
:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:D >:DSo as long there is a 'summary' video, people will be lazy and just watch that instead of all the individual videos. :ahhh
My original intention was to review and compare 16 popular tools in different sizes, but I figure if I want to go in-depth for each individual tool, that video will be waaaay too long and no one will ever finish it.
Right now, I am still not certain what's best for the video format. For future prosperity, I think do 1 multitool per video, semi in-depth, then do a bi-annual total summary may be a good idea. Decisions, decisions.....
-
@50ft-trad said:
Is your favourite still the one on the 108mm Vics, Nikola?



:ashley:
:P
Not really. >:D
I got two loose 108mm saws from lowtech some time ago to install them in some holder or into one of my GAKs to try the size/format again at some point and redo all the tests but never got around to do so yet.
I just rewatched your 108mm testing...man, I can only say I am so not looking forward to test my Mauser.

-
Many short plus a summary.

Hey, Zoidberg.
Sorry for making it confusing, I re-write what I have, so do you still stick to 'many shorts + 1 summary"?
:DSay I was looking for the info:
I would like to see the summary first - what tools worked better.
Then I would look at the tests in order of the sizes that interested me - everything in that size.
Followed by a quick visual comparison of the sizes for reference - gives it some perspective.
Summary plus different sizes plus size comparison, now I'm the one making it confusing. :D
Sounds like an i-bank investment memorandum format, and like most investors on prospectus, they always only read the first page. >:D
-
This reminds me of a competition my father had back in the day, his huntsman vs his friend's original supertool, through a 2x4. Huntsman took it, but I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
For me, I prefer Leatherman's saw on dry wood, and Vic's on green

Can't wait to see your tests!!
Edit: Short videos with a summary is preferable to me also
After 48+ min of testing and learning, I tend to think there maybe some trick to use MT saw more efficiently. But it may not make much of a difference if you fingers/arms are fatigue. So there is some merits of being athletic and fit, and you may saw longer and faster.
Is there any reason for LM for dry vs Vic for green? Or it's just experience?
Again, just opinion based, but it's felt like the leatherman saw, it bites really hard on the pull stroke, which in green, fibrous wood, can be more difficult to manage than the Vic saw, which is neutral pushing/pulling. So in dry wood, the leatherman saw won't get bound up by strong wood fibers as bad, but can get a really aggressive bite into it.
Hope that makes sense, I've gotten into the russe a bit :D
-
This reminds me of a competition my father had back in the day, his huntsman vs his friend's original supertool, through a 2x4. Huntsman took it, but I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
For me, I prefer Leatherman's saw on dry wood, and Vic's on green

Can't wait to see your tests!!
Edit: Short videos with a summary is preferable to me also
After 48+ min of testing and learning, I tend to think there maybe some trick to use MT saw more efficiently. But it may not make much of a difference if you fingers/arms are fatigue. So there is some merits of being athletic and fit, and you may saw longer and faster.
Is there any reason for LM for dry vs Vic for green? Or it's just experience?
Again, just opinion based, but it's felt like the leatherman saw, it bites really hard on the pull stroke, which in green, fibrous wood, can be more difficult to manage than the Vic saw, which is neutral pushing/pulling. So in dry wood, the leatherman saw won't get bound up by strong wood fibers as bad, but can get a really aggressive bite into it.
Hope that makes sense, I've gotten into the russe a bit :D
It's a little too early to disclose which saw is better
, but you are absolutely right in observing the LM Juice is sawing more on pull stroke.So far, my big away lesson from all these sawings is--if you know you may do a fair bit of sawing, and you could afford to lug a Silky Boy or Bahco Laplander with you, then by all means do it.
All the other functions on a multitool can be a decent alternative to the real tool, and user experience will not be that substantially different. But experience of using a real saw vs multitool saw is totally two different worlds apart. >:D
-
This reminds me of a competition my father had back in the day, his huntsman vs his friend's original supertool, through a 2x4. Huntsman took it, but I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
For me, I prefer Leatherman's saw on dry wood, and Vic's on green

Can't wait to see your tests!!
Edit: Short videos with a summary is preferable to me also
After 48+ min of testing and learning, I tend to think there maybe some trick to use MT saw more efficiently. But it may not make much of a difference if you fingers/arms are fatigue. So there is some merits of being athletic and fit, and you may saw longer and faster.
Is there any reason for LM for dry vs Vic for green? Or it's just experience?
Again, just opinion based, but it's felt like the leatherman saw, it bites really hard on the pull stroke, which in green, fibrous wood, can be more difficult to manage than the Vic saw, which is neutral pushing/pulling. So in dry wood, the leatherman saw won't get bound up by strong wood fibers as bad, but can get a really aggressive bite into it.
Hope that makes sense, I've gotten into the russe a bit :D
It's a little too early to disclose which saw is better
, but you are absolutely right in observing the LM Juice is sawing more on pull stroke.So far, my big away lesson from all these sawings is--if you know you may do a fair bit of sawing, and you could afford to lug a Silky Boy or Bahco Laplander with you, then by all means do it.
All the other functions on a multitool can be a decent alternative to the real tool, and user experience will not be that substantially different. But experience of using a real saw vs multitool saw is totally two different worlds apart. >:D
No 12 opinel saw is one of my staples for the woods

-
Pic for scale. I've had this for about three years, and used it on some impressive wood (hophorn beam, also called ironwood in these parts. Known for dulling the tools of early settlers in the area), it's still razor sharp, and stain proof to boot (had green wood residue on it for a year no permanent staining).
Very impressed.
Want the next size (18?) with replaceable blades. This one is nice, light and pocketable. Extremely effective, would recommend to anyone who needs a saw in this size


-
@SAKnight said:
Pic for scale. I've had this for about three years, and used it on some impressive wood (hophorn beam, also called ironwood in these parts. Known for dulling the tools of early settlers in the area), it's still razor sharp, and stain proof to boot (had green wood residue on it for a year no permanent staining).Very impressed.
Want the next size (18?) with replaceable blades. This one is nice, light and pocketable. Extremely effective, would recommend to anyone who needs a saw in this size

This looks really nice, I like the fact that it seems to be able to offer better sawing than my MTs, but meanwhile still pocketable if needed.

-
Just the size of the teeth tells a lot of the story

-
Shoot the video and do the editing, then see how long the video ends up. If it's > 30 min, break it down. < 30 min., leave it as one. This is kind of a speSmurfpillst video, so no need to clutter up your channel with lots of different similar videos.
Zoidberg: Good point about the saw thickness; I had not considered that. But I would still bet on the longer one.
@SAKnight said:
I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.Challenge accepted.

I'll use a 130mm Wenger saw, and you use a Rebar or similar saw. We'll both shoot videos.
I think I'll win because of the longer saw blade length, and because the saw teeth aren't biased for pull- or push-cutting.
To make it more interesting, the loser gets banned from MTo for two days. :D
What do you say? :D
-
@Smaug said:
Shoot the video and do the editing, then see how long the video ends up. If it's > 30 min, break it down. < 30 min., leave it as one. This is kind of a speSmurfpillst video, so no need to clutter up your channel with lots of different similar videos.Zoidberg: Good point about the saw thickness; I had not considered that. But I would still bet on the longer one.
I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
Challenge accepted.

I'll use a 130mm Wenger saw, and you use a Rebar or similar saw. We'll both shoot videos.
I think I'll win because of the longer saw blade length, and because the saw teeth aren't biased for pull- or push-cutting.
To make it more interesting, the loser gets banned from MTo for two days. :D
What do you say? :D
If it stays within +/- 1 size class I would gladly. The 130 saw is very nearly double the rebar, which while I'm confident, is like saying I could beat a bow saw with my opinel. Just not gonna happen.
However, I'd gladly take the challenge with a wave, og supertool, 91/93mm, or surge (stock saw) :D
I also have to make a YouTube account and figure out how to post vids

I'll report back on this in a couple days.
I assume a standard 2x4?
-
-
Make a presentation of all contesters tested (saws + handles only)
-
Announce winner(s) among candidates (all VS all)
-
Show brief visual material from tests
-
Expand, explain. (You could use additonal footage)
Many contributing factors in SAK/multitool saw efficiency, as mentioned; length, thickeness, teeth pattern, handle width, position of the saw blade within handles (to the side or in the middle?), sawing technique, condition of the wood at hand. (
:P )I agree that Vic saws work better on green wood or wood that's recently dried out. Additionally, the Spirit's wood saw is really not a favourite of mine, not even remotely. I much prefer the saw on SAK Huntsman / Ranger / Handyman in 91mm size and on SAK Rucksack and Workchamp in 111mm size (slide-lock). The ones on liner-lock Vics, I think they work but I'm not impressed due to the combination of backspring tension, shape of the saw and its position on one side of the handle. I suspect that the saws on liner-lock Vics might be less prone to bending but I have nothing to support this claim.
Looking forward to seeing your videos

-
-
@Smaug said:
Shoot the video and do the editing, then see how long the video ends up. If it's > 30 min, break it down. < 30 min., leave it as one. This is kind of a speSmurfpillst video, so no need to clutter up your channel with lots of different similar videos.Zoidberg: Good point about the saw thickness; I had not considered that. But I would still bet on the longer one.
I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
Challenge accepted.

I'll use a 130mm Wenger saw, and you use a Rebar or similar saw. We'll both shoot videos.
I think I'll win because of the longer saw blade length, and because the saw teeth aren't biased for pull- or push-cutting.
To make it more interesting, the loser gets banned from MTo for two days. :D
What do you say? :D
Shoot the video and do the editing, then see how long the video ends up. If it's > 30 min, break it down. < 30 min., leave it as one. This is kind of a speSmurfpillst video, so no need to clutter up your channel with lots of different similar videos.
Zoidberg: Good point about the saw thickness; I had not considered that. But I would still bet on the longer one.
I'm inclined to believe any decent saw is comparable, it just comes down to the user. I'd race anyone through a 2x4 with any Vic, leatherman, or sog saw and regardless of what they were using I think it'd come down to man vs. man.
Challenge accepted.

I'll use a 130mm Wenger saw, and you use a Rebar or similar saw. We'll both shoot videos.
I think I'll win because of the longer saw blade length, and because the saw teeth aren't biased for pull- or push-cutting.
To make it more interesting, the loser gets banned from MTo for two days. :D
What do you say? :D
If it stays within +/- 1 size class I would gladly. The 130 saw is very nearly double the rebar, which while I'm confident, is like saying I could beat a bow saw with my opinel. Just not gonna happen.
However, I'd gladly take the challenge with a wave, og supertool, 91/93mm, or surge (stock saw) :D
I also have to make a YouTube account and figure out how to post vids

I'll report back on this in a couple days.
I assume a standard 2x4?
Wow...Crazy Saw-off!
Honestly, not only we are dealing with a wide selection of saws from many different MTs, we have soooo many factors that will really affect the results: hand hold vs vice, height of the sawing platform, grip on tool, personal fitness, oil vs water vs nothing on saw, etc...
I discover from my own data that even a few inches apart, the density of the wood may feel different and yields different results, while everything is as tightly controlled as possible.
This is gonna interesting!

-
-
Make a presentation of all contesters tested (saws + handles only)
-
Announce winner(s) among candidates (all VS all)
-
Show brief visual material from tests
-
Expand, explain. (You could use additonal footage)
Many contributing factors in SAK/multitool saw efficiency, as mentioned; length, thickeness, teeth pattern, handle width, position of the saw blade within handles (to the side or in the middle?), sawing technique, condition of the wood at hand. (
:P )I agree that Vic saws work better on green wood or wood that's recently dried out. Additionally, the Spirit's wood saw is really not a favourite of mine, not even remotely. I much prefer the saw on SAK Huntsman / Ranger / Handyman in 91mm size and on SAK Rucksack and Workchamp in 111mm size (slide-lock). The ones on liner-lock Vics, I think they work but I'm not impressed due to the combination of backspring tension, shape of the saw and its position on one side of the handle. I suspect that the saws on liner-lock Vics might be less prone to bending but I have nothing to support this claim.
Looking forward to seeing your videos

Thanks for the support! I remembered doing some very quick comparison between 91mm vs Spirit, and did recall not liking Spirit saw, despite its advantage in build and everything. But this test should offer a more data to proof that which might be better for sawing.
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
