Help me choose
-
The Farmer will get you there. Get one from Tim (Felinevet), maybe pick up a used Camper from Tim as an affordable alternative to new. If you go the used route, be sure to get a new toothpick too. :D
Mike
-
@cgk said:
I am looking to supplement my Skeletool with my first SAK. At this point (and Im sure it will change) I am deciding between a Farmer and Camper. I want a saw, I have lots of trees so it would be good for LIGHT, impromptu trimming. I was hoping for a backside phillips and awl (or reamer) but neither have that. Basically I want a thin SAK with a saw. Please give your thoughts on which of my two are thinner or suggest others. Thank-you.I would also recommend the Farmer. It doesn't have the backside phillips, but the can opener has a very functional phillips head on the end.
If not, you might want to look at the Fieldmaster, which is coincidentally being discussed in another thread right now.
Actually, the Hiker mentioned below might be better, since you didn't ask for scissors...
-
Well, there is always the Hiker, if you really want the back side phillips.

-
Thanks for the help. Your right max I did not mention scissors, wasted space on a knife (for me). So how do these match up on thickness?
SkinThin to win!! -
How about a forester ora OHT?
-
Nezza, your killing me!! I originally thought about getting a OHT with a pocket clip, but then I would have no pliers because I wont carry my Skeletool with it. I could carry a small pliers tool with the OHT but then my Skeletool will sit. I dont think I put enough thought into the Skeletool when I bought it. Ok I have to step away from this for a few....my head is going to explode. Oh and to top it off I thought the rescue tool would be good for SWAT purposes oh but wait the Boker Cop Tool is coming out.....I need a loan or a new hobby!!!
-
The Camper, Hiker and Farmer are all about the same thickness. The Farmer is slightly heavier, but also noticeably heavier-duty. I vote for the Farmer for ruggedness.
I don't think anyone has mentioned yet that the Farmer has the best awl/reamer in the business.
-
I would still recommend an OHT. If your skeletool is PE, get the serrated OHT, and vice versa. The extra length of the saw on 111mm makes a difference for me.
-
The awl on the Farmer is much better than any backside awl.
The can opener works on a lot of Phillips and is less awkward than a backside Phillips. -
Im torn between a Farmer and a OHT.....so many choices out there.
-
Shockingly I'm going to vote Farmer :o :D
There's nothing wrong with a Camper, it's a bloody fine sak :), but the Farmer is special. Heavy duty, very good looking and sheeple friendly, but more than that it's just so capable of dealing with 99% of everything thats thrown at it :)
-
I can't believe no one has said it yet but, why not get both :D
-
I suppose eventually I could get both but something ($$$$$) is preventing me at the moment.
-
I'm in the same boat at the moment, i kept following people's advise to just get both and my funds dried up ;)
-
To be more accurate the question is "which do I get first" I will probably end up with both at some point.
-
My suggestion would be to buy the Farmer. Try it, and use the can opener to turn a few phillips screws. If you don't like using the can opener for that purpose, then plan to buy a hiker later.
My bet is that you won't fell the need for a Camper or Hiker after you've tried the Farmer.
-
I will definitely pick the Farmer over other pocket SAK's but my problem is over the OHT. I can see putting a pocket clip on the OHT, and making it my primary knife over my current one (Skeletool and home, Boker folder at work). I see the Farmer as a secondary and the OHT as a primary carry. Geez I am indecisive, I hope I don't start growing a Uterus.
-
@cgk said:
I will definitely pick the Farmer over other pocket SAK's but my problem is over the OHT. I can see putting a pocket clip on the OHT, and making it my primary knife over my current one (Skeletool and home, Boker folder at work). I see the Farmer as a secondary and the OHT as a primary carry. Geez I am indecisive, I hope I don't start growing a Uterus.:D :D
Get that Farmer, you'll be suprised just how capable it really is :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login