Urban EDC Tool Test?
-
Kinda agree with Al, sawless = urban tool?
-
-
The comparison between SAK and pliers base MT goes on, if you don't need pliers, go with SAK, or if you need pliers, SAK is out.
Even small keychain pliers based MT like Squirt has stronger pliers than the 91mm pliers.
-
-
@50ft-trad said:
Off the top, if you're including the Mp400 and Wingman, then here are a few others which may qualify.....Leatherman Juice
Leatherman Rebar
Gerber Crucial
Gerber Balance
Gerber Strata
Victorinox Spirit
Leatherman Kick
SOG Paratool
SOG Pocket Power Plier
CRKT Tool
Leatherman Leap
Gerber Octane
Leatherman Skeletool.... to be honest, I'm unsure as to what you are classifying as an urban tool, which is why I have put so many forward. Here for exampe, I wouldn't consider the Wingman or Mp400 or X-Tract as urban tools due to the locking blade. In Germany where locking OR OHO is permitted, then the MP400 would be fine, but the other two wouldn't. Different areas in the US permit different length blades, so that's even more confusing.
Multitools without saws maybe?

Then will heavy weight such as Gerber MP600 and SOG PowerAssist also qualify? >:D
-
@ducttapetech said:
SOG Paratool?That's us mobile.
NateI'll have to look into that. My thing with sog is all their inside components are the same. So one kind of covers the batch. Of course that isn't factoring in the frame.
Kind of
@50ft-trad said:
Off the top, if you're including the Mp400 and Wingman, then here are a few others which may qualify.....
Leatherman Juice
Leatherman Rebar
Gerber Crucial
Gerber Balance
Gerber Strata
Victorinox Spirit
Leatherman Kick
SOG Paratool
SOG Pocket Power Plier
CRKT Tool
Leatherman Leap
Gerber Octane
Leatherman Skeletool.... to be honest, I'm unsure as to what you are classifying as an urban tool, which is why I have put so many forward. Here for exampe, I wouldn't consider the Wingman or Mp400 or X-Tract as urban tools due to the locking blade. In Germany where locking OR OHO is permitted, then the MP400 would be fine, but the other two wouldn't. Different areas in the US permit different length blades, so that's even more confusing.
Multitools without saws maybe?

Then will heavy weight such as Gerber MP600 and SOG PowerAssist also qualify? >:D
Good question. I mean specifically tools that I look for myself. All of people have varying degrees of needs. For this test the basic tool sets would be: pliers, blade, scissors, and drivers (mainly phillips and flat) anything else is extra.
I do thing the juice is a better "option" than the wingman but it's more expensive than i think it's worth. and I don't have one.
so that's why I picked the wingman.Also note I not trying to do an exhaustive comparison but more of a "sample from each batch" type of comparison. Blade lengths, locking mechanisms, etc I did not take into account. All the blades listed are under 3" and the tinker is non locking. I'm in the US so it may not be the most helpful for those in the UK [emoji53] so all things considered this was the list I compiled based on my experience, preference, and basic tool needs of a us city citizen. I hope that helps.
-
-
Demel are you going to use this thread or start another for the results?
-
@NKlamerus said:
Demel are you going to use this thread or start another for the results?I will start another. Just wanted to get the opinions of those here.
-
Might sound silly but... Leatherman PST?
-
Well, I think you selected a pretty good batch there. Fire away.
Sent from 9 miles from the face of the sun
-
Here you go, a Juice crusher for you.
-
That looks good Kampfer. Is that the ppp? What tool is that next to the awl and bottle opener?
-
@50ft-trad said:
.... to be honest, I'm unsure as to what you are classifying as an urban tool,Clearly, an Urban EDC Tool 8) is a multitool raised in the inner city. Or a multitool you carry at a breakdance competition or rap battle?
They have implements for adjust pant-sag and for flattening the bill of your ball-cap. Also, an OHO crack spoon. Very handy...

-
That looks good Kampfer. Is that the ppp? What tool is that next to the awl and bottle opener?
It was a can opener but now is a flathead
Best thing to do with them - they're pretty feeble can openers but make a nice small flat driver.A lot of people have the same complain about the SOG can-openers, but I have never had a problem with them. Yeah, it's a jagged opening but it works just a well as Leatherman's and Gerber's openers.
-
I had nightmarish <u>can't opening</u> experience with SP2.0, which use standard SOG opener.
The grind is on the wrong side, very bull, it chewed up and disfigure the can instead of slicing the top off.
I have a pic here somewhere showing that. -
The comparison between SAK and pliers base MT goes on, if you don't need pliers, go with SAK, or if you need pliers, SAK is out.
Pretty much what Al decided. The test is a Deluxe Tinker vs. a Juice CS4
/post/456045
+1 JerseyDevil...thanks for sharing a great review and thread!

@Kampfer said:
The comparison between SAK and pliers base MT goes on, if you don't need pliers, go with SAK, or if you need pliers, SAK is out.Even small keychain pliers based MT like Squirt has stronger pliers than the 91mm pliers.
Agreed, Kampfer. I carry a Cadet or 84/91mm Golfer during the workweek, but have a Squirt PS4 in my backpack on a work-related keychain daily. It's a combo that takes care of most situations. The Gerber BG mini-tool or Gerber Clutch also work for me in this combination, though the PS4 is the lightest of the three.
@Lynn LeFey said:
Might sound silly but... Leatherman PST?Not silly at all Lynn!

While I have an early PST (actually two), I never liked the feel of them while using them...a PST is quite uncomfortable when you really grip it using the pliers. But I found the Juice S2 and found it to be a great companion, comfortable tool with an SAK in my pocket. I put the Juice on my belt and it's pliers compliment the SAK I'm carrying...when carrying the Juice, I can combine it with a Spartan Lite, a Super Tinker, a Cadet or Pioneer, or one of my Golfer/Compact mods for a good urban combination.
When I'm out in the country, I typically pair one of the above SAKs in my pocket and with a Gerber Strata on my belt. I know that I'm covered for almost all situations when hiking, working on the cabin, or just enjoying being outside.
For pocket carry SAKs, I find that for me, a 2- or 3-layer SAK is the most comfortable. Something like the Deluxe Tinker or an Explorer aren't comfortable. I have both, but never carry the DT. I have belt sheaths for both and carry the Explorer on occasion, but usually in combination with the S2 or Strata.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login