Your top brand
-
@50ft-trad said:
Aw man, I can't pick three of these :ahhh :ahhhHere's the problem. Top three fixed blade knives I'd want in my pack for general use, low maintenance (stainless), food safe (easy to clean), decent ergonomics, and not big budget but yet capable of more if things went awry, are as follows:
Cold Steel Roach Belly
Mora Hi Viz Companion
Boker + TUF.... and I haven't picked a multitool yet :ahhh
Clipped OHO non-locking folders:
Byrd and CRKT
.... still not picked a multitool
SAKs need to be mentioned, so that's Vic and Wenger, but Gerber and Leatherman both deserve a mention too....
It also should be noted that every single one of these manufacturers has A LOT of stuff I am not interested in. It's individual products that win me over, not the name that's on the side.
I think the most honest thing I can do is just tick "other" in the poll options, and state my reason as.....
I HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO BRAND LOYALTY WHATSOEVER!

Why a non-locking folder, when your options could be so much broader?
Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
-
@NG VI said:
Why a non-locking folder, when your options could be so much broader?Sent from my Z750C using Tapatalk
Pocket knives don't need locks, they slow me down, and I have had too many nicks and cuts CAUSED BY locks (specifically back locks and liner locks) where you have to put fingers or thumb in the path of the blade to release it. A lock often spoils what could be a very good knife, and in short I find them LESS safe.
With a non-locking folder, I can safely achieve everything that many people feel they need a locking blade for, including penetrating cuts or making a hole in something. If there is a task that I cannot achieve with a non-locking folder, then I need a fixed blade, not a folder that's pretending to be fixed.
I treat and handle lockers just the same way as slippies, and cannot recall a time when I was really glad the blade I was using locked, or wished I was using a locking blade instead. I see a dependence on locks as an impairment of knife skills, and see any use of a knife which relies on a lock as unsafe use of the knife.
YMMV

-
Ha! Victorinox wins by a landslide.
I "wasted" my #2 vote on Wenger. Didn't need to spend it there, since they are now under Vic.
Kershaw for the distant 3rd for me.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Pocket knives don't need locks, they slow me down, and I have had too many nicks and cuts CAUSED BY locks (specifically back locks and liner locks) where you have to put fingers or thumb in the path of the blade to release it. A lock often spoils what could be a very good knife, and in short I find them LESS safe.With a non-locking folder, I can safely achieve everything that many people feel they need a locking blade for, including penetrating cuts or making a hole in something. If there is a task that I cannot achieve with a non-locking folder, then I need a fixed blade, not a folder that's pretending to be fixed.
I treat and handle lockers just the same way as slippies, and cannot recall a time when I was really glad the blade I was using locked, or wished I was using a locking blade instead. I see a dependence on locks as an impairment of knife skills, and see any use of a knife which relies on a lock as unsafe use of the knife.
YMMV

That is really a stretch, to suggest that lockers are more dangerous to oneself than a slippy. It is written to comfort yourself over your draconic knife laws there. I know others are thinking it, but don't want to say it, since you're such a popular bloke around here. But I have to call you on it.
Locking folders do a REALLY good impression of a fixed blade, or they wouldn't be so popular. The only drawback is that they're harder to clean.
When it comes right down to it, I usually prefer slippies too, but not because they are somehow inherently safer.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Pocket knives don't need locks, they slow me down, and I have had too many nicks and cuts CAUSED BY locks (specifically back locks and liner locks) where you have to put fingers or thumb in the path of the blade to release it. A lock often spoils what could be a very good knife, and in short I find them LESS safe.
With a non-locking folder, I can safely achieve everything that many people feel they need a locking blade for, including penetrating cuts or making a hole in something. If there is a task that I cannot achieve with a non-locking folder, then I need a fixed blade, not a folder that's pretending to be fixed.
I treat and handle lockers just the same way as slippies, and cannot recall a time when I was really glad the blade I was using locked, or wished I was using a locking blade instead. I see a dependence on locks as an impairment of knife skills, and see any use of a knife which relies on a lock as unsafe use of the knife.
YMMV

That is really a stretch, to suggest that lockers are more dangerous to oneself than a slippy.** It is written to comfort yourself over your draconic knife laws there. I know others are thinking it, but don't want to say it, since you're such a popular bloke around here. But I have to call you on it.
**
Locking folders do a REALLY good impression of a fixed blade, or they wouldn't be so popular. The only drawback is that they're harder to clean.When it comes right down to it, I usually prefer slippies too, but not because they are somehow inherently safer.
Gee, that is about the most unkind thing I've heard said here in a while.
-
Looking at the results, I would never really consider LM as a top cutting tools maker.
It gets the votes because it has blades on its multitools, but you do not really buy a LM for its blade - the blade is a bonus :D50fttrad is popular?? :P :P :D
The idea is that if you use a locking blade like a fixed blade you run the risk (small or large - depending on the maker/lock) that it may close on you. This mainly happens when people are trying to stab objects with a folding knife.
Also for some if they only use locking knives they may hurt themselves with a non locking knife.
If you are just cutting, by pushing the blade down then locking or non locking works - unless the blade gets stuck and folds on you when you pull it back. A lot has to do with what people are used to, looks etc.
Some non locking knives are more secure (GEC Beartraps) than others (and more dangerous if they fold on you - get one with a halfstop)I use both types depending on how i feel like, but never trust any lock 100%
-
@50ft-trad said:
Pocket knives don't need locks, they slow me down, and I have had too many nicks and cuts CAUSED BY locks (specifically back locks and liner locks) where you have to put fingers or thumb in the path of the blade to release it. A lock often spoils what could be a very good knife, and in short I find them LESS safe.
With a non-locking folder, I can safely achieve everything that many people feel they need a locking blade for, including penetrating cuts or making a hole in something. If there is a task that I cannot achieve with a non-locking folder, then I need a fixed blade, not a folder that's pretending to be fixed.
I treat and handle lockers just the same way as slippies, and cannot recall a time when I was really glad the blade I was using locked, or wished I was using a locking blade instead. I see a dependence on locks as an impairment of knife skills, and see any use of a knife which relies on a lock as unsafe use of the knife.
YMMV

That is really a stretch, to suggest that lockers are more dangerous to oneself than a slippy. It is written to comfort yourself over your draconic knife laws there. I know others are thinking it, but don't want to say it, since you're such a popular bloke around here. But I have to call you on it.
Locking folders do a REALLY good impression of a fixed blade, or they wouldn't be so popular. The only drawback is that they're harder to clean.
When it comes right down to it, I usually prefer slippies too, but not because they are somehow inherently safer.
Wrong, actually! As a long time slip joint user, these are genuinely my views, and like I said I have never felt that locking blades give me personally any benefit, and are often more of a hinderance than a help.
I was asked why I prefer slippies, and I gave my explaination. You are more than welcome to disagree over tool preferences, but your xenophobic comments are wrong, unnecessary, and unwelcome.
-
:D -
As a Norwegian, I feel I should mention Helle as well. They do some screw-ups from time to time, but they make knives that feel good in the hand, look good, and work well.
Are you trying to tell us they make a Helle of a good knife?
And the Swedes are just trying to EKA out a few products.
-
@comis said:
But I forgotten to vote on 'Others', since I love the offerings from Enzo. They produce decent quality product with Scandi grind, but still at reasonable prices(unlike most small production 'bushcraft' knives we see nowadays that always range from 200 usd and up)Yes good call on Enzo. I have a couple of their PK70 slipjoints and the quality of fit and finish is amazing.
At the other end of the scale I think Hultafors deserves an honourable mention, just for value. You can find the Hultafors HVK, a perfectly reasonable carbon steel Mora-like, for £3 - £4.
-
As a Norwegian, I feel I should mention Helle as well. They do some screw-ups from time to time, but they make knives that feel good in the hand, look good, and work well.
Are you trying to tell us they make a Helle of a good knife?
And the Swedes are just trying to EKA out a few products.
A few? MORA than you think.
-
Look, Wenger you going to quit these jokes? I have Zero Tolerance for them. The Buck stops here, in my Opinelon. You had Becker quit it, or else!
-
It's well past my bedtime....

-
@Syncop8r said:
Look, Wenger you going to quit these jokes? I have Zero Tolerance for them. The Buck stops here, in my Opinelon. You had Becker quit it, or else!You have to strop it.
These cheap jokes Cold Steel my attention at work.
I will not Anza you anyMora.(My kids would not be proud if they saw this)
-
Arsène Wenger sounds really dirty when read the English way... :D :D
-
I re-voted, I also added cold steel to my favorites together with Victorinox and Mora.
Cold steel is my number one supplier of folding knifes. I think we share the same thoughts on how we would design a knife.
I owned an CS ak 47 before and loved it. I now have orderd the new 015 CS mini ak 47 with the new CTS XHP steel and DLC coating. We will see how it works out.I have a Mora MG carbon steel knife, for the money you can not get a better knife, i absolutely slammed the smurf out if it because i wanted to split some wood. After half a minute of hitting the knife i found out there was an old nail in the wood. Dent in the blade but it did not break. I mistreated it a couple of times so it is a bit rusty but it is bullet proof for a cheap price.
Victorinox: Swisstool is the best MT i have owned. -
I know I'll catch it for this but for multitools it has to be Leatherman. SAK's always seem like more of a slip joint than a tool based unit. Kind of like my MIL-K-818, but not as strong.
Another one you forgot to put on the list is Canal Street Cutlery. Great little slippies. Fit & finish is great and they use a variety of good steels.
You also forgot Bark River Knives. Really nice fixed blades.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
