Mega Multi-tool Saw Test - Mid Size MT
-
Thank you for watching!
That really is true--going into the tests, I wasn't expecting the kinda variance and learning curve that may involve, and one particular tool was so user unfriendly that I almost want to give up on the tool and pretend it never happened. It gotten so bad that the base of my right index finger were swollen for a day or two, just after 2 rounds of sawing.
Eventually, I adapted my handhold and developed different sawing strategies for different tool, and that significantly reduce all sawing time by at least 2-3 times.
-
When all of the testing is done, I think it might be interesting for you to do a short video on what you learned as far as usage. If you could explain your grip on various tools it might be helpful to viewers.
I seem to recall you had your index finger over the top of the tool on the smaller tools, and didn't notice that style grip used for the mediums.
I have to be honest and say that your testing methods are just SO much better than what I did in my saw tests. I almost feel embarrassed how much better, more thorough, and more scientific this is. I mean, as you mentioned, there's always going to be deviation in material, user at given time, etc. But i think you have done all due diligence in making this as unbiased and professional as possible.

-
Thanks for this video.

Now ... when you're done with the full size tools video ...
Could you redo all the tests with green wood? >:D

Some of the saws may behave differently on green wood as opposed to dry wood due to the teeth clogging up with sawdust, the juices flowing and crating a mass.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
When all of the testing is done, I think it might be interesting for you to do a short video on what you learned as far as usage. If you could explain your grip on various tools it might be helpful to viewers.I seem to recall you had your index finger over the top of the tool on the smaller tools, and didn't notice that style grip used for the mediums.
I have to be honest and say that your testing methods are just SO much better than what I did in my saw tests. I almost feel embarrassed how much better, more thorough, and more scientific this is. I mean, as you mentioned, there's always going to be deviation in material, user at given time, etc. But i think you have done all due diligence in making this as unbiased and professional as possible.

Lynn, as always, thank you for watching the video and your kind words.
You are right on the nail about using different grips on various tools. In pocket size tool saw test, I try maintain the index-on-top grip on all tools for consistency, and felt it was adequate for that size of tools.
But after 1-2 rounds into Mid size saw test, I surely feel that both one-grip-for-all ideology and index-on-top grip are less than optimal(index got really sore and not having enough leverage ), and I shouldn't fixate on any grip or ideology, but to just do what felt efficient and fast. By adopting different hand grips and saw strategy, overall saw time for all tools were greatly reduce. Though the process is tedious and long, I am just glad to take MTO advice on doing more rounds, otherwise, I would have never know how important relationship between grip/strategy/ergonomics.
-
@enki_ck said:
Thanks for this video.
Now ... when you're done with the full size tools video ...
Could you redo all the tests with green wood? >:D

Some of the saws may behave differently on green wood as opposed to dry wood due to the teeth clogging up with sawdust, the juices flowing and crating a mass.
That's in planning, and ideally I would love to do it if I could secure a fair amount of green wood with similar girth and consistency.
But meanwhile, I am making these videoes as building blocks for making killer comparison and review Vids for keychain/pocket/mid/large size MTs.
-
I doubt it's in the testing plans, but I also had a reciprocating saw wood blade clamped into a pair of vice grips as an additional test. I won't demand, but ask as nicely as possible, if you could add that to your testing with the larger tools. I'm curious how it compares in your better testing setup.
-
Love the commentary, hate that YT isn't showing the video in the subscription feed or sending a link via mail notification.
I have to say that I thought the Spirit and uncoated Wave would be even closer
-
@Lynn That's a great idea, I will look into that. I am thinking maybe the possibility of making an entire new video featuring all the impromptu saw setups(like different wire saws) vs folding saws, but with the same setup. What do you think?
@Styx Thanks for the subscription! I would look into that, and see what I can do to ensure subscribers get notice.
I would thought so too, but the different saw design/handle/grip may have something to do with the difference. But if I have to pick one to saw for hours, I still gonna choose Spirit. It is just more comfortable to use, and the feedback(it is weird, but I swear I could 'feel' the saw blade better, or maybe it was the coolaid I drink...) is phenomenal.@SteveC Thanks for watching!
-
-
Such a good video very professionall editing.And fun to watch.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
