Wingman vs. MP400?
-
I think it's a very fair comparison between these two tools. I do think the cap-lifter works better on the 400, though. However, I like both tools a lot. A ton of capability for not much money.
We need to convince Gerber to redesign the MP400:** an outside channel for the knife** and one for the scissors, add a clip and we would have a clear winner
Isn't that an Octane? :D
@50ft-trad said:
If Home Depot's $29.88 Skeletool deal continues into the holiday season this conversation could change....
I'm really not a fan of the Wingman, but I'd take one of those instead of a Skeletool every time
Yup, same here. The Wingman and Sidekick are flawed MTs, but I'd still rather own one than my old Skeletool. In fact I do own one rather than a Skeletool. ;)
Hahaha, I LOVE the Octane!
And yes it's close. But the Octane lacks scissors and it is not nearly as robust as the MP400. MP400 is a heavy-duty tool, no doubt about it. The Octane is a light-duty tool. I have actually retired mine because something in the plier head (pivot, I suspect) has warped enough that the plier action is really bound up. I have to exert a fair amount of force in order to open the jaws. And this damage came from light use. 
I fully agree with the second comment. Wingman is vastly superior to Skeletool, IMHO. The ergos on the Skele are awful. Being forced to use the driver in fully open position is annoying. And it barely has any functions. LM could greatly improve upon the Skeletool by adding function in the handle opposite the knife. It just looks cool - otherwise, not for me.

-
@50ft-trad said:
I think it's a very fair comparison between these two tools. I do think the cap-lifter works better on the 400, though. However, I like both tools a lot. A ton of capability for not much money.
We need to convince Gerber to redesign the MP400:** an outside channel for the knife** and one for the scissors, add a clip and we would have a clear winner
Isn't that an Octane? :D
@50ft-trad said:
If Home Depot's $29.88 Skeletool deal continues into the holiday season this conversation could change....
I'm really not a fan of the Wingman, but I'd take one of those instead of a Skeletool every time
Yup, same here. The Wingman and Sidekick are flawed MTs, but I'd still rather own one than my old Skeletool. ** In fact I do own one rather than a Skeletool. ;)**
Ditto! :D
Me as well. My Skeletool lasted about a week in my collection. Bloody uncomfortable thing to use.
-
I love the Skeletool and hosted a 31 days challenge last year to show how tough it is.
-
I like the Skeletool. I was surprised how well it did.
That's us mobile.
Nate -
Quality wise, I had no issues with it at all. In fact I'd go as far as to say it was very well made.... just very badly designed :P
Other than maybe a couple of recent releases ;) the Skele has got to be one of the most polarising tools in respect of owners opinion since the Mr Pinchys
-
@50ft-trad said:
Out of curiosity, what's your biggest complaint about the Skeletool, gentlemen?
I've played with one briefly in the past and I wasn't impressed. I played with a Wingman more extensively and I liked it some but those pliers handles are a complete deal breaker, still I think I would prefer the Wingman over the Skeletool, too.
I don't like using the driver in the open position as it doesn't feel robust, and ergonomically it feels wrong. Secondly, I really dislike the pliers handles, and how they scrunch your fingers together with the handle being concave. I just found it a horrible tool to use. I don't remember much else about the tool, as it was quite a while ago when I had it, and it wasn't for very long either.
That sums up my feelings as well. I'll happily admit that I think it's well made, but I found it very uncomfortable to use. As Al says though: each to their own. :)
-
To each their own, yes. I'd like to interview the people that designed the Skeletool, however.
The people that designed "The Kniper (is) an ultra-sophisticated weaponized lifesaver that'll easily replace every piece of survival gear in your bag", too

-
@50ft-trad said:
Quality wise, I had no issues with it at all. In fact I'd go as far as to say it was very well made.... just very badly designed :POther than maybe a couple of recent releases ;) the Skele has got to be one of the most polarising tools in respect of owners opinion since the Mr Pinchys
So much "YES" in this post. I cannot agree enough.
trad, get out of my head :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Quality wise, I had no issues with it at all. In fact I'd go as far as to say it was very well made.... just very badly designed :POther than maybe a couple of recent releases ;) the Skele has got to be one of the most polarising tools in respect of owners opinion since the Mr Pinchys
Pinchys aren't polarizing. You either love them or you're wrong...... >:D
-
@jerseydevil said:
Pinchys aren't polarizing. You either love them or you're wrong...... >:DThat's still polarizing, Bro.
-
I have no interest in the wingman or sidekick but I want a skeletool.

To each their own. -
@Alan K. said:
I have no interest in the wingman or sidekick but I want a skeletool.
To each their own.The Skeletool is actually a great little tool. I just prefer to carry other MT's that contain more features (onboard tools), so mine hasn't seen much action in a while. BUT there was a time several years ago when the Skeletool was my favorite of all. Things change I guess :P
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login