Swiza SAKs?
-
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.

-
@beerbaron said:
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.
To each his own.. I still have to find out what makes an undistinct 440 steel "good".
Vic uses a choppy 420 but it's been heat-treated insanely well and it's been tried and tested.
440 is what every China SAK is saying for a decade... unless it gives detailed info on type of 440, HRC, composition and steel mill, I'm not convinced... -
@Corwyn said:
Definately not Vic. I imagine Wenger's former CEO was like: "Silly Victorinox, firing me and my brilliant ideas. I'll show them and make a better knife with French-speakers, nicer steels and all the things I think saks need improving upon. We can even shove a white cross on it, use an existing watch maker and we can ride the Swiss coat-tails.":D :D

I can see why you call it a hipsterised Victorinox and part of me agrees. Another part of me also agrees that there's no real need for more pocket knife makers

I see this as a modern folder that has drawn conclusions from Vic's success (and copied/tweaked a few things in the process).
-
I like it!
Im looking forward to the first reviews!
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
Not for me, I will stick to what has served me so well fo the last 20 odd years.
-
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.

To each his own.. I still have to find out what makes an undistinct 440 steel "good".
Vic uses a choppy 420 but it's been heat-treated insanely well and it's been tried and tested.
440 is what every China SAK is saying for a decade... unless it gives detailed info on type of 440, HRC, composition and steel mill, I'm not convinced...I am pretty sure the blades on a SAK are inline with 440 instead of 420.
That's us mobile.
Nate -
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.

To each his own.. I still have to find out what makes an undistinct 440 steel "good".
Vic uses a choppy 420 but it's been heat-treated insanely well and it's been tried and tested.
440 is what every China SAK is saying for a decade... unless it gives detailed info on type of 440, HRC, composition and steel mill, I'm not convinced...I am pretty sure the blades on a SAK are inline with 440 instead of 420.
That's us mobile.
NateWell Vic uses X50CrMO steel hardened at 55-56 HRC.
I'm no speSmurfpillst on this, but I understood it falls between 420HC and 440A, it's the heat treatment that makes it stand out. It takes a good edge and nearly never rusts but it's miles behind modern steels.
http://www.pizzini.at/info_sak_engl.htm#Steelinfo
https://www.victorinox.com/medias/sys_master/8869928075294/CutleryINFO.pdf -
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.

To each his own.. I still have to find out what makes an undistinct 440 steel "good".
Vic uses a choppy 420 but it's been heat-treated insanely well and it's been tried and tested.
440 is what every China SAK is saying for a decade... unless it gives detailed info on type of 440, HRC, composition and steel mill, I'm not convinced...HRC is 57. Victorinox is ~56. So this is a small improvement, as long as they sharpen as easily as the Vics.
-
Hardness is not toughness is not abrasion resistance is not... DIN 1.4110 is old hat, but saying steel A is better than steel B, without any sort of context, is rarely informative at all. Personally, I'd rather have properly treated 440A than properly treated 440C in an "all-round" knife, because I don't like broken or chipped blades, while someone who wants to cut soft materials for a long time without having to sharpen the blade would obviously prefer 440C. (There is simply too much carbon and chromium in 440C, especially given that it isn't a PM steel.) I have seen at least one French knife manufacturer moving from very cheap steel A to another cheap steel, where steel A was more wear resistant given their heat treatment, but their customers prefered ease of sharpening. The current marketing trend in the US seems to be more (both more of each and a higher number of) alloy elements, higher HRC, and not caring too much about all the other factors which are harder to quantify in a meaningful way. You can get lovely knives with ridiculously cheap steel, it just isn't a useful marketing argument. And for hard use, several cheap steels utterly outperform popular high-end steels. There's a reason a Busse doesn't contain a lot of carbon...
Another problem with steels only identified by their standard number is the allowed variation means you know very little what you actually get, then factor in the problems with heat treatment and you end up with buying knives is a huge trust exercise.
-
Soft touch grip, nice modern style, good steel. I'm ordering one.

To each his own.. I still have to find out what makes an undistinct 440 steel "good".
Vic uses a choppy 420 but it's been heat-treated insanely well and it's been tried and tested.
440 is what every China SAK is saying for a decade... unless it gives detailed info on type of 440, HRC, composition and steel mill, I'm not convinced...HRC is 57. Victorinox is ~56. So this is a small improvement, as long as they sharpen as easily as the Vics.
Yeah, but it's not only strength and sharpening that make a good knife steel. It's also how well it can hold an edge, how easy is it to bend instead of snap, will it microchip, will it rust easily, how does it react to heat and acids... that we can only see in time...
-
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.
My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
-
Hey, they're actually dishwasher safe? That's cool! Really nice if using them for messy food.
-
@shamus said:
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
^^^ Now, that was mean!

-
@shamus said:
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.
My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
^^^ Now, that was mean!

They won't. Wenger was well known knife company and had a long history in Switzerland.
That's us mobile.
Nate -
@shamus said:
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.
My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
^^^ Now, that was mean!

They won't. Wenger was well known knife company and had a long history in Switzerland.
That's us mobile.
NateYou never know. Maybe they become incredibly popular in no time
I don't think they will, I'm just saying.

-
@shamus said:
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
I think they were buying the trademark "The Genuine Swiss Army Knife" more than anything else.
-
These look interesting but I will stick with my well-proven and tested Victorinox

-
If they innovate like wenger did with interesting tools, they MIGHT carve out a niche. But since Victorinox has been THE tool for 125 years... good luck with that. :D
If it was my company Id target a high end niche market. Do high end blade steels and finishes. People want that.
-
@shamus said:
Interesting. No scissors or pliers. Those moving parts are expensive and hard to make well. Makes sense to not have them when first starting out.
My only concern is if Swiza fails. Victorinox already bought one of Peter Hug's companies (Wenger) to keep it from being bought out by the Chinese. I don't think Vic would buy another company off him.
I think they were buying the trademark "The Genuine Swiss Army Knife" more than anything else.
So the Vic Delemont line is a result of buying the trademark?
-
I assume, if they sell enough knives, they will incorporate more tools. Victorinox is only know considering scissors on alox. :D
I assume people just do not like the idea of having the cross and swiss branding on a new company.
I am reminded of GEC, who in 2006, was started by ex employees of Queen?, and has now carved a niche market, mixing tradition with new ideas for those willing to pay the premium.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login