Swiza SAKs?
-
@Mextreme said:
I mean do we need can opener on basically all models when cans without pull rings are close to extinct, just as example? Room for a new impoved tool.This is mentioned often, and I assume it must be something that varies by country. In the UK it's definitely not true. I had a quick look through my food cupboards and found about half the canned goods had no ring pulls. Branded stuff like Heinz soup has ring pulls, but supermarket own-brand products, canned vegetables etc mostly don't.
-
I mean do we need can opener on basically all models when cans without pull rings are close to extinct, just as example? Room for a new impoved tool.
This is mentioned often, and I assume it must be something that varies by country. In the UK it's definitely not true. I had a quick look through my food cupboards and found about half the canned goods had no ring pulls. Branded stuff like Heinz soup has ring pulls, but supermarket own-brand products, canned vegetables etc mostly don't.
I agree that traditional cans are not yet extinct... still most people own more than one tool, so there is really no need for every one of them having a can-opener.
-
I mean do we need can opener on basically all models when cans without pull rings are close to extinct, just as example? Room for a new impoved tool.
This is mentioned often, and I assume it must be something that varies by country. In the UK it's definitely not true. I had a quick look through my food cupboards and found about half the canned goods had no ring pulls. Branded stuff like Heinz soup has ring pulls, but supermarket own-brand products, canned vegetables etc mostly don't.
I agree that traditional cans are not yet extinct... still most people own more than one tool, so there is really no need for every one of them having a can-opener.
I've had mixed feelings about can openers but some of my favorite foods still require them. Still, it seems every SAK and/or MT includes them and they can get a little redundant.
-
Well another thing against can openers is that few people carry cans on hikes when dry freeze food is an option. At least they should have options without them and offer some more useful EDC Items for us. It was years ago since I used a can opener outside my home.
-
I just use them to peel oranges :D
-
Here, the only cans with pull rings is the dog food...everything else is a standard can. Before I bought a Vic kitchen can opener, I was using the opener on my knife 2+ times a week.
Besides, the opener got me out of a jam with a stuck package.
-
I'm not saying it's impossible to find use for a can opener but I never carry cans outside my kitchen and even if i didn't own a real can opener, all the brands i purchase like Heinz, Bonduelle, green giant have pullrings. On a hike I sure will not ever carry cans when dry freeze is an option with less than 1/10 of the weight.
When the SAK was invented the soldiers got rations in cans. I don't. I use drivers and such daily and would prefer a better reach driver, in line awl, package opener, micro philips of 58 mm or some other invention that is more of a modern EDC item.
I feel the same about corkscrews. They are not EDC worthy items.
I think Victorinox can keep models with the classic tool set but I don't understand why not offer other options. -
I'm interested to hear reviews and see how these knives fare in their own right (as opposed to direct comparisons with Victorinox etc).
Will I get one? Not yet. I'll wait till they start having a go at incorporating scissors before I consider trying them out
-
I mean do we need can opener on basically all models when cans without pull rings are close to extinct, just as example? Room for a new impoved tool.
This is mentioned often, and I assume it must be something that varies by country. In the UK it's definitely not true. I had a quick look through my food cupboards and found about half the canned goods had no ring pulls. Branded stuff like Heinz soup has ring pulls, but supermarket own-brand products, canned vegetables etc mostly don't.
Pull tabs arent common here either. All of the cans I have are normal can opener style.
-
Speaking of cans, I hate the pull tabs because they leave a rim around the can and it's frickin' impossible to scrap everything out.
But it doesn't really matter since all the cans I buy need an opener. Everyone talks about pull tabs on cans but I rarely see them. It must be a European thing. :) But even if the can had a pull tab I'd use a can opener so I could get everything out of the can.The can opener is a great little tool besides opening cans. It can be used for popping open watch cases, and to open up packages (not clamshell packages, but I use the awl for those). But most importantly, its an extra blade which offers more utility; it makes an excellent scraper. Better for me to use that for scraping tasks than the main blade.
But back on topic; despite the cheekiness in my first post, I hope Swiza finds success.
-
@shamus said:
Speaking of cans, I hate the pull tabs because they leave a rim around the can and it's frickin' impossible to scrap everything out.
But it doesn't really matter since all the cans I buy need an opener. Everyone talks about pull tabs on cans but I rarely see them.** It must be a European thing. ** :) But even if the can had a pull tab I'd use a can opener so I could get everything out of the can.But back on topic; despite the cheekiness in my first post, I hope Swiza finds success.
It surprises me since I dont buy much cans but when I do most are american brands like: Heinz, Green Giant, Campbell soup and so on... All of those use pull cans.
Do they use old style opening on the home market? -
@shamus said:
Speaking of cans, I hate the pull tabs because they leave a rim around the can and it's frickin' impossible to scrap everything out.
But it doesn't really matter since all the cans I buy need an opener. Everyone talks about pull tabs on cans but I rarely see them.** It must be a European thing. ** :) But even if the can had a pull tab I'd use a can opener so I could get everything out of the can.But back on topic; despite the cheekiness in my first post, I hope Swiza finds success.
It surprises me since I dont buy much cans but when I do most are american brands like: Heinz, Green Giant, Campbell soup and so on... All of those use pull cans.
Do they use old style opening on the home market?Store brands are often 3/4 to 1/2 the price of the big brands and they rarely have pull tabs. This allows me to buy more knives with openers to open them with!

-
Yup i have all those brands and they are not pull tab.
Ok everyone post up your canned goods shelf pics lol
-
@shamus said:
Speaking of cans, I hate the pull tabs because they leave a rim around the can and it's frickin' impossible to scrap everything out.
But it doesn't really matter since all the cans I buy need an opener. Everyone talks about pull tabs on cans but I rarely see them.** It must be a European thing. ** :) But even if the can had a pull tab I'd use a can opener so I could get everything out of the can.But back on topic; despite the cheekiness in my first post, I hope Swiza finds success.
It surprises me since I dont buy much cans but when I do most are american brands like: Heinz, Green Giant, Campbell soup and so on... All of those use pull cans.
Do they use old style opening on the home market?Store brands are often 3/4 to 1/2 the price of the big brands and they rarely have pull tabs. This allows me to buy more knives with openers to open them with!

You got the priorities right then :D
I am ordering a red Swiza D04 right now with a can opener
so I will go out of my way to find an old style can here to test it on.I guess I´ll have to find some Ucranian saurkraut or something to do that here.
-
SWIZA
-
Going to use it for the last week of the OBC

-
@Etherealicer said:
Going to use it for the last week of the OBCThat was fast!!!
Any first impressions? -
@Etherealicer said:
Going to use it for the last week of the OBCAny first impressions??
-
Victorinox has patented the color red with a multi tool pocket knife or something like that, so does that mean they wont have red ones?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login