OPINELS
-
Hi Opinel fans,
I have not got an Opinel - But I do remember a year or so there was a 'MTs/kinves you must have' thread and Opinel was there.
So of course I checked them out ......
They look great, have a nice history, are made of wood
and have that lovely rustic look, by all accounts are very functional and well made - and they are French - and I love all things French - Yep I know the English are meant to hate the French - But I love 'em and all they do (well apart from blockading motorways).
I have a French friend here in Sydney - He always carries one - And gives them as presents at Christmas etc :DSo we all know what will happen sometime soon
Oh BTW - That will be - I'll buy one - I am not quite a good enough friend to get the pressie from my mate!! :(So I have a couple of questions ???
[list type=decimal]-
Carbon or stainless steel - Pros/cons whys/wherefores etc please - I am trending towards carbon - Dont know why - Maybe coz it is different from my SAKs?
-
Oak, Beech, Olive?? - Presumably this is just a matter of look/taste - The beech ones seem nice?
-
What size? - This will probably be my only Opinel (ha ha) - So what is best for general use? No. 7? - Not a small one - I believe they don't lock, and would not be good for slicing apples etc
I am sure the answers are in the thread somewhere - but 25 pages is too long
so thanks for your repliesAnd I know, I know - It depends an what I would use it for
But just tell me your opinion/what you have/prefer/like etcFor me it would be for general use - Probably not pocket carry - Eg in with my caming/picnic gear
Thanks guys
PS. Zoidy - How come you always take such great pics? Seriously ?? Does a lot of thought go into it? - Or does it just happen. The rural NZ backrops always help!!

-
-
I have a carbon number 6 which hardly gets any use:
A) It's fractionally too small, so I'd suggest starting with a #7 or #8
B) I've drifted away from carbon steels somewhat, so I would suggest stainless, particularly if thinking of using it for food. Carbon develops a nice patina if cared for, but that adds nothing to the function. If you don't like to mother your knives, then go stainless. The carbon will probably take a keener edge and be a lot easier to maintain though. Consider your usage and patience/dilligence when it comes to maintenance - or do it the MTO way and buy both then make up your own mind :P
C) Olive and Walnut look the best IMHO -
I would say SS, so as not to worry about rust (They use good quality SS)
The No' affects the size of the handle I find a No 9/10 easier to hold (it also shows the blade size in cm, so check for legality)
The more fancy handles look better but cost more, without any added function
You may also want to look into the slimline versions, for added elegance
-
- Stainless. Their carbon is nice and traditional, and it gets a nice patina, but has an awful metal smell and taste while the Stainless is nice Sandvik steel. Nice and cool and easy to sharpen and takes a wicked edge.
- Beech is the traditional, cheap option. My favourites are Olive and etched Boxwood. Walnut is great too and so is Rose. You also get nice plastic options nowadays.
- Mmmm... depends. For medium hands the 8 is the best fit, for smaller hands 7 is better while for big hands, the 9 might fit better. If you want non-locking the biggest one is the 5, but you can remove the locking system on any model.
-
Definitely carbon so you can get the patina, they are not difficult to take care of.
Get a few sizes to see which one you like best, and then some SS ones just to round it out
The more expensive the knife the nicer the wood, but it doesn't really matter. The best Opinels are the ones with the corners rounded off by touch - they wear in so nicely

-
More than most knives, with an Opinel you enter into a kind of relationship with them.
You have to look after them, especially those with a carbon blade. The handle can swell if over exposed to moisture and the blade is prone to rust if not properly cleaned.
I like this about the Opinel. I have a carbon No.7 with a Beech handle and it's ageing beautifully - there is an after image of its use left in the patina.
I suffer from hyperhydrosis which means my hands can literally drip with sweat but my Opi hasn't seized up yet. Or rusted. Bless.
So at the end of the day it depends what you want out of a knife. The Opi's have more character than any other knife I've ever had and I carry mine as much as I possibly can.
Best of luck with your decision

-
The stainless makes more sense, but for me it lacks a bit of the Opinel "character" that you get with the carbon.
-
-
The stainless makes more sense, but for me it lacks a bit of the Opinel "character" that you get with the carbon.
+1
++
I had a #6 with a green handle that was nice but ultimately it was on the small side. I now have a #8 and fits my hand good tho a #9 would be perfect. As far a wood choice
. The darker woods looks great while the standard are just as nice. WiSo, in conclusion
Get one in Carbon and one in SS also go with walnut and beech also go with an #8 & #9 so your only real quandery will be which to carry

-
@magentus said:
More than most knives, with an Opinel you enter into a kind of relationship with them.You have to look after them, especially those with a carbon blade. The handle can swell if over exposed to moisture and the blade is prone to rust if not properly cleaned.
I like this about the Opinel. I have a carbon No.7 with a Beech handle and it's ageing beautifully - there is an after image of its use left in the patina.
I suffer from hyperhydrosis which means my hands can literally drip with sweat but my Opi hasn't seized up yet. Or rusted. Bless.
So at the end of the day it depends what you want out of a knife. The Opi's have more character than any other knife I've ever had and I carry mine as much as I possibly can.
Best of luck with your decision

This, all day long.
-
Hey Guys
Thanks for the great advice.
I am a bit of a traditionalist - So will probably go No7, Beech, Carbon - As this seems to be very traditional Opinel and very different from the shiny SAK blade
Magentus's photo swung it :D Thanks mateAlthough I can see an SS following :o As food prep seems not so good with carbon - And I fancy an Opinel in my picnic basket!! 8) And here I would also get a prettier wood handle (walnut, olive :D )
-
I have a carbon Opinel and I love it. It does leave a metallic taste on food though. I'd be tempted to get another one, maybe stainless but certainly with olive wood handle. :D
-
@Huntsman said:
PS. Zoidy - How come you always take such great pics? Seriously ?? Does a lot of thought go into it? - Or does it just happen. The rural NZ backrops always help!!
I can find taking pics very frustrating at times.
Mostly because I still use an old 4MP Samsung Digimax camera.
Then there is the lighting, reflections, handshake, backrounds, timing etc.When I look at the pics (over a thousand now) I've taken for MTo, there are only a few that I like.
What makes the few stand out to me, are the parts I didn't have control over, water, animals, clouds etc.
Colours can be randomly good as well.It has to be the beauty of pics, they can appeal to the person viewing on different levels.
So you'll have to tell me what makes them good.
Given the limitations I try to make it work, I'm not special enough that things just happen for me. -
PS. Zoidy - How come you always take such great pics? Seriously ?? Does a lot of thought go into it? - Or does it just happen. The rural NZ backrops always help!!

I can find taking pics very frustrating at times.
Mostly because I still use an old 4MP Samsung Digimax camera.
Then there is the lighting, reflections, handshake, backrounds, timing etc.When I look at the pics (over a thousand now) I've taken for MTo, there are only a few that I like.
What makes the few stand out to me, are the parts I didn't have control over, water, animals, clouds etc.
Colours can be randomly good as well.It has to be the beauty of pics, they can appeal to the person viewing on different levels.
So you'll have to tell me what makes them good.
Given the limitations I try to make it work, I'm not special enough that things just happen for me.
In some ways, using a limited camera can make you better. A better camera can make everything easier but for me, if I can do it with a lesser camera, I own it. Does that make sense? In the past, using film cameras that were at their the technological apex in the 60's and having to make it work taught me a lot of things about seeing/imaging.
Always did everything the hard way.....

-
PS. Zoidy - How come you always take such great pics? Seriously ?? Does a lot of thought go into it? - Or does it just happen. The rural NZ backrops always help!!

I can find taking pics very frustrating at times.
Mostly because I still use an old 4MP Samsung Digimax camera.
Then there is the lighting, reflections, handshake, backrounds, timing etc.When I look at the pics (over a thousand now) I've taken for MTo, there are only a few that I like.
What makes the few stand out to me, are the parts I didn't have control over, water, animals, clouds etc.
Colours can be randomly good as well.It has to be the beauty of pics, they can appeal to the person viewing on different levels.
So you'll have to tell me what makes them good.
Given the limitations I try to make it work, I'm not special enough that things just happen for me.
In some ways, using a limited camera can make you better. A better camera can make everything easier but for me, if I can do it with a lesser camera, I own it. Does that make sense? In the past, using film cameras that were at their the technological apex in the 60's and having to make it work taught me a lot of things about seeing/imaging.
Always did everything the hard way.....

:D
-
Thanks for the great advice.
I am a bit of a traditionalist - So will probably go No7, Beech, Carbon - As this seems to be very traditional Opinel and very different from the shiny SAK blade
Magentus's photo swung it :D Thanks mateAlthough I can see an SS following :o As food prep seems not so good with carbon - And I fancy an Opinel in my picnic basket!! 8) And here I would also get a prettier wood handle (walnut, olive :D )
Yes! :D :ahhh Post pics when you get it! You're in for a treat.

-
@firiki said:
I have a carbon Opinel and I love it. It does leave a metallic taste on food though. I'd be tempted to get another one, maybe stainless but certainly with olive wood handle. :DI believe if you get a patina on the blade it will protect it and will remove that metallic after taste in the food.
-
I have a carbon Opinel and I love it. It does leave a metallic taste on food though. I'd be tempted to get another one, maybe stainless but certainly with olive wood handle. :D
I believe if you get a patina on the blade it will protect it and will remove that metallic after taste in the food.
My Douk-douk is the worst on fruit, even the patina couldn't help it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






