Website or Book?
-
Funny to see this thread resurface. The book is still in the works, albeit slower than I'd hoped. A good 75% of the delay is just life - getting kids through high school (one down, one to go) and working for a start up company. The rest is fleshing out my research. The thing that I hope will set this book apart from others is that most of the details - especially in tool evolution - are based on observation, not various "facts" or innuendo floating around the internets. All written details about tool evolution, dates, etc. I try to verify through observation.
You'd be surprised at how many of the facts - some that come straight from Victorinox themselves - are not supported by observation. Quick example - Vicotrinox's own PR info says:
**1973 **Magnifying glass and Phillips screwdriver, small blade with pointed tip instead of the old shape.
**1977 **Small screwdriver (on the back of the knife).So - four years difference between dropping the clip point pen blade and the intro of the small screwdriver back tool. So we should be able to observe this - there should be no knives with clip point pen blades and fine screwdrivers, there should be some early 70s knives with drop point pen blades and no fine screwdriver, and then we should see the typical drop point + fine screwdriver combos.
That's what we should see, but we don't. What we do see is that the fine screwdriver is introduced well before the change in the pen blade shape. There are a significant number of Craftsmans, Handymans, mag glass Champions, Rangers and Grand Prixs out there with clip point pen blades and fine screwdrivers. I have probably 10 in my collection alone, and many more in my auction database. So which data point is wrong then? In this case I'd bet money on the 1977 date for the intro of the fine screwdriver. The 1973 date for the pen blade change is supported by other data, so I think the date for the screwdriver is wrong.
This is just one example of many that I've found. The point I'm getting to is that taking this approach requires lots and lots of data. Both collected (which I've done well) and cataloged correctly (which I've done a little less well). The more data I collect, the better I am at reconstructing the history of these knives. This thread was started 2 years ago, and since that time I've learned things about early knife development that have caused me to rewrite a LOT of my initial chapters on early knife and tool development.
At this point, the main task is to catalog all my knives and the knives I've see sold in a way that lets me arrange them in chronological order. Once that's done (and this process has started), then I can get to writing in earnest.
-
I'll go on record now and say I'll be buying one when they come out.

-
good luck Jazzbass. I look foward to seeing the fruits of your labor, and hope that you will be satisfied with the results. Its one tthing to have a hobby or a collection. Its another to have a significant impact on the realm of that hobby. You are working to better your hobby, and enrich and enlighten your fellow collectors. Even though I don't collect SAKs myself, I can certainly appreciate what you are doing. -
hmm, jazzbass might put the first printed copy on ebay, with great pictures of the contents, and call it the RARE Swiss army knife encyclopedia.
bidding war! (by people not here at MTO)

two weeks later book sales start in earnest
-
Even though I mainly collect Alox I would also buy this as a book.
Reminds me of a rare book that I picked up recently.
Took me years to finally get one.
Expensive, but almost all the info that can only be found in this book.

-
Nice NSA!!! Wow, I've bought the pistols cheaper than some of those book prices.
-
Since this thread has bubbled back to the top, I'll use it to solicit some feedback.
One thing I plan to do with the book is include details of each known model. They'll be marked as "standard production" (Spartan, Huntsman, etc), "limited production" (Angler Deluxe, Mechanic Jr, etc) or "custom configuration" (Fuchs customs, VSAKS Doctor, etc), but the one thing they have in common is they were produced by Victorinox. I might add a section about mods, but I don't plan on going into details on specific mod models as they're like snowflakes - just too many to cover and they're not "official". But yes, one of my main goals is for there to be an "encyclopedia" section where you can look up any model you find.
So that leaves a sort of grey area - SwissBianco customs. For those that are new, the knives you get from SwissBianco today are 100% assembled by Victorinox in Ibach, fully warrantied, etc., so to me they fall in the "custom configuration" category and will be included. However, some of his early mods (back from 2008-2009) were actually hand assembled by Roger from new Victorinox factory parts. This includes the early Yeoman Mechanic (I have one and you can see it's clearly hand assembled), the 91mm Lumberjack Plus, and (I think) his original run of Scientists from 2010.
Where do you feel these fall in the continuum? Are they mods just as much as anything that Syph makes, as they were hand assembled from parts and not built in the Victorinox factory? Or are they sort of quasi-official models since they were made with the blessing of (and warrantied by) Victorinox themselves? I know what I think about this, but I'm curious to hear other people's thoughts.
Yes, I know there are some less-than-positive feelings here with some about SwissBianco and his views on modding. But I want to approach this as a historian, not as someone with an axe to grind (which I'm not to be honest - I personally bear Roger no ill will).
-
@jazzbass said:
Since this thread has bubbled back to the top, I'll use it to solicit some feedback.One thing I plan to do with the book is include details of each known model. They'll be marked as "standard production" (Spartan, Huntsman, etc), "limited production" (Angler Deluxe, Mechanic Jr, etc) or "custom configuration" (Fuchs customs, VSAKS Doctor, etc), but the one thing they have in common is they were produced by Victorinox. I might add a section about mods, but I don't plan on going into details on specific mod models as they're like snowflakes - just too many to cover and they're not "official". But yes, one of my main goals is for there to be an "encyclopedia" section where you can look up any model you find.
So that leaves a sort of grey area - SwissBianco customs. For those that are new, the knives you get from SwissBianco today are 100% assembled by Victorinox in Ibach, fully warrantied, etc., so to me they fall in the "custom configuration" category and will be included. However, some of his early mods (back from 2008-2009) were actually hand assembled by Roger from new Victorinox factory parts. This includes the early Yeoman Mechanic (I have one and you can see it's clearly hand assembled), the 91mm Lumberjack Plus, and (I think) his original run of Scientists from 2010.
Where do you feel these fall in the continuum? Are they mods just as much as anything that Syph makes, as they were hand assembled from parts and not built in the Victorinox factory? Or are they sort of quasi-official models since they were made with the blessing of (and warrantied by) Victorinox themselves?
Yes, I know there are some less-than-positive feelings here with some about SwissBianco and his views on modding. But I want to approach this as a historian, not as someone with an axe to grind (which I'm not to be honest - I personally bear Roger no ill will).
I understand your conundrum, and think that no matter which route you take, as long as you preface your decision in the into (or preface area) and explain your stance, the reader will have no problems at all.
to me personally they are just mods, and not a Victorinox product, but a product made of Victorinox parts, much in the same way I could take parts from a Chevy Truck, a Chevy Corvette, and a Chevy Malibu, and make a vehicle. it is not a Chevy product, but it is a Chevy in many respects. however the difference here is SwissBianco SAKs now are a Victorinox Product, where they were not before.
I Wish you luck figuring this enigma out. -
I'm with Detron on this one. The decision is obviously yours, but it's a product made outside of Victorinox from Victorinox parts... Just like something Syph makes, so to me, it's the same category.
-
I vote for a book, paper pages and all and maybe an e-book at some point. "The Working Folding Knife" by Steve Dick (published in 1998) is a favorite of mine and I have read and re-read it countless times.

-
Since they were officially sanctioned and warrantied by Victorinox, I think they are a different animal than individual mods done in the wilds like the ones that Syph makes. I would class them as "custom configuration" especially since there are many copies of the same configuration.
JazzBass, I hope your labor-of-love is successful beyond your expectations.
-
Regarding +Bianco, this is a unique case as far as I know, so I think the simplest way would be to make a dedicated chapter telling the whole story and let the readers form an opinion. Such a chapter would probably belong to the encyclopedic part and mods section. Also, if there's a presentation of Vic's marketing/sales policy an allusion could be made there as well. I still don't understand why they've chosen to work with +Bianco

-
Do they really warranty Rodgers hand built stuff? I didn't know that. IIRC he didn't have the best reputation for QC. Anyway, I agree that his current offerings would fall under your "custom configuration" heading, but I'd put his hand assembled stuff as a separate, though interesting, footnote.
-
@jazzbass said:
Since this thread has bubbled back to the top, I'll use it to solicit some feedback.One thing I plan to do with the book is include details of each known model. They'll be marked as "standard production" (Spartan, Huntsman, etc), "limited production" (Angler Deluxe, Mechanic Jr, etc) or "custom configuration" (Fuchs customs, VSAKS Doctor, etc), but the one thing they have in common is they were produced by Victorinox. I might add a section about mods, but I don't plan on going into details on specific mod models as they're like snowflakes - just too many to cover and they're not "official". But yes, one of my main goals is for there to be an "encyclopedia" section where you can look up any model you find.
So that leaves a sort of grey area - SwissBianco customs. For those that are new, the knives you get from SwissBianco today are 100% assembled by Victorinox in Ibach, fully warrantied, etc., so to me they fall in the "custom configuration" category and will be included. However, some of his early mods (back from 2008-2009) were actually hand assembled by Roger from new Victorinox factory parts. This includes the early Yeoman Mechanic (I have one and you can see it's clearly hand assembled), the 91mm Lumberjack Plus, and (I think) his original run of Scientists from 2010.
Where do you feel these fall in the continuum? Are they mods just as much as anything that Syph makes, as they were hand assembled from parts and not built in the Victorinox factory? Or are they sort of quasi-official models since they were made with the blessing of (and warrantied by) Victorinox themselves? I know what I think about this, but I'm curious to hear other people's thoughts.
Yes, I know there are some less-than-positive feelings here with some about SwissBianco and his views on modding. But I want to approach this as a historian, not as someone with an axe to grind (which I'm not to be honest - I personally bear Roger no ill will).
I see this as a separate chapter or an addendum.
-
SwissBianco's knives definitely deserve mention. I agree that the book should be encyclopedic, and the more information presented the better. On the other hand neither you, nor anyone else, probably has a complete selection of his knives. A short section on SwissBianco knives, with the comment that the shown knives are representative of the models and colors offered might be the way to go.
On the subject of custom knives you might show some and mention some names (Scibeer, Sylph, etc), and mention that there are a lot of non-standard knives out there.
-
Poor Syph007...first he had his screen name changed to syphilis, now he's a sylph

-
Poor Syph007...first he had his screen name changed to syphilis, now he's a sylph

well, luckily he has the name recognition that enables it to not be detrimental.
Come to think of it, that might explain the great job Sy(l)ph does! :P
Edit: It's worth noting Paracelsus was Swiss

-
Poor Syph007...first he had his screen name changed to syphilis, now he's a sylph

well, luckily he has the name recognition that enables it to not be detrimental.
Come to think of it, that might explain the great job Sy(l)ph does! :P
Edit: It's worth noting Paracelsus was Swiss

Think that was auto-correct, which can be a major pain. I have a Syph Storm Trooper (on the left).
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login