Rough Rider GAK?
-
Apparently, Rough Rider makes a copy of the second version of the 108mm German Army Knife (with nail file/match striker), made by Victorinox and others, which sells for $6. Interesting the tang stamp is the German Eagle.
I need to get one, as I need a saw cover/guard for a Victorinox GAK I just bought, but at the price I think I should buy a few of the knife to keep around.
How good are these compared to the real thing? Having just paid $20 on a used pre-1985 Victorinox GAK, I don't expect much out of the Rough Rider
-
Not seen that one before so I can't speak to the quality of that specific model, however in general RR make a very good knife. Not quite Vic quality but still respectable, well worth a go at $6 IMO. I'll be very interested to hear what you make of it if you get one.
-
Would like too see one of these in the flesh

-
@Gareth said:
Not seen that one before so I can't speak to the quality of that specific model, however in general RR make a very good knife. Not quite Vic quality but still respectable, well worth a go at $6 IMO. I'll be very interested to hear what you make of it if you get one.+1. Of all my slipjoints, my favorite for carry is a Rough Rider Barlow. Nothing fancy, but a good solid working knife. I'd be interested to see the GAK and hear your thoughts on it.
-
Is that a Rough Rider? I noticed scrolling through SMKW's Rough Rider models that some might be erroneously listed. One tip off is when the model isn't "RRxxxx". In this case, the model number looks to be MI212. The stuff that seems out of place are things like sword canes, Nazi nonsense knives, and the Bundeswehr knives. It's just curious that there are some goods that have no RR branding, little if anything in common with the rest of the RR line.
-
Looking up close on the main blade it looks like the same emblem thats on the handle,
-
@shecky said:
Is that a Rough Rider? I noticed scrolling through SMKW's Rough Rider models that some might be erroneously listed. One tip off is when the model isn't "RRxxxx". In this case, the model number looks to be MI212. The stuff that seems out of place are things like sword canes, Nazi nonsense knives, and the Bundeswehr knives. It's just curious that there are some goods that have no RR branding, little if anything in common with the rest of the RR line.Yup, my thoughts too. Probably Mil-tec at that price. Not too good of a brand as far quallity goes.
-
Is that a Rough Rider? I noticed scrolling through SMKW's Rough Rider models that some might be erroneously listed. One tip off is when the model isn't "RRxxxx". In this case, the model number looks to be MI212. The stuff that seems out of place are things like sword canes, Nazi nonsense knives, and the Bundeswehr knives. It's just curious that there are some goods that have no RR branding, little if anything in common with the rest of the RR line.
Yup, my thoughts too. Probably Mil-tec at that price. Not too good of a brand as far quallity goes.
Milltecs were sold by the kilo in the Kolo Bazar in Warsaw (there was a truckfull of these, flecktarn jackets and gasmasks). I was thinking of getting a couple but preferred to spend my money that day on a Wenger SI and a Victorinox Prince.
-
If you want a GAK, get one from one of teh makers of the issued knives!
Most copies are ofsub-par quality. There may be ones as good as the real ones, but you never know.
Withot thinking too hard or looking it up, makers were:Victorinox (Best quality IMHO)
Adler (GML Leegebruch follow up, IIRC. Good quality)
B&H (Good quality, less polished tools)
Aitor (Spanish maker, good quality, highly polished blade)
ICAR (less polished tools, springs finished rougher. Only maker I handled examples with broken springs - but only on 2 examples, might be a coincidence)
I´m sure I forgot one or two, but those are all respcetable makers.Common copies/fakes are
Mil-Tec
FoxThe 108s are great work knives.
-
I have a Klass, but I don't think it was issue...bought as a single knife.

-
It might very well be an issued one (maybe not your exampel, but knives from that maker) Klaas is a known german cutlery maker.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login