Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
-
@50ft-trad said:
The Swiza knives are multipurpose knives which happen to be made in Switzerland. They haven't supplied knives to the Swiss Army, and so cannot claim the honour of being producers of Swiss Army Knives.
However, whilst Victorinox can claim that honour, many of the knives they have produced are not SAKs, even though we call them that. So we have actual Swiss Army Knives, knives made by makers of Swiss Army Knives, and then we have other Swiss knife makers who haven't yet made anything for the Swiss or maybe any other army.
Swiza Should in my mind be collated with the multipurpose knives made in Solingen or elsewhere. The Boker Plus Tech Tools would be another example. Oh, and I don't consider them "sak-alikes" either. Multipurpose pocket knives have been around for centuries, way before the internet bourne misconception that SAKs are where it all started
What Al said

+100!!!!
+1 :)
IRC, the name "SAK" was termed by US soldiers referring to Victorinox products made for Swiss Army back in the war time, before the brand name Victorinox was used. So one way or another, I associated this term 'SAK' more like a brand name, than a genre.
Meanwhile, it probably is unfair to call every other knife-based MT as a SAK wanna-be(though it is the holy grail, due to their unparalleled knife/MT market domination). In fact, I love to see more variation and innovation from other brands, so we'll get to see more interesting products than just mere reiteration of the same product.
-
I agree with Grant.
What? He didn't say his opinion yet? Never mind, whatever he will say, I'll agree.
-
So I'm thinking this is already sorted with the technical perspective of a multitool with a knife supplied to the swiss army but...
If you have a soldier model, how much can it change and still be a sak? Can a Pioneer, essentially the old soldier, still be the sak? Can my One Handed Trekker, a 2008 Soldier without the serration and with different scales, be a sak?
"Go home Grass."
-
My definition of Swiss Army Knife does not include anything not made by either Victorinox or Wenger and their historical predecessors, so my vote is no. fwiw :P
-
@Grass said:
So I'm thinking this is already sorted with the technical perspective of a multitool with a knife supplied to the swiss army but...If you have a soldier model, how much can it change and still be a sak? Can a Pioneer, essentially the old soldier, still be the sak? Can my One Handed Trekker, a 2008 Soldier without the serration and with different scales, be a sak?
"Go home Grass."
Think of it as a family....
I still carry my grandfather's name and although I'm very different from him in every aspect, that name, history and experience still qualifies me for a place in the family. It's up to me if I live up to my family's expectations.
-
So, if your surname was "butcher" or "major" what would that require. :D :D :D :D
-
Also, I don't call knockoffs Swiss Army Knives, no matter where they come from, just like I don't call my Spirit a Leatherman. A matter of definition. :P
-
For the record,no I don't think SWIZAs are SAKs.
But,by definition,neither is the 108mm Victorinox built to German spec for the German army,yet it is covered by our Swiss sub forum,and has its honoured place in the sakwiki.
By the same logical progression,Delemonts can't really claim to be SAKs either,except that they're made by Victorinox
-
well, we all know who is to blame for Wengers downfall .....
-
-
are we gonna see any reviews of SWIZA knives?
-
I plan to write one about the D02 after I have EDC'ed it for a while.
-
there are a few first looks/reviews in the forum. no destruction testing
-
-
no batoning?
my screwdrivers did ok, so far
-
I like my SWIZA D04, I love my trusty Boker 182 Sports Knife and I'm very interessted in
the new Sanrenmu MPKs but all of them are no SAKs. The one and only real SAKs are
from Vic and Wenger. -
-
That doesn't bode too well
-
@Grathr said:
I have been thinking a bit about this. Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
It looks like one, its Swiss made, but it has no connection with the swiss army. The counter argument would be that neither does most of the Vic models. If I have understood it right,(feel free to correct me) only the Soldier/standard issue knives has been issued to the Swiss Army. So all the other models are really not Swiss "Army" Knives.
I know there might be some emotions regarding this issue, so please keep the discussion civilised and friendly ;)Oh! And dont forget to vote in the poll :D
Interesting !
I'm French, so I don't still understand the subtleties of the English language, but I think there is some confusion with the words...
Who first call "Swiss Army Knives" all the Swiss Knives ? The American GI's at the end of WW2...In French we say "Couteaux Suisses" (Swiss knives) for all civilian Swiss knives and "couteaux de soldats suisses" (Swiss soldiers knives) for all official knives in the Swiss Army, like Mod. 1961 (alox) or mod. 2008.
At the begining, (about 1900's) existed more than 30 manufactures of knives in Switzerland ! Not only Victorinox and Wenger !!!
Some of these cutlers made knives for the Swiss Army, but not all cutlers. And some knives (first 15000 soldiers knives) for the Swiss Army where made outside Switzerland (in Germany and probably in France).
Here 19 brands and tang stamps referenced for the Swiss Soldier Knife mod. 1908 :
http://www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch/J01/index.php/en/les-couteaux-du-soldat/les-modeles-1908Currently, "SK" (in French) or "SAK" (in English) have the common definition : "Knives made in Switzerland". This is what Urs Wyss (the boss of Victorinox factory) told me last year (2014) when I met him...
So... SWIZA are "SAK" or not ? That's the question !
- SWIZA never made knives for the Swiss Army, that's right, but who can say "they will never make knives for the Swiss Army ?
- SWIZA knives are completly made in Switzerland and for this reason SWIZA knives are Swiss knives.
To be fair, if for you, a Victorinox Huntsman or a Wenger S17 are "SAK", SWIZA knives are also "SAK" !
I bought the 4 SWIZA Knives and I said my first impressions here :
</post/1190466>
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

