There can be only one!
-
Can the pliers and the blades on the Charge XTI be flicked out one handed like other Leatherman models?
-
Swiss Tool Spirit for me, built like a tank!!
Thargor, the blades can be opened one-handed on the Charge, no idea about the pliers as I dont own one :(
-
well Thargor, my charge has been loosened up enough that I can flick it open, takes some practice....and it's no SOG but yea...it can be done.
David
-
Would hate to be limited to just one, but.....the Paladin would get my vote. Tough and strong, plus replaceable tools. Normally carry a Swiss Tool, but the other day while on a carpentry project I cut the nails on some window molding with my 525. They were no match for this tool or my SOG, but my trusty Swiss Tool could not and the LM Super Tool would not either. Actually, I could not squeeze hard enough. The Paladin has a long cutting surface on the pliers that is great for Romex and coaxial cable that I work with. My 2 cents. ;)
-
I voted for the Swisstool, if I had to chose one it would be it, an easy choice. I am a mechanical engineer working in a plastics plant and I use multitools daily. I have used following multitools:
SwissTool (a CS, an RS, an X PLus, and an Original Black Oxide), Spirit (a Plus and an ordinary version, unfortunately I cannot find the S model in Greece, would like to add that in my collection as well), SOG Powerlock S62, Leatherman Charge TTi and a Gerber MP600.
The Gerber I gave away, it was simply awful. I sold the Charge a few weeks ago, it was obvious it would not stand the test of time as it showed signs of wear only after a couple of monhts, plus it came nowhere near either of the Vic multitools. Grossly overpriced!!!
So at the moment I own my 4 Swisstools and the 2 spirits, plus the Powerlock, for me the only multitool worth owning after the 2 Victorinox models, and this is why I kept it although I seldomly use it. I carry a Swisstool when I am at work, and a Spirit the rest of the time.
-
Welcome to the forums Themelis :D Sounds like youve already worked out which tool is best for you ;) We're gonna get on just fine :)
Dunc
-
Themelis- supporting the SwissTool will make you a few friends here almost instantly as you have found out!
If you are interested in the Spirit S model, I suggest contacting some of our banner supporters at www.edcdepot.com or www.felinevet.sosakonline.com as they both have excellent prices and ship internationally. If you don't see them listed on the sites, e-mail them and ask as they often can't keep up with the amount of stock they have coming and going!
If I may, what signs of wear were showing up on the Charge, and in what ways in particular did you not feel it was measuring up? Judging from the results of our informal poll so far it seems that the Charge models are pretty popular among members, so I am certain they would all like to know what to look for!
Def
-
I started a Multitool poll over at British blades a while ago and it makes for a good read .196 voters took part . Only 5 owned Sogs , 119 Leathermans , Swisstool 15 , 30 SAKs , 19 Gerbers and 8 others .Clearly the Brits prefer the Leathermans but I have converted quite a few ;) http://www.britishblades.com/forums/showthread.php?t=25298&highlight=multitool
Heres a recent multitool thread
http://www.britishblades.com/forums/showthread.php?t=35021Dunc
-
Most of the members on here havnt voted :( Come on guys its not very accurate if we dont get most of you to vote .
Dunc
-
I agree with Dunc, come on and vote folks!
BTW Dunc, thanks for the BB link. I had somehow missed that discussion.
-
I found it a pretty interesting read... and I still haven't gotten all the way through it!
Def
-
@Defender said:
If you are interested in the Spirit S model, I suggest contacting some of our banner supporters at www.edcdepot.com or www.felinevet.sosakonline.com as they both have excellent prices and ship internationally. If you don't see them listed on the sites, e-mail them and ask as they often can't keep up with the amount of stock they have coming and going!Thanks a lot for the advice, I will, if nothing else for completion reasons.
@Defender said:
If I may, what signs of wear were showing up on the Charge, and in what ways in particular did you not feel it was measuring up? Judging from the results of our informal poll so far it seems that the Charge models are pretty popular among members, so I am certain they would all like to know what to look for!For one the pliers jaws became misaligned after a couple of weeks of heavy use. The file started oxidising, not rusting, but started becoming darker, a clear sign of corrosion to come. The plier jaws are too thin, you have to be careful about the force you exert. The ruler is not as easy to use as the Swisstool one, and I use that all the time. Finally, the tools I use the most are not the blades, so the one hand opening thing didn't balance things for having to unfold the pliers to gain access to the rest of the tools. Overall, it was not as rigid and heavy duty as I expected. That is not to say it is a bad one, just not on the standards I am used to. So I guess I will continue increasing my Swisstool when my toolcase is not at reach, and continue increasing my Swisstool and Spirit "collection" remaining a Vic fanatic.
However, bear in mind I work in a plant with heavy machinery, 3 floors high blown film extrusion lines, we are talking heavy machinery, huge extrusion screws etc. Also, I am a mech eng. If I was an electrician maybe I would think higher of the Charge.Well, I guess I now also made enemies

-
I don't think you have made any enemies per se, but I do think that maybe you pushed the Charge too far. The SwissTool is a heavy duty tool, built for heavy duty applications. The Charge series to me seems like more of a moderate duty tool designed for more everyday applications. You may find Leathermans like the Core, Surge or SuperTools more to your liking, or at least more capable of the tasks you ask of them.
Of course, the Surge has the outside opening blades, and all of them have to be opened to access the other tools, so judging by what you've said I seriously doubt any of them would overthrow the SwissTools.
As a SwissTool fan you may also be interested in seeing the predecessor to the SwissTool design, the Bear Jaws by Bear Cutlery. Victorinox purchased Bear in order to obtain their patents on the design for the outside opening tools. In 2004 (if I remember correctly) Bear was sold back to one of the original owners and is now Bear & Sons. It's not a SwissTool, but if you are interested in collecting SwissTool variants, it is definately a muct have. And don't get me started on the AutoTool! :P
Def
-
@Defender said:
I don't think you have made any enemies per se, but I do think that maybe you pushed the Charge too far. The SwissTool is a heavy duty tool, built for heavy duty applications. The Charge series to me seems like more of a moderate duty tool designed for more everyday applications. You may find Leathermans like the Core, Surge or SuperTools more to your liking, or at least more capable of the tasks you ask of them.I see your point and I agree, Charge is not the LM equivalent of SwissTool. However, even when compared to the more lightweight Spirit the Charge didn't measure up. I chose the Charge over the Core because it was advertised soemthing like the "best Leatherman ever".
I didn't know those details about Bear Cutlery, very interesting, thanks!
-
I voted for the SOG PowerLock but I wouldn't be very happy giving up my Charge XTi and SwissTool X and many others.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



