Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE NOTIFICATIONS 0 MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Cheap and Cheerful (or otherwise!)
219 Posts 1 Posters 28.1k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Cheap and Cheerful (or otherwise!)
  4. Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04
Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • SAK Guy Offline
    SAK Guy
    Posts: 23,929
    SAK Guy Offline
    SAK Guy
    wrote on last edited by
    #182 Quote Reply

      @jcfiguet said:

      @SAK Guy said:

      I just really dislike the hubris of Swiza. Allow me to cut through some of the marketing spin on their website and in the press release.... (Yes, I used to work in Advertising/Marketing and know how to put a pinstripe on a turd and sell it)

      "A legend reborn" ("Although the biggest knife manufacturer in the world is unaware the "legend" had died, we're gonna say this")

      "Swiza reinvents the Swiss Knife" ("Swiza takes aim at the urban yuppy segment of the Victorinox market share")

      "Revolutionary redesign of the legendary Swiss Knife." ("Realized without infringing on existing Swiss patents, a modernized version of a multi-function knife similar to other "redesigned" urban knives is here")

      "The knife is available in four Jura-inspired colors: Bright Red, Husky Eye Blue, Snow White and Graphit Black." ("We are so cool, hip and modern, even our made up color names are aimed attractive to our targeted consumer base")

      Swiza is untried, untested and claims a linage and reputation that is unearned IMO.

      That's hubris.

      Why simply not to welcome a new Swiss Army Knives and a new Swiss cutler ?
      Why to refuse the diversity?
      Why to refuse the competition?
      Why Switzerland should have only one brand of SAK?

      If they had billed themselves as a "Swiss knife for a New Generation" or as "the Modern Choice for 21st Century" etc., I would be more accepting. But to use "legend reborn", "revolutionary redesign" and "reinvents the Swiss Knife", Swiza compares and contrasts themselves to the 134 year standard and that irks me. Because, to echo your statement, I have owned 1000's of Swiss Army Knives over 40 years of collecting and know these statements are pure marketing fluff that so far haven't been lived up to. Diversity and competition are great but not at the expense of 134 years of history and experience, that was earned.

      Why not stand on their own merits/innovation and not have to portray Vic/Wenger as outdated, old fashion and subpar to make a big splash. As I said before, when Swiza has been down the Amazon, to the top of Everest and into space, then they can tell how they are as good as that old outdated brand next door.

      1 Reply Last reply
      • jcfiguet Offline
        jcfiguet
        Posts: 388
        jcfiguet Offline
        jcfiguet
        wrote on last edited by
        #183 Quote Reply

          @Etherealicer said:

          @jcfiguet said:
          Why saying "Swiza boastful claim of re-inventing the SAK" ?

          It's not "boastful" it is just simply the truth : When you begin from a white paper and a pencil to create a new Swiss knife, you can claim to have reinvented the SAK!
          You are Swiss citizen, you might know that canton of Jura is proud and rebel ! And those are legitimate sentiments, not 'boastful".

          At best it is a re-design (no new invention in the Swiza SAKs) and you said it yourself:

          @jcfiguet said:
          My opinion is the line of a Swiza knife is very similar to the french knife "Le Thiers" (the last knife).

          So it's not even a new design.

          And despite all their claims on how awesome they are, they heavily rely on the reputation built by Victorinox (and Wenger).

          Ok, Ok, but the concept is new in Switzerland : new line (even inspired by the Thiers) and I think the best of Victorinox and Wenger with some improvements.
          IMO, today when you create a new folding knife it's always from existing knives... A knife without blade could not be called a knife, a knife without tools could not be called a Swiss knife, etc.
          So I think, if we love Swiss Army Knives we must promote a new Swiss cutler. I can't imagine Switzerland with only one brand of chocolats, only one brand of watches, only one canton or worst without William Tell ! LOL !
          I think also Switzerland deserves more than a single brand of knives...

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Etherealicer Offline
            Etherealicer
            Admin Team
            Posts: 12,034
            Etherealicer Offline
            Etherealicer
            Admin Team
            wrote on last edited by
            #184 Quote Reply

              @jcfiguet said:

              @Etherealicer said:

              @jcfiguet said:
              Why saying "Swiza boastful claim of re-inventing the SAK" ?

              It's not "boastful" it is just simply the truth : When you begin from a white paper and a pencil to create a new Swiss knife, you can claim to have reinvented the SAK!
              You are Swiss citizen, you might know that canton of Jura is proud and rebel ! And those are legitimate sentiments, not 'boastful".

              At best it is a re-design (no new invention in the Swiza SAKs) and you said it yourself:

              @jcfiguet said:
              My opinion is the line of a Swiza knife is very similar to the french knife "Le Thiers" (the last knife).

              So it's not even a new design.

              And despite all their claims on how awesome they are, they heavily rely on the reputation built by Victorinox (and Wenger).

              Ok, Ok, but the concept is new in Switzerland : new line (even inspired by the Thiers) and I think the best of Victorinox and Wenger with some improvements.
              IMO, today when you create a new folding knife it's always from existing knives... A knife without blade could not be called a knife, a knife without tools could not be called a Swiss knife, etc.
              So I think, if we love Swiss Army Knives we must promote a new Swiss cutler. I can't imagine Switzerland with only one brand of chocolats, only one brand of watches, only one canton or worst without William Tell ! LOL !
              I think also Switzerland deserves more than a single brand of knives...

              William Tell as we know him today was created by Schiller and he is German ;)

              I do, I welcome Böker to the table :angel:

              1 Reply Last reply
              • jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                Posts: 388
                jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                wrote on last edited by
                #185 Quote Reply

                  @SAK Guy said:

                  @jcfiguet said:

                  @SAK Guy said:

                  I just really dislike the hubris of Swiza. Allow me to cut through some of the marketing spin on their website and in the press release.... (Yes, I used to work in Advertising/Marketing and know how to put a pinstripe on a turd and sell it)

                  "A legend reborn" ("Although the biggest knife manufacturer in the world is unaware the "legend" had died, we're gonna say this")

                  "Swiza reinvents the Swiss Knife" ("Swiza takes aim at the urban yuppy segment of the Victorinox market share")

                  "Revolutionary redesign of the legendary Swiss Knife." ("Realized without infringing on existing Swiss patents, a modernized version of a multi-function knife similar to other "redesigned" urban knives is here")

                  "The knife is available in four Jura-inspired colors: Bright Red, Husky Eye Blue, Snow White and Graphit Black." ("We are so cool, hip and modern, even our made up color names are aimed attractive to our targeted consumer base")

                  Swiza is untried, untested and claims a linage and reputation that is unearned IMO.

                  That's hubris.

                  Why simply not to welcome a new Swiss Army Knives and a new Swiss cutler ?
                  Why to refuse the diversity?
                  Why to refuse the competition?
                  Why Switzerland should have only one brand of SAK?

                  If they had billed themselves as a "Swiss knife for a New Generation" or as "the Modern Choice for 21st Century" etc., I would be more accepting. But to use "legend reborn", "revolutionary redesign" and "reinvents the Swiss Knife", Swiza compares and contrasts themselves to the 134 year standard and that irks me. Because, to echo your statement, I have owned 1000's of Swiss Army Knives over 40 years of collecting and know these statements are pure marketing fluff that so far haven't been lived up to. Diversity and competition are great but not at the expense of 134 years of history and experience, that was earned.

                  Why not stand on their own merits/innovation and not have to portray Vic/Wenger as outdated, old fashion and subpar to make a big splash. As I said before, when Swiza has been down the Amazon, to the top of Everest and into space, then they can tell how they are as good as that old outdated brand next door.

                  It's only a problem of communication. Swiza is 134-year-old heir of history of Swiss army knife :

                  if you compare this model 1890

                  with this model of Swiza

                  Except the corkscrew, these knives are similar

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • jcfiguet Offline
                    jcfiguet
                    Posts: 388
                    jcfiguet Offline
                    jcfiguet
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #186 Quote Reply

                      @Etherealicer said:

                      William Tell as we know him today was created by Schiller and he is German ;)

                      I do, I welcome Böker to the table :angel:
                      [/quote]

                      I will go to diner :
                      Grison Meat
                      Gruyère cheese
                      Wine Fendant of Valais
                      and a "branche of Cailler"
                      with my Swiza Knife ! LOL

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • Etherealicer Offline
                        Etherealicer
                        Admin Team
                        Posts: 12,034
                        Etherealicer Offline
                        Etherealicer
                        Admin Team
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #187 Quote Reply

                          @jcfiguet said:

                          @Etherealicer said:

                          William Tell as we know him today was created by Schiller and he is German ;)

                          I do, I welcome Böker to the table :angel:

                          I will go to diner :
                          Grison Meat
                          Gruyère cheese
                          Wine Fendant of Valais
                          and a "branche of Cailler"
                          with my Swiza Knife ! LOL

                          Fendant of Valais? Really? Thought you French guys would have better taste when it comes to wine... >:D
                          Also "viande du Grison" would be better paired with a red wine...
                          And if you want to drink something truly Swiss it has to be either Rivella or Ovomaltine :D

                          If I can make a recommendation try the "branche of Cailler" Caramel Sale, they are sublime

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • SAK Guy Offline
                            SAK Guy
                            Posts: 23,929
                            SAK Guy Offline
                            SAK Guy
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #188 Quote Reply

                              @jcfiguet said:

                              @SAK Guy said:

                              @jcfiguet said:

                              @SAK Guy said:

                              I just really dislike the hubris of Swiza. Allow me to cut through some of the marketing spin on their website and in the press release.... (Yes, I used to work in Advertising/Marketing and know how to put a pinstripe on a turd and sell it)

                              "A legend reborn" ("Although the biggest knife manufacturer in the world is unaware the "legend" had died, we're gonna say this")

                              "Swiza reinvents the Swiss Knife" ("Swiza takes aim at the urban yuppy segment of the Victorinox market share")

                              "Revolutionary redesign of the legendary Swiss Knife." ("Realized without infringing on existing Swiss patents, a modernized version of a multi-function knife similar to other "redesigned" urban knives is here")

                              "The knife is available in four Jura-inspired colors: Bright Red, Husky Eye Blue, Snow White and Graphit Black." ("We are so cool, hip and modern, even our made up color names are aimed attractive to our targeted consumer base")

                              Swiza is untried, untested and claims a linage and reputation that is unearned IMO.

                              That's hubris.

                              Why simply not to welcome a new Swiss Army Knives and a new Swiss cutler ?
                              Why to refuse the diversity?
                              Why to refuse the competition?
                              Why Switzerland should have only one brand of SAK?

                              If they had billed themselves as a "Swiss knife for a New Generation" or as "the Modern Choice for 21st Century" etc., I would be more accepting. But to use "legend reborn", "revolutionary redesign" and "reinvents the Swiss Knife", Swiza compares and contrasts themselves to the 134 year standard and that irks me. Because, to echo your statement, I have owned 1000's of Swiss Army Knives over 40 years of collecting and know these statements are pure marketing fluff that so far haven't been lived up to. Diversity and competition are great but not at the expense of 134 years of history and experience, that was earned.

                              Why not stand on their own merits/innovation and not have to portray Vic/Wenger as outdated, old fashion and subpar to make a big splash. As I said before, when Swiza has been down the Amazon, to the top of Everest and into space, then they can tell how they are as good as that old outdated brand next door.

                              It's only a problem of communication. Swiza is 134-year-old heir of history of Swiss army knife :

                              if you compare this model 1890

                              with this model of Swiza

                              Except the corkscrew, these knives are similar

                              :facepalm:

                              The Swiza we are discussing was in development for 2 years and was launched on Oct 21, 2015, not a knife they made in 1890. If you you google Swiza, 99.9% of the hits are about what great clock/watch makers they are....not 100's of thousands of hits on their famous and long lived line of innovative knives (like Vic/Wenger). 6,540,000 for Victorinox knives to be more exact.

                              In 1939, Singer Sewing Machine Co. made .45 cal service pistols for the US Army. Now if they popped up a couple of months ago with a new line of pistols and claimed it was a "legend reborn" or a "reinvented, revolutionary redesign" of the classic .45.....would they really be better than a Colt, the originator and continuous producer of the 1911 pistol since it's inception.

                              No, they would be maneuvering for marketshare, trying to generate interest and position themselves to compete in the marketplace.

                              I'm done discussing it. I wish them well but will never own one. "Rigid and inflexible" were the terms my 13 year old Daughter used to describe me 20 years ago....maybe she was right. After all, I've only accepted Wenger as a "real" Swiss Army knife in the last 3-4 years. :D

                              No offense intended and I have enjoyed and been enlightened by the discussion! :cheers:

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • jcfiguet Offline
                                jcfiguet
                                Posts: 388
                                jcfiguet Offline
                                jcfiguet
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #189 Quote Reply

                                  @SAK Guy said:
                                  [---]

                                  :facepalm:

                                  The Swiza we are discussing was in development for 2 years and was launched on Oct 21, 2015, not a knife they made in 1890. If you you google Swiza, 99.9% of the hits are about what great clock/watch makers they are....not 100's of thousands of hits on their famous and long lived line of innovative knives (like Vic/Wenger). 6,540,000 for Victorinox knives to be more exact.

                                  In 1939, Singer Sewing Machine Co. made .45 cal service pistols for the US Army. Now if they popped up a couple of months ago with a new line of pistols and claimed it was a "legend reborn" or a "reinvented, revolutionary redesign" of the classic .45.....would they really be better than a Colt, the originator and continuous producer of the 1911 pistol since it's inception.

                                  No, they would be maneuvering for marketshare, trying to generate interest and position themselves to compete in the marketplace.

                                  I'm done discussing it. I wish them well but will never own one. "Rigid and inflexible" were the terms my 13 year old Daughter used to describe me 20 years ago....maybe she was right. After all, I've only accepted Wenger as a "real" Swiss Army knife in the last 3-4 years. :D

                                  No offense intended and I have enjoyed and been enlightened by the discussion! :cheers:

                                  I think your Daughter is right !

                                  The "real and first" Swiss Army knives were German : the first 15000 soldier knives made in 1890 for the Swiss Army were manufactured by Wester & Co (Solingen), D. Pères (Solingen), C. Wermuth, etc.
                                  In October of 1891, the first Swiss versions of the Soldier Knife were produced and supplied to the Army by Karl Elsener...
                                  In 1893 Paul Boechat, Coutellerie Suisse (name before Wenger) produced soldier knives for the Swiss Army...
                                  And after, in 1900's, 30 other swiss brands followed the adventure...

                                  The Swiss Army Knife is a legend in all over the world, through all Swiss knives brands and since more 100 years. Who can claim that the only real, authentic or genuine Swiss army knives are made by Victorinox ? Nobody ! And nobody can change the history even persons described as "Rigid and inflexible".

                                  Today the birth of Swiza as new brand of Swiss Army Knives, but what is the problem ? Before they made only watches, yes it's true ! Like before making knives, the Elsener family was hatter and Wenger was minister of religion !

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    Posts: 388
                                    jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    wrote on last edited by jcfiguet
                                    #190 Quote Reply

                                      @Etherealicer said:

                                      @jcfiguet said:

                                      @Etherealicer said:

                                      William Tell as we know him today was created by Schiller and he is German ;)

                                      I do, I welcome Böker to the table :angel:

                                      I will go to diner :
                                      Grison Meat
                                      Gruyère cheese
                                      Wine Fendant of Valais
                                      and a "branche of Cailler"
                                      with my Swiza Knife ! LOL

                                      Fendant of Valais? Really? Thought you French guys would have better taste when it comes to wine... >:D
                                      Also "viande du Grison" would be better paired with a red wine...
                                      And if you want to drink something truly Swiss it has to be either Rivella or Ovomaltine :D

                                      If I can make a recommendation try the "branche of Cailler" Caramel Sale, they are sublime

                                      One of the best :

                                      To uncork with the corkscrew of a Swiza knife !

                                      Jura and Valais : the more rebels cantons of Switzerland LOL !

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • SAK Guy Offline
                                        SAK Guy
                                        Posts: 23,929
                                        SAK Guy Offline
                                        SAK Guy
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #191 Quote Reply

                                          @jcfiguet said:

                                          @SAK Guy said:

                                          [---]

                                          :facepalm:

                                          The Swiza we are discussing was in development for 2 years and was launched on Oct 21, 2015, not a knife they made in 1890. If you you google Swiza, 99.9% of the hits are about what great clock/watch makers they are....not 100's of thousands of hits on their famous and long lived line of innovative knives (like Vic/Wenger). 6,540,000 for Victorinox knives to be more exact.

                                          In 1939, Singer Sewing Machine Co. made .45 cal service pistols for the US Army. Now if they popped up a couple of months ago with a new line of pistols and claimed it was a "legend reborn" or a "reinvented, revolutionary redesign" of the classic .45.....would they really be better than a Colt, the originator and continuous producer of the 1911 pistol since it's inception.

                                          No, they would be maneuvering for marketshare, trying to generate interest and position themselves to compete in the marketplace.

                                          I'm done discussing it. I wish them well but will never own one. "Rigid and inflexible" were the terms my 13 year old Daughter used to describe me 20 years ago....maybe she was right. After all, I've only accepted Wenger as a "real" Swiss Army knife in the last 3-4 years. :D

                                          No offense intended and I have enjoyed and been enlightened by the discussion! :cheers:

                                          I think your Daughter is right !

                                          The "real and first" Swiss Army knives were German : the first 15000 soldier knives made in 1890 for the Swiss Army were manufactured by Wester & Co (Solingen), D. Pères (Solingen), C. Wermuth, etc.
                                          In October of 1891, the first Swiss versions of the Soldier Knife were produced and supplied to the Army by Karl Elsener...
                                          In 1893 Paul Boechat, Coutellerie Suisse (name before Wenger) produced soldier knives for the Swiss Army...
                                          And after, in 1900's, 30 other swiss brands followed the adventure...

                                          The Swiss Army Knife is a legend in all over the world, through all Swiss knives brands and since more 100 years. Who can claim that the only real, authentic or genuine Swiss army knives are made by Victorinox ? Nobody ! And nobody can change the history even persons described as "Rigid and inflexible".

                                          Today the birth of Swiza as new brand of Swiss Army Knives, but what is the problem ? Before they made only watches, yes it's true ! Like before making knives, the Elsener family was hatter and Wenger was minister of religion !

                                          Well, I was done till you went all argumentum ad hominem on me.

                                          My Daughter has a 16 year old wanting to date a 20 year old and suddenly she's even more rigid and inflexible than I was back when, at 13, she wanted to date an 18 year old....

                                          History proved me right in that instance but as for Swiss Army Knife history, I always defer to the experts on this site:

                                          Link Preview Image
                                          404 Not Found

                                          favicon

                                          (www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch)

                                          I missed all the historical entries on Swiza there, perhaps now you will amend that oversight.

                                          Thank you for the the discussion Jean Claude! You truly have a magnificent website that is definitive resource for all collectors interested in Swiss Soldier knives. :salute:

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • jcfiguet Offline
                                            jcfiguet
                                            Posts: 388
                                            jcfiguet Offline
                                            jcfiguet
                                            wrote on last edited by jcfiguet
                                            #192 Quote Reply

                                              [---]

                                              @SAK Guy said:
                                              Well, I was done till you went all argumentum ad hominem on me.

                                              My Daughter has a 16 year old wanting to date a 20 year old and suddenly she's even more rigid and inflexible than I was back when, at 13, she wanted to date an 18 year old....

                                              History proved me right in that instance but as for Swiss Army Knife history, I always defer to the experts on this site:

                                              Link Preview Image
                                              404 Not Found

                                              favicon

                                              (www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch)

                                              I missed all the historical entries on Swiza there, perhaps now you will amend that oversight.

                                              Thank you for the the discussion Jean Claude! You truly have a magnificent website that is definitive resource for all collectors interested in Swiss Soldier knives. :salute:

                                              Childrens are wonderfull ! LOL ! My Son is 30, my Daughter is 26 and I also have 2 other Sons of 24 and 22 years old.

                                              The web site "Les couteaux de l'armée suisse" is not my website but the website of my friend Robert Moix, a big collector and expert of swiss soldiers knives. I'm only his webmaster.
                                              Robert and me think together it's a good cooperation between Swiss and France before (the impossible) entry of Switzerland in European Union ! LOL !

                                              For us, the history of Swiss Army Knives is not closed. Today this history continue with Victorinox and Swiza and why not (we hope), with other new brands in the futur if it's possible.
                                              The futur is not for us but for our childrens. About Swiss Army Knives, during our life, we had only the choice between Victorinox and Wenger, so I hope our childrens will have still more choice !

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • SAK Guy Offline
                                                SAK Guy
                                                Posts: 23,929
                                                SAK Guy Offline
                                                SAK Guy
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #193 Quote Reply

                                                  @jcfiguet said:
                                                  [---]

                                                  @SAK Guy said:

                                                  Well, I was done till you went all argumentum ad hominem on me.

                                                  My Daughter has a 16 year old wanting to date a 20 year old and suddenly she's even more rigid and inflexible than I was back when, at 13, she wanted to date an 18 year old....

                                                  History proved me right in that instance but as for Swiss Army Knife history, I always defer to the experts on this site:

                                                  Link Preview Image
                                                  404 Not Found

                                                  favicon

                                                  (www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch)

                                                  I missed all the historical entries on Swiza there, perhaps now you will amend that oversight.

                                                  Thank you for the the discussion Jean Claude! You truly have a magnificent website that is definitive resource for all collectors interested in Swiss Soldier knives. :salute:

                                                  Childrens are wonderfull ! LOL ! My Son is 30, my Daughter is 26 and I also have 2 other Sons of 24 and 22 years old.

                                                  The web site "Les couteaux de l'armée suisse" is not my website but the website of my friend Robert Moix, a big collector and expert of swiss soldiers knives. I'm only his webmaster.
                                                  Robert and me think together it's good cooperation between Swiss and France before (the impossible) entry of Switzerland in European Union ! LOL !

                                                  For us, the history of Swiss Army Knives is not closed. Today this history continue with Victorinox and Swiza and why not (we hope), with other new brands in the futur if it's possible.
                                                  The futur is not for us but for our childrens. About Swiss Army Knives, during our life, we had only the choice between Victorinox and Wenger, so I hope our childrens will have still more choice !

                                                  Sorry for the mistake my friend! :salute: It's still a great site, please pass my complement along to Robert Moix!

                                                  :cheers: to the future!!!

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Etherealicer Offline
                                                    Etherealicer
                                                    Admin Team
                                                    Posts: 12,034
                                                    Etherealicer Offline
                                                    Etherealicer
                                                    Admin Team
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #194 Quote Reply

                                                      It appears we are somewhat at an impasse, so here is what I propose:

                                                      As jc owns the whole lot and seems to be very happy with it. Make a 30 day challenge and report every day what you used your knife for. Show us how good it is. Go beyond of what I've done for 10 days.
                                                      Deeds speak louder than words, right?

                                                      While I agree that the history of the Swiss Army Knife is far from over I also think:

                                                      • Being a Swiss Knife Manufacturer is not enough
                                                      • Having a CEO from a former Swiss Knife Manufacturer that went bankrupt is no qualification
                                                        What we care for is the product, but not just the looks. We also want it to be great built quality / durable and ergonomic.
                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • jcfiguet Offline
                                                        jcfiguet
                                                        Posts: 388
                                                        jcfiguet Offline
                                                        jcfiguet
                                                        wrote on last edited by jcfiguet
                                                        #195 Quote Reply

                                                          You proposed the challenge to show how Swiza is good, why not !
                                                          But what can I say more ?

                                                          I use a Swiza knife since 3 week in standard conditions and I didn't find any thing wrong, it is always like new, the blade has always a good cutting edge, I didn't have any problem to open can of food or to do holes in PVC or in leather...

                                                          For me a D03 is between a Victorinox Spartan and a soldier knife alox model 1961 with some improvements like autolock, new scales, new look, etc...

                                                          The quality seems the same and I didn't have any problem with it. I'm not a survivalist and I don't use it like a survivalist in extrem conditions. Moreover I don't think that this knife is intended to be used like that, it's not a Wenger Ranger or a Soldier knife !

                                                          So what else ? I think I already say all I think in other posts.

                                                          I could say it's elegant or I love its line, but these appreciations are subjectives and other persons could say "I don't like or I hate"... I also could force on tools or on the blade to break them but the results would be the same with all other SAK.

                                                          To be completly objective, measurements must be made in laboratory to compare for example the main blade of a Swiza with the main blade of a Victorinox spartan (of the same year) and to compare all other tools...
                                                          If somebody can do it, I am curious to see results.

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Etherealicer Offline
                                                            Etherealicer
                                                            Admin Team
                                                            Posts: 12,034
                                                            Etherealicer Offline
                                                            Etherealicer
                                                            Admin Team
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #196 Quote Reply

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              You proposed the challenge to show how Swiza is good, why not !
                                                              But what can I say more ?

                                                              Simple:

                                                              :worthless:

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              the blade has always a good cutting edge

                                                              Yup, no problem with that. It also held up pretty nicely when opening a can.
                                                              I personally dislike the hole at the tip (see my posts on food prep).

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              [...]I didn't have any problem to open can of food

                                                              Me neither, except I found the can opener easier to use left-handed but then opening cans is not my thing (remember, urban... healthy food... no cans)

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              [...] or to do holes in PVC or in leather...

                                                              Oh god, that would be horrible if it was unable to make hole in such soft materials... For me it worked well on soft wood and tin-cans but failed on harder wood (my desk).

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              For me a D03 is between a Victorinox Spartan and a soldier knife alox model 1961 with some improvements like autolock, new scales, new look, etc...

                                                              I agree the lock is good and the scales are great... It does have a new look which I quite like but the ergonomics suffer too much.

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              The quality seems the same and I didn't have any problem with it. I'm not a survivalist and I don't use it like a survivalist in extrem conditions. Moreover I don't think that this knife is intended to be used like that, it's not a Wenger Ranger or a Soldier knife !

                                                              Here is where I disagree...
                                                              Screwdrivers are for screws and both small-flat and Phillips were inferior to the offerings from Victorinox / Wenger.
                                                              Cap lifter works not as well as the offering from Victorinox / Wenger.

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              I could say it's elegant or I love its line, but these appreciations are subjectives and other persons could say "I don't like or I hate"... I also could force on tools or on the blade to break them but the results would be the same with all other SAK.

                                                              I truly tortured a Vic Classic and it is amazing what that little tool can take.

                                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                                              To be completly objective, measurements must be made in laboratory to compare for example the main blade of a Swiza with the main blade of a Victorinox spartan (of the same year) and to compare all other tools...
                                                              If somebody can do it, I am curious to see results.

                                                              No need, we know the result
                                                              Victorinox 56 HRc, Swiza 57HRc, both adequate (Victorinox has demonstrated that) without being outstanding/exceptional

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                jcfiguet
                                                                Posts: 388
                                                                jcfiguet Offline
                                                                jcfiguet
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #197 Quote Reply

                                                                  Your tests are not measurable in a scientific way.
                                                                  As I told before, I didn't try to break anything on this knife, I just try to use it in normal/standard use.
                                                                  As I told before, the awl is not planned to make holes in hard wood (FYI, the PVC is not particulary soft !)

                                                                  If you want photos I can also show you the results on screwdrivers, can-openers, or other tools, on Victorinox or Wenger knives when somebody force a lot or after opening 10 or 15 cans, you will have exactly the same defects that you blame to Swiza knives.

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                    AimlessWanderer
                                                                    Posts: 17,518
                                                                    AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                    AimlessWanderer
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #198 Quote Reply

                                                                      So to summarise so far....

                                                                      SAKguy and Etherealicer are not impressed with Swiza, in form, function, and also in promise

                                                                      Jcfiguet is quite impressed so far

                                                                      SAKguy won't go near them, and that's fair enough - they don't appear to offer me what I want, so I'll also stay clear for now :cheers:

                                                                      Jcfiguet and Etherealicer have both used the knives, and agree on some things but not others. Contention seems to be mostly on the drivers. They held up well for one, but not the other. The other main disagreement is ergonomics.

                                                                      Have I summed this up about right so far?

                                                                      Ergonomics are subjective. You only need to look at the Skeletool for proof. Some think it fits the hand well, and others think it's horrendous. Personally, I think this looks too much like the extent of protrusion on a OHO 111mm, and I don't think it'll suit my hands

                                                                      The advertising has got people talking and paying attention, and many say there is no such thing as bad advertising. Whether you like it or not, they are very much in your mind gnawing away.

                                                                      This just leaves screwdrivers. Two people got two different results. That could be different screws, different handling, or inconsistencies in the product. :think:

                                                                      What kind of screws, guys? Phillips or Pozi? Stubborn screws, or fairly loose? Are we talking about minor scuffs/signs of use, or actual damage which may mean the drivers are likely to strip completely (on Beat's knife). JC, have you been particularly careful with it being a new tool, or have you used it as hard as you would any other tool?

                                                                      Hope you don't mind me doing this guys, just trying to simplify the feedback in my own mind :cheers:

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        Posts: 388
                                                                        jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #199 Quote Reply

                                                                          @50ft-trad said:
                                                                          So to summarise so far....

                                                                          This just leaves screwdrivers. Two people got two different results. That could be different screws, different handling, or inconsistencies in the product. :think:

                                                                          What kind of screws, guys? Phillips or Pozi? Stubborn screws, or fairly loose? Are we talking about minor scuffs/signs of use, or actual damage which may mean the drivers are likely to strip completely (on Beat's knife). JC, have you been particularly careful with it being a new tool, or have you used it as hard as you would any other tool?

                                                                          Hope you don't mind me doing this guys, just trying to simplify the feedback in my own mind :cheers:

                                                                          For my test it was only 2 flat screws (1 small and 1 large) for the 2 flat screwdrivers (of the can-opener and of the cap-lifter).
                                                                          I can't say I tested it particularly carefully but <u>each screws were adapted to each screwdriver</u> :

                                                                          • For the small one I tried to screw and unscrew an electric plug
                                                                          • For the large one it was a screw of a Bookcase IKEA.

                                                                          I can't say this test was particularly hard or soft, IMO it was adapted to my idea of these kind of knives more "urban style" than Wenger or Victorinox...
                                                                          Stubborn screws, or fairly loose ? Neither one, nor the other, only normal to unscrew and after I tightened these screws firmly but without excessive force.
                                                                          I choose screws adapted to the screwdriver because if you don't do that you are pretty sure to deteriorate any screwdriver on any SAK.

                                                                          But IMO this is not a problem of screwdriver or other tool : the real problem is that some people don't accept a new Swiss knives brand. Everybody can say I like or I don't like this tool because...Etc...
                                                                          But when you see this topic : </topic/63224 with a pol "Are SWIZA knives SAKs? Yes/No/Sacrilege! they should not even be in the Swiss Army Knights forum", it's a lack of respect for Swiza...
                                                                          I had the same feeling of unhappiness when some were delighted by the end of the Wenger knives in 2013…
                                                                          On lot of other forums in Europe you can read "Welcome to Swiza" or "we are lucky to have a new Swiss brand" or other welcome messages...
                                                                          But not on multitool.org...

                                                                          Personally I prefer to remain positive and optimistic: A new brand of SAK is a cultural wealth, I am happy of this birth and I'm not alone to be happy.
                                                                          Like all new industry, Swiza is not perfect, but I am sure that it will improve in the future. Let us leave at least a chance to Swiza! We should not throw the baby with the water of his bath !

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                            AimlessWanderer
                                                                            Posts: 17,518
                                                                            AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                            AimlessWanderer
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #200 Quote Reply

                                                                              I take your point, and here is my opinion on that:

                                                                              They are not Swiss ARMY Knives because they never made knives for the Swiss Army. However, that is not a reflection on the quality - that is a seperate topic altogether. They could be the greatest multipurpose pocket knives ever invented, but that doesn't make them SAKs ;) just because they are "only" Swiss knives and not Swiss Army Knives, doesn't make them bad, nor does it mean that people won't try them and like them.

                                                                              Some people take the SAK definition more literally than others. These are Swiss knives, and should be judged either on their own merit, or in comparison with ALL multipurpose pocket knives. I don't like the style, I don't want a locking blade on a tool like this - that doesn't mean they are bad knives either. They are just not a style of knife that appeals to me.

                                                                              I look forward to hearing how people get on with them long term, and if they ever make any with non-locking blades and scissors, I might give them a try :)

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • Grathr Offline
                                                                                Grathr
                                                                                Posts: 7,683
                                                                                Grathr Offline
                                                                                Grathr
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #201 Quote Reply

                                                                                  @jcfiguet said:

                                                                                  @50ft-trad said:

                                                                                  So to summarise so far....

                                                                                  This just leaves screwdrivers. Two people got two different results. That could be different screws, different handling, or inconsistencies in the product. :think:

                                                                                  What kind of screws, guys? Phillips or Pozi? Stubborn screws, or fairly loose? Are we talking about minor scuffs/signs of use, or actual damage which may mean the drivers are likely to strip completely (on Beat's knife). JC, have you been particularly careful with it being a new tool, or have you used it as hard as you would any other tool?

                                                                                  Hope you don't mind me doing this guys, just trying to simplify the feedback in my own mind :cheers:

                                                                                  For my test it was only 2 flat screws (1 small and 1 large) for the 2 flat screwdrivers (of the can-opener and of the cap-lifter).
                                                                                  I can't say I tested it particularly carefully but <u>each screws were adapted to each screwdriver</u> :

                                                                                  • For the small one I tried to screw and unscrew an electric plug
                                                                                  • For the large one it was a screw of a Bookcase IKEA.

                                                                                  I can't say this test was particularly hard or soft, IMO it was adapted to my idea of these kind of knives more "urban style" than Wenger or Victorinox...
                                                                                  Stubborn screws, or fairly loose ? Neither one, nor the other, only normal to unscrew and after I tightened these screws firmly but without excessive force.
                                                                                  I choose screws adapted to the screwdriver because if you don't do that you are pretty sure to deteriorate any screwdriver on any SAK.

                                                                                  But IMO this is not a problem of screwdriver or other tool : the real problem is that some people don't accept a new Swiss knives brand. Everybody can say I like or I don't like this tool because...Etc...
                                                                                  But when you see this topic : /topic/63224 with a pol "Are SWIZA knives SAKs? Yes/No/Sacrilege! they should not even be in the Swiss Army Knights forum", it's a lack of respect for Swiza...
                                                                                  I had the same feeling of unhappiness when some were delighted by the end of the Wenger knives in 2013…
                                                                                  On lot of other forums in Europe you can read "Welcome to Swiza" or "we are lucky to have a new Swiss brand" or other welcome messages...
                                                                                  But not on multitool.org...

                                                                                  Personally I prefer to remain positive and optimistic: A new brand of SAK is a cultural wealth, I am happy of this birth and I'm not alone to be happy.
                                                                                  Like all new industry, Swiza is not perfect, but I am sure that it will improve in the future. Let us leave at least a chance to Swiza! We should not throw the baby with the water of his bath !

                                                                                  The way I see it everyone should be allowed to have their own opinion about the Swiza knives. Good or bad and they should be alowed to voice it without it turning into a big argument and blaming MTO for not liking it.

                                                                                  I welcomed the Swiza knives when I first heard about them, and I even ordered a D02 wich I gave been EDCing since it arrived. You can read about my first impressions of it here: /topic/63179

                                                                                  I started the poll thread out of curiosity as I wanted to see where the members of this community feel it belongs.
                                                                                  I do not understand why you feel its an attack on Swiza? Its a legitimate question.

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 7
                                                                                  • 8
                                                                                  • 9
                                                                                  • 10
                                                                                  • 11
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. Cheap and Cheerful (or otherwise!)
                                                                                  4. Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0