Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04
-
@50ft-trad said:
So to summarise so far....
This just leaves screwdrivers. Two people got two different results. That could be different screws, different handling, or inconsistencies in the product.

What kind of screws, guys? Phillips or Pozi? Stubborn screws, or fairly loose? Are we talking about minor scuffs/signs of use, or actual damage which may mean the drivers are likely to strip completely (on Beat's knife). JC, have you been particularly careful with it being a new tool, or have you used it as hard as you would any other tool?
Hope you don't mind me doing this guys, just trying to simplify the feedback in my own mind

For my test it was only 2 flat screws (1 small and 1 large) for the 2 flat screwdrivers (of the can-opener and of the cap-lifter).
I can't say I tested it particularly carefully but <u>each screws were adapted to each screwdriver</u> :- For the small one I tried to screw and unscrew an electric plug
- For the large one it was a screw of a Bookcase IKEA.
I can't say this test was particularly hard or soft, IMO it was adapted to my idea of these kind of knives more "urban style" than Wenger or Victorinox...
Stubborn screws, or fairly loose ? Neither one, nor the other, only normal to unscrew and after I tightened these screws firmly but without excessive force.
I choose screws adapted to the screwdriver because if you don't do that you are pretty sure to deteriorate any screwdriver on any SAK.But IMO this is not a problem of screwdriver or other tool : the real problem is that some people don't accept a new Swiss knives brand. Everybody can say I like or I don't like this tool because...Etc...
But when you see this topic : /topic/63224 with a pol "Are SWIZA knives SAKs? Yes/No/Sacrilege! they should not even be in the Swiss Army Knights forum", it's a lack of respect for Swiza...
I had the same feeling of unhappiness when some were delighted by the end of the Wenger knives in 2013…
On lot of other forums in Europe you can read "Welcome to Swiza" or "we are lucky to have a new Swiss brand" or other welcome messages...
But not on multitool.org...Personally I prefer to remain positive and optimistic: A new brand of SAK is a cultural wealth, I am happy of this birth and I'm not alone to be happy.
Like all new industry, Swiza is not perfect, but I am sure that it will improve in the future. Let us leave at least a chance to Swiza! We should not throw the baby with the water of his bath !The way I see it everyone should be allowed to have their own opinion about the Swiza knives. Good or bad and they should be alowed to voice it without it turning into a big argument and blaming MTO for not liking it.
I welcomed the Swiza knives when I first heard about them, and I even ordered a D02 wich I gave been EDCing since it arrived. You can read about my first impressions of it here: /topic/63179
I started the poll thread out of curiosity as I wanted to see where the members of this community feel it belongs.
I do not understand why you feel its an attack on Swiza? Its a legitimate question. -
One could claim that every French cheese is a camembert but that isn't true.
There are many things to be said about the SWIZA knives. I haven't handled one yet. I probably won't get one if it is going to cost me more than €20, despite initially welcoming the news. In the following lines I'll try to explain the reasons for this change of mind I've had. Before I begin, I'd like to state I'd be happy to handle a SWIZA eventually and be proven wrong by the quality of its construction.
SAK Guy and Etherealicer have already covered most of my arguments. These two posts sum things up nicely:
@Etherealicer said:
... despite all their claims on how awesome they are, they heavily rely on the reputation built by Victorinox (and Wenger).@SAK Guy said:
If they had billed themselves as a "Swiss knife for a New Generation" or as "the Modern Choice for 21st Century" etc., I would be more accepting. But to use "legend reborn", "revolutionary redesign" and "reinvents the Swiss Knife", Swiza compares and contrasts themselves to the 134 year standard and that irks me. Because, to echo your statement, I have owned 1000's of Swiss Army Knives over 40 years of collecting and know these statements are pure marketing fluff that so far haven't been lived up to. Diversity and competition are great but not at the expense of 134 years of history and experience, that was earned.Why not stand on their own merits/innovation and not have to portray Vic/Wenger as outdated, old fashion and subpar to make a big splash. As I said before, when Swiza has been down the Amazon, to the top of Everest and into space, then they can tell how they are as good as that old outdated brand next door.
In some other posts of theirs, SAK Guy provided a great piece of deconstruction of SWIZA's marketing approach and pragmatic Etherealicer highlighted the importance of construction quality and good design and I can only concur and

Now, why did I have a change of mind? First, because I was already annoyed by the pompous wording SWIZA's marketing uses. Also, because I had my concerns about the handle's shape and the ergonomics in regard to the blade. I still do, I'd much prefer it if they used a clip point blade with this sort of handle shape (incidentally, a clip point blade would eliminate the need for a big hole in the middle of the blade). Then came Etherealicer's first report on the awl found on SWIZA knives and that was the turning point for me. It makes me feel I am preliminarily taken for an idiot by the people that designed that thing. You may ask why. It's because of the tiny sewing eyelet; even if we assume that some thread so thin can be strong enough to sew a tent or a sack with it, which I'm not saying is impossible, the awl is bound to make very wide holes by the time the eyelet can be used. (
)Then, of course, there's the can opener design, so innovative they just had to copy VICTORINOX's.

Also, I don't understand the thin flat screwdriver's raison d'être, the same goes for the weak backspring.
Ultimately, I'd like to see the scissors they make. I'm another guy who's only accepted WENGERs as SAKs in the last few years, in fact after joining the forum, and I still only see them as complementary to my VICTORINOX SAKs that have set the standard in pocket knives for me ever since I can remember. I only say this to emphasize how, in my opinion, VICTORINOX scissors rock while WENGER's only have their uses sometimes, for my needs at least. Good scissors are a mighty useful tool on a pocket knife. SWIZA haven't still produced any scissors at all and yet they claim themselves to be "a legend reborn". I'm not buying that.
I don't think there's an actual need for more knife maker companies yet I am not contrary to SWIZA's venture. I don't have to like their offerings or their marketing strategy though, especially when I have a feeling vindictive ex-WENGER staff is trying to get back at VICTORINOX. In no way I consider myself a fan boy, I just appreciate a company that respects their customers -I think that's getting rarer every day- and "Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's" is how my brain works.
Sorry for the long post.
PS: I love attention to detail. SWIZA has put their name next to the nail nick/hole on the blade. I wonder how purposeful such a thing really is.
-
My screws where Phillips on an IKEA wardrobe, so no hard challenge.
No review is scientifically, that does not mean they are irrelevant (else we could close the Review forum). The trick is to judge what counts for your own applications, the way you use it.
-
@50ft-trad said:
I take your point, and here is my opinion on that:They are not Swiss ARMY Knives because they never made knives for the Swiss Army. However, that is not a reflection on the quality - that is a seperate topic altogether. They could be the greatest multipurpose pocket knives ever invented, but that doesn't make them SAKs ;) just because they are "only" Swiss knives and not Swiss Army Knives, doesn't make them bad, nor does it mean that people won't try them and like them.
Some people take the SAK definition more literally than others. These are Swiss knives, and should be judged either on their own merit, or in comparison with ALL multipurpose pocket knives. I don't like the style, I don't want a locking blade on a tool like this - that doesn't mean they are bad knives either. They are just not a style of knife that appeals to me.
I look forward to hearing how people get on with them long term, and if they ever make any with non-locking blades and scissors, I might give them a try :)
In that case, all "civilian" knives like Victotinox Spartan or Wenger Commander, not used in the Swiss Army are only Swiss knives, not SAK.
And what about "Swiss Officier Knives", never officially used by officiers in the Swiss Army ?You say "Some people take the SAK definition more literally than others"... Yes it's true ! Especially at the birth of a new brand and a new competitor!
Since the WW2 period, all english speaking persons called "SAK" all folding knives made in Switzerland. SAK became a generic word even used in other languages. But after the birth of Swiza some people want to make a separation between "Swiss Knives" and "Swiss Army Knives"... I'm sorry but IMO this separation looks like the Apartheid in South Africa ! -
I started the poll thread out of curiosity as I wanted to see where the members of this community feel it belongs.
I do not understand why you feel its an attack on Swiza? Its a legitimate question.OK, imagine we are in 1900's, no Swiss company had still enough production capacity, so the first 15 000 Swiss Soldiers Knives were delivered by German knives manufacturers of Solingen to the Swiss Army... Elsener-Schwyz began his production and in a news-paper (sorry the web did not exist yet) this poll :
Are Elsener-Schwyz knives SAKs?
YES
NO
Sacrilege! they should not even be in a news paper !You do not find it shocking?
-
Why do I keep thinking of this? ???
-
[---]
I started the poll thread out of curiosity as I wanted to see where the members of this community feel it belongs.
I do not understand why you feel its an attack on Swiza? Its a legitimate question.OK, imagine we are in 1900's, no Swiss company had still enough production capacity, so the first 15 000 Swiss Soldiers Knives were delivered by German knives manufacturers of Solingen to the Swiss Army... Elsener-Schwyz began his production and in a news-paper (sorry the web did not exist yet) this poll :
Are Elsener-Schwyz knives SAKs?
YES
NO
Sacrilege! they should not even be in a news paper !You do not find it shocking?
Im sorry, but I dont really see the proplem, and I dont see the relevance of your example.
- Swiza are not producing knives for the army.
- Its not a question of it not belonging on MTO, its a question wether it should be in the swiss army knights forum or somewhere else. If you read through the thread you can read arguments for and against this, and a suggestion of making a multifunction pocket knife subforum where Swiza, Boker, sheffield, Case.... belong.
I feel that the discussion was a fairly sensible and balanced one and people got to voice their opinions.
I understand that your opinion is that Swiza are SAKs, but according to the poll the majority disagrees with you.
Lastly, Im sorry if you got offended by the poll, that was never my intention.
-
Im sorry, but I dont really see the proplem, and I dont see the relevance of your example.
- Swiza are not producing knives for the army.
- Its not a question of it not belonging on MTO, its a question wether it should be in the swiss army knights forum or somewhere else. If you read through the thread you can read arguments for and against this, and a suggestion of making a multifunction pocket knife subforum where Swiza, Boker, sheffield, Case.... belong.
I feel that the discussion was a fairly sensible and balanced one and people got to voice their opinions.
I understand that your opinion is that Swiza are SAKs, but according to the poll the majority disagrees with you.
Lastly, Im sorry if you got offended by the poll, that was never my intention.
Who wants to kill his dog accuses it of rabies...
SAK or only SK this question arises for the first time about knives made in Switzerland. I can't believe it is accidentally...
A majority agree an insulting poll, that's OK... But don't forget there is only a few years apartheid existed in South Africa and black people could not sit down in buses in America. There was, at this time, also a majority which approved and justified that with polls…
The problem is not my opinion but your judgement and your sentence :
You think that the publicity of Swiza is too noisy, I can understand, you do not like some tools, or the line or the blade I can understand too.
But I do not understand that you seek to separate SAK from SK during creation of a new brand of knives in Switzerland.
SAK is a generic term that all the world understands, this term was used during very a long time and nobody disputed it.
Today, to make a distinction of term only for Swiza does not seem to me very honest.
If you do not wish to create a subforum for Swiza among the other SAK, you are free, but in this case Multitool.org will be practically the only one to not do it. -
[

-
[---]
Im sorry, but I dont really see the proplem, and I dont see the relevance of your example.
- Swiza are not producing knives for the army.
- Its not a question of it not belonging on MTO, its a question wether it should be in the swiss army knights forum or somewhere else. If you read through the thread you can read arguments for and against this, and a suggestion of making a multifunction pocket knife subforum where Swiza, Boker, sheffield, Case.... belong.
I feel that the discussion was a fairly sensible and balanced one and people got to voice their opinions.
I understand that your opinion is that Swiza are SAKs, but according to the poll the majority disagrees with you.
Lastly, Im sorry if you got offended by the poll, that was never my intention.
Who wants to kill his dog accuses it of rabies...
SAK or only SK this question arises for the first time about knives made in Switzerland. I can't believe it is accidentally...
A majority agree an insulting poll, that's OK... But don't forget there is only a few years apartheid existed in South Africa and black people could not sit down in buses in America. There was at this time also a majority which approved and justified that with polls…
So, you are comparing a fairly innocent poll about a multitool to apartheid and racism to prove your point.
I think you are taking this too far.
I suggest we let this topic cool down and focus on something positive in stead.

-
@Grathr said:
So, you are comparing a fairly innocent poll about a multitool to apartheid and racism to prove your point.I think you are taking this too far.
I suggest we let this topic cool down and focus on something positive in stead.

I am sorry, but I cannot believe that this poll is so innocent...
The history showed for a long time that the segregation started like that.
The new segregation SAK/SK appears for the first time at the birth of a new brand… Strange ! -
Jean Claude, you're free to believe whatever you wish, but it seems you are the only one who feels that way. Comparing a poll on an internet forum with apartheid and racism is far fetched at best.

And it seems you're getting getting way to personal into this and this might turn into a political discussion which are not allowed on this forum. Keep that in mind.

-
jcfiguet, this has been an interesting thread with good will all round.
Pesonally I have no feelings either way about the swiza and you are entitled to love it as others are to not love it.
I find it offensive though, that you are comparing peoples perfectly valid opinions (put across with consideration, care and knowledge) with apartheid and have to agree with Grathr that this has gone too far..
-
For the record: jcfiguet, I see you added 6 paragraphs of text to your post after I answered it.
Other than that, Ill let this topic go now.
-
You say "Some people take the SAK definition more literally than others"... Yes it's true ! Especially at the birth of a new brand and a new competitor!
Since the WW2 period, all english speaking persons called "SAK" all folding knives made in Switzerland. SAK became a generic word even used in other languages. But after the birth of Swiza some people want to make a separation between "Swiss Knives" and "Swiss Army Knives"... I'm sorry but IMO this separation looks like the Apartheid in South Africa !Hé ho, holà! Jean-Claude, vous n'allez quand même pas me traiter de raciste à cause de ma critique d'un fabricant des couteaux de poche pretentieux, surtout non quand vous venez d'ignorer de manière majestueuse l'intégralité du message de ce minable de grec et les arguments présentés là dedans. C'en est trop.
Par ailleurs, j'insiste:
@firiki said:
Then, of course, there's the can opener design, so innovative they just had to copy VICTORINOX's.

-
The problem is not my opinion but your judgement and your sentence :
You think that the publicity of Swiza is too noisy, I can understand, you do not like some tools, or the line or the blade I can understand too.
But I do not understand that you seek to separate SAK from SK during creation of a new brand of knives in Switzerland.
SAK is a generic term that all the world understands, this term was used during very a long time and nobody disputed it.
Today, to make a distinction of term only for Swiza does not seem to me very honest.
If you do not wish to create a subforum for Swiza among the other SAK, you are free, but in this case Multitool.org will be practically the only one to not do it.SWIZA make the distinction themselves

As for being the only ones not to have a SWIZA subforum (!); in some places clitoridectomy is practiced. Should this be the case everywhere in the world? I don't think so.
Be honest, Jean-Claude, are you a SWIZA shareholder?
-
This kind of posting stops now thanks. Turn around and walk away. Come back when you can play nice.

-
Thank you jcfiguet but that was not a suggestion.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login