Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
You make a good arguement that this is a very capable multipurpose knife. I have no contention with that. It doesn't make it a SAK in my mind, and more than any other very capable multipurpose knives. In my mind SAK's are issued knives, but I am willing to "relax" the term to cover Victorinox and Wenger knives that were not issued, purely as that is a generic term that has spread that far in common usage.
Maybe one day Swiza will earn an order from the Swiss military, and then be able to share that accolade too
I hope it serves you well, and gives you a lot of enjoyment from using it.

You know, I don't want to speak anymore on this forum. I prefere European forums more open-minded.
Multitool.org is the only knives forum, which I know, where we can read that Swiza is not SAK.
Keep your certainties... As Stalin had his !
I am sorry if I said something that offended. I thought I was saying positive things

Maybe if I study your posts and how you deal with accepting other peoples thoughts, I will learn how to be more openminded .....
I'm not offended and I don't want apology. It's not your fault.
I was blocked by Zoidberg this morning because I'm not agree with some members, but I never say insults to anybody or other things like that.
On this forum when somebody not agree a "big mouth" he's blocked or banned... I'm a moderator and administrator on other forums, but I never use this kind of censure !
I try to explain and to understand some contradictory or false assertions about Swisa, but I see that it goes against the "unique thought" of this forum.
First, I'm collector, so I'm on a knives forum for my pleasure and to share my passion, not to be on a rugby field or on a boxing ring.
So I prefere go away to share that I think on forums more opened with people without bias. -
-
I assume calling someone Stalinist or an oppressor of black people is not considered an insult in some areas..

-
Let's return to a more constructive discussion.
Being a SAK is like a title of honor, an Olympic Gold medal. Not every athlete automatically gets that Olympic Gold medal, he needs to earn it or else the title is without value.
To me Swiza is like a new athlete, still trying to qualify for the Olympics after all its very new and we have very few reviews on it, it is also still in a very basic form (no saw, no scissors etc.). So, first it has to proof it is good enough for the Olympics and then it takes years of hard work to win that gold.Anyway, that is how I feel.
-
Oh ffs another thread going down the rabbit hole!
-
@Etherealicer said:
Let's return to a more constructive discussion.Being a SAK is like a title of honor, an Olympic Gold medal. Not every athlete automatically gets that Olympic Gold medal, he needs to earn it or else the title is without value.
To me Swiza is like a new athlete, still trying to qualify for the Olympics after all its very new and we have very few reviews on it, it is also still in a very basic form (no saw, no scissors etc.). So, first it has to proof it is good enough for the Olympics and then it takes years of hard work to win that gold.Anyway, that is how I feel.
Good analogy

-
Personally I've found this is a very friendly, easy-going forum that is generally quite open to differing opinions. The main areas of friction that I've noticed is when discussion veers off into politics and religion, where strongly held beliefs can cause trouble (so I'm quite happy those topics are off-limits).
Of course sometimes some people can confuse their personal opinions with "facts" and can't cope with someone else having differing views

To get back on-topic, I don't have any strong opinion either way. I believe it comes down to who you recognize as "the authority" on SAKs.
If you go by common usage I'm sure the overwhelming majority of the general public would happily describe the Swiza's as a "SAK", because to them it looks much like the other "SAKs" they see. They would probably happily include all the similar looking knives that are made elsewhere (China, Japan etc).
On the other hand some purists might insist that unless a particular model was actually officially issued to the Swiss army then it isn't really a SAK. So all the other models produced by Vic and Wenger are not SAKs.
And then there is the considerable middle ground between these two extremes. I just don't see any need to get all emotional about the issue, it is difficult (some would say impossible) to change people's opinions when strong emotions and beliefs get involved. So maybe just agree to disagree is the safest course ?

-
@Etherealicer said:
Let's return to a more constructive discussion.Being a SAK is like a title of honor, an Olympic Gold medal. Not every athlete automatically gets that Olympic Gold medal, he needs to earn it or else the title is without value.
To me Swiza is like a new athlete, still trying to qualify for the Olympics after all its very new and we have very few reviews on it, it is also still in a very basic form (no saw, no scissors etc.). So, first it has to proof it is good enough for the Olympics and then it takes years of hard work to win that gold.Anyway, that is how I feel.
Being a SAK is being... Victorinox ? What a big choice !!!
Oh sorry I think it's also an insult ?
-
The REAL BIG dilemma will come if the Swiss Army places an order for some knives that are made outside of Switzerland! All bets will be off then :ahhh :ahhh

-
Let's return to a more constructive discussion.
Being a SAK is like a title of honor, an Olympic Gold medal. Not every athlete automatically gets that Olympic Gold medal, he needs to earn it or else the title is without value.
To me Swiza is like a new athlete, still trying to qualify for the Olympics after all its very new and we have very few reviews on it, it is also still in a very basic form (no saw, no scissors etc.). So, first it has to proof it is good enough for the Olympics and then it takes years of hard work to win that gold.Anyway, that is how I feel.
Being a SAK is being... Victorinox ? What a big choice !!!
Oh sorry I think it's also an insult ?
Yes, mostly Victorinox. They put a lot of work into that reputation. Swiss Army Knifes are known and liked in the whole world. Also Wenger.
Böker makes great pocket multi function knives with the City Tool line, but I would not consider them SAK. Böker is probably OK with that, they probably want to stay on their own feet, build something on their own.
-
@50ft-trad said:
The REAL BIG dilemma will come if the Swiss Army places an order for some knives that are made outside of Switzerland! All bets will be off then :ahhh :ahhh
As the Swiss law has changed, now Swiss Army could order knives outside of Switzerland.
Even it's not probable, it's could be possible...In this case the argument " the title of SAK is reserved for the manufacturer who makes knives for the army " will not be valid any more...
-
@50ft-trad said:
The REAL BIG dilemma will come if the Swiss Army places an order for some knives that are made outside of Switzerland! All bets will be off then :ahhh :ahhh

As the Swiss law has changed, now Swiss Army could order knives outside of Switzerland.
Even it's not probable, it's could be possible...In this case the argument " the title of SAK is reserved for the manufacturer who makes knives for the army " will not be valid any more...
The ties of Switzerland with European Union require that all large purchase are open to international competition. That is one of the reasons the Swiss Army now has a large, locking OHO knife, as this is considered a weapon and therefore not subjected to the rule above (weapon deals can always be restricted to national companies).
But essentially yes, the Swiss Army has the right to purchase knifes from any company in the world.
-
When making a translation, translators can be faced with the dilemma of having to choose between using the correct term/syntaxis instead of what is being (wrongly) used by the native speakers of the language in which they are translating. Writting down what is lexically, grammatically or syntactically correct could be seen as wrong!
I gather that in the USA the name Leatherman has come to mean a pliers-based multitool in general. Does this mean every pliers-based multitool is a Leatherman? No. So why should Swiza knives be considered SAKs?
In any case, on their website http://www.swiza.com/en/Brand/News/Press-Center/A-legend-reborn-SWIZA-reinvents-the-Swiss-Knife.html they speak of "Swiss knife" not Swiss army knife
Switzerland has a new knife! The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades.
I guess people at Swiza don't see their product as a SAK after all. Maybe they forgot to put the word "army" in their bulletin?

Edit: Corrected some errors.
-
Victorinox owns the license on "Swiss Army" branded goods in general, not just "Swiss Army Knife". (In fact, if I remember correctly, this is quite controversial. Basically a transfer of public brand name to a private company.) Anyways, I think if Swiza said "Swiss Army", they'd be in legal trouble in the USA and EU.
Edit: From Wikipedia
In August 2002, Victorinox acquired the American company Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI), to unify and gain control of the Victorinox and Swiss Army watch brands. Previously Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI) had sold the Swiss Army branded watch in North America and under license had sold the Victorinox branded watch outside North America. But after Victorinox AG acquired Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI), a combined Victorinox Swiss Army brand was created and has been marketed worldwide.
...
Victorinox has licensed the Swiss Army brand and shield logo to companies producing watches, writing tools, luggage and clothing.The Swiss Defense Ministry has given Victorinox permission to brand products as "Swiss Army". Swiza has no such concession.
-
Let's return to a more constructive discussion.
Being a SAK is like a title of honor, an Olympic Gold medal. Not every athlete automatically gets that Olympic Gold medal, he needs to earn it or else the title is without value.
To me Swiza is like a new athlete, still trying to qualify for the Olympics after all its very new and we have very few reviews on it, it is also still in a very basic form (no saw, no scissors etc.). So, first it has to proof it is good enough for the Olympics and then it takes years of hard work to win that gold.Anyway, that is how I feel.
Being a SAK is being... Victorinox ? What a big choice !!!
Oh sorry I think it's also an insult ?
Yes, mostly Victorinox. They put a lot of work into that reputation. Swiss Army Knifes are known and liked in the whole world. Also Wenger.
Böker makes great pocket multi function knives with the City Tool line, but I would not consider them SAK. Böker is probably OK with that, they probably want to stay on their own feet, build something on their own.
The "title" of SAK is not a like the title of "Champion of the World", with only 1 champion for 1 year, with new competition and generally a new champion every years... So SAK is not a title.
If the word SAK is reserved only for Victorinox, so we don't need to keek this word, all knives made in Switzerland could to become simply Swiss Knives.
And Victorinox ? Victorinox stay the bigest and historical manufacturer of Swiss knives.
Why a special name like SAK or like a title only for 1 manufacturer of knives ? In that case, the value of a special name like SAK is no longer justified.
-
@50ft-trad said:
The REAL BIG dilemma will come if the Swiss Army places an order for some knives that are made outside of Switzerland! All bets will be off then :ahhh :ahhh

As the Swiss law has changed, now Swiss Army could order knives outside of Switzerland.
Even it's not probable, it's could be possible...In this case the argument " the title of SAK is reserved for the manufacturer who makes knives for the army " will not be valid any more...
The ties of Switzerland with European Union require that all large purchase are open to international competition. That is one of the reasons the Swiss Army now has a large, locking OHO knife, as this is considered a weapon and therefore not subjected to the rule above (weapon deals can always be restricted to national companies).
But essentially yes, the Swiss Army has the right to purchase knifes from any company in the world.
Well, in that case what about the argument " the title of SAK is reserved for the manufacturer who makes knives for the army " ? Wrong or true ?
-
@firiki said:
When making a translation, translators can be faced with the dilemma of having to choose between using the correct term/syntaxis instead of what is being (wrongly) used by the native speakers of the language in which they are translating. Writting down what is lexically, grammatically or syntactically correct could be seen as wrong!I gather that in the USA the name Leatherman has come to mean a pliers-based multitool in general. Does this mean every pliers-based multitool is a Leatherman? No. So why should Swiza knives be considered SAKs?
In any case, on their website http://www.swiza.com/en/Brand/News/Press-Center/A-legend-reborn-SWIZA-reinvents-the-Swiss-Knife.html they speak of "Swiss knife" not Swiss army knife
Switzerland has a new knife! The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades.
I guess people at Swiza don't see their product as a SAK after all. Maybe they forgot to put the word "army" in their bulletin?

Edit: Corrected some errors.
You are true about translators !
Swiza in in a french speaking canton and in french no body say "Couteau de l'armée Suisse" but only "Couteau Suisse", for all knives made in Switzerland.
-
Jean Claude, please receive these comments with the respect I send them with

-
you say we are closed minded, but you seem to struggle that people think differently, and cannot accept their views as their (harmless) opinions.
-
I think the big issue here with people, is not the fact that you classify SAKs differently to most of us, but that you wish to "correct" us. There is no official classification, just popular belief and hearsay. If you had just said "I consider the Swiza knives as SAKs, but I understand if others don't", none of this upset would have happened.
-
The thread got locked, and this thread deteriorated, when you started accusing people of being like historical figures you consider to be atrocious monsters, because of their views on A POCKET KNIFE!!!
It is important that you realise that others have had opinions and have been prepared to accept yours UNTIL you got offensive with them (or at least appeared to). Can we accept that we have different opinions and move on? If not, then it is not "us" that are being closed minded.

Again, very importantly, I mean no offense by these comments, I just wish for us to stop looking at our differences and instead to focus on what matters.....
.... embracing the diversity of our needs and carries, blaming Kirky, and establishing that the LM Signal is poo! We are still awaiting third-party verification on the last item, but a Kiwi will hopefully be verifying that for us very soon. OK, he's not technically third party, but he is foreign and very strange, which is the best we could manage under the circumstances
-
-
@NetsNJ said:
Victorinox owns the license on "Swiss Army" branded goods in general, not just "Swiss Army Knife". (In fact, if I remember correctly, this is quite controversial. Basically a transfer of public brand name to a private company.) Anyways, I think if Swiza said "Swiss Army", they'd be in legal trouble in the USA and EU.Edit: From Wikipedia
In August 2002, Victorinox acquired the American company Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI), to unify and gain control of the Victorinox and Swiss Army watch brands. Previously Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI) had sold the Swiss Army branded watch in North America and under license had sold the Victorinox branded watch outside North America. But after Victorinox AG acquired Swiss Army Brands, Inc (SABI), a combined Victorinox Swiss Army brand was created and has been marketed worldwide.
...
Victorinox has licensed the Swiss Army brand and shield logo to companies producing watches, writing tools, luggage and clothing.The Swiss Defense Ministry has given Victorinox permission to brand products as "Swiss Army". Swiza has no such concession.
You're right, "Swiss Army" was quite controversial for Victorinox, but now I think disputes are gone. "Swiss Army" was never used by Wenger, I think because it's a commercial brand with something like a patent <u>but without real link with the army of Switzerland</u>...
If I remember it was the subject of a dispute with other cutlers and supplier of the Swiss Army. It's an old and vague story...I'm not sure that now the Swiss Defense Ministry has given Victorinox permission to brand products as "Swiss Army". I would like to see the official documents ! But I'm sure Swiza has no concession for "Swiss Army" !
The same confusion exists with "Officier Suisse" stamped on civilian knives of Victorinox. Everybody knows this knives were never made for Swiss officiers in the Swiss Army !
Do not forget that, for a long time, Victorinox profited from the benevolence of the army and the government which probably wanted to protect a famous Swiss brand. It explains probably the use of terms as "Swiss Army" or "Officier Suisse" without real rights...
-
Who cares...??

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login