Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE NOTIFICATIONS 0 MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Are SWIZA knives SAKs?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
126 Posts 1 Posters 14.0k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
  4. Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • NetsNJ Offline
    NetsNJ
    Posts: 676
    NetsNJ Offline
    NetsNJ
    wrote on last edited by NetsNJ
    #81 Quote Reply

      @jcfiguet said:
      You're right, "Swiss Army" was quite controversial for Victorinox, but now I think disputes are gone. "Swiss Army" was never used by Wenger, I think because it's a commercial brand with something like a patent <u>but without real link with the army of Switzerland</u>...
      If I remember it was the subject of a dispute with other cutlers and supplier of the Swiss Army. It's an old and vague story...

      I'm not sure that now the Swiss Defense Ministry has given Victorinox permission to brand products as "Swiss Army". I would like to see the official documents ! But I'm sure Swiza has no concession for "Swiss Army" !

      The same confusion exists with "Officier Suisse" stamped on civilian knives of Victorinox. Everybody knows this knives were never made for Swiss officiers in the Swiss Army !

      Do not forget that, for a long time, Victorinox profited from the benevolence of the army and the government which probably wanted to protect a famous Swiss brand. It explains probably the use of terms as "Swiss Army" or "Officier Suisse" without real rights...

      Wenger absolutely used the Swiss Army brand. Remember, Wenger was the "Genuine Swiss Army Knife", and Victorinox was the "Original Swiss Army Knife". This was the agreement the firms came to. No other knife could be marketed as a Swiss Army Knife. Also, of course Wenger has a link to the Swiss Army. They and Victorinox both supplied the Swiss Army with regulation Swiss Army knives.

      As for Victorinox owning Swiss Army,

      Le News[/url]"]Technically, the Swiza knife is not a Swiss Army knife. The term “Swiss Army” is a registered trademark owned by Victorinox AG and its subsidiary, Wenger SA.

      Swiss Army is a registered trademark of Victorinox:

      Victorinox[/url]"]Victorinox Intellectual Property

      Victorinox or its licensors are the exclusive owners of all designs, products, information and all copyrights, trademarks and other intellectual property or proprietary rights contained on or used in connection with the Website. Except as set forth herein or authorized by Victorinox, you agree not to copy, distribute, modify or make derivative works of any materials without the prior written consent of the owner of such materials or a legal right to do so. The Victorinox Cross & Shield, Victorinox® and Swiss Army® are separate trademarks owned and registered by Victorinox AG, Ibach, Switzerland and its related companies. All rights not granted under these Terms of Use are reserved by Victorinox.

      Encyclopedia.com[/url]"]
      A broader diversification began in earnest after Forschner registered the Swiss Army name as a trademark in the 1980s....The granting of the trademark provoked some public questioning since the Swiss Military Department did not require royalty payments in return. It did stipulate, however, that such products be made in Switzerland and be of "exceptional quality." In 1996, Forschner, then known as Swiss Army Brands, did agree to pay royalties, however.

      So in a precise sense, Swiza knives just aren't Swiss Army knives. Now you can disagree that the legal/trademark definition of Swiss Army Knife (according to European and US Law) is bad one, but it is still a reasonable definition.

      --

      I think the Swiza's look nice, though some early reviews looked troubling. I want to get one when the prices drop in the second hand market. But I think some of the opposition comes from a degree of chutzpah in their advertising.

      Switzerland has a new knife! The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades. The result is a unique creation manufactured and assembled in the Jura, restoring the status of the local cutlery industry. It is unveiled today as a world exclusive in Lausanne and Zurich by SWIZA, a brand with a history spanning over 110 years and an established reputation in watchmaking circles.

      Restoring the status of the local cutlery industry? I thought the Victorinox Delemont collection is still made in Jura? What, are those knives chopped liver? "Reinventing" the legendary Swiss Knife? That is a *tall *claim.

      I wish Swiza the best of luck and look forward to their future offerings. But I just think the digs at Victorinox are kind of classless.

      1 Reply Last reply
      • jcfiguet Offline
        jcfiguet
        Posts: 388
        jcfiguet Offline
        jcfiguet
        wrote on last edited by
        #82 Quote Reply

          @NetsNJ said:

          @jcfiguet said:

          You're right, "Swiss Army" was quite controversial for Victorinox, but now I think disputes are gone. "Swiss Army" was never used by Wenger, I think because it's a commercial brand with something like a patent <u>but without real link with the army of Switzerland</u>...
          If I remember it was the subject of a dispute with other cutlers and supplier of the Swiss Army. It's an old and vague story...

          I'm not sure that now the Swiss Defense Ministry has given Victorinox permission to brand products as "Swiss Army". I would like to see the official documents ! But I'm sure Swiza has no concession for "Swiss Army" !

          The same confusion exists with "Officier Suisse" stamped on civilian knives of Victorinox. Everybody knows this knives were never made for Swiss officiers in the Swiss Army !

          Do not forget that, for a long time, Victorinox profited from the benevolence of the army and the government which probably wanted to protect a famous Swiss brand. It explains probably the use of terms as "Swiss Army" or "Officier Suisse" without real rights...

          Wenger absolutely used the Swiss Army brand. Remember, Wenger was the "Genuine Swiss Army Knife", and Victorinox was the "Original Swiss Army Knife". This was the agreement the firms came to. No other knife could be marketed as a Swiss Army Knife. Also, of course Wenger has a link to the Swiss Army. They and Victorinox both supplied the Swiss Army with regulation Swiss Army knives.

          As for Victorinox owning Swiss Army,

          No, not exactly, Wenger was the "Genuine Swiss Army Knife", that's OK but I never see a Wenger knife stamped "Armée Suisse" nor "Officier Suisse" on the blade like Victorinox stamped his knives.

          @NetsNJ said:

          Le News[/url]"]Technically, the Swiza knife is not a Swiss Army knife. The term “Swiss Army” is a registered trademark owned by Victorinox AG and its subsidiary, Wenger SA.

          Swiss Army is a registered trademark of Victorinox:

          Victorinox[/url]"]Victorinox Intellectual Property

          Victorinox or its licensors are the exclusive owners of all designs, products, information and all copyrights, trademarks and other intellectual property or proprietary rights contained on or used in connection with the Website. Except as set forth herein or authorized by Victorinox, you agree not to copy, distribute, modify or make derivative works of any materials without the prior written consent of the owner of such materials or a legal right to do so. The Victorinox Cross & Shield, Victorinox® and Swiss Army® are separate trademarks owned and registered by Victorinox AG, Ibach, Switzerland and its related companies. All rights not granted under these Terms of Use are reserved by Victorinox.

          Encyclopedia.com[/url]"]
          A broader diversification began in earnest after Forschner registered the Swiss Army name as a trademark in the 1980s....The granting of the trademark provoked some public questioning since the Swiss Military Department did not require royalty payments in return. It did stipulate, however, that such products be made in Switzerland and be of "exceptional quality." In 1996, Forschner, then known as Swiss Army Brands, did agree to pay royalties, however.

          So in a precise sense, Swiza knives just aren't Swiss Army knives. Now you can disagree that the legal/trademark definition of Swiss Army Knife (according to European and US Law) is bad one, but it is still a reasonable definition.

          --

          I can't agree or disagree US and European law, a trademark is a trademark, and this is not the problem : "Swiss Army knives" is the generic term since 1944 given by American GIs to all folding knives made in Switzerland. This name of "Swiss Army knives" is not an exact definition but it's the name used, as generic term, by all english speaking people in the world, without references to trademarks or law.
          So :

          • Based on the law and trademark rules, "Swiss Army" is reserved to Victorinox, even if a trademark does not indicate if Victorinox is a supplier or not of the Swiss Army. I have no problem with that.
          • Based on the generic term "Swiss Army Knives" (not only "Swiss Army"), used by all english speaking people in the world since 1944, all folding knives made in Switzerland, even Swiza, are supposed to be "Swiss Army Knives"

          On this forum generally, when you say "Swiss Army Knives" you speak about brands like Victorinox, Wenger or one of the 30 former brands which made folding knives in Switzerland. I never understood it in an other way and I'm sure lot of members understood the same thing.
          But since a few days, some members want change this definition. Why not ! I always have no problem with that.
          OMI, the problems are on 2 points :
          1°) The new definition is proposed at the birth of Swiza (The law of fate? Not sure !)
          2°) Victorinox will stay a SAK and Swiza will become a SK
          At this step, this way is not mine, I think that these difference are not fair and this is not very honest (intellectually).

          @NetsNJ said:
          I think the Swiza's look nice, though some early reviews looked troubling. I want to get one when the prices drop in the second hand market. But I think some of the opposition comes from a degree of chutzpah in their advertising.

          Switzerland has a new knife! The legendary Swiss Knife has been given a redesign for the first time in decades. The result is a unique creation manufactured and assembled in the Jura, restoring the status of the local cutlery industry. It is unveiled today as a world exclusive in Lausanne and Zurich by SWIZA, a brand with a history spanning over 110 years and an established reputation in watchmaking circles.

          Restoring the status of the local cutlery industry? I thought the Victorinox Delemont collection is still made in Jura? What, are those knives chopped liver? "Reinventing" the legendary Swiss Knife? That is a *tall *claim.

          I wish Swiza the best of luck and look forward to their future offerings. But I just think the digs at Victorinox are kind of classless.

          "Victorinox Delemont collection is still made in Jura ?" No, not all knives! When I visit Victorinox Factory in 2014, I saw some Victorinox Delemont made in the factory of Ibach.

          "I think the Swiza's look nice, though some early reviews looked troubling." The best way : buy a Swiza and try it yourself ! LOL

          1 Reply Last reply
          • NetsNJ Offline
            NetsNJ
            Posts: 676
            NetsNJ Offline
            NetsNJ
            wrote on last edited by NetsNJ
            #83 Quote Reply

              "Swiss Army knives" is the generic term since 1944 given by American GIs to all folding knives made in Switzerland. This name of "Swiss Army knives" is not an exact definition but it's the name used, as generic term, by all english speaking people in the world, without references to trademarks or law.

              If you ask 99% of Americans if this is a Swiss Army Knife, they will say yes. No one here would consider it a Swiss Army Knife. If we are using the commonly held definition of Swiss Army Knife used by most people, there is no requirement that it be made in Switzerland. To the vast majority of people, any folding knife in the Victorinox "style" is a Swiss Army Knife.

              1 Reply Last reply
              • jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                Posts: 388
                jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                wrote on last edited by
                #84 Quote Reply

                  @NetsNJ said:

                  "Swiss Army knives" is the generic term since 1944 given by American GIs to all folding knives made in Switzerland. This name of "Swiss Army knives" is not an exact definition but it's the name used, as generic term, by all english speaking people in the world, without references to trademarks or law.

                  If you ask 99% of Americans if this is a Swiss Army Knife, they will say yes. No one here would consider it a Swiss Army Knife. If we are using the commonly held definition of Swiss Army Knife used by most people, there is no requirement that it be made in Switzerland. To the vast majority of people, any folding knife in the Victorinox "style" is a Swiss Army Knife.

                  Is it a SAK or a SK ? LOL !!!

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • SAK Guy Offline
                    SAK Guy
                    Posts: 23,929
                    SAK Guy Offline
                    SAK Guy
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #85 Quote Reply

                      @jcfiguet said:

                      @NetsNJ said:

                      "Swiss Army knives" is the generic term since 1944 given by American GIs to all folding knives made in Switzerland. This name of "Swiss Army knives" is not an exact definition but it's the name used, as generic term, by all english speaking people in the world, without references to trademarks or law.

                      If you ask 99% of Americans if this is a Swiss Army Knife, they will say yes. No one here would consider it a Swiss Army Knife. If we are using the commonly held definition of Swiss Army Knife used by most people, there is no requirement that it be made in Switzerland. To the vast majority of people, any folding knife in the Victorinox "style" is a Swiss Army Knife.

                      Is it a SAK or a SK ? LOL !!!

                      That particular one is a SUK. :facepalm:

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • jerseydevil Offline
                        jerseydevil
                        Admin Team
                        Posts: 10,459
                        jerseydevil Offline
                        jerseydevil
                        Admin Team
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #86 Quote Reply

                          :D

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • Etherealicer Offline
                            Etherealicer
                            Admin Team
                            Posts: 12,034
                            Etherealicer Offline
                            Etherealicer
                            Admin Team
                            wrote on last edited by Etherealicer
                            #87 Quote Reply

                              @jcfiguet said:
                              The "title" of SAK is not a like the title of "Champion of the World", with only 1 champion for 1 year, with new competition and generally a new champion every years... So SAK is not a title.

                              If the word SAK is reserved only for Victorinox, so we don't need to keek this word, all knives made in Switzerland could to become simply Swiss Knives.

                              And Victorinox ? Victorinox stay the bigest and historical manufacturer of Swiss knives.

                              Why a special name like SAK or like a title only for 1 manufacturer of knives ? In that case, the value of a special name like SAK is no longer justified.

                              Call it reputation / image / brand slogan or whatever

                              Audi Vorsprung durch Technik
                              Victorinox maker of the original Swiss Army Knife
                              Wenger maker of the genuine Swiss Army Knife

                              Also sometimes we use a brand name to describe a product. For example Band-Aid is a brand name, we still use it for all adhesive bandages. There is no need to justify that, its just how language / labels evolve.

                              In case of SAK, for a long time this meant both Wenger and Victorinox.
                              I think Victorinox worked more on that label, used it for their marketing. Wenger also used it, but the more they used it, the more they got overshadowed by Victorinox. I think they realized that and started to change their marketing (teaming up with Porsche / Mike Horn / Ueli Steck / Alinghi etc.). Going away from red with colorful scales...

                              All in all I think we would not do Swiza a favor by putting them in the same pot as Victorinox. Because SAK is associated with Victorinox, people might miss that Swiza is a brand on their own.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • kirk13 Offline
                                kirk13
                                Admin Team
                                Posts: 15,955
                                kirk13 Offline
                                kirk13
                                Admin Team
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #88 Quote Reply

                                  @alexTOOL said:
                                  Who cares...?? :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm:

                                  Amen brother :salute:

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    Posts: 388
                                    jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #89 Quote Reply

                                      @50ft-trad said:
                                      Your English is much better than my French, although I think you may still be misunderstanding some of the context, even though you understand all the words. Saying that a knife is not SAK does not belittle of mean anything bad to the brand. Swiza have yet to establish themselves and win the hearts of many, but that does not mean they are being prejudiced. Give them time to develop, and give the people time to accept them. :cheers:

                                      Do not be upset that we all think differently. That is why this forum is so good, not why it is bad. To be heard, first you must listen. The fact that we think differently, makes us all wiser. Embrace the differences, do not fight them.

                                      Yes, some threads will get very emotive. That is only because people care, not because people hate. Even when people do hate (or seem to hate) it is because they care about something else. The truth is not always on the surface.

                                      After sleeping some hours I like to read again topics / threads to be sure I didn' miss something important.

                                      You said "I may still be misunderstanding some of the context", it's possible but I don't think so : On this thread (and others) when you see the number of posts from all over the world, just from an error of definition made by GIs in 1944.... I think something is important because some persons feels hurted (not only me).

                                      We can nothing do against an error of the past, it is necessary to assume it and to do everything so that the consequences are tiny for all. It was the case for "SAK" : it was allowed that all brands of knives in Switzerland manufactured "SAKs" without distinction.

                                      Today a new brand of knives : Swiza...
                                      Why change the rules of a common naming and thus introduce an injustice and a distinction ? Everybody knows that the injustice was always the starting point of brawls and even of wars.
                                      During 125 years, there be the “cold war” between Wenger and Victorinox. At the end there were a winner and a defeated, while some shouted “victory!”, others cried...
                                      To be objective and neutral, I do not think that it was a good thing. Especially for collectors of the 2 brands like me.
                                      When somebody does not feel well somewhere, he goes away and it is the beginning of a new fight for revenge... It was the case for some people of the Wenger factory.

                                      In this world there is place for everyone and for all the talents.
                                      Today, everybody knows that there's no difference in intelligence, or else, between an African, an European or an Asian.
                                      Is our role, in a forum, it to create this kind of distinction, SAK and SK ? Especially when it is known that “SAK” was at the beginning an error of language!

                                      No matter what some think of it, I note the every day that the destruction of Wenger (I speak about the brand of knives) was not appreciated by everyone. The father of Mr. Elsener did not want it, I think that he knew that it would be badly perceived and that the risk was important. After all, it had the control of the company and it was sufficient.
                                      But after his death, his son wanted to make this fusion with the single brand Victorinox… And thus he created himself his competitor...
                                      Swiza is not a dangerous competitor for Victorinox, but it exists and manufactures knives, at the end not so bad.
                                      They are the facts and the history of Swiss Army Knives (or Swiss Knives if you prefere this name) of these 2 last years...
                                      And now, what else ? Some members of a forum, even if it's an international forum, want to change a used term all over the world, want to introduce a distinction, It will never change the story, it will never change the facts, and at the end it will never change anything. In the worst case, it will be like “putting oil on the fire”. IMO it's not our role and I will never in collusion with this way of thinking.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                        AimlessWanderer
                                        Posts: 17,518
                                        AimlessWanderer Offline
                                        AimlessWanderer
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #90 Quote Reply

                                          I appreciate your standpoint on that Jean Claude :cheers: It does not change my opinion, and I do not seek to change yours :salute:

                                          We have lots of different viewpoints here on a great many things. What people call slipjoints, were known in Sheffield as spring knives. I do not use this term, because nobody would know what I mean :D I have a strong dislike for backlocking blades, even though many others like them, particularly the Classics like the Buck 110. I am unlikely to change my views, and again do not wish to change theirs. I want to understand other people's perspectives, and be understood myself. I want to think freely and reach my own conclusions, and try to encourage to do likewise, even if we ultimately disagree.

                                          This topic that we have been churning over so intensely is one of many which will never be resolved and agreed upon by all. Another example is "is a SAK a multitool?", some (like me) say yes, but others do not. That's fine. A term I do not like is "SAKalike", as if all other multipurpose knives copied the Swiss models. They were produced in several countries many many years before we saw what many call a SAK. However, I do not try and change everyone's views, or get angry/frustrated whenever the term is used.

                                          In some countries, the word for hand includes the wrist, in others it doesn not. The scientific classification for bananas are herbs I believe, but most people consider it a fruit. Some will take differing views on mushrooms and toadstools. It's really not worth getting that agitated about :)

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • jcfiguet Offline
                                            jcfiguet
                                            Posts: 388
                                            jcfiguet Offline
                                            jcfiguet
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #91 Quote Reply

                                              @Etherealicer said:
                                              Call it reputation / image / brand slogan or whatever

                                              Audi Vorsprung durch Technik
                                              Victorinox maker of the original Swiss Army Knife
                                              Wenger maker of the genuine Swiss Army Knife

                                              Also sometimes we use a brand name to describe a product. For example Band-Aid is a brand name, we still use it for all adhesive bandages. There is no need to justify that, its just how language / labels evolve.

                                              I'm sorry but no ! It's not a reputation, image or a brand slogan, it's only a naming by error which used now everywhere in the world ! And this naming means "knives made in Switzerland with the Swiss quality".

                                              @Etherealicer said:
                                              In case of SAK, for a long time this meant both Wenger and Victorinox.

                                              And what about former Swiss Brands of SAK ?

                                              @Etherealicer said:
                                              I think Victorinox worked more on that label, used it for their marketing. Wenger also used it, but the more they used it, the more they got overshadowed by Victorinox. I think they realized that and started to change their marketing (teaming up with Porsche / Mike Horn / Ueli Steck / Alinghi etc.). Going away from red with colorful scales...

                                              If I say "I am the only expert of Victorinox (or Wenger) in the world", first, is it the truth ? I don't think so LOL ! It's not because a brand use a generic terme for advertizing that it's completly true...
                                              Victorinox also stamped "Officier Suisse" and "Armée Suisse" on former blades. This knives are generally highly collectors and pretty rares, but.... IMO it introduces confusion for lot of persons. I can't say it's a lie, but... It's a truth for advertizing...

                                              @Etherealicer said:
                                              All in all I think we would not do Swiza a favor by putting them in the same pot as Victorinox. Because SAK is associated with Victorinox, people might miss that Swiza is a brand on their own.

                                              This is another thing... People can also think that bad chinese copy of SAK are made by Victorinox...
                                              But that will never mislead any collector, any speSmurfpillst nor any person who knows what is a ... SAK or SK.

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • jcfiguet Offline
                                                jcfiguet
                                                Posts: 388
                                                jcfiguet Offline
                                                jcfiguet
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #92 Quote Reply

                                                  @50ft-trad said:
                                                  I appreciate your standpoint on that Jean Claude :cheers: It does not change my opinion, and I do not seek to change yours :salute:

                                                  We have lots of different viewpoints here on a great many things. What people call slipjoints, were known in Sheffield as spring knives. I do not use this term, because nobody would know what I mean :D I have a strong dislike for backlocking blades, even though many others like them, particularly the Classics like the Buck 110. I am unlikely to change my views, and again do not wish to change theirs. I want to understand other people's perspectives, and be understood myself. I want to think freely and reach my own conclusions, and try to encourage to do likewise, even if we ultimately disagree.

                                                  This topic that we have been churning over so intensely is one of many which will never be resolved and agreed upon by all. Another example is "is a SAK a multitool?", some (like me) say yes, but others do not. That's fine. A term I do not like is "SAKalike", as if all other multipurpose knives copied the Swiss models. They were produced in several countries many many years before we saw what many call a SAK. However, I do not try and change everyone's views, or get angry/frustrated whenever the term is used.

                                                  In some countries, the word for hand includes the wrist, in others it doesn not. The scientific classification for bananas are herbs I believe, but most people consider it a fruit. Some will take differing views on mushrooms and toadstools. It's really not worth getting that agitated about :)

                                                  That you said is true !

                                                  I am particularly sensitive on this subject because in French SAK (Couteau de l'Armée Suisse) is never used. We say "Couteaux Suisse" (SK) for all knives of Switzerland, without distinction.
                                                  In France this kind of distinction is generally very badly perceived in a large majority. So we try to be carefull with some words.
                                                  We only add "Swiss soldier knives" to indicate a model used by soldiers in the Swiss Army. But it's an information, not a distinction, the Swiss soldier knives are not manufactured for the civilians, even if a Soldier knife seems the same, some differences always exist.

                                                  Last week I say to a french-speaking Swiss friend "les handicapés", in France we have no problem with this word, but in Switzerland it's not correct, you must say "les personnes handicapées"... I read that exists the sames problems about this word between english-speaking people, somewhere you must say "handicaped persons" or "handicaped of... something" or other words that I don't remember.

                                                  Somebody spoke about translalors... Generally "Couteau Suisse" is translated as "Swiss Army Knife"... I wanted to know how to translate SAK and SK in French, Spanish, Italian, etc... If a distinction will now exist in English and US English for Victorinox and Swiza... LOL !

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • enki_ck Offline
                                                    enki_ck
                                                    Global Moderators
                                                    Posts: 20,936
                                                    enki_ck Offline
                                                    enki_ck
                                                    Global Moderators
                                                    wrote on last edited by enki_ck
                                                    #93 Quote Reply

                                                      The Swiza company isn't allowed by **LAW **to use the name Swiss Army knife (SAK) but we should cause you say so? Really? Where's the logic in that?

                                                      You seem to disregard this obvious fact, and yes, it's a fact, not an assumption or personal belief, just to prove your point. :salute:

                                                      Yes, the name was coined by the US soldiers, but it is now protected by law by both Victorinox(original Swiss Army Knife) and Wenger(genuine Swiss Army Knife). It's not reputation, it's their **TRADEMARK **slogan. Just pick up and look at any box of Victorinox you have and you'll see it there.

                                                      So yes, there were knives issued to the Swiss military before the Victorinox and Wenger became the only contractors, and yes, other companies will be able to sell their knives to the Swiss military under the new law. BUT they won't be able to call themselves Swiss army knives, that term is reserved for Victorinox and Wenger. Not by members of MTO, by international law. :salute:

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • Corwyn Offline
                                                        Corwyn
                                                        Posts: 3,534
                                                        Corwyn Offline
                                                        Corwyn
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #94 Quote Reply

                                                          I am getting tired of seeing this topic over and over (while I casually refresh the site to see how close I am to winning Harley's Surge ::) ). We'll end up locking threads one by one. :-\

                                                          I am tired of people riding on the Swiss Army name and logo coat tails... am I'm not speaking about the Chinese knock-offs only, but also: Royalty Line, Swiss Tech, Swiss Bianco, Aitor, Pradel, Century, Hanova, Ellehammer and now this "thing".

                                                          What is a sak is debatable, is a Vic GAK a SAK, a Vic Classic, a Vic Hunter Pro, a Vic Spirit, a Vic Baker's knife, an Adler GAK, an Amefa DAK, a Wenger BusinessTool? It really is up to the members of a community to choose and this one (probably the most versed in this) decided 4 to 1 about this issue.

                                                          I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic, it looks like a step back in every direction... if I want a more modern version of the SAK idea, I'd get a Boker/SRM or an Emerson.

                                                          I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection and keep for next year after they go bankrupt as well, but my mild disinterest has turned to sheer distaste for this subpar toy due to these discussions...

                                                          The true test of SUK-iness will come soon. If it is considered a true SAK by the Swiss Government and by Vic, they will buy them out again, after they go under again....

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Steinar Offline
                                                            Steinar
                                                            Posts: 3,435
                                                            Steinar Offline
                                                            Steinar
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #95 Quote Reply

                                                              @jcfiguet said:

                                                              @Etherealicer said:

                                                              Call it reputation / image / brand slogan or whatever

                                                              Audi Vorsprung durch Technik
                                                              Victorinox maker of the original Swiss Army Knife
                                                              Wenger maker of the genuine Swiss Army Knife

                                                              Also sometimes we use a brand name to describe a product. For example Band-Aid is a brand name, we still use it for all adhesive bandages. There is no need to justify that, its just how language / labels evolve.

                                                              I'm sorry but no ! It's not a reputation, image or a brand slogan, it's only a naming by error which used now everywhere in the world ! And this naming means "knives made in Switzerland with the Swiss quality".

                                                              As mentioned earlier in the thread, the colloquial definition today isn't “a really great knife that is made in Switzerland”, it's “a pocket knife with some extra tools, and it doesn't hurt if it's red”. NetsNJ's post was a perfect illustration of exactly that. Now, MT.o has its own jargon, and then the colloquial definition becomes useless, as it includes anything from Case scout knives to multi-layer knives made in Sheffield before the founder of Victorinox even was a glint in his father's eye. So, think it's a perfectly valid question to ask the community whether they find it natural to call that particular new line of multi-layer folders from Switzerland SAKs.

                                                              As for the Swiss Army trademark... Remember, the knife makers were allowed to use the Swiss Army trademark because they already had established themselves as quality brands with international markets and it was good for Switzerland. It wasn't some magnanimous gesture or strange deal in corridors with hushed voices. They (Victorinox and Wenger) started in an era were trademark and copyright law was rather more lax than today, and when it became an issue, the Swiss authorities went for the pragmatic approach.

                                                              I would never term a Swiza a SAK when talking to knife people, but I would do so when talking to people who didn't care or know much about knives. When talking to knife people, the term simply becomes too ambiguous.

                                                              The colloquial definition obviously includes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                                                              The legal definition obviously excludes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                                                              So then we get the MT.o definition, and then it boils down whether it's useful to include Swiza there. So, whether including it (“We need a specific term for knife based multi-tools made in Switzerland!”) or excluding it (“For collectors, the historical term is useful, and for the enthusiast, a term more focused on the country of origin than class of knife isn't that useful, on cause the offerings from Böker, Case, Nontron, Hartkopf, etc ad nauseam.”), it isn't about discrimination or quality, it's about being able to talk about the same things when using the same words.

                                                              Disclaimer: I do own a red Swiza D03, even though I can't possibly see what relevance that has for this discussion.

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                jcfiguet
                                                                Posts: 388
                                                                jcfiguet Offline
                                                                jcfiguet
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #96 Quote Reply

                                                                  @Corwyn said:

                                                                  I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic, it looks like a step back in every direction... if I want a more modern version of the SAK idea, I'd get a Boker/SRM or an Emerson.

                                                                  I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection and keep for next year after they go bankrupt as well, but my mild disinterest has turned to sheer distaste for this subpar toy due to these discussions...

                                                                  [...]

                                                                  Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                                                                  "it looks like a step back in every direction" "I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection"
                                                                  If I understand, it's a bad knife but you want to try it for a cheaper price...

                                                                  "... after they go bankrupt as well ..."
                                                                  What a friendly welcome !

                                                                  By reading this kind of post, I can only suppose that the birth of Swiza disturbs really lot of persons…

                                                                  I agree only 1 point, like you I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic but not for the same reasons.

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • firiki Offline
                                                                    firiki
                                                                    Posts: 6,076
                                                                    firiki Offline
                                                                    firiki
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #97 Quote Reply

                                                                      @jcfiguet said:
                                                                      Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                                                                      With all due respect, demonstrating the poverty of your own arguments, Jean-Claude, would be too much work. Maybe you would like to read through them again, perhaps doing so would cause you to reconsider some things. :angel:

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        Posts: 388
                                                                        jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #98 Quote Reply

                                                                          @Steinar said:

                                                                          I would never term a Swiza a SAK when talking to knife people, but I would do so when talking to people who didn't care or know much about knives. When talking to knife people, the term simply becomes too ambiguous.

                                                                          The colloquial definition obviously includes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                                                                          The legal definition obviously excludes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                                                                          So then we get the MT.o definition, and then it boils down whether it's useful to include Swiza there. So, whether including it (“We need a specific term for knife based multi-tools made in Switzerland!”) or excluding it (“For collectors, the historical term is useful, and for the enthusiast, a term more focused on the country of origin than class of knife isn't that useful, on cause the offerings from Böker, Case, Nontron, Hartkopf, etc ad nauseam.”), it isn't about discrimination or quality, it's about being able to talk about the same things when using the same words.

                                                                          [...]

                                                                          The colloquial definition includes all Swiss knives, it's OK.

                                                                          But "The legal definition" does not exists, a trademark "Swiss Army" (property of Victorinox) for watches, knives, rucksacks, etc. is not "Swiss Army Knife" for knives only. Swiss Army is stamped everywhere on victorinox products but it was never stamped on Wenger products. So it's impossible to invoke this definition for Wenger <u>AND</u> Victorinox. The term "SAK" was used for Victorinox, Wenger, Röthlisberger - Bärau, E.H.A., Forges de Vallorbe L & Co, Grieshaber Schaffhausen and other Swiss brands.

                                                                          The term (SAK) simply becomes too ambiguous, yes, of course ! Like "officier suisse" or "armée suisse" for civilian knives. Ambiguous and introducing confusion.

                                                                          The poll at the begining of this page is about colloquial definition ? legal definition ? or Mto definition ? or other definition ?

                                                                          It may be time to announce what we talk about, what definition is chosen and be more honest by saying clearly what is the objective of this discussion. Don't you think ?

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                            jcfiguet
                                                                            Posts: 388
                                                                            jcfiguet Offline
                                                                            jcfiguet
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #99 Quote Reply

                                                                              @firiki said:

                                                                              @jcfiguet said:

                                                                              Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                                                                              With all due respect, demonstrating the poverty of your own arguments, Jean-Claude, would be too much work. Maybe you would like to read through them again, perhaps doing so would cause you to reconsider some things. :angel:

                                                                              No problem !

                                                                              Tell me what things I have to reconsider ! But with valid arguments.

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • NetsNJ Offline
                                                                                NetsNJ
                                                                                Posts: 676
                                                                                NetsNJ Offline
                                                                                NetsNJ
                                                                                wrote on last edited by NetsNJ
                                                                                #100 Quote Reply

                                                                                  The colloquial definition includes all Swiss knives, it's OK.

                                                                                  I can't speak for Europe, but in the <u>United States</u>, the colloquial definition of Swiss Army Knife is any pocket knife with multiple blades. (Maybe France is different.) It simply doesn't matter if it was made in Switzerland or Shanghai. So yes, in that sense, Swiza is now a manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. And the Chinese company "Diamond" (?) is the world's largest manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. We *could *use the colloquial definition but I am not sure it is a helpful one.

                                                                                  Look, I am not a Victorinox fanboy, it isn't about that. I love the company, but probably love Wenger more. My first "Swiss Army Knife" when I was a kid was a cheap Chinese knockoff, and I loved that thing to death. (At least until the rivets gave out.) The cheap Chinese Swiss Army Knives still hold a special place in my heart, and I still pick them up on impulse here and there.

                                                                                  Anyways, I don't care that much about whether Swizas are SAKs or not. I think not, but also think there is room for disagreement precisely because the definition of SAK is so fuzzy (legal? literal? colloquial?). I am just put off by what honestly reads as hostility in your posts. To be frank, multitool.org is the nicest community I have yet encountered on the internet, and we should probably all work harder to make it even nicer.

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 3
                                                                                  • 4
                                                                                  • 5
                                                                                  • 6
                                                                                  • 7
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
                                                                                  4. Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0