Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE NOTIFICATIONS 0 MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Are SWIZA knives SAKs?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
126 Posts 1 Posters 14.0k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
  4. Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • enki_ck Offline
    enki_ck
    Global Moderators
    Posts: 20,936
    enki_ck Offline
    enki_ck
    Global Moderators
    wrote on last edited by enki_ck
    #93 Quote Reply

      The Swiza company isn't allowed by **LAW **to use the name Swiss Army knife (SAK) but we should cause you say so? Really? Where's the logic in that?

      You seem to disregard this obvious fact, and yes, it's a fact, not an assumption or personal belief, just to prove your point. :salute:

      Yes, the name was coined by the US soldiers, but it is now protected by law by both Victorinox(original Swiss Army Knife) and Wenger(genuine Swiss Army Knife). It's not reputation, it's their **TRADEMARK **slogan. Just pick up and look at any box of Victorinox you have and you'll see it there.

      So yes, there were knives issued to the Swiss military before the Victorinox and Wenger became the only contractors, and yes, other companies will be able to sell their knives to the Swiss military under the new law. BUT they won't be able to call themselves Swiss army knives, that term is reserved for Victorinox and Wenger. Not by members of MTO, by international law. :salute:

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Corwyn Offline
        Corwyn
        Posts: 3,534
        Corwyn Offline
        Corwyn
        wrote on last edited by
        #94 Quote Reply

          I am getting tired of seeing this topic over and over (while I casually refresh the site to see how close I am to winning Harley's Surge ::) ). We'll end up locking threads one by one. :-\

          I am tired of people riding on the Swiss Army name and logo coat tails... am I'm not speaking about the Chinese knock-offs only, but also: Royalty Line, Swiss Tech, Swiss Bianco, Aitor, Pradel, Century, Hanova, Ellehammer and now this "thing".

          What is a sak is debatable, is a Vic GAK a SAK, a Vic Classic, a Vic Hunter Pro, a Vic Spirit, a Vic Baker's knife, an Adler GAK, an Amefa DAK, a Wenger BusinessTool? It really is up to the members of a community to choose and this one (probably the most versed in this) decided 4 to 1 about this issue.

          I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic, it looks like a step back in every direction... if I want a more modern version of the SAK idea, I'd get a Boker/SRM or an Emerson.

          I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection and keep for next year after they go bankrupt as well, but my mild disinterest has turned to sheer distaste for this subpar toy due to these discussions...

          The true test of SUK-iness will come soon. If it is considered a true SAK by the Swiss Government and by Vic, they will buy them out again, after they go under again....

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Steinar Offline
            Steinar
            Posts: 3,435
            Steinar Offline
            Steinar
            wrote on last edited by
            #95 Quote Reply

              @jcfiguet said:

              @Etherealicer said:

              Call it reputation / image / brand slogan or whatever

              Audi Vorsprung durch Technik
              Victorinox maker of the original Swiss Army Knife
              Wenger maker of the genuine Swiss Army Knife

              Also sometimes we use a brand name to describe a product. For example Band-Aid is a brand name, we still use it for all adhesive bandages. There is no need to justify that, its just how language / labels evolve.

              I'm sorry but no ! It's not a reputation, image or a brand slogan, it's only a naming by error which used now everywhere in the world ! And this naming means "knives made in Switzerland with the Swiss quality".

              As mentioned earlier in the thread, the colloquial definition today isn't “a really great knife that is made in Switzerland”, it's “a pocket knife with some extra tools, and it doesn't hurt if it's red”. NetsNJ's post was a perfect illustration of exactly that. Now, MT.o has its own jargon, and then the colloquial definition becomes useless, as it includes anything from Case scout knives to multi-layer knives made in Sheffield before the founder of Victorinox even was a glint in his father's eye. So, think it's a perfectly valid question to ask the community whether they find it natural to call that particular new line of multi-layer folders from Switzerland SAKs.

              As for the Swiss Army trademark... Remember, the knife makers were allowed to use the Swiss Army trademark because they already had established themselves as quality brands with international markets and it was good for Switzerland. It wasn't some magnanimous gesture or strange deal in corridors with hushed voices. They (Victorinox and Wenger) started in an era were trademark and copyright law was rather more lax than today, and when it became an issue, the Swiss authorities went for the pragmatic approach.

              I would never term a Swiza a SAK when talking to knife people, but I would do so when talking to people who didn't care or know much about knives. When talking to knife people, the term simply becomes too ambiguous.

              The colloquial definition obviously includes Swiza knives as SAKs.

              The legal definition obviously excludes Swiza knives as SAKs.

              So then we get the MT.o definition, and then it boils down whether it's useful to include Swiza there. So, whether including it (“We need a specific term for knife based multi-tools made in Switzerland!”) or excluding it (“For collectors, the historical term is useful, and for the enthusiast, a term more focused on the country of origin than class of knife isn't that useful, on cause the offerings from Böker, Case, Nontron, Hartkopf, etc ad nauseam.”), it isn't about discrimination or quality, it's about being able to talk about the same things when using the same words.

              Disclaimer: I do own a red Swiza D03, even though I can't possibly see what relevance that has for this discussion.

              1 Reply Last reply
              • jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                Posts: 388
                jcfiguet Offline
                jcfiguet
                wrote on last edited by
                #96 Quote Reply

                  @Corwyn said:

                  I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic, it looks like a step back in every direction... if I want a more modern version of the SAK idea, I'd get a Boker/SRM or an Emerson.

                  I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection and keep for next year after they go bankrupt as well, but my mild disinterest has turned to sheer distaste for this subpar toy due to these discussions...

                  [...]

                  Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                  "it looks like a step back in every direction" "I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection"
                  If I understand, it's a bad knife but you want to try it for a cheaper price...

                  "... after they go bankrupt as well ..."
                  What a friendly welcome !

                  By reading this kind of post, I can only suppose that the birth of Swiza disturbs really lot of persons…

                  I agree only 1 point, like you I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic but not for the same reasons.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • firiki Offline
                    firiki
                    Posts: 6,076
                    firiki Offline
                    firiki
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #97 Quote Reply

                      @jcfiguet said:
                      Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                      With all due respect, demonstrating the poverty of your own arguments, Jean-Claude, would be too much work. Maybe you would like to read through them again, perhaps doing so would cause you to reconsider some things. :angel:

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • jcfiguet Offline
                        jcfiguet
                        Posts: 388
                        jcfiguet Offline
                        jcfiguet
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #98 Quote Reply

                          @Steinar said:

                          I would never term a Swiza a SAK when talking to knife people, but I would do so when talking to people who didn't care or know much about knives. When talking to knife people, the term simply becomes too ambiguous.

                          The colloquial definition obviously includes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                          The legal definition obviously excludes Swiza knives as SAKs.

                          So then we get the MT.o definition, and then it boils down whether it's useful to include Swiza there. So, whether including it (“We need a specific term for knife based multi-tools made in Switzerland!”) or excluding it (“For collectors, the historical term is useful, and for the enthusiast, a term more focused on the country of origin than class of knife isn't that useful, on cause the offerings from Böker, Case, Nontron, Hartkopf, etc ad nauseam.”), it isn't about discrimination or quality, it's about being able to talk about the same things when using the same words.

                          [...]

                          The colloquial definition includes all Swiss knives, it's OK.

                          But "The legal definition" does not exists, a trademark "Swiss Army" (property of Victorinox) for watches, knives, rucksacks, etc. is not "Swiss Army Knife" for knives only. Swiss Army is stamped everywhere on victorinox products but it was never stamped on Wenger products. So it's impossible to invoke this definition for Wenger <u>AND</u> Victorinox. The term "SAK" was used for Victorinox, Wenger, Röthlisberger - Bärau, E.H.A., Forges de Vallorbe L & Co, Grieshaber Schaffhausen and other Swiss brands.

                          The term (SAK) simply becomes too ambiguous, yes, of course ! Like "officier suisse" or "armée suisse" for civilian knives. Ambiguous and introducing confusion.

                          The poll at the begining of this page is about colloquial definition ? legal definition ? or Mto definition ? or other definition ?

                          It may be time to announce what we talk about, what definition is chosen and be more honest by saying clearly what is the objective of this discussion. Don't you think ?

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • jcfiguet Offline
                            jcfiguet
                            Posts: 388
                            jcfiguet Offline
                            jcfiguet
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #99 Quote Reply

                              @firiki said:

                              @jcfiguet said:

                              Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                              With all due respect, demonstrating the poverty of your own arguments, Jean-Claude, would be too much work. Maybe you would like to read through them again, perhaps doing so would cause you to reconsider some things. :angel:

                              No problem !

                              Tell me what things I have to reconsider ! But with valid arguments.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • NetsNJ Offline
                                NetsNJ
                                Posts: 676
                                NetsNJ Offline
                                NetsNJ
                                wrote on last edited by NetsNJ
                                #100 Quote Reply

                                  The colloquial definition includes all Swiss knives, it's OK.

                                  I can't speak for Europe, but in the <u>United States</u>, the colloquial definition of Swiss Army Knife is any pocket knife with multiple blades. (Maybe France is different.) It simply doesn't matter if it was made in Switzerland or Shanghai. So yes, in that sense, Swiza is now a manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. And the Chinese company "Diamond" (?) is the world's largest manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. We *could *use the colloquial definition but I am not sure it is a helpful one.

                                  Look, I am not a Victorinox fanboy, it isn't about that. I love the company, but probably love Wenger more. My first "Swiss Army Knife" when I was a kid was a cheap Chinese knockoff, and I loved that thing to death. (At least until the rivets gave out.) The cheap Chinese Swiss Army Knives still hold a special place in my heart, and I still pick them up on impulse here and there.

                                  Anyways, I don't care that much about whether Swizas are SAKs or not. I think not, but also think there is room for disagreement precisely because the definition of SAK is so fuzzy (legal? literal? colloquial?). I am just put off by what honestly reads as hostility in your posts. To be frank, multitool.org is the nicest community I have yet encountered on the internet, and we should probably all work harder to make it even nicer.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    Posts: 388
                                    jcfiguet Offline
                                    jcfiguet
                                    wrote on last edited by jcfiguet
                                    #101 Quote Reply

                                      I can also suggest an other thing :

                                      We can construct a list of generic naming that includes all knives made in Switzerland without distinction, for new and former swiss brands, military and civilian knives, etc.

                                      These namings should be translatable in some languages like German, Spanish, Italian, French, etc. And understood by all without ambiguity.

                                      And next , create a new poll to choose the best name.

                                      I think it's a positive way...

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • Steinar Offline
                                        Steinar
                                        Posts: 3,435
                                        Steinar Offline
                                        Steinar
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #102 Quote Reply

                                          @jcfiguet said:
                                          But "The legal definition" does not exists, a trademark "Swiss Army" (property of Victorinox) for watches, knives, rucksacks, etc. is not "Swiss Army Knife" for knives only. Swiss Army is stamped everywhere on victorinox products but it was never stamped on Wenger products. So it's impossible to invoke this definition for Wenger <u>AND</u> Victorinox. The term "SAK" was used for Victorinox, Wenger, Röthlisberger - Bärau, E.H.A., Forges de Vallorbe L & Co, Grieshaber Schaffhausen and other Swiss brands.

                                          If the point of this poll was discussing whether arbitrary Swiss cutlers should be allowed to sell bags made outside Switzerland under the brand “Swiss Army”, I assume on good faith the author of the initial post would have written so in the initial post.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Steinar Offline
                                            Steinar
                                            Posts: 3,435
                                            Steinar Offline
                                            Steinar
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #103 Quote Reply

                                              @jcfiguet said:
                                              I can also suggest an other thing :

                                              We can construct a list of generic naming that includes all knives made in Switzerland without distinction, for new and former swiss brands, military and civilian knives, etc.

                                              I humbly suggest the term “knives made in Switzerland”. ;)

                                              These namings should be translatable in some languages like German, Spanish, Italian, French, etc. And understood by all without ambiguity.

                                              And next , create a new poll to choose the best name.

                                              I think it's a positive way...

                                              That's a job for people like https://mw.lojban.org/papri/Lojban , not MT.o. Here, a common context and a healthy dose of tongue in cheek is often valued over perfect (i.e. boring) communication with artificially constructed terms.

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                AimlessWanderer
                                                Posts: 17,518
                                                AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                AimlessWanderer
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #104 Quote Reply

                                                  @jcfiguet said:
                                                  I can also suggest an other thing :

                                                  We can construct a list of generic naming that includes all knives made in Switzerland without distinction, for new and former swiss brands, military and civilian knives, etc.

                                                  These namings should be translatable in some languages like German, Spanish, Italian, French, etc. And understood by all without ambiguity.

                                                  And next , create a new poll to choose the best name.

                                                  I think it's a positive way...

                                                  Why?

                                                  SAK means different things to different people. That will not change. The previous poll, and the discussions since have proved that.

                                                  If we do another poll do you think people will change their minds?
                                                  Do you think they should?

                                                  Why can't we all have our own opinions and be happy if other peoples opinions are different?

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • jcfiguet Offline
                                                    jcfiguet
                                                    Posts: 388
                                                    jcfiguet Offline
                                                    jcfiguet
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #105 Quote Reply

                                                      @NetsNJ said:

                                                      The colloquial definition includes all Swiss knives, it's OK.

                                                      I can't speak for Europe, but in the <u>United States</u>, the colloquial definition of Swiss Army Knife is any pocket knife with multiple blades. (Maybe France is different.) It simply doesn't matter if it was made in Switzerland or Shanghai. So yes, in that sense, Swiza is now a manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. And the Chinese company "Diamond" (?) is the world's largest manufacturer of Swiss Army Knives. We *could *use the colloquial definition but I am not sure it is a helpful one.

                                                      Look, I am not a Victorinox fanboy, it isn't about that. I love the company, but probably love Wenger more. My first "Swiss Army Knife" when I was a kid was a cheap Chinese knockoff, and I loved that thing to death. (At least until the rivets gave out.) The cheap Chinese Swiss Army Knives still hold a special place in my heart, and I still pick them up on impulse here and there.

                                                      I think the problem of SAK or no SAK is the same everywhere in the world for the public, but not for collectors or persons interested by Swiss Army Knives...

                                                      The Chinese company "Diamond" makes MTO but not SAK in my opinion.

                                                      I have also an old french knive without brand given by my grand-father when I was young and it's for me the best knife in the world but it's not a sak.

                                                      I love all Swiss Army Knives in all brands as a collector and can't understand a distinction between 2 brands, it's just not fair for me.

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • NetsNJ Offline
                                                        NetsNJ
                                                        Posts: 676
                                                        NetsNJ Offline
                                                        NetsNJ
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #106 Quote Reply

                                                          Why is brand discrimination worse or more unfair than geographic discrimination?

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • jcfiguet Offline
                                                            jcfiguet
                                                            Posts: 388
                                                            jcfiguet Offline
                                                            jcfiguet
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #107 Quote Reply

                                                              @Steinar said:

                                                              @jcfiguet said:

                                                              I can also suggest an other thing :

                                                              We can construct a list of generic naming that includes all knives made in Switzerland without distinction, for new and former swiss brands, military and civilian knives, etc.

                                                              I humbly suggest the term “knives made in Switzerland”. ;)

                                                              These namings should be translatable in some languages like German, Spanish, Italian, French, etc. And understood by all without ambiguity.

                                                              And next , create a new poll to choose the best name.

                                                              I think it's a positive way...

                                                              That's a job for people like https://mw.lojban.org/papri/Lojban , not MT.o. Here, a common context and a healthy dose of tongue in cheek is often valued over perfect (i.e. boring) communication with artificially constructed terms.

                                                              I suggest "Swiss Knives" it can be translated in all languages !

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • SteveC Offline
                                                                SteveC
                                                                Global Moderators
                                                                Posts: 73,535
                                                                SteveC Offline
                                                                SteveC
                                                                Global Moderators
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #108 Quote Reply

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                    jcfiguet
                                                                    Posts: 388
                                                                    jcfiguet Offline
                                                                    jcfiguet
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #109 Quote Reply

                                                                      @NetsNJ said:
                                                                      Why is brand discrimination worse or more unfair than geographic discrimination?

                                                                      A geographic discrimination is not a real discrimination but just an information : the history is important, the history of French knives is not the same than Swiss knives or Spanish knives or American Knives. So to speak seriously about a brand or a knife, it's easiest to have country references and its knives history.

                                                                      A brand discrimination stay a discrimination for comparisons. If you say Swiza is not SAK but only a SK it can be understood "Swiza makes bad knives, it's only... Something with small importance"...

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        Posts: 388
                                                                        jcfiguet Offline
                                                                        jcfiguet
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #110 Quote Reply

                                                                          @SteveC said:

                                                                          LOL !

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • Corwyn Offline
                                                                            Corwyn
                                                                            Posts: 3,534
                                                                            Corwyn Offline
                                                                            Corwyn
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #111 Quote Reply

                                                                              @jcfiguet said:

                                                                              @Corwyn said:

                                                                              I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic, it looks like a step back in every direction... if I want a more modern version of the SAK idea, I'd get a Boker/SRM or an Emerson.

                                                                              I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection and keep for next year after they go bankrupt as well, but my mild disinterest has turned to sheer distaste for this subpar toy due to these discussions...

                                                                              [...]

                                                                              Interesting by the poverty of the arguments… !

                                                                              "it looks like a step back in every direction" "I meant to get a Swiza second hand to try for a bit and put in the Wenger collection"
                                                                              If I understand, it's a bad knife but you want to try it for a cheaper price...

                                                                              "... after they go bankrupt as well ..."
                                                                              What a friendly welcome !

                                                                              By reading this kind of post, I can only suppose that the birth of Swiza disturbs really lot of persons…

                                                                              I agree only 1 point, like you I do not find Swiza to be a proper competitor for Vic but not for the same reasons.

                                                                              Didn't mean to answer again, but you seem to be missing the points.

                                                                              Yes, keeping a perceived mediocre/poor product in a collection is fine. See Swissflame or Spartan Lite or Tomo...

                                                                              Yes I would get one if it was cheaper because it looks pretty and I understood it feels fine.

                                                                              Yes, it is a step back. Did you see the other two Sak-representations launched recently: Boker City Tool and the Emerson EDC? They would make better next-gen saks than the Swiza...
                                                                              Current Sak-design is getting old. There are many things to improve: proper steel, proper handle materials, proper opening, proper locking, proper wrenches, proper pliers, more reliable scissors etc. The Boker and Emerson designs improve some of these. Swiza doesn't improve anything... just adds a trendy look to stolen tools, logo and tagline.

                                                                              Why I think they will go bankrupt soon? Well the industry is dieing and Vic barely holds on due to Multitools, Classics, Aloxes and various designs with saws and scissors. Also they have a huge network, huge Marketing, huge name recognition, watch and bags businesses to fall back on as well as amazing kitchen knives. Swiza has none of these... just a hipsterish design and a separate watch business. Also Swizas are locking and easy to OHO, making them illegal in half of Europe...
                                                                              Now also ask yourself if it said Ganzo PRC on the blade instead of Swiza and if it had a star instead of a cross on the scales.... would you buy it? Would you support it so dearly?

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • Smashie Offline
                                                                                Smashie
                                                                                In Memoriam
                                                                                Posts: 5,337
                                                                                Smashie Offline
                                                                                Smashie
                                                                                In Memoriam
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #112 Quote Reply

                                                                                  Please, can this subject die? I'm sure I'm not the only one who's sick of it

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 3
                                                                                  • 4
                                                                                  • 5
                                                                                  • 6
                                                                                  • 7
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
                                                                                  4. Are SWIZA knives SAKs?
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0