Crazy
-
I understand these kind of knives have some appeal (most from US buyers), but more than $ 400 for this knife is simply too much.
I can even recognize a forum member you placed the bid of $ 435. It would be interesting to hear the logic about it. -
@basilio said:
Did you see this?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Rare-Wenger-Dynasty-Series-Lancelot-Swiss-Army-Knife-Circa-1993-Discontinued-/191749120629?hash=item2ca5236275%3Ag%3A8eIAAOSw7FRWWzn~&nma=true&si=uu3HBDMsya5IJLyY99jltaKdUBc%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557I understand these kind of knives have some appeal (most from US buyers), but more than $ 400 for this knife is simply too much.
I can even recognize a forum member you placed the bid of $ 435. It would be interesting to hear the logic about it.Yeah, it's very cool but that's crazy money IMO.
-
I think someone posted this earlier...
The original price for this Classic was $250 - What a joke
http://www.ebay.com/itm/EUC-McDonnell-Douglas-Boeing-F-15-Ejection-Seat-Pen-Knife-Swiss-Army-Victorinox-/281876846283?&autorefresh=trueI watched it just for interest.
After several relistings and no sales of course the price went to 150 and now 75 - I offered 15 just for a laugh
I think someone mentioned earlier he would never sell at that price to a SAK guy (no I don't mean you SAKGUY) - But maybe a aeroplane or MacDonald Douglas enthusiast ??Greedy and not very clever seller!!
-
@Huntsman said:
I think someone posted this earlier...
The original price for this Classic was $250 - What a joke
http://www.ebay.com/itm/EUC-McDonnell-Douglas-Boeing-F-15-Ejection-Seat-Pen-Knife-Swiss-Army-Victorinox-/281876846283?&autorefresh=trueI watched it just for interest.
After several relistings and no sales of course the price went to 150 and now 75 - I offered 15 just for a laugh
I think someone mentioned earlier he would never sell at that price to a SAK guy (no I don't mean you SAKGUY) - But maybe a aeroplane or MacDonald Douglas enthusiast ??Greedy and not very clever seller!!
-
Red alox Bantam. Listed earlier today, already at $200 :o
-
Main blade is 1/2 inch short. A least they say reprofiled and with a top down closed pic it is easy to see.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1957-1961-Victorinox-Victoria-Swiss-Army-Knife-Vintage-With-Bail-Triangle-Awl-/321940355327?hash=item4af523f8ff:g:w0AAAOSw7FRWYbY0 -
@GigaHz said:
Main blade is 1/2 inch short. A least they say reprofiled and with a top down closed pic it is easy to see.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1957-1961-Victorinox-Victoria-Swiss-Army-Knife-Vintage-With-Bail-Triangle-Awl-/321940355327?hash=item4af523f8ff:g:w0AAAOSw7FRWYbY0That whole knife is a disaster. The only tool not worn or damaged is the corkscrew. It's the first time I've ever seen a worn out fish scaler.
-
How does one wear out a fish scaler? Maybe too much polishing? -
Maybe he thought it was a very dull saw. :D
-
Dozens of carved pumpkins!
-
:ahhh
-
It appears you are paying for sympathy and the sellers sentimental value.
-
Doris
I stopped buying after i got a surprise like that in the mail. ;)
But I stopped buying from the US anyways a few months after that so I doubt she noticed. :P
A friend of mine swears by her name, says she's extremely nice and loves buying stuff from her. Weird... She's my Facebook friend too and she seems like a nice lady. Having seen the photos above, I agree that there's mismatch between the description and the photos...
I've bought several knives from her in the past, one quite recently. She's nice, ships quickly and sends exactly what you bought. Answers questions quickly too. What's she's doing can be considered a "gray area" depending on your perspective. For example, if I buy a car for cheap, replace the tires, vacuum it and wax the body and resell it for more, that's legit right?
With collectibles though, my opinion is that you should either (a) leave it in original condition and let the buyer refurbish as they want or (b) refurbish - then clearly and explicitly call out said refurbishment. She does neither, which is what I have an issue with.
She's sold over 10,000 knives in the last 5 years. She knows quite well which knives are collectible and which are just $10 Spartans. Overall the percentage of refurbished knives is somewhat low - there really isn't a lot of value in refurbishing a late model TSA seized Climber. But the knives that are sought after?
Refurbishment probably runs 10% or greater.edit - I just looked because I was curious. From July 2014 until today, 35% (21 of 60) of knives from her that I consider "collectible" in some way (pre-1974, 84mm scissors, Scientist, Yeoman, Alox, etc) have some bit of work done one them. If you see a knife from her with a bail, clip point blade, exposed rivets, etc. - be very careful and inspect it closely.Here are some examples - in none of these was the re-profiling mentioned. Some, like the pen blade in #1 and the main blade in #3 are obvious when you look at them. Some like the main blades in #1, #2 and #4 are less obvious but noticeable if you know what to look for. Caveat emptor.
FWIW - the finish work on the re-profiling of the blades is actually quite well done. It still needs to be called out, mind you, but its still pretty nicely done.
What really bothers me is that I can only tell that a blade has been re-profiled in half those pictures. I really need to improve that if I'm going to keep buying online.
-
@Thales of Miletus said:
What really bothers me is that I can only tell that a blade has been re-profiled in half those pictures. I really need to improve that if I'm going to keep buying online.Here's the method I use - look where the main blade meets the tang. On all Victorinox knives since 1951 there should be a prominent notch between the blade and the tang. If there isn't the blade has been sharpened and/or re-profiled. Now this isn't always 100% - I've seen blades that were re-profiled at the tip that still have the notch present. But if you see the notch is missing, you can be sure the blade has had some work done.

-
Nice one JB
Of course the other easy way is if they show a picture from 'on top' and the blade does not reach the end of the knife compartment inside.Here is another suggestion - You can even try measuring !! :o
Not very scientific, or accurate, you need maths!, and it's a bit fiddly - And you also need an equivalent at home.Here's the routine
Measure the blade length on the screen - tang notch to tip is usually possible - you may need to 'zoom' the image
Measure another length you know on the ebay picture - eg the length of the whole SAK or another tool.
Measure the length of the blade on a SAK at home
Do the maths and see if the picture blade length is correct.Example:
For this example - Assume you know its a 91mm -
Otherwise choose another tool length and measure the equivalent tool in the photo and at home to replace 91 and 'EBS' in the calculations below!!Length of blade on EBay = EBB
Length of SAK on EBay picture = EBS
Real length of SAK = 91mm
Length of real 91mm SAK blade (tip to tang notch) = 60mmSo your blade length (EBB) should be 60 x EBS / 91
If it is not it has been shortened!!I even did this once on a SAK on ebay I was not sure about!! And it worked!!
Still bought the knife though :D - That's how I knew it worked
-
... but, in fact, a Standard for 600 bucks it's quite rare 
-
:ahhh
... but, in fact, a Standard for 600 bucks it's quite rare 
I assumed it was a Tourist, so that's a whole different ballgame! ;)
-
@Thales of Miletus said:
What really bothers me is that I can only tell that a blade has been re-profiled in half those pictures. I really need to improve that if I'm going to keep buying online.
Here's the method I use - look where the main blade meets the tang. On all Victorinox knives since 1951 there should be a prominent notch between the blade and the tang. If there isn't the blade has been sharpened and/or re-profiled. Now this isn't always 100% - I've seen blades that were re-profiled at the tip that still have the notch present. But if you see the notch is missing, you can be sure the blade has had some work done.
So.......this Soldier really wasn't issued to the elite Swiss Cheese Brigade?


-
@Thales of Miletus said:
What really bothers me is that I can only tell that a blade has been re-profiled in half those pictures. I really need to improve that if I'm going to keep buying online.
Here's the method I use - look where the main blade meets the tang. On all Victorinox knives since 1951 there should be a prominent notch between the blade and the tang. If there isn't the blade has been sharpened and/or re-profiled. Now this isn't always 100% - I've seen blades that were re-profiled at the tip that still have the notch present. But if you see the notch is missing, you can be sure the blade has had some work done.
I really appreciate your explanation, that advice will probably end up saving me some grief later.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login