Official MT.O 31-Days Leatherman SURGE® Challenge!
-
-
While it would be nice to win a Spirit, as I can't really drop the cash on a single tool any time real soon, I'm just having fun trying to come up with ways to fit this monster of a MT into my daily activities. I've also enjoyed following everyone else's threads. You guys seem to all have more interesting lives than me!
-
@WoodsDuck said:
I'm just having fun trying to come up with ways to fit this monster of a MT into my daily activities.Same here. I carry much, and use little. So most of my usage for this challenge is in the kitchen. But I do get to turn a screw or snip a wire once in a while.
-
-
Would a leatherman brewzer be allowed to carry during the challenge or would that be "cheating"? Can't carry my new charge or folder but unsure on the brewzer.
-
Yep, I put my Shard aside too

-
I was hoping I could have used something new that I got, I can carry the mini sharp and bit kits that are new, thanks for letting me know. Well only 6 days till I can try out the charge for real :) the suspense

One day I'll know all the rule a tricks, until then thanks for teaching everyone -
A few thoughts on the Surge as we enter the final week:
The Surge's 12.5 ounce/335 gram weight has always made it a difficult MT to EDC, and that hasn't changed. But that weight gives you perhaps the most capable MT on the market. The outside, one hand deployable blades are a key part of that equation. I have become very accustomed to the ease of deploying the main blade, which allows me to forego a separate knife. The interior tools are easily accessed.
I can't think of much that I would change about the Surge. It could certainly benefit from a long shank phillips, as is found on the Supertool 300. The stubby phillips on the Surge, Wave and Charge have always made me grumpy. But I can't honestly say that the Surge's stubby phillips has ever let me down.
It would be nice if the Surge could lose a couple of ounces, but then it wouldn't be a Surge.
The Surge compares directly with the Victorinox Swisstool. The Surge is not as refined in its design and build quality, and lacks the Swisstool's chisel, box opener (?) and long phillips. The Surge has beefy scissors, which are not found on my 2x Swisstools. The Surge's replaceable cutters are a win, and I prefer the profile of their pliers. The Swisstool's pliers are not sure whether they are needlenose or blunt, and end up being neither.
Which would I prefer between the two? That's a tough one, because they both rock. But for me, the Swisstool's design and implementation win out. It packs more tools, more efficiently. The tools open more precisely and smoothly. But much of this is subjective, and the Surge is a serious piece of MT that I will continue to carry often. The one-hand deployable blades, for me, keep the Surge essentially equal to the Swisstool in a direct competition. So it really comes down to what you subjectively prefer.
We have a few days left, but I want to thank Obi for running this show, and brother Zoidberg for his encouragement and daily pics.

-
@powernoodle said:
A few thoughts on the Surge as we enter the final week:The Surge's 12.5 ounce/335 gram weight has always made it a difficult MT to EDC, and that hasn't changed. But that weight gives you perhaps the most capable MT on the market. The outside, one hand deployable blades are a key part of that equation. I have become very accustomed to the ease of deploying the main blade, which allows me to forego a separate knife. The interior tools are easily accessed.
I can't think of much that I would change about the Surge. It could certainly benefit from a long shank phillips, as is found on the Supertool 300. The stubby phillips on the Surge, Wave and Charge have always made me grumpy. But I can't honestly say that the Surge's stubby phillips has ever let me down.
It would be nice if the Surge could lose a couple of ounces, but then it wouldn't be a Surge.
The Surge compares directly with the Victorinox Swisstool. The Surge is not as refined in its design and build quality, and lacks the Swisstool's chisel, box opener (?) and long phillips. The Surge has beefy scissors, which are not found on my 2x Swisstools. The Surge's replaceable cutters are a win, and I prefer the profile of their pliers. The Swisstool's pliers are not sure whether they are needlenose or blunt, and end up being neither.
Which would I prefer between the two? That's a tough one, because they both rock. But for me, the Swisstool's design and implementation win out. It packs more tools, more efficiently. The tools open more precisely and smoothly. But much of this is subjective, and the Surge is a serious piece of MT that I will continue to carry often. The one-hand deployable blades, for me, keep the Surge essentially equal to the Swisstool in a direct competition. So it really comes down to what you subjectively prefer.
We have a few days left, but I want to thank Obi for running this show, and brother Zoidberg for his encouragement and daily pics.

Very nice summary. It's very similar to how I feel about the wave vs spirit debate. The wave is no near as heavy as the surge. Did you use the blade exchanger much on the surge? What are your thoughts on choosing between the file and saw?
-
I have to mostly agree with Noodle's assessment, though I don't actually have a SwissTool to compare. The Surge is a beast, but you get a heck of a lot in that slab of steel.
The Surge's scissors might be my favorite of any MT I've tried. Even better than SAK scissors, in my opinion.
-
@Demel said:
Did you use the blade exchanger much on the surge? What are your thoughts on choosing between the file and saw?I have not used the blade exchanger this month. To me, its a little bit of a downside because other MTs give you a saw and file and the same time without having to take a timeout to install a new tool. But as with everything, there is a corresponding upside. But I prefer an MT to have a saw and file ready to go at all times.
I don't use either a saw or file that much, but prefer to keep the saw in place as I'm a little more likely to use it.
This month I have mostly pocket carried the Surge in the vertical pocket of a pair of 5.11 Taclite Pro pants. Its works nicely. So without the sheath, I'm not carrying the file to exchange. That's another downside (for me) of having a blade exchanger.
@WoodsDuck said:
The Surge's scissors might be my favorite of any MT I've tried. Even better than SAK scissors, in my opinion.I agree that they are the best for Big Boy cutting, like canvas and so forth. But for precise work, like skin abrasions and detail work, the SAK scissors are unsurpassed. For me, and after this Challenge is over (and after the SOG Challenge), I'll carry both an MT and a small SAK to get both flavors of scissors.
-
BRAND NEW SPIRIT X COMING FOR DRAW WINNER
GOOD LUCK EVERYONE .. HAPPY NEW YEAR .. YEAR OF MONKEY IS COMING
-
Last week thoughts as well, the weight hasn't been an issue most of the time. I've just about filed away all use of the wire crimpers. Really like the outside scissors. Miss the gut hook.
I think this challenege will make me mod a wave or charge. Outside scissors, Rebar head, awl, and added gut hook unless I can get a Charge with one.
-
@Obi1shinobee said:
BRAND NEW SPIRIT X COMING FOR DRAW WINNER
GOOD LUCK EVERYONE .. HAPPY NEW YEAR .. YEAR OF MONKEY IS COMING

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






