Big knives
-
About 4 hours today, down to 400 grit but not perfect yet....but good enough.
Tomorrow I need to try and get my car fixed, then I'll make fire >:D
From research I need to normalize 3 times, then oil quench on the 4th

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
About 4 hours today, down to 400 grit but not perfect yet....but good enough.Tomorrow I need to try and get my car fixed, then I'll make fire >:D
From research I need to normalize 3 times, then oil quench on the 4th

Normalise 3 times? Why? Bear in mind the more times you get I up to the transition temperatures, or the longer you keep it there, you increase the chances of burning off carbon content.
How are you cooling during normalising/annealing? If you need to repeat three times you might be cooling too quickly. One way you can slow it down is to bury it in a deep steel chest (ammo box type thing) of ashes or vermiculite so that it cools down over a much longer period (12 hours or so)
Normalising is actually different to annealing, but if you're using the stock removal method rather than hot working, you shouldn't need it anyway really. If you are hot working, the normalising will undo any grain modification from forging, so you might as well just grind it :D I'd anneal it, then either forge and quench, or machine the annealed blank then quench harden. I don't see any benefit of normalising as you're not going to have a gross imbalance of grain structure on something as thin as a knife.
BTW, I was told the edge should be blunt to the tune of a 1.5 to 2mm flat prior to quenching, to avoid/minimise cracking. I'm far from an expert on these matters, but thought I'd share what little I know :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
@Gerhard Gerber said:
About 4 hours today, down to 400 grit but not perfect yet....but good enough.
Tomorrow I need to try and get my car fixed, then I'll make fire >:D
From research I need to normalize 3 times, then oil quench on the 4th

Normalise 3 times? Why? Bear in mind the more times you get I up to the transition temperatures, or the longer you keep it there, you increase the chances of burning off carbon content.
How are you cooling during normalising/annealing? If you need to repeat three times you might be cooling too quickly. One way you can slow it down is to bury it in a deep steel chest (ammo box type thing) of ashes or vermiculite so that it cools down over a much longer period (12 hours or so)
Normalising is actually different to annealing, but if you're using the stock removal method rather than hot working, you shouldn't need it anyway really. If you are hot working, the normalising will undo any grain modification from forging, so you might as well just grind it :D I'd anneal it, then either forge and quench, or machine the annealed blank then quench harden. I don't see any benefit of normalising as you're not going to have a gross imbalance of grain structure on something as thin as a knife.
BTW, I was told the edge should be blunt to the tune of a 1.5 to 2mm flat prior to quenching, to avoid/minimise cracking. I'm far from an expert on these matters, but thought I'd share what little I know :D
Hi 50
Very simple - normalizing 3 times was the general consensus from my research, but what you said makes perfect sense. I did hotwork to get it straight, but that was minimal, the rest was stock removal.
To anneal I left the blank in (another) fire while it burned out overnight.I don't have a furnace so for the normalizing I would need to make a big fire each time, use relatively briefly and then let it die while the blade cools......and that would happen simply on some sand.
I hope to get a big enough piece of pipe today to make a furnace in the fire, worried about burning out the carbon myself.
This is all new to me so any advice welcome

-
Can't wait to see how it turns out when you put some handles on it
-
This is properly amazing GG!

-
Great work so far, it's turning out really well! Love the looks of that knife
. -
This actually looks like it would live through the "hold my beer and watch this" parts of life
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
@50ft-trad said:
@Gerhard Gerber said:
About 4 hours today, down to 400 grit but not perfect yet....but good enough.
Tomorrow I need to try and get my car fixed, then I'll make fire >:D
From research I need to normalize 3 times, then oil quench on the 4th

Normalise 3 times? Why? Bear in mind the more times you get I up to the transition temperatures, or the longer you keep it there, you increase the chances of burning off carbon content.
How are you cooling during normalising/annealing? If you need to repeat three times you might be cooling too quickly. One way you can slow it down is to bury it in a deep steel chest (ammo box type thing) of ashes or vermiculite so that it cools down over a much longer period (12 hours or so)
Normalising is actually different to annealing, but if you're using the stock removal method rather than hot working, you shouldn't need it anyway really. If you are hot working, the normalising will undo any grain modification from forging, so you might as well just grind it :D I'd anneal it, then either forge and quench, or machine the annealed blank then quench harden. I don't see any benefit of normalising as you're not going to have a gross imbalance of grain structure on something as thin as a knife.
BTW, I was told the edge should be blunt to the tune of a 1.5 to 2mm flat prior to quenching, to avoid/minimise cracking. I'm far from an expert on these matters, but thought I'd share what little I know :D
Hi 50
Very simple - normalizing 3 times was the general consensus from my research, but what you said makes perfect sense. I did hotwork to get it straight, but that was minimal, the rest was stock removal.
To anneal I left the blank in (another) fire while it burned out overnight.I don't have a furnace so for the normalizing I would need to make a big fire each time, use relatively briefly and then let it die while the blade cools......and that would happen simply on some sand.
I hope to get a big enough piece of pipe today to make a furnace in the fire, worried about burning out the carbon myself.
This is all new to me so any advice welcome


Some materials do havetheir own subtle nuances, but I genuinely can't see the benefit of triple normalising here.
Annealing takes the material to a base condition anyway. You can "bump" a hardness without annealing, but there is an increased risk of cracking. Annealing is the way to go

Throughout the roughing process, try to work both sides gradually and equally, to prevent the material pulling to one side. Normalise if you wish, but I do not see the benefit, as the quench and temper will change the grain structure anyway.
Some materials benefit from multiple tempering. Might be worth checking out for this steel. It would make more sense to me than multiple normalising. The normalising may have a purpose, but I'm struggling to figure out what

Please don't take my opinions as gospel. My experience is in the design and manufacture of mechanical components, not knife blades, though many of the principles cross over to both applications
-
Just a note from my perspective, here I where I WOULD include normalising..... shaft manufacture...
If you are upset forging a shaft, you would be working it at high temperatures, but machining without normalising could lead to some problematic distortion. There are different sections in play, and the transitions are not uniform. There's a greater need to add an additional treatment phase to make the grain more homogenous and remove internal stresses. Sometimes proof machining then stress relieving is enough, and sometimes normalising I better.
On a knife application though, the section is essentially consistent, and I can't imagine the straightening op fighting back if it was done hot enough (or annealed after). Even if it did, you would notice distortion in the roughing stage.
-
Oh, one more thing :D when you elevate to the hardening temperature, heat spine down and edge up to stop it sagging

-
Hi
The knife is done, had it tested today and got 50 RC......I'm happy, and it performs.
Just a question, I have about 50 pics, could I set the FB album to public and share a link here? No ways I could upload more than highlights.....?

-
I named it

Black & Blue: The Bruise Bowie


-
It looks good!

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
HiThe knife is done, had it tested today and got 50 RC......I'm happy, and it performs.
Just a question, I have about 50 pics, could I set the FB album to public and share a link here? No ways I could upload more than highlights.....?

Awesome
and yes by all means post a link to the pics -
Wow! Nice work man!
-
Looks fantastic mate.
Good job. 
-
Lookin good G!
-
Thanks dudes....let me know if it works for you:
https://www.facebook.com/gerhard.gerber.31/media_set?set=a.10153891555119459.1073741841.607719458&type=1 -
Nice work!
I don't do Facebook, so I'll only be able to see pics posted here 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login