Boker > SAK
-
@Sea Monster said:
For better or worse, it did actually make me want to pick up a Boker Tech toolMe too. I'll order the blade-only version when Mrs. Powernoodle isn't looking. I like the overall look of the MT, and the deep clip. $28 shipped on Amazon - and less on eBay - is not terrible. But you can also get a Victorinox Climber for that kind of money, with a lot more utility.
-
@dks said:
Yes, blame capitalism.... I assume the alternative is much better.There are middle grounds between laissez-faire capitalism and fully government controlled communism. Just mentioning. :P
A company which is publicly traded in the US has a legal obligation to “create shareholder value” as its first priority. Victorinox, on the other hand, has the Victorinox Foundation as a majority shareholder, and the foundation has goals like creating employment in Ibach, as well as Victorinox being regulated by Swiss law.
As Adam Smith himself pointed out, capitalism will only function well with the correct mix of checks and balances.
As an aside to the above on US companies, I use to say, Americans are really good at everything except moderation.
Sorry for going on a semi-political rant.
-
@WoodsDuck said:
Am I the only one who thinks he should have compared the Bokers to 111mm Vics instead of 91mm?Interesting perspective. I see your point, but I'm really not sure.
Another thought on “made in (somewhere the main office is not)”; it has to do with whether a company is a production company or a design company too. When production is outsourced, the company becomes less of a production company, and responsibility is diluted. I think many people here, myself included, has a certain attachment to companies being production companies, and not just abstract “brands” getting stuff made wherever it's cheaper this quarter. It has to do with pride in a craft, I think.
Disclaimer: I have a Böker or two made in Taiwan (from the plus line), and they are fine knives, I think.
-
@Smaug said:
'know what else? To me, it's doesn't even matter what nationality we're speaking about. If it was a (original) Chinese design, I'd be find with it being made in China.</rant>
Yep, i dont want a german made samurai :D
It has to be hand forged by a 120 year old chinese man high up in the mountains in his century's old workshop.Sorry for letting my imagination on the loose

And back to topic:
I think that all the companies that try to copy an Swiss army knife fail. Look at gerber with their bear grylls style pocket knife.
Companies just can't compete with the quality that victorinox can offer for such a low price. That is probably because they have had this production line for a couple of decades and can manufacture almost all their models on the same line without major modifications.
When you would calculate the total cost of their production plant and divide that through all the millions of knives they have produced it would only be a couple centas on every knife.
Even chinese factorys cant compete to the Swiss business model :D

-
I'm not a diehard Vic-guy (yet, my day is coming quickly) and I've never seen one of these Bokers yet, but they look like a logical evolution of the traditional SAK. The pocket-clip and G10 scales are no brainers. I am sort of thinking shame on Vic for not developing their product into this year's ago.
Although, they will be fine regardless - they're Victorinox after all.
-
@rdub934 said:
I'm not a diehard Vic-guy (yet, my day is coming quickly) and I've never seen one of these Bokers yet, but they look like a logical evolution of the traditional SAK. The pocket-clip and G10 scales are no brainers. I am sort of thinking shame on Vic for not developing their product into this year's ago.Although, they will be fine regardless - they're Victorinox after all.
Agreed on all counts. I hope Victorinox provides a response to the Boker line, even if they don't go for the G-10 scales. a cellidor 91mm with a good liner lock and a pocket clip sounds great...
-
I hope nothing changes at all.
-
I hope Victorinox provides a response to the Boker line, even if they don't go for the G-10 scales. a cellidor 91mm with a good liner lock and a pocket clip sounds great...
Using staff room wild math here - I would say 1/10, perhaps 1/100 or 1/1000 SAK purchasers know or care what G-10 is.
In many markets, not having a lock is a selling point in favour of SAKs,and if they changed the classic look of the SAK with a pocket clip (handy as they are) I'd say half your mall type shoppers would assume they are fakes, because they've never seen them with them before.
Would I like these options? sure (maybe not the lock), but enthusiasts are weird.
I think SAK has a strong market and a strong reputation, and while I enjoy their forays out of their niche, they sell hundreds of Tinkers, Climbers and Spartans every day, and (presumably) that is what keeps them going. -
@Sea Monster said:
I hope Victorinox provides a response to the Boker line, even if they don't go for the G-10 scales. a cellidor 91mm with a good liner lock and a pocket clip sounds great...
Using staff room wild math here - I would say 1/10, perhaps 1/100 or 1/1000 SAK purchasers know or care what G-10 is.
In many markets, not having a lock is a selling point in favour of SAKs,and if they changed the classic look of the SAK with a pocket clip (handy as they are) I'd say half your mall type shoppers would assume they are fakes, because they've never seen them with them before.
Would I like these options? sure (maybe not the lock), but enthusiasts are weird.
I think SAK has a strong market and a strong reputation, and while I enjoy their forays out of their niche, they sell hundreds of Tinkers, Climbers and Spartans every day, and (presumably) that is what keeps them going.I agree on that, because there product is so well know they're kind of stuck with it.
They do offer the evogrip series but those do not seem to catch on with the public. -
Vic definitely don't need to replace the classic SAK line. But offer an alternate line of these updated "Boker-beaterz" for the tacti-cool/mall-ninja crowd.
Quick! How do I get elected king of Switzerland?
-
-
There is another…
Emerson EDC-2, 440C steel, G10 handles, and with take-down screws.
Also offering less utility than a Tinker, while costing six times as much.

-
@ColoSwiss said:
There is another…Emerson EDC-2, 440C steel, G10 handles, and with take-down screws.
Also offering less utility than a Tinker, while costing six times as much.
Yeah, some minor advantages like all locking tools IIRC.
But it is also 150g (like 3x the weight of the Tinker). -
In my opinion they are extremely over priced especially since it has 440 for the blade steel. It should have S35VN for the price. I hate the re-curve as well. I still really want one, but will never buy one.
-
Recurve in a blade is a dealbreaker for me. It is something has saved a lot of money for me. :)
(I have many pet peeves with knives. I have more knives than I need, so of course I am picky if I consider buying more.)
-
@captain spaulding said:
Recurve in a blade is a dealbreaker for me. It is something has saved a lot of money for me. :)
(I have many pet peeves with knives. I have more knives than I need, so of course I am picky if I consider buying more.)
Same for me. I do not do recurve or tanto.
Ditto. :D
-
Double ditto on the tanto. Never had a need to poke a hole in bamboo-and leather-armor, and can't think of anything else they're good for.
-
@rdub934 said:
Quick! How do I get elected king of Switzerland?There is no direct way, but you could try something like this:
- Join the Catholic church
- Become Pope
- Use Papal Guard to invade Switzerland
- Proclaim yourself King
Hmmm, that doesn't work for me. Plan B: 1. Get elected POTUS. 2. Deliver some freedom to Switzerland (the 'Murican kind). 3. Declare the former Switzerland the 51st state and rename it Barry Switzer Land. 4. Institute my changes at Victorinox
Easy 
You know how us Americans can be.
Jk, of course
@captain spaulding said:
Recurve in a blade is a dealbreaker for me. It is something has saved a lot of money for me. :)
(I have many pet peeves with knives. I have more knives than I need, so of course I am picky if I consider buying more.)
Same for me. I do not do recurve or tanto.
What are the negatives/positives with re-curved blades? I see a fair amount of dislike towards them. Also, what is the deal with Tantos? Supposed to be better for piercing. How so? Stronger tip. Compared to what? Wouldn't a sheepsfoot be just as strong?
Someone please enlighten me? I am genuinely interested, especially since I recently acquired a Tanto M16.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login